A total original. A joy to listen to. Nothing but positive comments from all, both at the audition and at Simon's home. She was easily the most entertaining of all the performers. I have heard Melani Amaro, a million times. I have never heard someone as creative as Caitlin. Too bad politics got in the way. X factor, could not have an American Idol reject win the prize. So sad.
simon is smart. he knew there were too many strong girls adn only one winner. this girl has the voice to actually win, but up against melanie amaro she would've lost her chance. she can come back a year after much stronger and could actually win season 2 if she wants
This was one of the best performances of the season, by any contestant. I still listen to it regularly, and when I heard others perform this song on this years American Idol, it just didn't compare. I will never hear this song again in my life without noticing how it falls short of this performance. Caitlin, you are incredible.
damn propz to her also... weather they win or not these girls have to be pulled from somewhere cause there is alot of ppl that would consider great voices.
@MariiKittyNoBieber Dont be a hatter because you are fat and ugly. And who cares if she was bitchy. Tiah sucked and should never have been at the judges house.
Would love to hear Simon reason for sending Caitlin home...still dont understand the group of initial picks as it turned out: Drew, too young and boring, Rachel, too young and prone to a classic meltdown w/o 5 million and her own bathroom, Tiah..LMAO! and Simone ROTFLMAO!! Dont get me started on Nicole sending Christa Collins home, Enrique loved her!!!! he should've slapped Nicole with his.. DICtionary, no word in it for Nicole performance as a X Factor judge letting Dexter thru.
Ok, I am just now watching these videos for the first time (have not been following the show). I have see the Drew...now on to her. I saw her first audition now this. Oh MY GOSH..she is absoulutely breath taking voice. I LOVE HER!!! Now I read through comments she is GONE?????? Why oh why? I feel she is better than Drew Drew is folky, young and has promise..good in her own style. But Simon was right about this one's pitch..control, style. Plus I could FEEL this song. I loved everything
He probably let her go because of her snotty stuck up attitude...I'd rather work with someone who was a crappy singer with a great personality than with someone with a pompous attitude. There is a point where you have to be humble and she was just a bitch sometimes.
@Dramawitsvu17 so you think tiah tolliver had a great personality lol?? face it, caitlin had better talent than simone AND tiah, not too mention simon has a pompous attitude so they would've made a perfect team
@Dylano33 oh shut up you are only saying that because she's white. I'm not one to usually bring race into the picture but this is an obvious one on you side. I am going to admit if anything Tiah and Simone were not the brightest cookies in a box. Simone...was kind of...slow...but they both had likable personalities. Whether you see it or not now is a moot point. she gone now move on. Caitlin was MUCH MUCH better than them singing wise thats not doubt in that but she was a snob.
@Dramawitsvu17 because she's white? that has nothing to do with anything you dumb shit. and i guess that's something you, tiah, and simone have in common, you're all slow.
@Dylano33 yeah yeah, you know it's true. Just stay in lala land. I actually take the time to listen and watch their mannerisms. It is you Dylano who is the oblivious dumb shit. You just say that shit about everyone else being slow cuz she's pretty. It's okay to like someone just for there looks and talent. But clearly it doesn't matter about talent cuz she still got SENT HOME! Shit for brains.
@Dramawitsvu17 you said the other two were slow haha i just simply agreed with you. and i actually don't even think she's pretty i just think her talent was far better than the other two. it's a talent competition, not a personality contest. get your shit straight.
@Dylano33 Clearly thursday night's elimination had NOTHING to do with talent. You are running the show so your opinions don't matter..."get your shit straight" back to you.
@Dramawitsvu17 you realize thursday night's elimination was based on america's votes not actual talent right? all of these shows are a popularity contest. it was different at the judges houses because they picked, or shouldve picked, based on talent. now go do something productive with your life and stop finding people to respond to over youtube.
