I cannot understand why Melinda Doolittle is not included in your list. Her rendition of "FUNNY VALENTINE" topped everyone else's version, including those of the "seasoned superstars." I can understand why she did not win; people may have decided that since she has formal training and experience, she was able to stand out in the competition. Please review your list because Melinda's performances were stellar.
I'm from Australia and I agree with Diana DeGarmo's No1 position here and I do remember her and by the way Anthony Fedorov singing "surrender" was amazing too!!
I disagree with your order. I like Diana, and she should have won over Fantasia (I believe it was the two of them), but #1?!? Taylor and Mandisa should have both been up higher. WAY HIGHER!!! (It should have been Mandisa and Taylor at the end at not Katherine). Wrong Archuleta song too (Stand By Me was the phenomenal song!!!)
tannerah and ratanya Carrie Underwood not only is my favorite American Idol contestant ever, but my favorite singer ever. I know that her rendition of "Alone" was great, but I wanted the not so rememberable performances in this video. Hence Diana DeGarmo being number 1. She is one of the biggest talents ever to set foot on that stage, but no one remembers her. I'll make a new video with some more, well deserving, performances in it.
Carrie Underwood should have at least 5 of these spots! She's the most talented being that has EVER graced that stage. No one else had a CHANCE that season!
Not bad, but could have added Cook and Adam...but I like Kelly Clarkson, Allison Iraheta, David Archuleta, Jordin Sparks and Carrie Underwood they are great!
YES! I am thrilled that you have the EXTREMELY RIDICULOUSLY underrated "Don't Cry Out Loud" as number one. I also have that as best idol performance ever. Her ENCORE performance of "I Believe" is also up there.
diana deagarma should not have been number 1 fantasia should have
alexhugh999 4 months ago
I cannot understand why Melinda Doolittle is not included in your list. Her rendition of "FUNNY VALENTINE" topped everyone else's version, including those of the "seasoned superstars." I can understand why she did not win; people may have decided that since she has formal training and experience, she was able to stand out in the competition. Please review your list because Melinda's performances were stellar.
loyestor1951 5 months ago
allison!!!!
ladycallirgos 10 months ago
How the heck is Taylor Hicks on this list? David Cook's Billie Jean and Adam Lambert's Mad World should be on here!
peaceloveerin100 1 year ago
I'm from Australia and I agree with Diana DeGarmo's No1 position here and I do remember her and by the way Anthony Fedorov singing "surrender" was amazing too!!
ausrico1 1 year ago
Allison's blazing version of "Papa was a Rolling Stone" should have been put ahead of about 5 of these!!!!!!!!!
MidAgeAllisonFan 1 year ago
how 'bout jennifer hudson she was good
cute251000 1 year ago
I disagree with your order. I like Diana, and she should have won over Fantasia (I believe it was the two of them), but #1?!? Taylor and Mandisa should have both been up higher. WAY HIGHER!!! (It should have been Mandisa and Taylor at the end at not Katherine). Wrong Archuleta song too (Stand By Me was the phenomenal song!!!)
SuperDude2569 1 year ago
Allison Iraheta owns "Alone" :) Great video!
VCHSA 1 year ago
Thanks to everyone for your comments.
tannerah and ratanya Carrie Underwood not only is my favorite American Idol contestant ever, but my favorite singer ever. I know that her rendition of "Alone" was great, but I wanted the not so rememberable performances in this video. Hence Diana DeGarmo being number 1. She is one of the biggest talents ever to set foot on that stage, but no one remembers her. I'll make a new video with some more, well deserving, performances in it.
mastuba24 2 years ago
Carrie Underwood should have at least 5 of these spots! She's the most talented being that has EVER graced that stage. No one else had a CHANCE that season!
tannerah 2 years ago
@tannerah kelly clarkson is
kyleandjewelshow 1 year ago
I'm surprised you didn't include Carrie's 'Alone'. That, to me, was one of the best performances ever. Her performance of 'Alone' is legendary.
rytanya26 2 years ago
Not bad, but could have added Cook and Adam...but I like Kelly Clarkson, Allison Iraheta, David Archuleta, Jordin Sparks and Carrie Underwood they are great!
archiecook55 2 years ago
Anthony Fedorov "I Surrender"
clay aiken "build me up buttercup"
adam lambert "no satisfaction"
david cook "always be my babe"
carrie underwood "alone"
latoya london "all by myself"
legitxeris 2 years ago
Great video, thanks!
idoladdicts1 2 years ago
YES! I am thrilled that you have the EXTREMELY RIDICULOUSLY underrated "Don't Cry Out Loud" as number one. I also have that as best idol performance ever. Her ENCORE performance of "I Believe" is also up there.
Getabrainfool 2 years ago
Kelly Clarkson's vocals have an edge...she is more than just a good singer. She is as good as any of the big female vocalists in popular music
bumblywumblybee 2 years ago
OMG, I can just read it all now...........lol
For myself I will reserve any further comment until i've watched this a few more times.
MidAgeAllisonFan 2 years ago
Kelly - your just amazing!!
Addicted2kelz 2 years ago
David Archuleta's Imagine da best!
hogwart81800 2 years ago 2
Archuleta -"Love Me Tender" belongs on any Top AI list
blisskasden 2 years ago 2
david cooke.. billy jean
adam lambert.. Mad World
adam lambert.. Tracks of my Tears
adam lambert.. Feelin' Good
allison iraheta.. Someone to Watch Over Me
allison and adam.. Slow Ride
chris allen.. Heartless
.
syeshasucks 2 years ago