Added: 3 years ago
From: winterbrush
Views: 989,613
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (983)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song is perfect in every way possible.

  • It just occurred to me that, if you look at the lyrics (in context of the musical), it's really not a very romantic song :\ Christine comes across as needy and high maintenance and Raoul comes across as having a hero complex. Oh well, at least, Raoul says he loves Christine, which, btw, she *never* says back to him!

  • Mine and my boyfriends song... <3 you know hes a keeper if one of his favorite movies is phantom of the opera or titanic <3 I love you baby

  • This scene in the movie makes me cry every time. When she drops the rose and the phantom is watching, I just lose it -.-

  • that's "ALL" you ask of Raoul? C'mon Christine - that's a lot!!!

  • Well i wish when he was hipmitizing her, he at least kissed her it would have been more romantic but still he got a kiss from her in the movie still good

  • TOTAL TEAM PHANTOM PHAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Yeah Christine? You love him? But you love the phantom more, is that it?! People after watching this look up "Love Never Dies-Beneath a Moonless Sky" and see what happened with Christine the night before her and Roul's wedding -:( ALW why did you have to do that to all of the POTO fans?

  • Dang.... This is the worst break up on a movie Gerard Butler ever had to go through..... Sniff

  • TEAM PHANTOM!

  • my boyfreind sang this song to me...i forgot to breathe when he did

  • "Love me, that's all I ask of you." that makes me think of my ex that just broke up with me a week ago... I still love and miss you. :/

  • Saw the movie for the first time today. As a grown man it made me feel like I could cry hearing this song, and I'm not ashamed to say that.

  • My boyfriend told be about this song... I nearly cried when I heard it... it's like... the perfect song for any couple... (especially me since I'm like... emo)

  • I know it's just made up, but people really need to stop judging, The Phantom would NOT be a murderer if people didn't make fun of him. I mean I don't think he burnt half his face for attention...

  • Someone sang this at my mother and stepfather's wedding

  • Man i wish i could sing this song for a girl that i like, but its to bad shes taken :(

  • @kirby00023 same :( I wanted to sing this to my boyfriend but he moved away :( and now I can't sing it to my crush cuz he's taken

  • Haha I'm also on the phantom side cuz all he wants is love. And that all I want too.

  • I LOVE PHANTOM. PHANTOM FOREVER <3

  • Okay, so yes i understand the phantom is romantic and a genius, but he is also..A MURDERER, Don't get me wrong, id still choose him, i hate the pretty boys love the bad boys, but i can understand her apprehension. Plus, to be fair Raul and Christine are childhood sweethearts, they grew up together in love and did all the cute stuff. Still would totally steal the phantom though. ;) Gerald you sexy beast

  • If we all gang up Im pretty sure we could take the 24 dislikes. :)

  • This song makes me cry. It's so beautiful :D Too bad I'm FOREVER ALONE u.u back to watching All By Myself by Celine Dion videos

  • I don't care if he is disfigured, I think the Phantom is handsome, at the very least: in his heart. Raoul is like that preppy kid at school that every1 likes, and the Phantom is the truely kindhearted one who isn't as good-looking and gets called a drama/ band-geek.

  • i mean, all he did was want someone to love! his mother and father cast him away, not caring about him, and he wanted someone to love him! i cant blame him for going insane. if my mom and dad abandoned me, with no siblings or no relatives that cared about me or want to take care of me, and i was forced to live in "secret laire" under a place that i loved, i would be pretty upset. being a "musical genious" and not being able to pursue something that i love, right when its directly in my reach,

  • @TigersUnleashed and everybody thought i was scary and stuff, just cuz i was disfigured at birth, so WHAT?!?!!? Oh my gosh, i cryed, thinking about his lonleyness, i mean, he just wanted someone to LOVE!! Oh, poor Erik.... he was just so LONLY!! he just wanted to love someone! he just got so jelous of Raoul and Christine. he tried to sing to her, just like he did! but, for some stupid reason, she didn't choose him! he just was so lonely!! oh, i can't stop talking about him! i feel so BAD!