@Dylano33 You replied to my comment first you moron! YOU go do something without arguing with people for their opinion. Your opinions are just as pointless as mine douche bag.
x factor sucks. She hould have won oh and Astro too. Now they have talent! Theys say oh the age matters. i meen SHUT UP there are 13 year old famous rich, singers out there and they have a recodrd deal
Simons mum didnt raise no fool......he knows precisely what hes doing. He is PRESERVING her. Youll know what i mean when she releases her own album in the not so distant future, signed by non other Mr Cowell himself.
@lee4ivy I never understood why simon didn't put her through. In my opinion she was the best of all the contestants. her voice is so pleasant to the hear!!!
i loved caitlin, but u have to admit, it was a really really tough decision for simon. seriously, i wouldn't be able to choose between her, drew, rachel, or melanie. he had to choose SOMEONE to go, and besides, caitlin's gonna be famous anyway :)
hmmm...........I think Simon was developing a little crush on her and rejected her based on his own insecurities. I might be wrong...........but I don't think so.
I certainly hope she makes it despite her not making it on X-Factor, she has a beautiful voice, she has the complete package. I will be looking for her.
When that guy said there is something about her, he unintentionally said she had the "X factor", Simon made a professional mistake not putting her through instead we got the poor man's Rihanna Simone, it's also ironic hearing her sing those words because all though he covered her with compliments he didn't "love her tomorrow".
OMG when she left, it was the reason why i stop watching. like wtf!!! i was rooting for her since her first audition. Her voice calms me down. Hahaha funny i auditioned for this show last april in NY.
oh nooo, she got to work on smoothing her vocals. i have the same problem she got. Maybe we need surgery to correct this. Also she has to learn to hold notes longer. I think problem with alot of people is they judge with eyes and not with ears. Thank God Simon knows what's talking about. I think Stacy and Melanie are the best in vocals but they need to loose some weight. if i add weight, i cant sing. Maybe i need more practice.Hmmmm
Her & Melanie were the best out of the girls....I still cant believe Simon let her go & kept Tia & skanky Simone....what a waste of time they were...theyre live performances sucked so bad it was unreal....this girl deserved to be in the live performances....she was my favorite....she sings like an angel & is so beautiful...guess she wasnt slutty enough for Simon
OH MY GOSH STUPID ASS SIMON PUT THAT UGLY ASS TIAH THROUGH AND SIMONE AND INSTEAD HE COULD OF PUT CAITLIN AND TORA THROUGH!!!!!!!!!!!! UGHHHH SIMONS THE WORST MENTOR.
I don't understand why Simon let Simone Battle in instead of Caitlin. Simone's overconfidence really got on my nerves. Maybe Simon let her in 'cos she's hot. Pervert.
Normally I think Simon is dead on but I love this girl very disappointed that I will probably never get to here her sing anything other than the few songs she sang on this show that I can find on youtube.
She is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!! Quit the show when she was booted.
@jdriddle8 I'm willing to bet she will have a CD sometime in the next 6-8 months. She got the recognition she needed and is way to good for someone not to sign her.
Um, pardon my French......Why the F*ck did Simon let her go?!?! Unbelievable, based on that audition, not to mention, she absolutely looks like a star!! Oh, wait!! Does this mean she will get a recording contract despite the disappointing result for this show?! "I've Gotta Feelin'"
@CrazyExciting82 Coz i thought that she was better then some of the people who went through. Pity that there is people like you who think their clever by being sarcastic.
complete bull that she didnt make it, she has such an amazing voice, and add the fact that shes dropdead gorgeous, just makes her all that much better
This song reminds me of Ally McBeal every time I hear it. I thought this girl looked beautiful (Shakira-like) and sounded beautiful. Much better than the 2 he threw out on the first live show. She is a little bit cocky - although sometimes that is not a bad thing if it's not too much.
"Will you still love you tomorrow" is a pure classic of american composer and performer Carole King. Amy Whinehouse performed this song 30 years later the original version.
Can't believe that he took Tia, who couldn't stay in tune at all, and let Caitlin go home. He should have been making two visits to contestants that he made mistakes on.
