Park Hyo Shin (박효신) & Fly to the Sky (Live)

[HanFanyVal]

Fly to the Sky and Park Hyoshin forever!

[childsweethearts]

Can someone please tell me Brian's last name?

[jiamonx2]

@childsweethearts Joo, should've been so easy to google, he's not a nobody...

[browneyedS]

박효신이 플투랑 같이 불러준 이유, 환희랑 같은 대학나왔음

플투 다시 합쳐라 ㅠ

[loveyoujaypark33]

omggggggggggggg so olddddddddddddd

[TheLittlemshotty]

박효신과 노래할려면 정말매우용감해야할듯

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ브라이언 조권싱크로율100펔ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[AdeLINEwiwi]

wow . brian looks hot . hwanhee look haha cute . park hyo shin looks freaking cutee . but he looks better now with his hair ! love them !!

[mellove5]

dont get me wrong, i love them all, but i think Brian ruined it....Park Hyo Shin is too good to be singing with them!

[tellmewhy328]

I cant believe some singer, why did they sing with Hyo shin? I think that, Hoy shin is better than everysinger~ Hyo shin is no comparison between everysinger!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[drasoureen]

dang!! park hyo shin is really different then and now.....!!

[funnysung]

why is park hyo shin so fat here

[laughmoojii]

haha, brian and fany's hair cracked me up.

btw, love the song.

3 powerful vocals.

[Annishii]

whos the third guy

his cute :)

[laughmoojii]

@ Annishii

from left to right:

Brian, Park Hyo Shin, Hwanhee

[KyoHanjin]

This would've been so much better if Park Hyo Shin sang it alone

[dhbasnk]

this song... no offense, isn't a very appealing song. they all have amazing voices but the song just didn't suit their styles at all.

[juzfon]

beautiful voices

im glad they all look different today

[slypatt2]

park hyoshin's deep voice, aaaah~~ sooo goood~~!

[kawaiilana]

i LOVE park hyo shin~~~and i like ftts..but im sorry..this is NOT a good performance.. with hwanhee and park hyo shin both singing like dueling divas...and the fact that their voices do NOT harmonize at all..and the weird choir in the back...its just.not good~~~park hyo shin and ftts..good separately..but not together~~

[Annishii]

theres a band called solid who sang this along time ago

i think there trying to copy it... the original song by solid sounds so much better... trust me

[jaslee2003]

HOLY *_______________*

Can someone please tell me where I can download this!

[startwigg]

wow~~~~~

i love them

thanks

[1337SFpro]

go hwanhee

woot

[patti0311]

One of the rare times I see Park Hyo Shin's entire face. His hair usually hides some part of his face, usually his laft eye. I thought he had some scar he was trying to hide. He got a nice face. Should show more of it.

[SlaveOfGod1993]

its called Hairstyle man

american people's showing face isnt style

[woqnmn]

They are cute  ㅋㅋ

[AznSao9]

good performance. hehe, love it. so long ago, but glad that they still singing now. anyways, thank you for sharing.

[manystylesxjunki]

tthe guy in the middle looks like my friend ....

its disguisting

[genkasik]

I love them that much

it's all because FTTS that I start to hear korean songs

they're really good singer

and also PHS

[osmayomama]

phs and hwanhee graduated same highschool... i heard

[divineryushe]

Um, you people do realize that this was in 2002 right? Brian is a much better singer. They are ALL much better singers now. It's bit laughable that people are criticizing a performance of more than 5 years ago. xD

[Neighborhoood]

It would've been better if Brian sang it a little softer. Hwanhee and Hyo shin sang just great but they(except brian) should've had different hair style. Thx for this great movie clip.

[flyingdell]

all look like boys next door lol.same look all 3 of them.(hairstyle)a bit spikiesh!!!

[rose85t]

two of them makes Fly To The Sky... so that should be reason enough to not compare the two.... they're both unique and same goes for their voices too! ^_^

[judy54700]

Both of Fly to the Sky has great voices. Each different and great. I love Brian's sweet sound and Hwanhees soulfui voice. You go Guys!

[dvalentino81]

At least you see them trying their best,don't they?I like Brian's voice because of that and I don't judge any of them.

[afgess]

Why are you so negative towards criticisms/judgings

Criticisms aren't just pure insults; they give individuals chances to reconsider certain aspects of themselves that they can't see bythemselves, and to strive to become better than they are now.

By the way, if celebrities/singers can't take criticisms, they don't deserve to become famous. That's why everyone isn't up there on stage, singing. And if you feel that you should stand up against these criticisms, you're very shallow-minded.

