at 5:08 her comment we are neither with you nor terrorist is a very diplomatic statement and called Hippocracy one has to choose either humanity or barbarism there is no middle way.
cont'd... Pakistan has been abused by external powers, but in the inside Pakistan is as if a dead rotten donkey with the guts open and the insides spilled all around and the scavengers feeding on it under the open sun, and the people passing by are standing and often clapping to amuse themselves. Its a sad situation, unique to the land of Pakistan alone. Others are also Muslim, others are also Punjabis, but never a bunch such as in Pakistan. Heart breaking really.
cont'd... India's poor understand far more, and for their own good. They have produced a cultural resistance to all things perceived as pervasive (according to their own perview)---First modernity, and now against liberal-capitalism(postmodernity). Pakistan's had more than its share of intellectuals, but its sad to see them drown away in the noise of nothingness. As someone said, 'Pakistan is not a state, but a real-state.'
OMG. What a unique sight this is. Looks like a gazelle has come down to the lower rings of inferno. Pakistani public is so not used to being spoken to by an intellectual (as opposed to rhetoric and hegemony). She looks so peculiar in that atmosphere. So much distraction going on, like the people have come to a zoo to see an exotic bird. No one listens to an intellectual in Pakistan. To not have a 'Degree' , to be poor and uneducated is not an excuse to not respect an intellectual.
I like Roy, but i don't I don't think statement by 14 year old boy is representative of the ideological underpinning of why Talibans are doing what they are doing, at least in regards to issue of women.
Pakistan is such a wonderful country, the people are so wonderful and kind and embracing of all religions and so tolerant than any hindu I have ever met. Arundhati, please accept Pakistani citizenship and live here for the rest of your life. Your life is so much more valuable and you can do so much for Pakistan than that horrible country India.
Are u speaking on behalf on Pakistan? Because that doesn't sound very tolerant as you claim.
Yes, there are many wonderful Pakistani people as there are wonderful people anywhere else in the world including India. Quit bullshitting like you were born yesterday.
Some indians on this forum miss that point r here criticising her without reading her point of view or looking at the big picture. Narrow minded flag waving pricks, not honestly realising that indian Govt does alot of bad things. The Pak Govt is the same bad book for me. But please stop praising india, more than half population is uneducated/poor, india is polluted, dirty, over-populated,corrupt, education worth shit overseas, police incompetent.
@yzia2009 Listen dude.. u can say wtever u want bout ur country.. dont say any shit about India.. problems are there with every country... the need is to solve those problems.. and if India were such a "horrible" country.. there wudnt be so many ppl defending it here.. Indian education is not worth shit overseas (IIMs, IITs).. pollution is coming down in all major cities (use of CNG).. as are illiteracy, corruption and filth.. I invite you to India.. come and see fr urself hw it is prospering..
I have done my MBA from a college in India. People from all over India were there.. of all religions and castes and creed. You will never be able to imagine the amount of respect we have for each other. And the amount of respect we have for India. We all come frm diff parts of the country, how do we share this view? There was energy because of the diversity of the group and our being with each other and bailing the other person out. That is what India is about. It is about humanity, and oneness.
Ms. Roy.. have u ever wondered why are you so popular in Pakistan.. ?? because in a very evident way, you just confirm every whim that any Pakistani with ill-wishes against India has. I would just like to ask you one thing: Do you believe in the concept of India..?? not the execution of dat concept but the very concept that all kinds of people can live and prosper in harmony ?? At least India has got that right unlike a lot of other countries u like to visit..
It is because of people like you that brand all pakistanis as haters and enemies of India that we still aren't able to acheive a true friendship between us. OPEN YOUR MIND & HEART! Ignorant thinking like yours is spreading too much hate. Ms Roy isnt a nationlist which is why she's able to point out the faults within India and any other nation. The things she says are undeniably true and supported by facts- not just empty propaganda. People from all over the world love and trust her!
We don't need friendship.. a "mind ur own business" attitude will do.. !! I am all for pointing out faults with India.. I am not saying my country is perfect.. but this woman.. is totally out of her league talking on nationalist issues.. her views on everything are nothing but sensationalist.. she just wants the limelight.. n dats y i've never seen her sayin anything gud about India.. hence my question abt the concept of India... which is just plain common sense.. and isn't flawed in any way !!
the execution of the concept is ovbiously non-existant- on a social level, political level, legal level etc & it will never be executed unless people speak out against it. This is what people like her are trying to do. Nobody is questioning the concept. They are questioning the contrasting actions that being executed against the concept. There is no point to a concept that isn't being adhered to. This why India, US, Israel etc. is just bad as the countries they are supposedly trying to reform.
Exactly.. !! what i wanted to say was this only.. the concept of India is sound and noble.. and I agree, execution hasnt been perfect.. but we're getting there.. and the majority of Indians realize that..
Anyway.. what i wud like is to hear her praise the concept.. make people aware and use positivity to bring about change instead of the news grabbing stuff she has become used to..