If she was so perfect then why did you let her go? you bloody idiot?!! Really Simone Battle over her??!!! Well, i guess you needed someone to kick out for the live shows, sorry Simone but Caitlin has a much better voice than you.
Caitlin was 10 times better than the acts they let through to the finals. She's gonna be an incredible Artist and Simon will be dying inside knowing he let her go.
"Something about her"?? If you can't see or hear what that something is, then WHY ARE YOU EVEN THERE?? That's the same troll that tried to sabotaged Jazzlyn.....Why does Simon have a guy like that hanging around. Simon that guy helped ruin your 1st season for millions of fans.He's the one who should be cut, not Caitlin and Jazzlyn.
i really like her voice
rosselsalazar 1 day ago
THIS SONG HAS BEEN WRITTEN BY THE GREAT CAROLE KING.AMY WINEHOUSE DID AN UNFORGETTABLE COVER OF IT.
cannonballmishell 3 days ago
best performance ever
yuenne 6 days ago
she is so unique, much better than most of finalists..
seyn23 1 week ago
A total original. A joy to listen to. Nothing but positive comments from all, both at the audition and at Simon's home. She was easily the most entertaining of all the performers. I have heard Melani Amaro, a million times. I have never heard someone as creative as Caitlin. Too bad politics got in the way. X factor, could not have an American Idol reject win the prize. So sad.
strooomon 1 week ago
simon is smart. he knew there were too many strong girls adn only one winner. this girl has the voice to actually win, but up against melanie amaro she would've lost her chance. she can come back a year after much stronger and could actually win season 2 if she wants
stephendiego 1 week ago
This was one of the best performances of the season, by any contestant. I still listen to it regularly, and when I heard others perform this song on this years American Idol, it just didn't compare. I will never hear this song again in my life without noticing how it falls short of this performance. Caitlin, you are incredible.
tlnelson7 1 week ago
Wow !
AshtiaNezbeth 1 week ago
wow she's incredible
ellengundorff 2 weeks ago
I can listen the moment when she singing last "tomorrow" 10000000000 times!!!
gajcor 2 weeks ago 2
she gives me chilllssss
Giiirgis 2 weeks ago
wow really good! how did she not get through?
Fanfil1 2 weeks ago
amazing performance!1
MrMassi86 2 weeks ago
mila kunis ♥
TheAngelcutie22 2 weeks ago
1:20- 1:26 took my breath away..
supergoddess20 3 weeks ago
Her voice reminds me a little of Sara McLachlans.
pauljoneslove 1 month ago
Comment removed
dchiggs 1 month ago
yes i thought he would send her through she has a pretty and diff voice
beth12803 1 month ago
yes...
buckfast2k 1 month ago
Amazing!
MichelleOo93 1 month ago
Tears #thatisall
Endocrine1 1 month ago
Simon loved everything about her, yet he sends her home from here.... IDIOT!
de6430 1 month ago
damn propz to her also... weather they win or not these girls have to be pulled from somewhere cause there is alot of ppl that would consider great voices.
southernfowl 1 month ago
How she didnt make it through blows my mind...
mccox1004 1 month ago
If you loved her so much Simon, why on earth did you cut her and keep Tia? Have you lost your hearing or what?
MsSugardimple 1 month ago
@MariiKittyNoBieber Dont be a hatter because you are fat and ugly. And who cares if she was bitchy. Tiah sucked and should never have been at the judges house.
CrazyExciting82 2 months ago in playlist X FACTOR
Best vocal performance of all X Factor. I could listen to her sing for HOURS.
CrazyExciting82 2 months ago in playlist X FACTOR
@CrazyExciting82 wow your joking right? i mean this was amazing and i have it in my favorites but it wasnt the best =/
embergram 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
@MariiKittyNoBieber I'm glad someone else feels the same
chrisbrwnbaby2 2 months ago
Simon- "How are you doing?"
Caitlin-"Im fine"
Me-"You got that right!"
