even though the group has disbanded but the song has been playing in my mind for the past few weeks. When they debuted they were so awesome, but when they cameback with dynamite, most of the fans dissapeared. Boo DSP for not giving good and better songs for them just like SS501 and KARA. They deserve so much better y'know :/ I wish to see them as a group again :(
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
@SgHan92 > me too but his charismatic shown when him singing while dancing...not only static at one place n singing....n think hanbyul miss dancing so much coz i've seen other video while he's in monday kiz n he look very cheerful when fan ask him to dance...
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK... i also missed the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK... i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK, he still wanna dancing if has a request...i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
I mad thy disbanded i balme dsp they are to much into kara and ss501 when they have a perfect groip right here i think they werent promoting them or let alone doing anything with them when they probly have a ton of fans i pissedp
i liked this performance. they have improve a lot from their first live performance. they still need to tweak somethings though. tomo moved the mic too fast each time after he sang. i loveddd ingyu's rap. xD gave me tingles. jangmoon seems to be gaining more confidence! :) loved everyone else.
they are pretty good in live as a newbie. the sound is catchy but there is no real concept for this group (since we pretty much see this in dbsk, suju and ss501 too). if the company were to give this group a different concept, they might become more known.
i want to see this group grow, they do have talent and it's up to the company now.
I insist they need to work on the mic, haha, need more experience in lives and all. I think they are still quite nervous and need more confidence in their performances.
They sing acapella very well so I know they are pretty talented.
appa is actually pretty good in live. i think its just the whole dancing while singing thing. cuz in Naega Baboyeosseo appa's voice is <3 they just need to have more practice with breathing.
This live performence was more better than last performence in M!countdown...But HAIMING really need more practice since he is beneath other member (in singing)...
They need to practice in holding their mics properly. I have to say Hanbyul redeemed everyone in this perf. He is so amazing here. *g* and Jangmoon's voice was still awesome<3
it was better than last time, but not good enough to stop the criticisms...but did anyone else hear jungjin's voice @ 1:55? XD i'm sry, but that's just proof they need to work on their live
it was overall good cause they did better with their voice and still kept on with their dance moves. Also i didn't really hear anyone who sounded like they were out of breath.
well, i know that much but just cuz they were better doesn't mean what i said wasn't true. they're competing against some strong vocals in the entertainment world.
also, tomoki was out of breath here. surprising, but yes. listen to it again.
the mics were changing in volume range towards the beginning...but overall the perf was ok...some of the members still need to practice singing and dancing at the same time
Comment removed
PatriciaTuugamusu 1 month ago
DOES ANYONE HAVE ANY NEWS OF THEM??? WHERE THE MEMBERS ARE NOW AND WHAT THEY ARE DOING?? HAVE THEY GONE BACK TO LIVING LIKE A NORMAL PERSON???
afgnaz 9 months ago
even though the group has disbanded but the song has been playing in my mind for the past few weeks. When they debuted they were so awesome, but when they cameback with dynamite, most of the fans dissapeared. Boo DSP for not giving good and better songs for them just like SS501 and KARA. They deserve so much better y'know :/ I wish to see them as a group again :(
deathgon 9 months ago 3
Love Jangmoon!!
DrowingIntoHatred 1 year ago
*sniffsniff* I want them to perform together again. WHY DID THEY DISBAND?!
Iciebleu 1 year ago 3
WHY DID THEY HAVE TO BREAK WHY WHY : (
I MISS THEM PERFORMING TOGETHER
Nii0109 1 year ago
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
missapple23 1 year ago
@missapple23 do you know that hanbyul has came back as one of the new members of Monday kiz?? I like his new style more than previous one;;
SgHan92 1 year ago
@SgHan92 > me too but his charismatic shown when him singing while dancing...not only static at one place n singing....n think hanbyul miss dancing so much coz i've seen other video while he's in monday kiz n he look very cheerful when fan ask him to dance...
