michael is singing with them ! LITERALLY ! in the ORIGINAL song.. he did 12 WOOS... nd how come on the last part before "You didnt give a damn" he says
"what if I lived again" ???? 0_o ALSO... RIGHT before that part STARTS.. Usher lifts his mic to begin singing.. Michael's original version to this song sounds completely different.. he is DEFINITELY singing along with them therefore.. he's NOT dead.. nd u cant see it cuz they cut to the vid.. but as he's singin everyone looks up to him.. balcony
i thought this was a very pleasing tribute, but if i can just voice my opinion for a quick second. I think usher is a very solid performer and the closest to MJ that we have right now, but i do think that he didn't take this tribute seriously. If you seriously watch his movements and things, he's on the floor crawling, dancing, moving all around stage, unnecessary things. His vocals were the worst on stage, and he didn't seem to be in it for the right reasons. love Jennifer's part though
Isn't it funny how when he was alive no-one gave two s%!ts about the man and do nothing but slate and publicly humiliate him. Then he dies and all of a sudden he's hailed by the press as a Legend which by the way he has always been. His Bad album was without doubt the best i've ever heard. R.I.P
usher sucked, i was a little disappointed, because at the climax of the song, they turned down celines voice, you can tell from the recordings and rehearsals that her voice resonates more..
Michael, i love you soooooo much, no one can ever compare to your talents and your gifts, thank you for all of your beautiful music, all of my kids will l hear about the king of pop! You are the most talented singer of all time!!!!! I love you Michael Jackson!!!!!!!!!!!
Just because the color of Carrie Underwood's skin,doesn't mean she shouldn't be able to perform in Micheal's Tribute.And to be honest,Carrie Underwood sounded better than Celine,Smokey,and Usher.Especially in the verse they where singing what about us.Don't be a hater. (:
WHOW!!!! SIMPLY WONDERFUL, AWESOME, UNBELIEVABLE!!!! WHY MICHAEL IS DONE ? WE MISS YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU WILL STAY IN OUR HEARTS FOREVER!!
Anyone notice that will.i.am was crying at 3:33? During Smokey's part, will.i.am's so into it, he's tearing up, look closely at his eyes. Remember he worked with Michael, he said that he was an amazing person. Will's great in my book and a true class act, I think Michael himself would've been proud of his friends performing this song like this, this was an amazing moment at the Grammys.
charice would've killed this perfomance, man, if her perfomance with Ne-Yo at David Foster tour was just breathtaking, imagine with celine dion jennifer hudson and carrie. omfg i get goosebumps just by thinking about that.
Great quality video but I really think that Michael would've liked for his speech at the beginning to stay so that it would create a purpose for the rest of the performance.
I was happy that these five were chosen, because they are five artists that can downright sing!!! And they all have different styles, which is good, because there is no comparison between them. THEY'RE AWESOME IN THEIR OWN WAY, AND THEY DID A WONDERFUL JOB WITH THIS SONG!!! MICHAEL WOULD'VE BEEN PROUD!!!
Usher's little "fall on my knees so people know how serious and passionate I am" stunt was a little pathetic. Get over yourself Usher. Other than that it was great.
The best performance of my young life. I truly wish those who can't feel the power could because it is overwhelming beautiful empowering and just amazing. This song is meant to go past your ears and into your soul and sometimes it doesn't which is sad but for those who can hear it for what it is I am so happy for you.
@xotrendz yup, CARRIE UNDERWOOD. 5 x Grammy winner with a HUGE voice who absolutely killed her part, and was hand-picked by MJ's own brother to pay tribute to The King Of Pop, since he was a fan of hers. You're mad because she's a white country singer? Girl's still got pipes til heaven and more than held her own in the performance. Get the fuck outa here with that hate.
Michael had specifically stated before his death that he has "a great admiration for Carrie Underwood".
So, when they asked Carrie to perform a tribute, of course she said yes. Quite honestly, I'm proud that they respected Michael's admiration for her and asked her to sing. I'm sure it would have made him proud as she really brought some variety and added flavor by lifting the performance with her vocal talents on her lines.