MrDragonmillionaire 2 months ago
what is the name of the song in the beginning of this movie? anyone knows it?
katiamagalhaes1 2 months ago
@katiamagalhaes1 Hi Katia, the song you're looking for is Nothing sweet about me by Gabriella Cilmi.
Fredinotmercurybut 3 weeks ago
She's a bitch and I'm happy she didn't make it
chrisbrwnbaby2 2 months ago
she is amazing!!! it shouldve been her instead of tiah and simone
fatbummblebee 2 months ago
She has one of the most beautiful voice I've ever heard : Pure, smooth, niceeee !! Wish she could make at the live show :(
MultiAymeno 2 months ago
wish she didnt have to get cut
thestewy321 2 months ago in playlist Music
Amy Winehouse copied the song.
This song was written by Carol King in the 60"s.
Amy didn't have the brain waves to put words on paper.
warvet486 2 months ago
Would love to hear Simon reason for sending Caitlin home...still dont understand the group of initial picks as it turned out: Drew, too young and boring, Rachel, too young and prone to a classic meltdown w/o 5 million and her own bathroom, Tiah..LMAO! and Simone ROTFLMAO!! Dont get me started on Nicole sending Christa Collins home, Enrique loved her!!!! he should've slapped Nicole with his.. DICtionary, no word in it for Nicole performance as a X Factor judge letting Dexter thru.
tmharr63 2 months ago
@tmharr63 Ok actually Drew and Rachel aren't too young seeing as they lowered the age smarts.
ixavior100 2 months ago
I DON´T GET IT, WHY SHE DIDN´T MAKE IT???!!!!
srtalululu 2 months ago 6
the way she sings from 1:20 to 1:27 is so ill...
whyilee 2 months ago
angelic voice!1
MrFluffyPants35 2 months ago
Fucking amazing she is
gazzyN2k8 2 months ago
WOW!!!!!!!!
taeze89 2 months ago
i'm still not over that she didn't make it! ... i mean that performance was amazing!
bradleyy2kaii8 3 months ago 49
Comment removed
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
simon should have kept kaitlin over that drew chick.
jocelinlou 3 months ago
She's hot!
ecruz5827 3 months ago
Ok, I am just now watching these videos for the first time (have not been following the show). I have see the Drew...now on to her. I saw her first audition now this. Oh MY GOSH..she is absoulutely breath taking voice. I LOVE HER!!! Now I read through comments she is GONE?????? Why oh why? I feel she is better than Drew Drew is folky, young and has promise..good in her own style. But Simon was right about this one's pitch..control, style. Plus I could FEEL this song. I loved everything
Sydney0502 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
xkiller not xfactor
Caitlin Koch, Elain Gibbs, Tiger Budbil, Jeremiah Pagan and Emily Michalak
Rayantation 3 months ago 2
Comment removed
Rayantation 3 months ago
He probably let her go because of her snotty stuck up attitude...I'd rather work with someone who was a crappy singer with a great personality than with someone with a pompous attitude. There is a point where you have to be humble and she was just a bitch sometimes.
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
@Dramawitsvu17 so you think tiah tolliver had a great personality lol?? face it, caitlin had better talent than simone AND tiah, not too mention simon has a pompous attitude so they would've made a perfect team
Dylano33 3 months ago
@Dylano33 oh shut up you are only saying that because she's white. I'm not one to usually bring race into the picture but this is an obvious one on you side. I am going to admit if anything Tiah and Simone were not the brightest cookies in a box. Simone...was kind of...slow...but they both had likable personalities. Whether you see it or not now is a moot point. she gone now move on. Caitlin was MUCH MUCH better than them singing wise thats not doubt in that but she was a snob.
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
@Dramawitsvu17 because she's white? that has nothing to do with anything you dumb shit. and i guess that's something you, tiah, and simone have in common, you're all slow.