@rohitcbs12 well said rohit....i just have one thing to say to mrs roy....if u have a problem with india,juss stay out of india,we know very well how to love and live in our beloved nation,and for pakistaan,if u love so much to hear about poverty and inequality and woman deprivation....u might juss love to read a newspaper from pakistan,it must be filled with all this,or may be not...ohh i forgot..."the freedom of media and speech" have u people heard of it ,it actually exists u know :)
Roy must speak her mind regarding the issue of Pak Army's brutalities in Sindh and Balochistan as well. The reason being, that she holds immense prestige where everybody deems her as an independent political analyst.
ارندھتی رائے ملکوں اور ریاستوں کی حدود سے آزاد ایک اسی باشعور خاتون ہیں جنہیں صحیح معنوں میں دنیا کا شہری کہا جا سکتا ہے۔ وہ اتنی ہی پاکستانی ہیں جتنی وہ ہندوستانی ہیں۔ جاری۔
یہ بات کراچی والوں کے لیے باعث فخر ہے کہ وہ کراچی آئیں اور انہوں نے پریس کلب میں لوگوں سے خطاب کیا۔ کاش کہ وہ ہر سال کم از کم ایک بار کراچی کا دورہ ضرور کیا کریں۔ ہمیں ان کی روشن خیالی سے مستقل مستفید ہونے کی شدید ضرورت ہے۔
@Harpy87 well said.let her be there and her pakistani fans will become communist shits and crush islam from their country.hehehe.
qwertyui66771 3 months ago
SHES SO COOL
qwerty1234569479 7 months ago 3
Comment removed
need4peace 7 months ago
at 5:08 her comment we are neither with you nor terrorist is a very diplomatic statement and called Hippocracy one has to choose either humanity or barbarism there is no middle way.
ajeet619 1 year ago
Pakistani terrorists like Arundhati Roy. because because both are against India and its democracy...She is a Disaster...
jkabc25 1 year ago
Arundhati Roy, the most loved woman in porkistan....
ThePseudoBasher 1 year ago
koel boli...
asasolsh1 1 year ago
cont'd... Pakistan has been abused by external powers, but in the inside Pakistan is as if a dead rotten donkey with the guts open and the insides spilled all around and the scavengers feeding on it under the open sun, and the people passing by are standing and often clapping to amuse themselves. Its a sad situation, unique to the land of Pakistan alone. Others are also Muslim, others are also Punjabis, but never a bunch such as in Pakistan. Heart breaking really.
failef 1 year ago
cont'd... India's poor understand far more, and for their own good. They have produced a cultural resistance to all things perceived as pervasive (according to their own perview)---First modernity, and now against liberal-capitalism(postmodernity). Pakistan's had more than its share of intellectuals, but its sad to see them drown away in the noise of nothingness. As someone said, 'Pakistan is not a state, but a real-state.'
failef 1 year ago
OMG. What a unique sight this is. Looks like a gazelle has come down to the lower rings of inferno. Pakistani public is so not used to being spoken to by an intellectual (as opposed to rhetoric and hegemony). She looks so peculiar in that atmosphere. So much distraction going on, like the people have come to a zoo to see an exotic bird. No one listens to an intellectual in Pakistan. To not have a 'Degree' , to be poor and uneducated is not an excuse to not respect an intellectual.
failef 1 year ago
@failef you sound like a intelligent person , nice comment
rohitshaikh 1 year ago 2
I like Roy, but i don't I don't think statement by 14 year old boy is representative of the ideological underpinning of why Talibans are doing what they are doing, at least in regards to issue of women.
ovaisreza 1 year ago
Pakistan is such a wonderful country, the people are so wonderful and kind and embracing of all religions and so tolerant than any hindu I have ever met. Arundhati, please accept Pakistani citizenship and live here for the rest of your life. Your life is so much more valuable and you can do so much for Pakistan than that horrible country India.
tolykozin 2 years ago
haha
freesoul2005 1 year ago
"Horrible country..India"
Are u speaking on behalf on Pakistan? Because that doesn't sound very tolerant as you claim.
Yes, there are many wonderful Pakistani people as there are wonderful people anywhere else in the world including India. Quit bullshitting like you were born yesterday.
christaykendra 1 year ago
@tolykozin was there some sarcasm?
sumanbasu 1 year ago
@sumanbasu You are so smart, now how did you guess that
5jeeves 1 year ago
Roy is a great person who looks beyond borders.
Some indians on this forum miss that point r here criticising her without reading her point of view or looking at the big picture. Narrow minded flag waving pricks, not honestly realising that indian Govt does alot of bad things. The Pak Govt is the same bad book for me. But please stop praising india, more than half population is uneducated/poor, india is polluted, dirty, over-populated,corrupt, education worth shit overseas, police incompetent.
yzia2009 2 years ago
@yzia2009 Listen dude.. u can say wtever u want bout ur country.. dont say any shit about India.. problems are there with every country... the need is to solve those problems.. and if India were such a "horrible" country.. there wudnt be so many ppl defending it here.. Indian education is not worth shit overseas (IIMs, IITs).. pollution is coming down in all major cities (use of CNG).. as are illiteracy, corruption and filth.. I invite you to India.. come and see fr urself hw it is prospering..
rohitcbs12 1 year ago
can any one tell me what is her point?