You know that song how they all came togehter and sang it was the most chilling goose bumping song I hve heard in a long time. They all did a fantastic job in relaying michaels message
Todo esta bien.... lo peor de todo USHER.... fue una gran idiotez decirle que participara, su voz no encaja, y no llega a las notas.... del resto, preciosa cancion y las interpretaciones de celine, carrie, y jennifer me estremesen
Celine Dion and Jennifer were flawless in this song..Celine showed technique and professionalism singing , Jennifer kicked some butt with that big 'What' in the end , I loved it.Carrie was a bit out of tune , Usher was really bad , Smokey was great , I liked him too.Overall , great great performance.
@MonikaAhatX Carrie and Celine were amazing. Carrie was particularly surprising seeing as she doesn't normally dabble in that genre of music. Her "ravaging the seas, burned despite our pleas" was the highlight of that night!
@MonikaAhatX If you think Celine Dion was the only one who performed well on stage, you are sorely mistaken. Yes, Usher and Carrie Underwood were bad. Jennifer Hudson has a much bigger and more skillful voice than Celine Dion. Smokey Robinson also sings like a seasoned singer. Do you even know who Smokey Robinson is? Learn to listen for technique and accurate pitch. Celine Dion sounds bad at the beginning when she enters.
@JerryRSun oOh my dear you are totally wrong. i know who is Smokey Robinson but still his voice is No Competition to Celine. And don't even compare amateur Jennifer Hudson to such Divas like Celine. You sound very silly. What? Celine sounds brilliant at the beginning darling
@MonikaAhatX It means nothing to call Jennifer Hudson an amateur or to say that Smokey Robinson doesn't compare to Celine. I think Celine is good, but try to listen with a critical ear and not with preconceived bias and you'll agree with me that Jennifer has much better control and power than Celine. Celine Dion is not the best singer by any stretch of the imagination. There are many singers who are technically better than her.
@JerryRSun I love Smokey Robinson and really respect him but please....Celine wins in every department of singing. By the way, even musical critics said that her performance was the most impressive and memorable so I guess they know more than u and me. J.Hudson has a voice but people definitely overrate her vocal abilities and there are many singers better than Hudson including Leona Lewis, C.Aguilera, Beyonce, A.Keys etc. They have way better vocal abilities.
@JerryRSun LMFAO @ "Carrie was bad." You officially have zero credibility. All of the reviews, including those from MJ fans, praised her part in this performance.
@mellynumerounoo Carrie was bad in comparison to Jennifer Hudson and Smokey Robinson, or Michael. But I have a feeling there's no reasoning with someone like you.
@JerryRSun lmfao, how was she bad compared to either one of them? Not only was her voice just as strong as theirs, she also sang perfectly in tune. Yes, there's "no reasoning with someone like me" because unlike you, my ass isn't tone-deaf. Carrie got RAVE reviews for her performance, and once again, was HAND-PICKED by the brother of The King himself. Suck on that.
@JerryRSun The only thing "bad" in this equation is your hearing apparently, because virtually everyone else lavished Carrie with nothing but praise for her great contribution to the tribute. Her voice was strong, raw, powerful, and soulful. I can't help but feel as though your comment is racially motivated since Carrie is a white country singer. But she had EVERY bit the fire power as Jennifer Hudson and Smokey Robinson in this performance, even though it isn't as much her genre.
Replacing Carrie? WTF? She was the best singer on the stage 3:13 - 3:27 is totally the best part of the song, she sounds AMAZING!!! Jennifer was also really good, and Celine as well. I wouldn't change any of the women.
@batfan903 How do you even dare suggesting Carrie be replaced? She was by far Michael's female equivalent on that stage. Yeah, those singers you suggested are great but no one could have taken Carrie's and Celine's part. As much as I like Britney, she could not have delivered on this song!
Listen i saw that you're Carrie's fan but sorry Michael has no equal. You can hate me for saying that but that's the truth. I am also a Britney fan but still I can't compare her with Michael.Although Celine or Carrie ar good singers Michael has no equal, no match.Even if Carrie would have been replaced here on this stage by other singer, no matter who it is Michael has no equal.
So these comments here saying that Carrie or Celine should have been replaced have no relevance.