Dylano33 3 months ago
@Dylano33 yeah yeah, you know it's true. Just stay in lala land. I actually take the time to listen and watch their mannerisms. It is you Dylano who is the oblivious dumb shit. You just say that shit about everyone else being slow cuz she's pretty. It's okay to like someone just for there looks and talent. But clearly it doesn't matter about talent cuz she still got SENT HOME! Shit for brains.
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
@Dramawitsvu17 you said the other two were slow haha i just simply agreed with you. and i actually don't even think she's pretty i just think her talent was far better than the other two. it's a talent competition, not a personality contest. get your shit straight.
Dylano33 3 months ago
@Dylano33 Clearly thursday night's elimination had NOTHING to do with talent. You are running the show so your opinions don't matter..."get your shit straight" back to you.
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
@Dramawitsvu17 you realize thursday night's elimination was based on america's votes not actual talent right? all of these shows are a popularity contest. it was different at the judges houses because they picked, or shouldve picked, based on talent. now go do something productive with your life and stop finding people to respond to over youtube.
Dylano33 3 months ago
Comment removed
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Dylano33 You replied to my comment first you moron! YOU go do something without arguing with people for their opinion. Your opinions are just as pointless as mine douche bag.
Dramawitsvu17 3 months ago
@Dramawitsvu17 "Your opinions are just as pointless as mind douche bag." good english buds!
Dylano33 3 months ago
I bet he let her go so he can sign her himself without being tangled up in the 5 million record deal!
groep 3 months ago
wow! beautiful performance
johanitaa21 3 months ago
Simon, it wasnt smart to let her go.
dedrellmcfadden 3 months ago
her voice wuznt even tht good
PrincessNetNet331 3 months ago
xfactor killed ( Caitlin Koch&Elain Gibbs&Tiger Budbil ) q
Rayantation 3 months ago 4
she looks good enough to eat..love her face and voice..
saylahboi 3 months ago
x factor sucks. She hould have won oh and Astro too. Now they have talent! Theys say oh the age matters. i meen SHUT UP there are 13 year old famous rich, singers out there and they have a recodrd deal
988512ify 3 months ago
Simon was just in love with that big lip chick and that trashy chick Simone. What a fag Simon is for sending this girl home. Smh
SupremeGodSon 3 months ago
This girl should have went through. No Simone, no Tiah... CAITLIN!
gleasontv 3 months ago 2
Simons mum didnt raise no fool......he knows precisely what hes doing. He is PRESERVING her. Youll know what i mean when she releases her own album in the not so distant future, signed by non other Mr Cowell himself.
stingerj 3 months ago
@stingerj EXACTLY what I thought! Hah! He is smart!
groep 3 months ago
shes cocky and she said something to tiah behind her back and thats why she got the boot
jojoandjenna 3 months ago
@jojoandjenna Amen!
MsQwilliams 3 months ago
@MsQwilliams lol
jojoandjenna 3 months ago
This is amazing
MissElleTaylor 3 months ago 4
her eyes are soooo piercing...and her voice is angelic. i genuinely genuinely love her so much, and IT IS NOT JUST BECAUSE SHE'S PRETTY.
lee4ivy 3 months ago 48
@lee4ivy amen!!!
jayhizzur 3 months ago 3
@lee4ivy Very well said I TOTALLY agree
LIPSHEN81 1 month ago
@lee4ivy I never understood why simon didn't put her through. In my opinion she was the best of all the contestants. her voice is so pleasant to the hear!!!
jtrdesign7 1 month ago in playlist Television performances 3
She's beautiful to look at but her voice is limited.
Donlakyounomoah 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Donlakyounomoah And She has no personality...
LucasHoffmeister 3 months ago
shes mediocre you people are crazy, im glad she is gone.
tanyuhhsaurusrex 3 months ago
She is in the open air, but it sounds like she is singing in a closed space, no?...
(this is not about her voice - voice is great.. I am just curious if X-Factor pre-records this).. =)
karpovka 3 months ago
@karpovka The microphone cuts out the other sound except for the singing and the piano, that's why it doesn't sound like she's outside...