missapple23 1 year ago
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK... i also missed the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
missapple23 1 year ago
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK... i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
missapple23 1 year ago
so sad when this happen...i love to hear hanbyul's voice and his dance...he has some charisma that make me paralyse when he singing or dancing...but after this i just can hear him singing only....for information, hanbyul is join with monday kiz....i know he love dancing so much...i can see it even after he join MK, he still wanna dancing if has a request...i also miss the others too and really hope they never breakup and this is just a dream...DSP SO CRUEL...
missapple23 1 year ago
DSP is made a big mistakefor not treasuring this young and talented guys.indeed, THEY ARE GOOD.
tvxqfreakz 1 year ago 4
Why is he holding the microphon away from his face ? I feel sorry for him , because it´s the only part he is singing solo !! :(
ashnr1 1 year ago
dang they're good live!! why the heck didnt dsp promote them more??
dsp really dont have as strong as singers like sm (actually i think sm has the best singers), but ast1 is really good!!
shame that they disbanded a group that has great vocals
jenny72089 1 year ago 3
i miss them so much. aww its too bad they broke up. but i hope to see some work from the members in the future
byakugan0074 1 year ago 2
I mad thy disbanded i balme dsp they are to much into kara and ss501 when they have a perfect groip right here i think they werent promoting them or let alone doing anything with them when they probly have a ton of fans i pissedp
batter2323 2 years ago 2
DSP please improve your management? this group has alot of potential - they need to be have more promotions! and they sound really good live.
bahbahwhiteship 2 years ago 3
i love this!!!!
my favorite kpop band ever!
ihatetokiohotel678 2 years ago 3
i sooo love this group. Tomo is just....love. ;p
evianlay 2 years ago 2
good performance. love it. thank you for sharing.
AznSao9 2 years ago 3
i'm always impressed of hanbyul's vocals!! i love him! :] and i love TOMO! XD
jiyongyong 2 years ago 4
I always like Inkyu & Tomo parts of A'ST1's songs.
popoamazing 2 years ago 5
Yay!! AStar'1 fighting!
xXDavitchiXx 2 years ago 2
yes finally some singing for real
neolookmiu 3 years ago 2
i love tomo. i like the fact that hes half japanese and half korean. thats cool. plus he speaks both languages.
meganwaltjen 3 years ago 16
who is the second one to sing???
00:34?
weiirdot 3 years ago
im pretty sure its Sung In Kyu also known as the rapper.
meganwaltjen 3 years ago
wait hold on. its not Sung In Kyu. Let me check again. I just realized it.
meganwaltjen 3 years ago
srry its Jang Moon. im sure now. sorry.
meganwaltjen 3 years ago
glad to hear that they're singing live
4y3p 3 years ago
Their tight pants are distracting... ^^;
amisam 3 years ago
the silver pants is distracting too
Amara843 3 years ago
Not their best live. But this is probably Haiming's best performance :D
TSWchelar 3 years ago
Nice combine! Love them so much!
nomeroGreen 3 years ago
Hanbyul was close to perfect in this. Still can't believe its live. damn, they're amazing
pEaCh93jam 3 years ago 2
i liked this performance. they have improve a lot from their first live performance. they still need to tweak somethings though. tomo moved the mic too fast each time after he sang. i loveddd ingyu's rap. xD gave me tingles. jangmoon seems to be gaining more confidence! :) loved everyone else.
xDiTSLAN 3 years ago
they are pretty good in live as a newbie. the sound is catchy but there is no real concept for this group (since we pretty much see this in dbsk, suju and ss501 too). if the company were to give this group a different concept, they might become more known.
i want to see this group grow, they do have talent and it's up to the company now.
verlorenlove 3 years ago
They're incredible singing live... I LOVE IT!
thevampiregod 3 years ago
jangmoon is the bestt<3
SEXY BEASTTT
jaykayyysx3 3 years ago 2
jangmoon voice quite good ^.^ i lyk his voice ^.^
pinky3040 3 years ago
I insist they need to work on the mic, haha, need more experience in lives and all. I think they are still quite nervous and need more confidence in their performances.
They sing acapella very well so I know they are pretty talented.
HWAITING! LOVE YOU A'ST1!!
