Seether "Broken" featuring Lzzy Hale - 98Rock Fest 4/2/11

[Mustang66GirlMn]

sry but Amy Lee she ain't : ( 

[MrShizz77]

fuck I was gonna go to that show, but I took this damn Arrow to the knee

[FenryrsWolfgirl]

God i Love Lizzy Hale,a nd she totally makes this song even better, I like Amy Lee's version too, but yeah, Lizzy'attitude, her vocal strength and performances are just always amazing!!!!

[Dlano619]

Lzzy definitely wins. Amy isn't a great vocalist, as evidenced by many producers saying she is one of the most difficult vocalists to produce. Lzzy is comparable to a Pat Benatar or Anne Wilson with the Lita Ford attitude.

[captainawesome830]

I don't if Lizzy is a good as Amy but she has one of the most amazing voices in music.

[TheNightWitch]

I was at this concert :)

[buffblogger]

@TheNightWitch I was too, was suprized everyone left after Stone Sour. Place was empty by the time 3 doors finished.

[TheGloryrockz]

Im sorry for all who said this is better than amy´s voice.... i really like halestorm... but Lzzy is amateur compared with AMY.......

[TheFeeez21]

@TheGloryrockz i disagree i've always thought amy lee was overrated and now that i discovered lzzy its like whoa she can sing!

[itsavirus47]

After having seen this...I believe I have fallen in love with her voice all over again. Magnificent. Simply magnificent.

[dadonate]

Like it or not this song will be around for a while

[dadonate]

Awesome awesome awesome

[terrtj]

She sings better than Amy!!!!!!!

[dreambleedofficial]

@terrtj hell NOT!!!!!

[rhamin555]

lizzy can turn trash into music ;3

[MsCabo36]

So much better than Amy!

[Diianxz]

woooaaah! I love it!!

more than Amy!

Lizzy is Fucking awesome!

[KevinPaul06]

Lzzy > Amy -_-

[STORMCHASER715]

4 ppl ride the short bus!!!

[Rusty2FTW]

This is the only song i like w/ Amy Lee, I don't like Evanescence, but Lzzy is great of doing any song from any genre (Lady Gaga, Skid Row, The Beatles, Bon Jovi, who knows any metal bands like Anthrax she can sing 2). <3 Her madly!

[XxTimothysMomxX]

thumbs up if you can't stop staring at her legs :p

[booboo481]

Amy and Lzzy both have very different singing styles and they both do this song very well. They are both great, just different.

[Nagina33]

She's good but I prefer Amy's angelic voice to her belty voice

[brendanmcwilliams]

@Nagina33

Studio magic my friend. Watch her live to hear the "angelic" voice without "assistance".

[bloodvenomlove]

this is hard... i LOVE amy but looks like this girl could give any female in rock a run for thier money ;)

[AKOverlord]

Id like to hear this version without the screaming fans :P

[Dagorlord]

If Amy didnt do this first I would love Lizzy's version more. Better yet kick Shaun out and Amy & Lizzy sing it together :)

[TobyxxVenom]

this was good, don't get me wrong i love lizzy but amy lee makes this song and it's just not the same with out her

[misbahdude]

Amy lee doesn't sound good live..i may get a lotta flack for this, but Lzzy's sounding much better.. thats just my opinion..so pro amy fans dont get worked up!

[magicdust4000]

@misbahdude I agree. I've been a fan of Amy's for years but she cannot sing well live.

[lovemetal2010]

@magicdust4000 i first saw her in 2004 than saw her last year and she was incredible

[SpyderOne1981]

@misbahdude I agree...i am an Evanescence fan and all, but people really try to put Amy over the top and i dont get it, cuz i really dont think shes all that great live! I'm not saying shes horrible, just not great! Lzzy on the other hand...Lzzy is fuckin GREAT!!

[TheGlideIsHere]

Amy's voice is great in a different way, but for sure NO ONE can belt like Lzzy.

[Keefedrummer333]

Wow! amys got nothin on lizzy! soo much more passion! Way better.

[Gviktorovich]

Yes. She will never be Amy Lee because she is much better ...

[40twilightbella]

she will never be amy lee:/ but she is good

[RhythmGotGirls]

@40twilightbella I'm sorry but Amy can never sing this live as good as Lzzy. Lzzy is miles above.

[angelsdemon33]

She blew amy lee's part right outta the water!!! AMY LEE WHO???

[740BIGSTEVE]

I actually got to see this performed live. All I can say it wow. It was before Halestorm had made a name for theirself and we didn't know of them. Needless to say they got a fan for life. Way way better than Amy. Can't wait to see them in Dayton later this month.