JSol80 3 months ago
@UglyRhubarb yeah i guess you're right. even simon makes mistakes :/
jelidonuts 3 months ago
She's gorgeous
KazAnn97 3 months ago 2
She's a beautiful singer. Simon, what were you thinking???
valenise 3 months ago 4
Absolutely stupid to eliminate her, especially when you hear some of the crap they put through.
elizmsmith 3 months ago 2
i loved caitlin, but u have to admit, it was a really really tough decision for simon. seriously, i wouldn't be able to choose between her, drew, rachel, or melanie. he had to choose SOMEONE to go, and besides, caitlin's gonna be famous anyway :)
jelidonuts 3 months ago
@jelidonuts Those were the four he should have let through. Not Simone Battle or the other chick.
UglyRhubarb 3 months ago
very very beautiful
lucech1 3 months ago
hmmm...........I think Simon was developing a little crush on her and rejected her based on his own insecurities. I might be wrong...........but I don't think so.
sumoleguy1 3 months ago
@sumoleguy1 I saw her just once, and I have a crush on her :P
neohayabusa2 3 months ago 2
WOW! So that is what they mean when say someone sings like an angel. Just so beautiful!
sezen1h 3 months ago
I certainly hope she makes it despite her not making it on X-Factor, she has a beautiful voice, she has the complete package. I will be looking for her.
liebschen851 3 months ago 2
shes good..really good
samainie 3 months ago
sshes really good, but i like the other girls better, I just cant believe tiah tolliver made it farther than her!!
jenanjeha 3 months ago
America has so much talent
elementsofstars 3 months ago
i really hope she re-auditions next year. simon fucked up. caitlin if you see this comment WE WANT YOU BACK ON THE X FACTOR!!!!!!!
LauraIsPink 3 months ago 3
Did you see when Simon said "I've made a terrible mistake".
He actually made 4 mistakes.
He sent the best 4 girls home !!!
Imagine Jazzlyn, Tora, Caitlin and Melanie on the live shows. WOW!!!
Maybe he got his list mixed up and didn't like to admit it !!!
petethedeej 3 months ago
Big screw up letting her go....beautiful and talented, with a future, but again, they and this time Simon was wrong!
HershelAlan 3 months ago
When that guy said there is something about her, he unintentionally said she had the "X factor", Simon made a professional mistake not putting her through instead we got the poor man's Rihanna Simone, it's also ironic hearing her sing those words because all though he covered her with compliments he didn't "love her tomorrow".
bukkake999 3 months ago 2
OMG when she left, it was the reason why i stop watching. like wtf!!! i was rooting for her since her first audition. Her voice calms me down. Hahaha funny i auditioned for this show last april in NY.
Matt102585 3 months ago
she sounds like an angel and shes absolutely stunning
noucox 3 months ago
Thumbs up if you think Simon is in love with her, got her off the show so that they can start dating ;)
G5performance 3 months ago 3
Comment removed
meowtrix1 3 months ago
Put her in Lakoda Rain!
RookieTrader 3 months ago
Simon let a star slip through his fingertips.
ThePowerWithinMe 3 months ago 84
@ThePowerWithinMe
I bet simon was thinking more about where, he would like to put his Fingertips!
kadeespatch 2 months ago 2
oh nooo, she got to work on smoothing her vocals. i have the same problem she got. Maybe we need surgery to correct this. Also she has to learn to hold notes longer. I think problem with alot of people is they judge with eyes and not with ears. Thank God Simon knows what's talking about. I think Stacy and Melanie are the best in vocals but they need to loose some weight. if i add weight, i cant sing. Maybe i need more practice.Hmmmm
BeckyUmeh 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BeckyUmeh nobody cares about you
Dylano33 3 months ago
@BeckyUmeh i like her voice the way it is. i closed my eyes and i think it was great.
westlock101 3 months ago
I've had so much respect for Simon but he failed us and America by letting her go. America wants Caitlin!
