Added: 3 years ago
From: TheGargantuanSock
Views: 249,309
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (217)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Dude. They rock...That solo note held from 2:35 to 2:47. So much feeling in a single note.

  • This song is a tribute from Eddie Vedder to his band.

    Imortality!

  • Happy Birthday Eddie!!!..

    Your music, everything you do makes our lives so much better and happier!!

    Tkank You for all these years!!

  • Mesmerizing.......

  • Just saw them live in Santiago, McCready is really awesome!!

  • foda!!!

    

  • Great <3

  • Mccready..underrated,,he's a great and humble guitarist

  • immortality & vitalogy album are one of my favorites...

  • Comment removed

  • ok I watched Seethers cover.... nice cover.

    but PJ were in concert, and this was prob their 13th song of the night........

    let them setup in an unplugged setting like they did on MTV and NOBODY CAN TOUCH THEIR SHAT

  • Seethers version is better. Way better. And ACDC is shit since back in black.

  • @slitherlock it's a good cover, but it's not better than the original. They just play the album version of the song. And Vedder is Vedder.

  • @slitherlock I disagree on both assertions. Seether's is OK, but doesn't quite reach that of the original. And, as far as AC/DC goes, not a huge fan, because i do agree they have a 'samey sound(!)' but i thought Black Ice was great. Straight up R n R, which we're in dire need of, i think! Both points merely an opinion though!

  • @nashmiddleton you carry around a picture of Eddie Vedder around in your wallet for when u want to be sensitive, don't you? Admit it and set your secret free.

  • seether are like kiss.

    they

    suck

  • Mike Mc Cready solo... amazing.

  • Seethers cover is one of the best covers ever, but original Immortality by Pearl Jam is masterpeace, and uncomparably better.

  • Everybody listen to seether's version of this song... It's better

  • @it3659 Thats a discrace to the band!

  • best song all ever

  • At 1:23 When they first cut to Mike he looks so much like Eric Clapton....

  • My favorite Pearl Jam song!

  • I like a lot Pearl Jam but i think there aren't so much Mike Mccready solo guitar unfortunately in Pj songs...this is my opinion

  • I know who you are now mr. sock...you are the guy MTV fired for sniffing Bono's leather caps. stop taking everything so literally and for heavens sake lose the anger you have...it's dangerous for small children, the elderly, and tiny animals around you.

  • @slitherlock

    I wasn't angry in the slightest, but I must say I'm a little irked now. Don't make literal comments if you don't mean for them to be taken literally. Also, being rebutted is not an excuse to be rude. Start posting some sense, or you can start being blocked :)

  • @TheGargantuanSock

    who the fuck are you to block someone from posting a comment on a pearl jam video?

    yeah, you uploaded the vid, good fucking job.

  • @chadd990

    Who the fuck are you if you think insulting someone because they say something positive about Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam video has any place on YouTube? Did you even bother reading the thread? I was not rude to this individual, my opinion differed to his and he attempted to turn a positive debate relevant to the video into a slagging match. If people troll, post spam or are unnecessarily rude or insulting to me or others on my uploads I have every right to block them.

  • @TheGargantuanSock

    no i didn't bother reading the thread. it is not your place to moderate what comments can be posted on a video that you do not own. it matters not if the person is a troll.

  • @chadd990

    Actually it is my place, it's also my place to disable the comments section altogether should I see fit. You think I shouldn't moderate my channel just because I don't 'own' most of its content? Moderating comments on something you don't own is surely not as bad as sharing it for free with everyone on YouTube, who am I to share something that isn't mine? Perhaps this and most of the other music based channels should be closed because they aren't 'owned' by record companies?

  • @TheGargantuanSock

    you're such a fucking tool.

  • @chadd990

    It's now apparent that you are woefully incapable of piecing together a coherent argument, hence why you fall back on weak, childish insults. You don't read the relevant thread, you criticise me and then fail to back up any of your criticisms with anything even remotely similar to substance... amateurish really.

  • @TheGargantuanSock

    great defense mechanism. and let me guess, I first started arguing with you because I'm jealous? No, I'm done arguing with you because its pointless. Your ego is obviously too big, there's no point talking to you. that's why resorted to insulting you instead continuing with my argument.

  • @chadd990

    God only knows where you plucked jealousy from, I thought you saw yourself as some sort of cyber protector of free speech, standing up for trolls and the like... until you brought ownership into it. Now, rather than back up your claims you insult me - my ego is too big because you don't like me disagreeing with you, arguing with me is pointless because you haven't made any decent points - so you insult me because you can't back up or back out of a poor argument gracefully.

  • @TheGargantuanSock Shut up please and enjoy one of the best bands to ever walk this earth.

    Let him have his own opinion; you can have yours. 

  • @bagelman10

    As far as I could tell that argument ended a week ago... why bother bringing it up unless you're trying to be confrontational? If you really care about enjoying this band then I'd suggest you shut up yourself.

  • @TheGargantuanSock Aye-aye, boss ;)

  • @slitherlock funny shit... better than anger...

    not takin' sides, don't even know what you're referring to... just had to give you props.

