Added: 4 years ago
From: hollyloving
Views: 1,136,546
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (3,648)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ew dont try to make songs gross Miley

  • omg. melanie and mariah make this so much better than u miley.. but i still loving u

  • 1:23 xDDDDD

  • What's with the speed singing??? WTH...she is ruining the song.

  • I love her dress <3

  • At some parts she sounds like Janice from FRIENDS.

    But she's good.

  • Kocham ją<33 I love Miley.xD ;**

  • i feel so fucking old watching this -_- i remember waking up and this was on tv live lol

  • @Lover93music me too! I still can't believe it's been 4 years, like shit I'm old!

  • it's okay miley.. those high notes ARE kinda hard to hit, aren't they?

  • listen to miley cyrus singing this makes me happy lol im not the only one who cant do high notes :(

  • that was amazing

  • i love this song and miley cyrus

  • i usually can stand her voice ok enough but its toooo whiny for the first part -_-

  • moja ulubiona piosenkarka i piosenka

  • Ona ma taki "inny" ( w pozytywnym znaczeniu tego słowa ) głos.

    B. Ładnie jak na 15 lat. ;]

  • This was 2007 people. She was FIFTEEN. Could you sing like that when you were 15?

  • well don't compare MILEY CYRUS to MARIAH CAREY they're BOTH DIFFERENT persons in their own talented wayyssssss.. so BETTER JUST SHUT UP.

  • I think she's AMAZING!

    Yes, maybe she's not Mariah... and? She has an amazing voice, and this is an amazing song!

  • NO NO Miley Cyrus is better than her and she sould make a Christmas cd as Her and Hannah Montana

  • 900 people do not know that miley cyrus is the best singer

  • It feel of she is my best friend. All I want for Christmas is a glimp of my best friend. I really like her!

  • She is awesome...she really can sing live

  • i dont rlly luv or hate miley, but this isn't th@ bad. I mean sure she's no mariah but this isnt terrible

  • eh.....

  • How old was she when she sang this?

  • @maggieevie34 i think 14

  • its for younger kids i agree that she isnt mariah but she has the heart to sing for the kids on christmas parade

  • what the hell is this?? she can't sing!!!

  • @Gattiniable ey du behinderter sie ist die beste sängerin auf der welt!!!!!

  • SHE SUCKS!!!!!

  • Why does Miley sound better here than in all other live performances I've seen her in on tv? The girl cannot sing! Only Mariah can sing this song.

  • this seems fake...i mean seriously..when u hear someone singing don't u hear them taking a quick breath?

  • Miley is pretty good. This may not be the best song for her voice, but she doesn't suck. She did pretty well with this song considering she grew up country and she is like 14 years old here. Mariah may be better at this song, but whatever, don't come here just to hate, all you haters.

  • This performance proved top me that Miley can sing :)

  • okeeeey????

  • essa musica melhor na voz da mariah aff

  • There's a reason why Mariah gets all the adoration, magical special effects, cos players dancing on stage and big fireworks while Miley only gets a stage with some background lights. Cause Mariah's signature christmas song is ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU and she's the BEST at it. :)))

  • she ruined the song .

  • Comment removed

  • give her a break. shes like 14 here. you get up there and sing it then

  • FAIL!

  • 882 people don't like christmas -.-''

  • Well, If only Miley could sing on stage again like she did in this video... Now she's become a screamo artist :D

  • OMG!!!! Where is Esc?!!! Where is Ctrl+Alt+Del?!!

  • @EvStellciak fuck you. btw i know your mother.

  • Omg they're all maximum 7 years old. I feel so sorry for her!!

  • WOW... I can't believe people are still actually giving her a hard time... it's really annoying. Shes not ugly, She CAN sing, and shes not a whore, so just stop. Some people are just idiots.

  • SHE SUCKS.

    

  • @juddice10 totally, she sucks even more than the ppl that sings this song at the Xfactor is even better

  • @juddice10 you suck

  • @MrEdaht she doesn't

  • @juddice10 Well you shut-up .

  • booooooooo bitch get off the stage

  • @MySexymoney hmmm... wonder why u searched this video up. interesting.

  • um....... no.......... 

  • Wow, listening to the Mariah version and then this just shows how God awful Miley's voice is.

    Ew.

  • @ToxicJoon Tell me about it.

  • auto-tune ftw.

  • she is so amazing

  • No one should sing this but Mariah. Mariah Co wrote the song and sings it from the heart and has a way better voice than this Kid off the Disney Channel. She so ruiens everything everytime she opens her mouth.