[dvalentino81]

Oh so you're saying I'm shallow-minded? Dude, I don't go against any criticism and yes I understand what you trying to say about singers can't take that risk, then they don't deserve to be famous. I also think it is true about what you said too. But if you really think I'm shallow-minded just cause I go against criticisms, just to tell you.

[dvalentino81]

I don't go against any criticisms and btw, I have criticize people before and have been criticized before too, I can handle taking it. But what I'm saying is that the comments can just be a little bit nicer, that's all I'm saying. And I also said that Brian improved in his singing now, so there should be a cheer up for them too.Anyways, I apologize for what I said.

[afgess]

Okay... but the only thing is that there's no reason for you to take the criticisms personally and to try to get the people who have criticized to change to your own likings. If i'm completely off, I apologize as well.

[dvalentino81]

I hope I'm affecting anyone's feelings,I'm just saying.Brian have improved a lot in his singing,and yeah I agree with some of you.He sings better than,if not most then some of the other singers.And for those who compared Brian with Hwanhee when they both sing together, come on now.They are in the same group,why people like to judge other people of how they sing,what they do, what they look like, or whatever.

[dvalentino81]

^^oops haha, I made a mistake on "I hope I'm affecting..."There was supposed to be a not* after I'm and before affecting.hahah my bad.

[dvalentino81]

Brian is just Brian, he's a person too. I wonder if he go through youtube. If he do, how would you think he will feel?And how would it feel if you were in the same condition that he's in. I'm not taking all this serious, but I'm just saying for those of you who have negative point of views for any singers,actors/actresses, or whoever, just keep it to yourself please.

[dvalentino81]

Like seriously man, they are just people, aren't they? They can have their weakest point cause we all do have some too. About Brian can't sing for those that said this. I know it's all your opinions and stuff, but if you see them singing lives in person. Would you able to say that in front of their face, or would you just give it away?Like seriously,if you don't like that person or whether you think they don't sing good enough,can you please keep it to yourself?

[ctharyar]

Hwanhee has very powerful voice.

so dreamy. <333

[samdanza]

Oh please dont say so, Brian really tried his best.. can't say those bad word, will hurt ppl, you know?

[hwan2]

grow some balls, saying that wont hurt anyone

[afgess]

brian butchered the intro -_-

he shouldn't be here

[killjadeskye]

he messed up a bit

no biggie

[afgess]

he didn't mess up

he only demonstrated his limitations in singing

[killjadeskye]

well, if he has some limitations singing this song, he wouldn't sing it, would he?

[afgess]

Each person has his/her own limitations...right??? lol

[coyotelala]

yup brian's the weakest link gg

nj hwanhee and phs

[DeathAngelNaruto]

park hyo shin weird voice but cool :D

[Holamybutt]

i dont know why brian is even in there

[wwwgrace]

all three singers here have improved a lot over these few years. their voices are a lot better now than in this video. not that they were bad, but better now...

[strifes]

why the hell does korean music suck so much?

[faith520]

OR it could be you who don't know any shit about music ?

[leoscorpion]

(O_o) if u dnt like it why u listen to it from da 1st place !!! wndring

[Tedchanghoonyi]

oh wow why are you even listening to it then? well if u have anything to say about krn music, why dont you say that in front of my face? please do grow some balls

[mankogood]

because ur ears are so fucked

[afgess]

brian is a shaky singer lolz

[wangundegi]

park hyo shin is in other world compared to hwanhee and brian

[flyvidz]

Park Hyo Shin and Hwanhee = great voices!!

Love both to them <3

[teddybearluver16]

BRIAN!!! <333

he looks sooooo cute with that hair ^^

[s4m222]

question when PHS is singing is he sort of flexing his lower stomach diaprahm area or is he more relaxed?

[itzsaemi]

브라이언 쪼아

[ayasi05]

i love this song since hwanhee sang it on Xman.. aahh.. how i wish he was singing alone.. no offence to anyone.. i just love hwanhee's vocal sooo much lol

[truevibesgal2003]

lol n no offense to you but i prefer brian and park hyo shin's

[rainme4ever]

no offense to the 2 of u here....I prefer PHS and Hwany together, or either one alone.....LOL

Both PHS and Hwany has great vocals!!!

[SMasta]

damn..i love hyo shin and hwanhee...i never liked brian much though =X

[typhoontank]

song title "EE bam eh kkut eul jab ko" - "holding on to the edge of tonight" <- translation.

[genkasik]

what is the title of the 1st song?