How the fuck can u dislike this?
sammoyer7 3 days ago
guys chill usher just hit a bad note! that doesn't mean he can't sing! ill bet u if he tried it again it would come out just fine!
tolisPOLOLIS 3 weeks ago
I don't think Carrie belonged in that group
TheTrackgirl1 1 month ago
@TheTrackgirl1 well, your high
fishinetsu400 2 weeks ago
Celine!!!!!!
neerrg 1 month ago 3
Jennifer's voice is not pleasant.
LexieHaddon 1 month ago
3:03
Rihanna- "I am not amused. -.-"
Kaiuchka 1 month ago
Usher owned it!
DavidSchifone 1 month ago
OMG! BAD IDEA.
kevinpunongbayan 1 month ago
YOU ARE ALL TRYING SO FUCKING HARD TO IMMITATE MJ. TOO BAD! MJ IS STILL THE BEST. SO FUNNY USHER!!!! :D
kevinpunongbayan 1 month ago
@kevinpunongbayan Imitate? do you know what the word tribute means???? Cause thats the point of this.....dumbass
neerrg 1 month ago
Jennifer Hudson and Celine Dion ---------
RhysssR14 1 month ago
Carrie Underwood 3
lilrockstr 1 month ago
USHER & CELINE DION The BESTS
doullax 1 month ago
I'm sorry but usher is doing way to damn much I can understand that the song is powerful but come on now YOU......R......NOT.........MJ OKAY? lol
QplusH 1 month ago
Jennifer Hudson's entrance was divalicious.. didn't even take a simple look to Celine lol!
DaliaChild 2 months ago
RIP MICHAEL !
atleticoprterror 2 months ago
Celine dion THE BEST !!!!!
Gor8006 2 months ago 4
Jennifer Hudson ruled that
leeleedejong 2 months ago
Haha.. Celine is the best on taht stage.. She could be superior, but she gives of course the other a chance! ;)
Nofiih 2 months ago
Usher is so damn extra
alexanderson010 2 months ago
ps did you guys also heard what if i lived again/ what if i died again would you give a damn ?
maximc93 2 months ago
when usher started singing at 3:05 the song was screwed up the man at 3:37 had the are you kidding me/wtf face xD
maximc93 2 months ago
Besides the amazing performance of this song i will never get over 3:34. PRICELESS.
arich31590 3 months ago
loving celine dion here, she's looking amazing""""""
MayaSummers 3 months ago
Carrie and Jennifer all the way!!!!
softballgirl100100 3 months ago
im here cause melanie Amaro!
oaklandfc28 3 months ago
@dejan19990 She said "What about crying whales"
MrLiquidjcb13 3 months ago
WHAT ABOUT KANYE WEST =))
borrowedangels 3 months ago
This made me cry
WrRaIt 3 months ago
MJ's voice is fucking epic, gotta love his angry singing from the 90s onwards.
DoctorCapitalist 3 months ago
michael is singing with them ! LITERALLY ! in the ORIGINAL song.. he did 12 WOOS... nd how come on the last part before "You didnt give a damn" he says
"what if I lived again" ???? 0_o ALSO... RIGHT before that part STARTS.. Usher lifts his mic to begin singing.. Michael's original version to this song sounds completely different.. he is DEFINITELY singing along with them therefore.. he's NOT dead.. nd u cant see it cuz they cut to the vid.. but as he's singin everyone looks up to him.. balcony
jeifresh123 4 months ago
love Michael Jackson...love Celine Dion..
nelson520sammuel 4 months ago
i thought this was a very pleasing tribute, but if i can just voice my opinion for a quick second. I think usher is a very solid performer and the closest to MJ that we have right now, but i do think that he didn't take this tribute seriously. If you seriously watch his movements and things, he's on the floor crawling, dancing, moving all around stage, unnecessary things. His vocals were the worst on stage, and he didn't seem to be in it for the right reasons. love Jennifer's part though
Rock36Star 4 months ago
Will.I.Am Looks dead :P
cutiecarol123 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Michael Jackson sang, the world hoped.
Michael Jackson danced, the world smiled.
Michael Jackson laughed, the world laughed.
Michael Jackson died, the world cried, but sang, danced, laughed because we know that's what he would've wanted.
Michael Jackson was Michael Jackson, and always will be.
We are all Michael Jackson when we cry, sing, dance and laugh.