  • me and my bestie were CRACKING UP during this song! its cuz of the pic at 4:06 He's just like, oh i'm stalking u cuz i love u Emmy! he's just like I luv u. read lovetheblackandwhite 's comment. she's my best friend. he's just like, in a really low and stupid voice, "i love you" we were really hyper and joking around, no intention to offend people. we were really hyper. :D

  • at 4:06 , the pic is like the phantom going in a really deep and stupid voice, "I love u" no rudness intended. gerry is so my hubby

  • my BF needs to sing this to me for V-DAY

  • Phantom of the Opera vs. Romeo & Juliet

    Phantom of the Opera wins~

  • I'm watching it right now . and All I could think is .. I feel so sorry for the Phantom . Who would just let him go like that ? He's the reason she found her voice . I cried throughout the movie . and i just cant believe it . I love this movie but i still feel sorry for him .

  • I feel bad for the Phantom. My ending of the movie Christine would have ended up with him but I still like how it ended even if i think the Phantom was better.

  • but what about the phantoms part in the song??? I love that part!!! <3

  • Comment removed

  • this song inspires me so much. I feel so bad for the phantom yet I favor Raoul more. This is perfect for a wedding song

  • I'm not afraid to proudly say that the fact that this is an R/C song makes it even better (if that's possible), in my opinion! Really an amazingly beautiful song... :-)

  • I want to see this so bad! I'm going to see on DVD, but I bet it isn't the same as seeing it in Broadway, I bet! I'm learning the song on piano and maybe play it in a talent show! MAYBE!

  • Rauol's a bitch! YAY TEAM PHANTOM :D

  • The whole time I was listening to this song in the movie, I could only think about how sorry I felt for the Phantom. This is probably one of the sweetest stories ever, and I could listen to the Phantom of the Opera songs for hours and never get tired. I'm pretty sure I cried at the end of the movie.It really is a wonderful song.

  • @lilyflower5181 i cried at the end every time i watch it it is so sad

  • You like the movie, you should see it on Broadway, it will blow your mind

  • Phantom of the opera is the greatest movie of all time.Its a beautiful love story with music I think is sweeter than any modern music. I can never get tired of the Phantom of the Opera, the characters are lovable and display the greatest acting/singing performance. They dont add unnecessary, corny drama they just stick with classic beauty and passion for music. Although it is set a while back we can all relate to the feelings of jealousy, love, confusion, fear and disapointment. Greatest movie<3

  • ALL MY TEARS AT ONCE

  • I absolutely love the opera. The music and the costumes and everything. I even saw it on stage. That was a great experience!

  • if you dislike this then you a either don't have a heart or a special someone

  • i could imagine jesus singing this to me <3 

  • I had this song at my wedding

  • Anybody else think this would make the perfect set of wedding vows?

  • @bcprocks13 apperently 46 people do!

  • @bcprocks13 yep! im totaly making my husband sing this with me when we get married. its gonna be great!!! now i have to find a husband. that can sing. :/

  • @bcprocks13 me and my best friend, Derek sand this at his aunts wedding during the reception :-) there wasn't a dry eye in the place

  • @bcprocks13 I planned this to be a duet of me and my husband when we are married! (like 15-20 years away!)

  • @bcprocks13 If I liked weddings, yeah. (BTW: My favorite part is the fifth stanza thing :D

  • @bcprocks13 as i was listening to it all i thought was "i'd love this at my wedding" . Whenever I get married.

  • I'm shaking.. This song is so perfect

  • love you keira

  • OMG!!! Today the same boy that played me the song, played this song again and did a duet with me XD

  • Love this song.

  • i love this song ♥ c:

  • Orchestra is one of the best music genres of all time, I don't care what you think, because this just touched my heart. And if you do feel the same, then hit like. TT___TT

  • this is my FAVORITE song in the world!

  • i really love this song ..

  • this is at my wedding

  • i was texting my best guy friend (i think i like him but i have a boyfriend so confusing!) he sent me this; "you dont have to say a word just be happy thats all i ask of you" i know its not in the song but yeah

  • I love this song it's my fave & I can't stop listening to it XD

  • Phantom will always own my heart.. But this is one of the most incredible songs I have ever heard. <3

  • This song always makes me cry... And I am your stereotypical sports/tough guy :P

  • OMG love this! Raoul is my dream!

  • Very good song

  • so beautiful

  • uuugggg... I'm so sick of people getting mad at raoul because christine fell for hm and not her stalker. (Note that the phantom is old enough to be her father) For cryin out loud! Let's not forget that at the end of the movie she showed the phantom that she could love him but truely fell in love with raoul. -_- now shut up about that and enjoy the song.