[childsfan999]

lzzy is incredible. that is all.

[djsleezyc]

lizzy hale > amy lee. sorry about your damn luck.

[morbidxpixie187]

I love this.. It takes the song to a whole new level. Hearing Lzzy sing this gives me chills. Both Amy Lee and Lzzy are beautiful and amazing singers. Both have very unique voice that are easily recognized. As far as the Lzzy screaming her verses comment.. Screaming??? Really? Just because she has more of an edge to her singing than like, oh let's say.. Britney Spears? Ha doesn't mean she is screaming. Lzzy is fantastic end of story.

[newjug1234]

I'd really prefer Amy Lee over this singer because I'm not really familiar with her or her band but Amy Lee I'm familiar with. I guess I just have to get used to Izzy. She does sound good in this song though.

[MissAlice15]

I like Amy Lee and Lzzy Hale. Usually I do like Lzzy Hale/ Halestorm better than Amy Lee/ Evanescence. However, as wonderfully as Lzzy sings this song, I still feel like the more feminine voice fits a little better, but I still wish like hell there was a recorded version. Halestorm is my favorite band and hearing Lzzy sing this is really cool. :)

[FromWishingDreams]

I love both Izzy and Amy.

[progamus]

Yeah, I don't think one's better than the other. Lizzy and Amy both have stellar voices and I don't think Lizzy screams the verses at all. I would actually love to hear a recorded version with Lizzy. Lizzy does bring a more Rocker edge to it than Amy and I do like that she's not trying to be Amy either. Huge respect to them both as singers AND musicians.

[FuzzyBuns09]

i love them both but since amy was the original of course her's sounds better because we're use to it. Nice to see a change tho

[Tutone66]

Lizzy is good but she screams her verses in Broken, Amy Lee sings hers. I wish both singer the best.

[J70mega777]

@Tutone66 She does have to make it hers though. Not Amy's.

[fefobiz]

Lzzy is a better singer than Amy ever was. Her technique is flawless.

Check Lzzy's cover of "All I Wanna Do Is Make Love To You" by Heart.

If you disagree I can't/won't argue with you because you know nothing about music and it would be pointless.

[killj0y15]

lzzy would eat amy alive

[MLCJracer]

@killj0y15 I'd love to see that ;)

[tbrhunter]

@killj0y15

lol :)

[NirvanaLover321]

amy is better

[kmzin1234]

they need to rerecord this...

[meadowcloud519]

I like both versions. They both bring something different to the song. Lzzy has a hard rocker vibe and Amy brings a softer, vulnerable feel and while they're both DIFFERENT, both are tremendously amazing :)

[orlando7897]

I was there ! Best damn concert ever !

[nicodemus311]

I was there.....it was awesome :)

[EvanescenceLikeYou09]

People shouldn't compare Lzzy to Amy! They are completely different people :)

[babbles915]

in my opinion i like amy better but lzzy did an amazing job on this also. (:

[ASimLadyLove]

Lzzy is SO much better than Amy Lee.

[PornorifficGirl]

AMY can't even sing like AMY anymore..so what does it matter...lol Let someone else who can still sing it SING IT!

[JukoDDT]

Lzzy just adds a different dimension to the song. Nothin wrong with that at all.

[Isaacred14]

I love how she adds that really rock voice to it that amy doesnt have

[tawny312]

I know that's why I love the hell out of her singing it over Amy Lee..... Oh my she is soooo much better in person!! She is truly the next BIG THING!!

[455eley]

until now my favorite duet was if I close my eyes forever by ozzy osborne and lita ford. broken beats it all to hell

[jg4eva240]

@455eley Lzzy really does an amazing job with it. as does Amy.

[455eley]

@455eley this has to be my vavorite recording of lzzy doing this song and they did it on my birthday thank you

[jg4eva240]

@455eley glad you like it! this show was actually 3 days before my birthday haha

[rakohammmas]

wont ever compare to amy.but nevertheless she sang pretty

[jg4eva240]

@rakohammmas but that's the beauty of it, she's not trying to be Amy, she's being Lzzy.

[ScreamingSnake03]

I was there as well, this song was probley the best one of the entire concert IMO.

[sizzle4550]

thanks for uploading this! this was amazing.....agreed she isnt amy lee, but why compare them? they have such different styles, and both bring their own thing to this song......i do rather enjoy this version!

[allpimpsnohoes]

I was there!! She did sooooo amazing! She may not be Amy Lee, but I thought it was beautiful<3

[RachyRawrz]

I officially love you forevver for this <3