Post this on every Michael Jackson video you see today, and thumbs up if you agree with this
DjJon810 4 months ago
Carrie was incredible!!!!! Miss you MJ!!!!
BOOMERPETE1 4 months ago
Usher...retournes chez toi tu gâches tout !
kimcattralouh 4 months ago
Isn't it funny how when he was alive no-one gave two s%!ts about the man and do nothing but slate and publicly humiliate him. Then he dies and all of a sudden he's hailed by the press as a Legend which by the way he has always been. His Bad album was without doubt the best i've ever heard. R.I.P
Poopy2308 5 months ago
Everyone on that stage is classy. Except Usher. Fail.
JerryO89 5 months ago 2
usher sucked, i was a little disappointed, because at the climax of the song, they turned down celines voice, you can tell from the recordings and rehearsals that her voice resonates more..
Krobra91 6 months ago
@Krobra91 He was great...His first line in the big chorus was kind of iffy, but he was great.
gamefreak9210 5 months ago
love u michael
wupassable 6 months ago
Happy Birthday Michael.
Potooful 6 months ago
Michael, i love you soooooo much, no one can ever compare to your talents and your gifts, thank you for all of your beautiful music, all of my kids will l hear about the king of pop! You are the most talented singer of all time!!!!! I love you Michael Jackson!!!!!!!!!!!
SinfulAlchemist 6 months ago
I love you michael jackson you have a heart of gold rip ):
oliviaketoff 6 months ago
Michael, I love you so much. Thanks for blessing us with your music. We will always remember you.
sthannes 6 months ago
usher kinda killed it not so talted vocally
kevin5655 7 months ago
Michael was murdered by the world elite, they did not want his messages to spread
SPREAD THE TRUTH
tokersrule 7 months ago
i am crying ILY MICHEAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :'(
TaylorAlexis334 7 months ago
3:54 withJennifer Hudson gives me chills every time. Amazing.
GingerCritic1 7 months ago 12
This made me cry ALL the way through!!!! :'( I miss him so much....
billiejarmstronglvr 8 months ago
This makes me cry every single time...
scottluvsjenna 8 months ago
Just because the color of Carrie Underwood's skin,doesn't mean she shouldn't be able to perform in Micheal's Tribute.And to be honest,Carrie Underwood sounded better than Celine,Smokey,and Usher.Especially in the verse they where singing what about us.Don't be a hater. (:
lilrockstr 8 months ago
Carrie,Celion,Jennifer,Smokey =great (: Usher=Terrible (:
lilrockstr 8 months ago
Anyone else notice will.i.am tearing up during Smokey's part at 3:34? That's how powerful this song is. Michael would be proud of this.
PrimeTimeJokesta 8 months ago
Even when he has been in heaven, his voice are still the loudest.
God bless you, Michael.
DQLePhat 8 months ago
Jennifer was the best performer! She hit every single note on pitch! MJ would be very proud.
BigBlueBeast 8 months ago
Look @ jay bopping on da left of beyonce
2lovlife 9 months ago
...Wow. Took me to the third play to realise this recording is backwards (ie. Look at the logo in the left-hand corner has been flipped)
Either I'm slow, or the performance was so good I never bothered to notice everyone's in a parallel universe :D
Bananaphoneinc 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHOW!!!! SIMPLY WONDERFUL, AWESOME, UNBELIEVABLE!!!! WHY MICHAEL IS DONE ? WE MISS YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU WILL STAY IN OUR HEARTS FOREVER!!
TokyoForever1981 9 months ago
Comment removed
TokyoForever1981 9 months ago
Michael Jackson was killlin them and he wasn't even there...His voice is just so unique and none can do it like him. I love you, Michael... RIP! :(
heywassupification 10 months ago
One of my most favorite songs he has sung. The government should listen to this.
RosesNightengales 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wtf is up with rihanna >> shes so full of her self !
aranamin 11 months ago
Comment removed
aranamin 11 months ago
Anyone notice that will.i.am was crying at 3:33? During Smokey's part, will.i.am's so into it, he's tearing up, look closely at his eyes. Remember he worked with Michael, he said that he was an amazing person. Will's great in my book and a true class act, I think Michael himself would've been proud of his friends performing this song like this, this was an amazing moment at the Grammys.