  • I also love jackie evanchos version

  • I used to watch this 3 times a day for the whole year when I was around 7 or 9 or something. I couldn't understand anything yet but I just thought the songs and the voices were so damn beautiful. I am now in my school's Glee club as a result. lol. Listening to this song is so freaking nostalgic I'm tearing up T_T

  • Raoul's voice is so...(sigh)

  • shoot. My mom caught me listening to this. Now she thinks I am a wuss. I should just tell her "I am in love...."

  • ..nice it,,,

  • my girlfriend just dedicated this song to me

    it couldnt be more true

  • ohmygawsh.i can't choose.Raoul or Phantom?HAHAHAHA

  • i love the movie this is from, seen it a billion time, so good :D

  • I so want this to be played at my wedding... if that ever comes.

  • Is a very good one

  • I wish I could sing this:(

  • every one who sad the phatom deserves love too thank you , u r so smart and kind , thank u

  • My favorite i sung this is chorus class ♥

  • My wedding song....

  • Opps stupid auto correct. I ment cried.

  • I would have fired at this scene, with the phantom and everything, but I didn't cause my mom was in the room! (she was watching the movie too).

  • Raoul.... *sigh* cmon dude. y u no let the phantom have Christine?

  • i really love this song .... i just wish I could sing oprea (yes I can sing regularly and in a chior ) but oprea is too difficult but I'm working on it ! :)

  • I love Raoul!!

  • it's fun to try and sing this. lol

  • Such a beautiful song xxxx

  • my little sister and me cryed at this song when we say the movie and poor phantom

  • *sob* poor phantom! *sob*

  • What is the best love songs I've ever heard. I love the phantom of the opera. I saw the show back in the nineties.

  • I wanted Erick to win Christines heart ]:

  • @xXxPoiisonxXx He did they got married i always wanted the phantom to get christine they could have done amazing things together

  • @fooyo13 no they didnt, in the book the phantoms name is Erick, the guy she married is Raoul :/

  • I loove the movie and this song! <3

  • can i ask you a question, do you think it would be sweet if a boy play this song to you?

  • @chsEP6

    If you do the girl part, not really...

    

  • @Eternai91

    Thanks for the reply~!! ^.^ I asked because the boy that I like played this song on piano for me and I don't really know whether it's because he likes me or I just happened to be there when he rehearsed it

  • @chsEP6 I think that would mean he is not so subtly trying to prove his undying love for you...maybe

  • @radforGod07

    XD well that's one way to look at it Thanks~!!! -^.^-

  • @chsEP6 YES!!!!

    

  • @KairiUmazaki

    Thanks for the answer ^^

  • @chsEP6 YES! i would probably cry if a guy played this to me :3

  • @Music14Lover14

    when he played to me i was like "why is he playing a love song??" and when i got home i realised that he played me a love song?? and just start screaming my head off XD

  • @Music14Lover14

    the same boy played the song again and he did a duet with me XD

  • @chsEP6 If you played it for any girl who was into romantic stuff, she'll be crying with happiness before you finish the song.

  • @chsEP6 YES!!!!

  • @chsEP6 Yes i think so...

  • @chsEP6 No, I don't think so, I know so. My boyfriend sang this to me last night and I started crying because it was so beautiful&emotional. <33 It was so sweet and amazing... Now he wants me to learn Christine's part so we can do this as a duet together. [: I love you, Cody. Forever and always~!

  • @chsEP6 most definately

  • @chsEP6 Yes Yes Yes!

  • @chsEP6 yes it is sweet.

  • @chsEP6 Yes

  • This is my favorite song from the Phantom of the Opera :3 ♥

  • A beautiful song, one of my favourites

  • smart people dont date their stalkers even if they are hot

  • @charlie19932009

    And that's why I like Raoul better than the Phantom.

  • i hate raoul cuz he took chritine when we all know she should be with the phantom!!!!! i love this song. even though its a love song between raoul and christine

  • @cArli3lmin Yeah, but since they grow up Rauol didn't noticed Christine that much. :))

  • @KHJPerfection08 didn't she move because of her dad or something? 

