The tempo its just right. I´m learning the piece right now and my teacher insisted that I play slow. Thank you. I just discovered this treat while searching for Die Kranke Puppe (The Sick Doll). She´s really sick. Poor little thing. Let´s play her better:))))
I remember this one from primary school assemblies. The music teacher played piano pieces as we children traipsed in and this one (she called it "Dolly Is Ill") was always followed by "Doll's Funeral" and then "New Doll". The minor chords and alternating high and low notes in the right hand always suggested the distress and uncertainty caused by serious illness. As liuketto says: "very emotional and sad".
It is not perfect, but better than the other recordings. The slower tempo and the really subtle accents on certain notes give it that proper dark feeling, which is why they used it in "Kings."
I concur, Kings skillfully implemented my favourite song of all time. That's certainly a big ol' bucket o' win. Period . <---and another actual period to convey my god damn adamance.
I checked for how pianists that recorded this song played and I found yours to be the best. Others are a bit faster and you can't really dive in to the deep feeling the notes produce. Do you know any pianist that plays closest to your style?
i prefer this piece played slower although it is supposed to be cut time which is probably why everyone else plays it quickly. but people like to put their own style into it and i like the slower version ^^
its hard to find the sheet music unless your going to buy the book or just that specific piece. its only 1 page. i dont know if im allowed to post links on this so ill pm you the links and directions
I like your dynamics, though the tempo is a bit too slow to my liking, and the rhythm sounds a bit like 4/4 instead of 2/4 to me. The melody is in quavers, you play them cross the measures (pedal is your foe here, just leave it), which takes a bit of the brilliance away (imho). Your pianissimo however is really excellent, esp. towards the end, I like it!
Note that at 0:38 (11th measure) you play a G in the bass where it should've been an A.
At the 11th measure I play G and F in the left hand as stated in the score used but checking another score it says G and E are the right notes. I don't see any A's in my scores at the 11th measure.
Apparently we have different versions of the score, that makes it hard to compare. But I was wrong about the correct note, it's only one note in my score, and it is an E. Sorry for the confusion. Compare the same part (0:38) with others on Youtube and you'll notice the difference.
In other words, it is when the bass takes over and mimics the original theme (from bar 9): G-Fis-E-(D+Fis)etc.
(I'm a bit surprised that different scores contain different notes, but that happens more)
I suspect your version to be the correct one, as the score used seems to be a quite new transcription with possible typos. But both variants are pleasent to the ears I think.
I liked the tempo. You really nailed it, brah.
underwateroutfitter 5 months ago
The tempo its just right. I´m learning the piece right now and my teacher insisted that I play slow. Thank you. I just discovered this treat while searching for Die Kranke Puppe (The Sick Doll). She´s really sick. Poor little thing. Let´s play her better:))))
universoeterno1 9 months ago
Excellent job here. Very hypnotic, mysterious, melancholy, expressive. I want this played at my funeral!
estebandesade 9 months ago
minor. im 10. and i enjoy minor music. and im hyper. weird huh? great job love it.
TheGirl91780 9 months ago
Nice performance! Bravo!
I just wanted to share how in my album this song is followed by Dolly's Funeral and then soon after My New Dolly. :|
teodortenchev 10 months ago
I watched this video like 100 times, do u have the music sheet? where can I find it? Thank you!
snaveluos 1 year ago
beautiful music splendid work i am in level 3 in piano cause i'm only in 4 grade and i playd the song
catcatcat331 1 year ago
i dont know who you are but you feel it exactly as i do... and i like the sound effect.
shit1986cannibal 1 year ago
5/5 for sound qual.
rememberdank 1 year ago
you can find the sheets here musicnotes
waymilky442 1 year ago
the sick doll died
watch Tchaikovsky - The Doll's Funeral
waymilky442 1 year ago
i <3 this type of music.
suasides 1 year ago
I remember this one from primary school assemblies. The music teacher played piano pieces as we children traipsed in and this one (she called it "Dolly Is Ill") was always followed by "Doll's Funeral" and then "New Doll". The minor chords and alternating high and low notes in the right hand always suggested the distress and uncertainty caused by serious illness. As liuketto says: "very emotional and sad".
gusgorilla76 2 years ago 2
It is not perfect, but better than the other recordings. The slower tempo and the really subtle accents on certain notes give it that proper dark feeling, which is why they used it in "Kings."