PrimeTimeJokesta 11 months ago
2:02 LOL
paulita078 1 year ago
if you say carrie sounded/is/was bad you hace no ears... DEAL WITH IT
oscarrr99 1 year ago
celine perfect !!!!!!!!!
pepe60627 1 year ago
charice would've killed this perfomance, man, if her perfomance with Ne-Yo at David Foster tour was just breathtaking, imagine with celine dion jennifer hudson and carrie. omfg i get goosebumps just by thinking about that.
MrEliudNeto 1 year ago
Amazing.
tinytwin29 1 year ago
Great quality video but I really think that Michael would've liked for his speech at the beginning to stay so that it would create a purpose for the rest of the performance.
bonnieblunt 1 year ago
i love carrie.... carrie... carrie....
LippyCarrieGaga 1 year ago
ewww smokey can go somewhere
itzarexx 1 year ago
I was happy that these five were chosen, because they are five artists that can downright sing!!! And they all have different styles, which is good, because there is no comparison between them. THEY'RE AWESOME IN THEIR OWN WAY, AND THEY DID A WONDERFUL JOB WITH THIS SONG!!! MICHAEL WOULD'VE BEEN PROUD!!!
TrillLibra93 1 year ago
from somaliy all the bust good forgive him
hx37077 1 year ago
good
hx37077 1 year ago
I love that Carrie is out there
Tenma20 1 year ago
Usher's little "fall on my knees so people know how serious and passionate I am" stunt was a little pathetic. Get over yourself Usher. Other than that it was great.
burbscinates 1 year ago 3
At 2:45 I ALWAYS crack up. Beyonce's too funny.
burbscinates 1 year ago 9
I.heart.MJ
<3
scottluvsjenna 1 year ago
Diva Beyonce
davidbeyoncemoya09 1 year ago
1:52 I Saw Beyonce
davidbeyoncemoya09 1 year ago
The best performance of my young life. I truly wish those who can't feel the power could because it is overwhelming beautiful empowering and just amazing. This song is meant to go past your ears and into your soul and sometimes it doesn't which is sad but for those who can hear it for what it is I am so happy for you.
Darkchild393 1 year ago
will.i.am killlllssss me in this video
hardrider2 1 year ago 3
i luv how will i am and rihanna look all pissy and then beyonces like WOO haha
TheEverChance 1 year ago
wtf carrie underwood really
xotrendz 1 year ago
@xotrendz yup, CARRIE UNDERWOOD. 5 x Grammy winner with a HUGE voice who absolutely killed her part, and was hand-picked by MJ's own brother to pay tribute to The King Of Pop, since he was a fan of hers. You're mad because she's a white country singer? Girl's still got pipes til heaven and more than held her own in the performance. Get the fuck outa here with that hate.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@mellynumerounoo i was just saying i was surprised to see her in the mix dearrr calm down thanks
xotrendz 1 year ago
Why was Carrie here?
This was not a random addition.
Michael had specifically stated before his death that he has "a great admiration for Carrie Underwood".
So, when they asked Carrie to perform a tribute, of course she said yes. Quite honestly, I'm proud that they respected Michael's admiration for her and asked her to sing. I'm sure it would have made him proud as she really brought some variety and added flavor by lifting the performance with her vocal talents on her lines.
Enjoy and love
clearcrimson 1 year ago 74
@clearcrimson awwww
avarix98 1 year ago
@clearcrimson I agree one hundred percent. All of these people questioning Carrie's presence are clearly ignorant. It's rather upsetting.
PlayOnCarrie 1 year ago
@clearcrimson Then why Carrie says "What about Kanye West....." at 3:15 :P
dejan19990 7 months ago 29
@dejan19990
What about crying whales
minimonberg34 7 months ago
@minimonberg34 its a joke dude , chill out
dejan19990 7 months ago
@dejan19990
I'm not a DUDE, I'm a girl
minimonberg34 7 months ago
@minimonberg34 DAMN.Sorry <3<3<3
dejan19990 7 months ago
@dejan19990
It's alright <3
You couldt know when it dosen't say anywhere <3 <3 <3
minimonberg34 7 months ago
@dejan19990
Like I said, It's alright :D
minimonberg34 7 months ago
@dejan19990 I know, and Usher says "What about Elmo?!" Didn't know he was such a Sesame Street fan! LOL
gilbertgonzalezjr 2 months ago
@dejan19990
That would be "what about killin whales..."