littlejumbo06 3 months ago 2
Her & Melanie were the best out of the girls....I still cant believe Simon let her go & kept Tia & skanky Simone....what a waste of time they were...theyre live performances sucked so bad it was unreal....this girl deserved to be in the live performances....she was my favorite....she sings like an angel & is so beautiful...guess she wasnt slutty enough for Simon
Angie2466 3 months ago 2
What's the song in the beginning of the video?
botofeh 3 months ago
OH MY GOSH STUPID ASS SIMON PUT THAT UGLY ASS TIAH THROUGH AND SIMONE AND INSTEAD HE COULD OF PUT CAITLIN AND TORA THROUGH!!!!!!!!!!!! UGHHHH SIMONS THE WORST MENTOR.
SexyMuuffin 3 months ago
I don't understand why Simon let Simone Battle in instead of Caitlin. Simone's overconfidence really got on my nerves. Maybe Simon let her in 'cos she's hot. Pervert.
thelalaladream 3 months ago
I love her from the audition, i still dont understand WHY Simon didn't pick her, and pick Simone instead? She deserves the spot
azamofficial 4 months ago
her pitch ,her tone, amazing....really? so lets reward her by turfing her off the show. odd
imsneeky 4 months ago
Normally I think Simon is dead on but I love this girl very disappointed that I will probably never get to here her sing anything other than the few songs she sang on this show that I can find on youtube.
She is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!! Quit the show when she was booted.
jdriddle8 4 months ago
@jdriddle8 I'm willing to bet she will have a CD sometime in the next 6-8 months. She got the recognition she needed and is way to good for someone not to sign her.
CrazyExciting82 3 months ago in playlist X FACTOR
THIS is RUBBISH how the hell did Simon let go of Caitlin. Pure nonsense i really cant comprehend it
fozdokas 4 months ago
Um, pardon my French......Why the F*ck did Simon let her go?!?! Unbelievable, based on that audition, not to mention, she absolutely looks like a star!! Oh, wait!! Does this mean she will get a recording contract despite the disappointing result for this show?! "I've Gotta Feelin'"
30kendra 4 months ago 43
WHY Simon - i simply don't get it, how you could let Caitlin go.
TheAnnestube 4 months ago
can some1 tell me why she didn't go through? What a joke!
johnnywonderful14 4 months ago
@johnnywonderful14 oh oh pick me, I know the answer to this. It's cause Simon said No.
CrazyExciting82 3 months ago in playlist X FACTOR
@CrazyExciting82 The fact that you are trying to be funny by stating the obvious backfired. I question your intelligence. Fool!
johnnywonderful14 3 months ago
@johnnywonderful14 If it was so obvious then why did you ask the question?
CrazyExciting82 3 months ago
@CrazyExciting82 Coz i thought that she was better then some of the people who went through. Pity that there is people like you who think their clever by being sarcastic.
johnnywonderful14 3 months ago
THE VOICE OF AN ANGEL...THAT'S HER !
TheAngelrose10 4 months ago
I think Simon ended up with the 3 he wanted but created a lot of controversy by putting those other rubbish girls through
jenniloureid 4 months ago 3
complete bull that she didnt make it, she has such an amazing voice, and add the fact that shes dropdead gorgeous, just makes her all that much better
shadowcat1455 4 months ago
I felt sorry 4 her when she didnt make it!!!
moniquethinksyourdum 4 months ago
Shes like a blonde hotter Emma Stone
robhartjr1993 4 months ago
This song reminds me of Ally McBeal every time I hear it. I thought this girl looked beautiful (Shakira-like) and sounded beautiful. Much better than the 2 he threw out on the first live show. She is a little bit cocky - although sometimes that is not a bad thing if it's not too much.
verleneclaringbold 4 months ago
Simon, Why not? She deserved something more than great private life. People like her a lot.. Sure we will hear about her soon
mindlogos1 4 months ago 2
How could they take Simone Battle over her?!
She's pretty and has an AMAZING voice!