[battlesarang]

wow.. three amazing singers all at one stage :D

[soul2angel]

PARK, Hyo Shin's live songs are always amazing... and is one of the best singer.

I love hyoshin!!!

[vlee123]

damn... pure talent right there on stage

[trojan71]

i remember this song its by an old group called solid

[square788]

i luv them. both singers.. specially, i crazy fany's adlib.. hehe

[peha1309]

fly to the sky♡

[endless1eternity]

park hyo shin sure sounds a lot better now ! o_O;

[paintbutterfly]

my favorite singers performing together!! bravo!!

[BeautifulReverie]

<3333

[dyreen]

oh great voices!!! Thanks for sharing:)

[BOBAHOLICME]

park hyo shin is the king of romantic/ sweet/ self-sacrificing songs and so great LIVE. What perfect harmony with FFTS, Hwanhee and Brian are so hot! haha.

[tenka]

hwanhee was better on Xman - i agree, this perf wasn't the best. but considering how long ago this was...they've improved (FTTS that is) iono about hyoshin.

[alwiya]

gr8 voices! luv them!

[simplydream]

this is so awesome =D they are so good, that's why you gotta love sexy man who can sing =)

[dtsheej]

gosh this was ages ago...ftts was good back than BUT way better now.

[Caramelito2006]

ihave seen better performances from Brian... i love Brian!!! uhmm he was not that good at this song... Park Hyo Shin amazing as usual!!! thanks for uploading.

[Home2boston]

They're all awesome! Thanks for sharing.

[colorzna]

The harmony is soooo sweeeeet!!!

[dannykawaii]

my god Hyo Shin is fat like a pig in this video, and realy strange with this hairstyle.

[uws]

he always looks like that

[yurika975]

He is not fat. just healthy. who wants a Stick man?!

[Caramelito2006]

hahah i think you need some glasses!fat? i think Fany looks fatter than him in that video ... and i dont think any of them are fat for God s sake! And they re not models, they only need to have a good voice and they do!!

[JoeS0Fly]

to da smallfry up there named ethelea, brian CAN sing. YOU cant. lol

[ethelea]

What would you know. I sing for my school's choir. And reply directly next time so I can laugh at you.

[uws]

everybody will have their own opinion whether someone can sing or not - but hey, brian's the one with the record deal, not you..haha

[bubbleslin]

brian is not that bad really. don't want to name names but comparing the A-listed celebs in korea, brian is still way better than many of them.... like the number guy and the snake girl, for example....

[patti0311]

Who is Hyo Shin's hairstylist - should be sacked. His hairstyles really suck. If it's not like curtains, he looks like a woodpecker or just been electrically shocked!!

[amberch0]

fly to the sky is a lot better now. i dont think they did well in this performance, but i think that they're really really good now. i think they've gotten wayyy better. brian CAN sing.

[ethelea]

brian sucks... he cant sing, poor thing.

[moviebookfan]

brian's good. His solo album is out. And he's improved which is all that really matters. Also the fact that he loves to sing.

[dubblecx301]

Park hyo shin did fine... I don't know about fly to the sky... I can't believe Park hyo shin and Fly to the Sky debuted at the same time~~~ Hyo shin's singing seems so much more mature~~~

[MizNouP]

I heard HwanHee singing this song on one of the X-Man episode and it was awesome. I guess this version is too slow but it's still good.

[blissful712]

which xman episode? [i love watching xman!]

[ladygirlbaby]

i remember that...kim jong kook later wanted to sing it because he didn't really have a set plan to the couple selection. who sang this song originally? it's really gorgeous?

[kperic]

The group that sang this is 솔리드 (Solid).

[kylieu]

to see HwanHee n Hyo Shin is just awesome!!

[nyceguy79]

omg, they massacred this song

[uws]

hahaha. i guess..well everybody has their preferences. i like how you described it as 'massacred.' haha

[dexkk]

i like the original better too even though hwanhee is a good singer.

[nyceguy79]

sorry if this offends u but hwanhee sucks

[haemii]

haha are you fucking serious

[YungWonYoung]

omg... youre right... wat the hell did they do to this song...

[melissarenat]

whats this song called??

[choi13a]

it's called "Ee bahm eh kkeut eur jahb goh", roughly translated as "Holding on to the End of this Night"

[melissarenat]

thank you!

[melissarenat]

they sound really good together

[fallcloud]

Brain is so cute

喜欢BRAIN，哈哈

[musicstar88]

OMG BRIAN

[kylieu]

OMG!!!..Hwanhee n Hyo Shin!!..

thanks so much!!