Added: 4 years ago
From: unanoche98
Views: 246,370
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (74)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • kya baaaaaaat

  • They killed a classic!

  • These 2 singing together is my worst nightmare..On top of that they chose an awesome song and wrecked it!!

  • I am big fan of both of them, but I can't say which one killed this song more :(

  • imposters

  • A melodious song by Hari haran & Shankar maha devan..song in vrindaavana saaranga raagam

  • hari'ji nd shankr......no can trace ur path......tz totally amzng....nd tis s ma favrite song ever....

  • marvelous,,,

  • I think A.R Rahman ka ye wala was better........

  • No match to the original one sung beautifully by TMS/PBS

  • soft song but voices in paandithiya sangeetham awsome voices not graduated from tamil nadu but voicing tamil basic notes nodes clearly. proud of these tamilians and keralites.

  • Nicely sung. Brings the lyricist Kannadasan back to life, and also brings back old memories of TMS and PBS from the original version. This version is just as good; feels much more relaxed, actually. Funny to see Hariharan resorting to the swaras in between: he doesn't seem to know the song well. Wish the audio had been better here.

  • nice song!!!

  • hats of to both off dem, its pleaseure to hear old songs sung by present singers

  • what a good song and superb singing by Hariji and Shankarji

  • A great melodious song  of yestyeryear spoiled by two good singers.

  • what a vocal, this two are living tamil legends!

  • Two amazing singers. Hariharan's voice is just mesmerizing!!

  • wow good performance

  • I agree.. This version sounds contrived and fake. The original was the best.

  • Wow..wow..wow..superb!

  • awesome!!!...wat a voice!!....great!!

  • I nominate you for "Biggest Douche in the Universe" award.

  • my vote is for him...

  • They are my 2 favourite singers!! Wat a luck to have them together for fans!!!

  • i'm fan of both hariji n shankar mahadevan...wat language they are singing? wat does it mean?

  • They are singing in Tamil. HArd to translate the whole song. But the song in English translates to " seeking a girl "

    Pon = girl

  • Pon= gold

    Penn = girl

    I saw gold but not a girl.

    I saw a flower not a face.

  • @pirusan123 ..yeen endre naan sole lagu ma?yeen endre naan sole vendu ma?do u want me to tell u why?both same ille?

  • 'yaen endru naan sollalaguma?' Can i explain why? with an implied answer ''you shouldn't' included in the question. The reason could be societal norms. I guess he is the younger brother to the other. On the other hand 'yaen endru naan solla venduma?' means 'should I explain to you?'

  • thanks talaiva...am a tamilean n know exactly what they mean...konjam confussion...thats it.thanks again.

  • They sing nice but the only problem is that it's duet and they don't have practise with each other.

  • unless the music director controls them i guess the singers will come with a crap like these , they feel that they are generating a master piece when they have made a fool of themsleves . I like them both personally but they have disappointed me here

  • you must be a real ........ do u know what is music? i doubt someone like u know. do not post some kind of stupid comments like this. do u think u can sing like them to sent this type of comments? i guess u must be a bathroom singer.. do not comment if u think u're not even their dust on their feet.

  • have you listened to the original version of the song in youtube ... .. and also it is a fact that has been told by ar rehman that unless he controls the singer they get carried away .. No bad feeling i like both of them for their work in breathless and colonial cousins and many more songs but this one is total crap and btw you need not have to be a good singer to differenciate good music from bad

  • horrible

  • I'm a great fan of Hariji. But, it is disappointing to see him doing a stage play of this kind. The song has such great value and this duo had attempted to make fun of it. Bad!

  • Thanks for this video...enjoyed it...

  • All the guys who are commenting critically about this rendering are perhaps above 50.

    Listen guys taking an old song and re-rendering it in itself is a tribute to the old song. And the two guys here are the best ones we have!!

  • Wrong! Many talented kids can sing better than this. Two stalwarts of yester years sang this song of great vintage value;a great duo set music and lyrics were by master poet Kannadasan. What these two did was total injustice to the song. Messed up the words and were out of tune in quite a few places and there was a major Sruthi alignment problem for Shankar in this piece. No doubt,these two are great singers. But they lacked respect and humility in rendering this and that showed obviously.

  • I fully agree with you AshokSubra. The original was sung by two stalwarts of South Indian music, P.B. Srinivos and T.M.Sounderarajan. That original song is im-mortal and it is a disgrace that these fellows are more or less mocking it. And Hariharan, despite all his talents does not possess the mellifluous voice of P.B.Srinivos. Re-rendering songs to correct blemishes in recording ir-regularities is one things, attempting to mutilate that great song is deplorable.

    V. Suresh

    Strasbourg, France

  • This horrible performance just makes you yearn for TMS and PBS. Sigh!

  • These guys murdered a classic by TMS/PBS

  • I've Heard The Old Song Sung By Two Legends TMS and Some Other Person...

    Here Hari Ji And Shankar Totally Got Us Into Some New Ways Of Musical World...The Actuall Thing No One Singer Wouldn't Like To Immitate Like Others...

    Hari Ji Rocks

  • no.. they r experts singing in their own style

  • shit happens!!

    dammit!!

    what the hell these two spoilers were thinking while singing this good old song!!

  • They have spoilt this song!!!!

    And from the way they sang it i doubt they even know the original

  • luved the beginning 00:01 - 00:35 vah kya baat hai!! awesome!!

  • agreed.

  • why this type of try, it wont come to these guys especially the voice of TMS

  • spot on mate... this was a cheap show !

  • both are great singers,,but shankar performed well???anyway hari is my fav singer

  • Didnt understand a word.. .but got the feel.. amazing..

  • FEEL PITTY FOR THE AUDIENCE !!

  • why hariharan has ate the beautiful words -" tuvandu vizhum kodiyidaiyaaL'-being a tamilian-he should be sincere in redering tamil songs- had Kannadasan would be alive and watch this video, he would have called hariharan and scolded him left and right.

  • geo yaar geo. i don't understand the language, nevertheless, it's a fabulous composition and collaboration by the 2 singers. if i'm not mistaken, it's in raag Megh-malhar, is it not?

  • In karnatic music the raag is supposedly ' Vrindavan Saranga'.

  • i think problem with the audio.. song kinda lost its luster. nevertheless i wish the singers took the song more seriously instead of taking too much liberty. good show tho.

  • Its not the audio.. its the singers who made a mess of it !!

  • wow.. this s called silk voice

  • wonderful .. classic..

  • thanks for the video.. i watched it in sun tv. shankar mahadevan is making a breathing mistake right ? His breathing sound is heard .. Can I comment like this ?

  • whatta beautiful song ...... both these ppl are gems.. especially shankar mahadevan has sung beautifully and attracted the crowd better than hariharan.

  • Two of the best together; thanks man.

  • Audio could have been a bit louder!

    which language is this? sounds very melodious

  • yeah there was some problem wit my audio device n so t recording was not clear... n obviously its a tamil song.. he he... old song..

  • Yes this an old Tamil song from a block buster movie ' Padithal mattum poduma", sung by TMS and PBS- music composed by evergreen MSV and wonderful lyrics by evergreen Kannadasan.

  • @skyward01 this is a tamil language

  • @skyward0 this is tamil song

  • @skyward01 tamil

  • YA TRue some or at the capturing the audio is increasead at 16-18Khz which makes the audio Shrill

    Also level is low.

    But we dont mind while these two are performing

    What notes they go through while singing

    MY FAV SINGERS

    SHANKAR MAHADEVAN

    S P SUBRAMANYAN

    HARIHARAN

  • @skyward01 A 'golden oldie' from a Tamil movie!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more