MaxumusRide 4 months ago 4
25 people that don't know what real singing is. how sad.
westlock101 4 months ago
"Will you still love you tomorrow" is a pure classic of american composer and performer Carole King. Amy Whinehouse performed this song 30 years later the original version.
07jasminA07 4 months ago
Seriousl. I can't believe that Simon threw her out/
KhaleeqaIDRUS 4 months ago 3
Tia is a rubbish! Should have not been chosen for live performances.
KhaleeqaIDRUS 4 months ago
OMG how could Simon send her home and put Tia and the other idiot through. He must be getting old!
MrFabianSingh 4 months ago
OMG! She shouldve stayed!
immabfamous2011 4 months ago 2
Can't believe that he took Tia, who couldn't stay in tune at all, and let Caitlin go home. He should have been making two visits to contestants that he made mistakes on.
UNCRatDog 4 months ago 3
fuck... I have never had goosebumps like that
cityisonfire1 4 months ago 2
can't believe he took Simone over her. Like really? Stupid mistake. She was great
weedy984 4 months ago 3
If she was so perfect then why did you let her go? you bloody idiot?!! Really Simone Battle over her??!!! Well, i guess you needed someone to kick out for the live shows, sorry Simone but Caitlin has a much better voice than you.
mpms04 4 months ago 2
beautiful voice.
and pure emotions when she sings...
Why simon? Why didn't she make it through.
hessounusual95 4 months ago
Caitlin was 10 times better than the acts they let through to the finals. She's gonna be an incredible Artist and Simon will be dying inside knowing he let her go.
KayceeSparks 4 months ago
She's way better than simone or tia. Jesus, simon, what's up?
Eivyll 4 months ago
She was/is good, but not the best in this competition......
NoTimeForBullCrap 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is the best one
LEMON1899 4 months ago
I am PISSED that Simon let her go she was the best one! Caitlin DONT give up because your voice is beyond amazing.
kandykarmel2009 4 months ago
effin retarded Simon doesn't know talent when he sees it. I am beyond piss that he sent her home. She was my favorite. ugh!
kin09x 4 months ago
She's my fav .fuckkkkkkkkk you hard Simon
diepwright 4 months ago
Love you Caitlin, you´re THE X FACTOR, I hope you do your best and be the winner of this competition, you deservet it!!!!! exito, desde México!!!
marianade091 4 months ago
Ella es la mejor de todo X FACTOR, She is the best of all X FACTOR.
WWLLHH 4 months ago
1:22- 1:27 beautiful
nbgreen333 4 months ago
25 people don't know how to appreciate REAL MUSIC!
iPostMix 4 months ago
shes just a lesser drew simon was right to let her go.
Elektrikkiss 4 months ago
this is better than the original song by amy.
ntee1111 4 months ago in playlist Liked
ewww he picked simmin over her simon is no bueno
davidsanchez230 4 months ago
i hope Caitlin Koch make debute album .
she is the good good singger .
IyankZia 4 months ago
she should have stayed , she was my fav , shes amazing (:
gemacome 4 months ago
CAITLIN HAS A CD FOR SALE ON HER WEBSITE!! Everybody support this great young lady. GO BUY 1 NOW!!
oilguy7777 4 months ago 3
"Something about her"?? If you can't see or hear what that something is, then WHY ARE YOU EVEN THERE?? That's the same troll that tried to sabotaged Jazzlyn.....Why does Simon have a guy like that hanging around. Simon that guy helped ruin your 1st season for millions of fans.He's the one who should be cut, not Caitlin and Jazzlyn.
oilguy7777 4 months ago
I was so sad to see her go too!!!
CrossQueen76 4 months ago
caitlin + drew is the reason i watch this show. simon is deaf
emylxtra 4 months ago
pisses me off that she was cut for that gapped toothed tramp and the other one, you know, the one with the legs. this chick has way more talent.
PrettyDaisee 4 months ago
@PrettyDaisee you are absolutely right, she can sell way more records, the other two you were talking about can't even stay on key
Messie1986 4 months ago