LoliPi 3 years ago 2
fantastic song!!!! LOVE it!
only haiming should hold his mic better...-.-
Alpalaya 3 years ago
Aww these guys are luff :D They do need more practice but I still love them. Shinee is pretty good also.
jelloness00 3 years ago
appa is actually pretty good in live. i think its just the whole dancing while singing thing. cuz in Naega Baboyeosseo appa's voice is <3 they just need to have more practice with breathing.
other than that.
heh they're awesome <3
tamkan 3 years ago 3
I think u are trying to call them oppa, appa is father
susantng 3 years ago
a'st1 calls their leader, jungjin, appa. i was talking about jungjin xD
tamkan 3 years ago
Ah i see, i dunno well about them. Haha, trying to act smart here, my apologies:P
susantng 3 years ago
They were pretty good. =]
It was a bit shaky at first but they did better at the end.
As much as I love Tomo, I'm sorry, but you need practice hun. =(
darkcontender 3 years ago
thank u! i luv these guys, but seriously. ever since SHINee debuted, gotta step up their game. *not against SHINee*
aznrocker14 3 years ago
OMG love Jangmoon
koreangrl08 3 years ago
wow... i'm impressed
i didn't think they'd do good live
but for first timers KUDOS to them
~annie*~
iluvpanic26 3 years ago
even though hanbyul's the youngest, he's definitely got the leadership and charisma more so than the other members.
janepak 3 years ago
leader has to improve...
cherylveenc 3 years ago
This live performence was more better than last performence in M!countdown...But HAIMING really need more practice since he is beneath other member (in singing)...
JANGMOON is really good the best one~~
HANBYUL is also awesome but also need practice~~~
dickytvxq 3 years ago
What do you mean? Hanbyul did amazing.
They all need practice.
qtsoccergurl77 3 years ago
omg love jangmoon's voice!!
jaynerox91 3 years ago 2
wat is there official balloon color???
iLuVsHiN 3 years ago
I was wondering about that too. It looked green to me. =/ like, emerald green?
darkcontender 3 years ago
are u talking about their color? possible "official color"? green...never thought of that one.
aznrocker14 3 years ago
their official color is purple.
purple used to be ses's official color but, since they disbanded, it was available.
peanutbuttergummy321 3 years ago
Pearl Purple it was just out like 2 days ago ^^
GiRlli3 3 years ago
their official color is purple.
and i was going to click on reply but, i accedentally clicked on spam.
sorry.
peanutbuttergummy321 3 years ago
They need to practice in holding their mics properly. I have to say Hanbyul redeemed everyone in this perf. He is so amazing here. *g* and Jangmoon's voice was still awesome<3
schizofragile 3 years ago 4
overall it was alright but I still love their pef love them ^^
ehehe jangmoon adn hanbyul
GiRlli3 3 years ago
it was better than last time, but not good enough to stop the criticisms...but did anyone else hear jungjin's voice @ 1:55? XD i'm sry, but that's just proof they need to work on their live
BUT. i still luv them!
aznrocker14 3 years ago
it was overall good cause they did better with their voice and still kept on with their dance moves. Also i didn't really hear anyone who sounded like they were out of breath.
kimchiCHOOAH 3 years ago
well, i know that much but just cuz they were better doesn't mean what i said wasn't true. they're competing against some strong vocals in the entertainment world.
also, tomoki was out of breath here. surprising, but yes. listen to it again.
aznrocker14 3 years ago
Yeah, Tomo WAS out of the breath.
darkcontender 3 years ago 2
omgsh!!! his voice cracked....
they seriously need more practice...-__-
but it was overall ohk...;]
lilmissunshine1004 3 years ago
HangByul and Jangmoon were awesome!!!
kimchiCHOOAH 3 years ago 19
they sounded really good singing live! i think all them just need to practice singing live more ...
femmefataleartemis 3 years ago 2
I'm really impress how good they are for beginners! very proud of them.
kimchiCHOOAH 3 years ago
the mics were changing in volume range towards the beginning...but overall the perf was ok...some of the members still need to practice singing and dancing at the same time
booya1004 3 years ago 4