Right2Carry1911 2 weeks ago
OMG I got goosebumps hearing this song (in a good way)
they all have such strong voices and they sounded really good together
loved it
tashke94 1 year ago
luv this, luv jennifer hudson
bmjw06 1 year ago
You know that song how they all came togehter and sang it was the most chilling goose bumping song I hve heard in a long time. They all did a fantastic job in relaying michaels message
squirt3313 1 year ago
Todo esta bien.... lo peor de todo USHER.... fue una gran idiotez decirle que participara, su voz no encaja, y no llega a las notas.... del resto, preciosa cancion y las interpretaciones de celine, carrie, y jennifer me estremesen
gatboy 1 year ago
#1 This song performance was amazing
#2 They all sounded WONDERFUL
#3 Carrie was brilliant and she did NOT need replacing
#4 Jennifer . . . Wow.
PlayOnCarrie 1 year ago 10
oh my god, love celines legs. ;o but I loved the whole performance, so great they did this! loved seeing Beyoncé too, she's a TrueType fan.
deborahlovesmj 1 year ago
THAT WAS THE MOST BRILLIANT THING IVE EVER HEARD IN MAH LIFE HAHA
TheEverChance 1 year ago
OMG !
Usher is just incredible in 3 minutes !! The ultime high notes....
loudghiri6 1 year ago
Jennifer Jennifer Jennifer, what an amazing voice that "what" was a amazing so much power and emotion
darrian202 1 year ago 2
WOOW! YOU PPL ARE CRAZYY! COMPARING ARTIST... WOW... LISTEN TO THE SONG PLEASE!!! & IT LOOKS LIKE BEYONCE WAS REALLY FEELIN THIS SONG!
maliklik95 1 year ago 4
They shoulda gotten beyonce in there instead of carrie or summit she would be really good in this song and she loved michael so much
grantalex31 1 year ago
@grantalex31 She dissed their family so of course MJ's brother didn't pick her...
Fodemanga 1 year ago
WTF!!! o_0 3:02
yassin166 1 year ago 3
we miss you mj..dis video really made me cry
mjkrazyhugefan 1 year ago
usherrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr <3
burimpacolli 1 year ago
nice
burimpacolli 1 year ago
Celine Dion and Jennifer were flawless in this song..Celine showed technique and professionalism singing , Jennifer kicked some butt with that big 'What' in the end , I loved it.Carrie was a bit out of tune , Usher was really bad , Smokey was great , I liked him too.Overall , great great performance.
LittleBigArtist 1 year ago
mrs hudson gives me goose bumps every time she sings
tarun139 1 year ago
what are you ppl talking about? they all did AWESOME. this was amazing and they all sounded and performed professionally and exceptionally.
TheEverChance 1 year ago
in order of the best imo smokey, hudson, underwood, dion and usher.
esco42085 1 year ago
Celine Dion was the only one who showed brilliant and very professional singing. All others looked like simple fillers.
MonikaAhatX 1 year ago 9
@MonikaAhatX Carrie and Celine were amazing. Carrie was particularly surprising seeing as she doesn't normally dabble in that genre of music. Her "ravaging the seas, burned despite our pleas" was the highlight of that night!
Myra1991JR 1 year ago
@MonikaAhatX If you think Celine Dion was the only one who performed well on stage, you are sorely mistaken. Yes, Usher and Carrie Underwood were bad. Jennifer Hudson has a much bigger and more skillful voice than Celine Dion. Smokey Robinson also sings like a seasoned singer. Do you even know who Smokey Robinson is? Learn to listen for technique and accurate pitch. Celine Dion sounds bad at the beginning when she enters.
JerryRSun 1 year ago
@JerryRSun oOh my dear you are totally wrong. i know who is Smokey Robinson but still his voice is No Competition to Celine. And don't even compare amateur Jennifer Hudson to such Divas like Celine. You sound very silly. What? Celine sounds brilliant at the beginning darling
MonikaAhatX 1 year ago
@MonikaAhatX It means nothing to call Jennifer Hudson an amateur or to say that Smokey Robinson doesn't compare to Celine. I think Celine is good, but try to listen with a critical ear and not with preconceived bias and you'll agree with me that Jennifer has much better control and power than Celine. Celine Dion is not the best singer by any stretch of the imagination. There are many singers who are technically better than her.