  • @kevgonzal85 omg i couldnt agree more, all these artists try to get a piece of the greatness that is MARIAH CAREY, they jus make themselves look terrible

  • @geglamb Ain't that the truth.

  • SHE SUCKS!!! I CAN'T WAIT UNTIL SHES A HAS BEEN!

  • Miley was better here... :'( I miss the old Miley...

  • OMG STOPPP STOPPPPPP Nowwww ------- where this mariah to save us ? :P

  • i probably shouldnt have heard this version after hearing the original by mariah it makes this one sound even 790679037x worse by comparison......... THIS IS MY FAVORITE CHRISTMAS SONG♥

    I REALLLYYY HATE THE WAY SHE SAYS "MAKE MY WISH COME TRUE" uhhh what a nasally voice!

  • She sounds like Rebecca Black without auto tune... :'( Ruins it...

  • Mariah does this song better. No offence.

  • Was this at California or florida? 

  • Well this version isn't that bad, but Mariah Carey is the only one that can sing this song...Mariah Carey songs on songs only she can sing no one else can. Whereas Miley Cyrus, has her own set of songs which only she can sing...

  • omg shes so hot!!! i ly miley <3

  • Good try. But Mariah is the Queen of this song. Kudos to Miley for adapting it to suit her voice.

  • its so off tune!!

  • Love:) amazing ::))

  • I miss seeing her on disney channel. and her show.

  • She ruined my favorite Christmas song even I can sing it better then her -_-

  • I feel as though this song shouldn't be remade...

  • They had just left her and Nick..

    My Miley =') <3

  • Miley Cyrus is amazing. #RoleModelForLife

  • shit omg only mariah cn do this song damn dont freaking ruuin my christmas thumbs up

  • This is AMAZING<3<3

  • mariah will always be the best! :) miley's not that bad but she'll never top mariah's version!

  • She ruined a classic... :(

  • miley is not mariah.

  • @Jojo13Lorin I think she butchered it. I also think she's tone-deaf.

  • @Jojo13Lorin She's Better

  • @HorseCrazyChic230 ummmmmm. NO.

  • @Jojo13Lorin but she´s much better than mariah

  • @Jojo13Lorin we know that. We're all not blind.

  • eww miley

  • @DEMIANDJESS1 LOL!!!!

  • this is how much i cant wait till Christmas looking up Christmas songs this early lol

  • I <3 this song!!!!!!!!!!!!

    

  • LOOK AT THAT MONOLITHIC CASTLE BEHIND HER

  • I don't really care for her. Not going to hate, just not a fan typically. But I love this cover, I must confess.

  • I miss Miley being on disney channel:(

  • Mariah's version is, of course, better. The original is ALWAYS better! But I LOVE Miley and, although her voice may not be AS powerful as Mariah Carry's, she still did GREAT... especially since she was only 14 there and her voice was going through a DRASTIC voice change AND she was wearing TEETH BRACES!!!

    Still great!

    If she did it now, being 19 (on the 24th of November), she would kill it and sound amazing! :) Her voice is SO unique and distinct now!

  • da war sie noch keine bitcch ..

  • This is a mess!!!! This is proof that Mariah's songs are for HER!!!

  • @sixfobrutha11- It's really not THAT bad!

  • Im looking up christmas songs because justin biebers christmas album is coming out in a few hours.

  • @15girl1994 Nobody cares, really because you mentioned Justin Beiber. You can leave the internet now...

  • @ttuurrttlle i never mentioned justin beiber. I mentioned Justin Bieber, a whole different person.

  • @15girl1994 Sorry I forgot how to spell an obscure last name, regardless. I'm sure Justin Beiber's music is just as bad as Justin Bieber's music...

  • The Better Version to me . <33

  • Sooo cute amazing :)

  • Aaawh, she has such a cute voice here <3

  • Thumb up if you are watching this in 2011 and you will watch next year too!

  • Ugh .she totally butchered this song:(

  • I have a song lesson

    'The voice of christmas '

    but i think i gonna sing this song

  • she sings better than Justin sings^^

  • Uglyyy. She can't sing this song like Mariah, so better she don't sing this song. Whore.

  • @bballgirl261 LOL.yes.Mariah's version is like so slow and she like takes an hour in each word XD.

  • Justin bieber sings this the best

  • Ok, we can all agree that Mariah Carey is a thousand time better singer. But Miley cyrus does sound really good.

  • @TheOldSchoolSims2 listen to her version of smells like teen spirit and say that again

  • Amazing!