JHoff1991 2 years ago 15
@JHoff1991
I concur, Kings skillfully implemented my favourite song of all time. That's certainly a big ol' bucket o' win. Period . <---and another actual period to convey my god damn adamance.
H3TCykaCT0 1 year ago
Very beautiful - I compared few versions on youtube and I really like how it sounds in yours. Thanks
iamtanvn 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too slow
MJLoV3r4eVeR 2 years ago
not bad... room for improvement
leeny11 2 years ago
I like your speed, the way it should sound homey.
H3TCykaCT0 2 years ago 16
this song is used prominently in the NBC tv show "Kings". I really like it, beautifully dark.
beethovenist966 2 years ago 3
I checked for how pianists that recorded this song played and I found yours to be the best. Others are a bit faster and you can't really dive in to the deep feeling the notes produce. Do you know any pianist that plays closest to your style?
TheDarkLordSeth 2 years ago
i prefer this piece played slower although it is supposed to be cut time which is probably why everyone else plays it quickly. but people like to put their own style into it and i like the slower version ^^
RiceballSamurai 2 years ago
It seems like your asking for tone not style.... Tone is partly the pianist but the piano itself is the largest contributing factor......
davidparkowski 2 years ago
I still can't find the music sheet. >:[
filiwian 2 years ago
its hard to find the sheet music unless your going to buy the book or just that specific piece. its only 1 page. i dont know if im allowed to post links on this so ill pm you the links and directions
RiceballSamurai 2 years ago
i"m learning that right now and it doesnt sound anything like that! i love this peice!
singlegirl2015 2 years ago
Good job! Very emotional and sad...as it must be
liuketto 2 years ago 2
I like it :) i think i'll play this one for my next piano assignment. it's in the book i have for my class.
stardarkstar 2 years ago
you are really wonderful, cubusdk
MissMarieskie 2 years ago
I used to play all the doll pieces by tchaikovsky.. this one was and still is my favourite :)
AishwaryaRai 3 years ago
I like your dynamics, though the tempo is a bit too slow to my liking, and the rhythm sounds a bit like 4/4 instead of 2/4 to me. The melody is in quavers, you play them cross the measures (pedal is your foe here, just leave it), which takes a bit of the brilliance away (imho). Your pianissimo however is really excellent, esp. towards the end, I like it!
Note that at 0:38 (11th measure) you play a G in the bass where it should've been an A.
Misteribel 3 years ago
At the 11th measure I play G and F in the left hand as stated in the score used but checking another score it says G and E are the right notes. I don't see any A's in my scores at the 11th measure.
cubusdk 3 years ago 5
Apparently we have different versions of the score, that makes it hard to compare. But I was wrong about the correct note, it's only one note in my score, and it is an E. Sorry for the confusion. Compare the same part (0:38) with others on Youtube and you'll notice the difference.
In other words, it is when the bass takes over and mimics the original theme (from bar 9): G-Fis-E-(D+Fis)etc.
(I'm a bit surprised that different scores contain different notes, but that happens more)
Misteribel 3 years ago
And of course, maybe I (and the performers of the other versions) are just wrong. Your change of the theme there does sound quite modern ;)
Misteribel 3 years ago
I suspect your version to be the correct one, as the score used seems to be a quite new transcription with possible typos. But both variants are pleasent to the ears I think.
cubusdk 3 years ago
so..beutiful molody ....
elito92 3 years ago
Very, Very nicely done!
Congratulations. I believe you captured
the spirit of the piece, or rather brought it out.
Thanks for posting.
Norman60Fahrer 3 years ago 2
this is the best version I've found on youtube!
all the other ones are so...fast.
But I love this version! very nicely done!
Justsailaway 3 years ago 2
i play this piece its really easy to play but very expresive in a way that it sounds more complex than it really is
oyemechema 3 years ago
very nice experession!
klavierspielerin83 3 years ago
Simple and perfect..love it
Danielluscombe 3 years ago
good control
mistmv12 3 years ago