JerryRSun 1 year ago
@JerryRSun I love Smokey Robinson and really respect him but please....Celine wins in every department of singing. By the way, even musical critics said that her performance was the most impressive and memorable so I guess they know more than u and me. J.Hudson has a voice but people definitely overrate her vocal abilities and there are many singers better than Hudson including Leona Lewis, C.Aguilera, Beyonce, A.Keys etc. They have way better vocal abilities.
MonikaAhatX 1 year ago
@JerryRSun LMFAO @ "Carrie was bad." You officially have zero credibility. All of the reviews, including those from MJ fans, praised her part in this performance.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@mellynumerounoo Carrie was bad in comparison to Jennifer Hudson and Smokey Robinson, or Michael. But I have a feeling there's no reasoning with someone like you.
JerryRSun 1 year ago
@JerryRSun lmfao, how was she bad compared to either one of them? Not only was her voice just as strong as theirs, she also sang perfectly in tune. Yes, there's "no reasoning with someone like me" because unlike you, my ass isn't tone-deaf. Carrie got RAVE reviews for her performance, and once again, was HAND-PICKED by the brother of The King himself. Suck on that.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@JerryRSun The only thing "bad" in this equation is your hearing apparently, because virtually everyone else lavished Carrie with nothing but praise for her great contribution to the tribute. Her voice was strong, raw, powerful, and soulful. I can't help but feel as though your comment is racially motivated since Carrie is a white country singer. But she had EVERY bit the fire power as Jennifer Hudson and Smokey Robinson in this performance, even though it isn't as much her genre.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@MonikaAhatX i think smokey robinson did a lil more
princev11 1 year ago
@MonikaAhatX well, that's why she's the QUEEN. CELINE FOREVER =). She looks absolutely incredible in this vid
insideurheaven 1 year ago 2
@MonikaAhatX You forgot Usher.
2pac4e 1 year ago
Replacing Carrie? WTF? She was the best singer on the stage 3:13 - 3:27 is totally the best part of the song, she sounds AMAZING!!! Jennifer was also really good, and Celine as well. I wouldn't change any of the women.
sharapova4eva 1 year ago 2
My suggestions that would have helped this song:
Celine's replacement: Barbra S, Gloria E, Patti Labelle
Carrie's replacement: Britney, Beyonce, or Christina!
batfan903 1 year ago
I agree Beyoncé should have sung this aswell :)
HUGOM2C 1 year ago
@batfan903 How do you even dare suggesting Carrie be replaced? She was by far Michael's female equivalent on that stage. Yeah, those singers you suggested are great but no one could have taken Carrie's and Celine's part. As much as I like Britney, she could not have delivered on this song!
Myra1991JR 1 year ago 5
@Myra1991JR
Listen i saw that you're Carrie's fan but sorry Michael has no equal. You can hate me for saying that but that's the truth. I am also a Britney fan but still I can't compare her with Michael.Although Celine or Carrie ar good singers Michael has no equal, no match.Even if Carrie would have been replaced here on this stage by other singer, no matter who it is Michael has no equal.
So these comments here saying that Carrie or Celine should have been replaced have no relevance.
MichaelJacksongenius 1 year ago 3
i almost cried seeing this. it's amazing.
i think michael would have been proud
melmart94 1 year ago
i loved it dont understand y hudson is there and not janet but still loved it
kayteeelle 2 years ago
@kayteeelle Janet was asked to do it but she denied becaue she wasnt ready... :)
pcdfan87 1 year ago
*agree
MelWolff 2 years ago
O_O!!
im totally agreed with emercute98
MelWolff 2 years ago
it's mirrored!!!
emercute98 2 years ago
@emercute98 DUH! since they are since ALONG With mihael in sme parts!!!~!!
pcdfan87 1 year ago
i cant understand you...
emercute98 1 year ago
@emercute98 you said its mirrored which means its the same..i said yeah because they are singing along with michael..
pcdfan87 1 year ago
@pcdfan87 okay.. :)
emercute98 1 year ago