  • Now that i just listened to alot of the songs, im gonna go to church tomorow and instead of singing those songs i will b singing Phantom of the Opera songs. My favorite song is Past the Point of No Return

  • I first watched this movie when i was 5 and i loved it i would go around singing it. I didnt c it for years and finally i saw it 2 years ago and cried at the end. It is such a beautiful story and i love it. I am 12 and LOVE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA. It is wierd because i cant talk to anyone about it becausr im in seventh grade. When my fifth grade teacher asked me what i was humming i quickly go " nothing". She would have thought i was lying. Anyway love the movie and I saved my money for the sound

  • @KenzeeMusicc That is very true! I take back my question.

  • WHYYYY did she not stay with the PHANTOM!!!

  • Question, how old is the phantom? He was young when Madame Giry was young. Just wondering.

  • @SnitramJ93 In the version of this movie with music, it's Gerard Butler playing Phantom. If it's Gerard Butler, is there really a reason to care about age? <3

  • Does anyone else think that she desperately belongs with the phantom !?!?!?!?

    

  • I think Erick deserved Christine even more because Raoul only noticed Christine when she got famous. Remember the Erick was the person behind Christine's fame. Although I have nothing against it, it's the girl's choice! :))

  • @KHJPerfection08 actually raoul and christine were friends when they were little....

  • She sudnt b with the phantom cuz he threatens her pus hes a control freak on da oder hand raoul is sweet caring compassionate and sooooo hot do the math i wud so pick raoul

  • @mar0987kitty the phantom just wanted to be loved, everyone hated him just cuz he had a scar on his face.... not hating...just my opinion :)

  • It's so sad...I feel sorry for the phantom in the movie :c

  • saw this live <3

  • @MsNaniiXD me too!! it was amazing<33

  • I soooo would have picked Erik!!!

  • Am I the only eleven year old (twelve in eight days) who deeply loves Phantom of the Opera? I mean, I grew up on this stuff. I used to watch the movie all the time on road trips. Love it!

  • my little cousin loves it too

  • @queenofeveryone same here!!!!!!! xD

    

  • @queenofeveryone I wish everyone your age had your spelling capabilities and taste in music.

  • i wish she picked the phantom...i mean for fucks sake you gotta pick the bad guy for once..not that hes bad or anything

  • Those people that disliked this video, you sure you got taste in music?

  • i wouldn't be able to decide; a childhood friend, or a mysterious man, i just wouldn't be able to choose

  • i wouldn't be able to decide; a childhood friend, or a mysterious man, i just wouldn't be able to choose

  • I THINK THAT CHRISTINE SHOULD STAY WITH ERICK (phantom) AND NOT WITH RAOUL!! THE PHANTOM WAS VERY KIND WITH HER. HE HELPS HER SING AND BE THE BEST AND SHE? what do she give to erick?? NOTHING!

  • Mine and mi bf's song. =)

  • I love this song... I want someone to love me like that...<3

  • @BlizzardFangs Why not have both?

  • I love Emmy Rossum <3

  • @BlizzardFangs I LOVE THE PHANTOM..I WILL WATCH A TRILLION TIMES..THIS CLIP MUST PLAY ON MY WEDDING DAY.

  • he was bound to love you once he heard you sing!!!

  • @DontKnowxDontCare, we didn't ask and we don't care. Cool story ,bro.

  • this song makes me think of my old school i just left- we sang this in chorus- i miss them all so much and i would give anything to be back there</3

  • this song reminds me of my ex-bf. i miss him sooooo much.

  • Whether you like Raoul or not, you can't deny the fact that this is a beautiful song...

  • @BlizzardFangs I balance both

  • @BlizzardFangs very well said! i feel the same way!! i wish i could choose both!! .. or chirstine... hhaha

  • Has anyone else thought that the phantom deserves love too??

  • @lovedove52 fuck yeah

  • @lovedove52 listen to the point of no return. That'll cheer ya up!

  • @lovedove52 no

  • @lovedove52 Yes, and actually, I'm writing a story about Erik(the Phantom's) happy ending.

  • @lovedove52 I wanted to vote up this comment but I saw that it had exactly one hundered forty-three vote ups and I thought it was too perfect.

  • @lovedove52

    that what i thought so.. he just became so obsessed and revengeful that's why nobody seems have the heart to love him but he's kind from what i see...

  • My parents had this song played at their wedding. <3