  • she sings out of her nose and it is not attractive at all! i dont even know how she became famous!?..haha

  • Mariah is way way waaaaayyy better ;)

  • it sound weird but in a good way!

  • Why does everyone say it sucks?I like this more than mariah's version.

  • her voice issss annoying.

  • Annoying voice compared to Mariah!

  • i cant belive im lookiing up christmas songs this earsly! lol

  • yes lol

  • fully cheatercock of cheetah girls but still she is singing better lol

  • @kittykayla1101

    me neither

  • @kittykayla1101 i am looking up christmas songs in the summer already, wish it coul be christmas every single day of the year!!

  • @briantjuh94 but it's not summer.... it's fall.

  • HIJ BY BY LOVE LOVE MILEY

  • NOT BAD MILEY GOOD

  • its 2011 right now

    

  • I PREFER THE MCR VERSION

    REALLY

  • i love miley so much but this song just isnt made for her voice lol <3

  • ... no one shud do this behind mariah

  • WHATS WRONG WITH YOU GUYS....sure she doesn't sing like Mariah, but she tried, and look how happy she made all those fans and kids isn't that what that concert was all about, nowon ever asked for your review.....!!!:)

  • Here she is only 14?? Woaah i think she looks like 18 or 19.

  • She did good job by doing this. What's wrong with you guys? It's cover of her. She doesn't have to sing like Mariah.

  • Christmas music is the best music ever created.

  • Glad to see I'm not the only person looking up Christmas songs already :)

  • @ashi847

    LOL I know right.......... AHHHHH THE JOY OF EARLY CHRISTMASERS... LOL christmasers

  • @ashi847 same (:

  • @ashi847 I started about a month and a half ago!! :)

  • I dont want much for christmas, only to stop her from singing this!!!! (singing)

  • i rember when it came on

  • Okay I like Miley but this one I was like 10 seconds in and I had to stop it. I still like her though but this wasn't her best.

  • People are so stupid. If you don't like Miley Cyrus, don't look at her videos. That simple. If Miley Cyrus couldn't sing then she wouldn't be famous and had gotten as far as she did. Yes, her voice is different from Mariah's but it's still a great and unique voice.

  • I can't believe she would even try to sing Mariah Carey. As if shes not already a bad singer, now shes making herself look bad compared to Mariah Carey. She really isn't singing, just yelling the lyrics in a high pitch, kinda like a 5 year old would.

  • oh my gosh...this is actually the first time ive ever heard miley cyres singing and i totally cant understand why everyone likes her so much because she cant sing!! honestly are all her fans deaf or what?? it cant be that millions of people have such bad taste! But i guess for those who also like weird singers like lady gaga or kesha who cant sing either its normal...here i can only say poor mariah...

  • @FUTuRaMaBeNdIngUNit HEY......LADY GAGA IS SUCH A GOOD SINGER OK AND THEY ALL HAVE FREKIN FEELINGS SO THINK BEFORE YOU POST, ALRIGHT!!!:)

  • i dont like her voice

  • I like to listen to this version more than Mariah's,don't know why.

  • Idk, why ppl say she cant sing while obviously she can. Ive been already to her concerts and she doesnt like crap!

  • Hahaha its so funny when shes says make my wish come true because she sucks

  • this sounds horrendously autotuned. 

  • Haha 1:21!!! Funny!

  • ieuw, she cant sing.

  • @lilmissmaryrose How do you know she's a slut? Do you peep in her bedroom window or something and see her having sex with someone? Because that's what sluts do, sleep around. And I'm pretty sure she doesn't so that.

  • Love when Miley sings this song, never really liked the song but when Miley sang it, it was awesome!! great job Miley!!=D

  • she ruined the song! >:( first she ruins part of your world from the little mermaid! and now! she ruined all i want for chirstmas is you! uhh... sometimes she make me sick >:( but i still kinda love her kinda...... if she keeps ruining songs she's gonna lose me as her fan

  • She can sing; but she butchered it compared to Mariah.

  • you don't have to like miley but it's a lie if you say she can't sing!

  • @lilmissmaryrose i just wanted for christmas is to see you beaten up by miley herself:)

  • I LOVEEEEE MILEY

  • Auto tuned live.. :/

  • @Bugsynature i thought that..

  • @bethieegh It's a shame.. :/

  • I expected something worse. xD I'm not a big Miley-fan, but I think she did this pretty good.

  • i liked how she looked the most for this video...lol; i like other versions better:) this isn't TERRIBLE like omg my ears are bleeding, but i like other versions better. ha