ramPrare23 2 years ago
u would never get it cos u dont seem to want to
southsidegyan 2 years ago
I have done my MBA from a college in India. People from all over India were there.. of all religions and castes and creed. You will never be able to imagine the amount of respect we have for each other. And the amount of respect we have for India. We all come frm diff parts of the country, how do we share this view? There was energy because of the diversity of the group and our being with each other and bailing the other person out. That is what India is about. It is about humanity, and oneness.
rohitcbs12 2 years ago
Ms. Roy.. have u ever wondered why are you so popular in Pakistan.. ?? because in a very evident way, you just confirm every whim that any Pakistani with ill-wishes against India has. I would just like to ask you one thing: Do you believe in the concept of India..?? not the execution of dat concept but the very concept that all kinds of people can live and prosper in harmony ?? At least India has got that right unlike a lot of other countries u like to visit..
rohitcbs12 2 years ago
It is because of people like you that brand all pakistanis as haters and enemies of India that we still aren't able to acheive a true friendship between us. OPEN YOUR MIND & HEART! Ignorant thinking like yours is spreading too much hate. Ms Roy isnt a nationlist which is why she's able to point out the faults within India and any other nation. The things she says are undeniably true and supported by facts- not just empty propaganda. People from all over the world love and trust her!
sweetkitty20008 2 years ago
i agree with sweetkitty, we need more indians like that in india...
hawakajhonka1 2 years ago
We don't need friendship.. a "mind ur own business" attitude will do.. !! I am all for pointing out faults with India.. I am not saying my country is perfect.. but this woman.. is totally out of her league talking on nationalist issues.. her views on everything are nothing but sensationalist.. she just wants the limelight.. n dats y i've never seen her sayin anything gud about India.. hence my question abt the concept of India... which is just plain common sense.. and isn't flawed in any way !!
rohitcbs12 2 years ago
the execution of the concept is ovbiously non-existant- on a social level, political level, legal level etc & it will never be executed unless people speak out against it. This is what people like her are trying to do. Nobody is questioning the concept. They are questioning the contrasting actions that being executed against the concept. There is no point to a concept that isn't being adhered to. This why India, US, Israel etc. is just bad as the countries they are supposedly trying to reform.
sweetkitty20008 2 years ago
@sweetkitty20008
Exactly.. !! what i wanted to say was this only.. the concept of India is sound and noble.. and I agree, execution hasnt been perfect.. but we're getting there.. and the majority of Indians realize that..
Anyway.. what i wud like is to hear her praise the concept.. make people aware and use positivity to bring about change instead of the news grabbing stuff she has become used to..
rohitcbs12 2 years ago
@rohitcbs12 well said rohit....i just have one thing to say to mrs roy....if u have a problem with india,juss stay out of india,we know very well how to love and live in our beloved nation,and for pakistaan,if u love so much to hear about poverty and inequality and woman deprivation....u might juss love to read a newspaper from pakistan,it must be filled with all this,or may be not...ohh i forgot..."the freedom of media and speech" have u people heard of it ,it actually exists u know :)
marathi1214 1 year ago
Obviously she is thrilled. I wish she makes pakistan as her home the place of the pure where she belongs.
Metaemipricus 2 years ago
god bless arundhati. she is fantastic every time she says something.
shankyxyz 2 years ago
Roy must speak her mind regarding the issue of Pak Army's brutalities in Sindh and Balochistan as well. The reason being, that she holds immense prestige where everybody deems her as an independent political analyst.
sekhat1661 2 years ago
@sekhat1661 criticizing state for every wrong doing doesn't make her political analyst, she is media attention whore.............................
rohitshaikh 1 year ago
@rohitshaikh
And you are a bad grammar whore.
Sorry, but one brute and uninsightful comment deserves another.
Chronone 1 year ago
@Chronone
when you will loose some of your family members to some terrorist attacks
she will hold press conference to protect human rights of those terrorist ,
that time you understand my comment and regret yours .
rohitshaikh 1 year ago
@sekhat1661
im baloch and proud pakistani so let us sort out our problems, go fix ur endless problems
S2000XC 8 months ago 6
Comment removed
seesaw128 2 years ago
Brilliant !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
oceanbound222 2 years ago 13
ارندھتی رائے ملکوں اور ریاستوں کی حدود سے آزاد ایک اسی باشعور خاتون ہیں جنہیں صحیح معنوں میں دنیا کا شہری کہا جا سکتا ہے۔ وہ اتنی ہی پاکستانی ہیں جتنی وہ ہندوستانی ہیں۔ جاری۔
cemendtaur 2 years ago
یہ بات کراچی والوں کے لیے باعث فخر ہے کہ وہ کراچی آئیں اور انہوں نے پریس کلب میں لوگوں سے خطاب کیا۔ کاش کہ وہ ہر سال کم از کم ایک بار کراچی کا دورہ ضرور کیا کریں۔ ہمیں ان کی روشن خیالی سے مستقل مستفید ہونے کی شدید ضرورت ہے۔
cemendtaur 2 years ago
you are amazing ms.roy! please continue to visit pakistan!
76corollacoldrain 2 years ago