    "lose the anger."

  • pearl jam

    

  • I would give my cat, my wisdom teeth, and two thirds of my mojo juice if pearl jam could put out 10 more albums like 10.

  • @slitherlock

    If they'd done that they would never have released this song for starters, and they'd be pretty damn dull. Pearl Jam aren't AC/DC, they can't put out the same album for 20 years and still make it sound great - they needed and indeed wanted to evolve and change and as a result have been one of the most fresh and interesting sounding bands around for a very long time. That's one of the reasons why they've built up such a dedicated fanbase over the years.

  • @TheGargantuanSock (sigh) AC/DC hasn't been relevant since back in black. there are absolutely no dynamics or changes in vocal range of their singer and the guitar riffs are distorted blues scales like most of the other 80's guitar "gods"

  • @slitherlock

    (sigh) exactly! So why the hell would you want Pearl Jam to do an acca dacca and put out 10 more albums like 10 if you don't think the masters of staying the same despite everything haven't done a very good job of it?

  • @slitherlock

    AC/DC had a fantastic album streak from about '76 to '80 (SIX full length albums) when they could do no wrong - any grungy band that has tried anything similar has failed miserably and PJ would be no different. In the same timeframe after 10 they released Vs, Vitalogy and No Code - a great streak of their own where they made a great deal of progression with their sound! Had they simply tried to release carbon copies of 10 they'd have been consigned to the pages of history.

  • @TheGargantuanSock

    1.U CANT COMPARE AC/DC WITH PEARL JAM!!!!!!

    2. IF "NEVERMIND" WAS NEVER PUBLISHED "TEN" WOULD HAVE KILLED METAL !!!!

    3. IF U DONT FEEL THE GRUNGE ERA LIKE WE DO GET THE FUCK OUT FROM HERE AND LISTEN TO YOUR SHITTY AC/DC SONGS !!!!!

    4. THIS SONGS MEAN MY WHOLE LIFE AND I BET HALF OF THIS PEOPLE HERE MEAN THE SAME THING ABOUT THIS MUSIC, SO U CAN FUCK OFF AND GO LISTEN TOO YOU'R SHIT AND DONT BOTHER US HERE !!!

    LONG LIVE GRUNGE !! LONG LIVE PEARL JAM !!!!

  • @Guitariification

    1. I wasn't, I said Pearl Jam could not have put out ten albums like ten, because then they would have turned into the AC/DC of grunge and they'd never have released this song - no grunge band has ever put out albums as regularly and with as little ambition as AC/DC successfully.

    2. Not only is that statement moronic, it's completely irrelevant.

    3 & 4. I have dedicated most of my channel to Pearl Jam, you fucking idiot.

    5. Stop writing in caps lock, it's unsightly.

  • @Guitariification lol u mad

  • @TheGargantuanSock blah blah blah evolve blah blah blah fresh and interesting blah blah blah dedicated fanbase blah blah blah

    think about it man. 10 more 10s.

  • @SAclammy

    I have thought about it, though you clearly haven't. Ten albums in the same style back to back would be really, really boring. There is however a saying that great albums come in threes... and that saying has a great deal of truth in it.

  • @TheGargantuanSock Ten albums in the same style as 10 would be really, really awesome, you mean. 

  • @TheGargantuanSock Amen bro. They are my favorite band and probably always will be. Each album is different, but seemingly similar. They are changing yet the same. That's why they will remain one of the driving forces of music in the last twenty years. Thank God for Pearl Jam.

  • @slitherlock grow up

  • 0:45 So fuckin' hot!

    And yes, I am a guy.

  • Ahhh, Dios mio..  Mike Mcready es il diablo.......

  • Fucking God...McCreedy is fucking good player! His solos kicks assess

  • @mab01 they usually do, some just give instant goose bumps

  • ¡Que grande por dios!

  • At 2:18 Mike McCreedy looks like Fukin Frankenstien on crack , He just lets it go and dominates the riff with minimal effort and total perfection. I always knew Pearl Jam was awesome! But it took Sirius Xm radio and the Pearl Jam Channel for me to understand that these guys are clearly one of the greatest ever...........

  • sempre...live!

  • MUITO BOM VIVA PEARL JAM...............SEMPREEEEEEE­EEEEE

  • bravo majstori.nesto najbolje sto sam poslusao uzadnje dvije godine,pozdrav iz mrkonjića

  • this song hits so close to the heart...I only knew ten as a child...then had my heart torn in half and found the later years of Pearl Jam...and like Ben Harper, Eddie Vedder and Pearl jam are definitely godsend...Thanks for your continued motivating lyrics...

  • Chile <3 

  • legendary song from a legendary band. amazing..

  • much better than the original. pure beauty.

  • I love this song..... I just love it...

  • people think it's about Kurt.. but i actually think the song is about the Holocaust

  • India!! Please come to India.. we've all been waiting for so long now.

  • Led Zeppelin, Pearl Jam, Mumford and Sons. In my opinion, the 3 best bands ever. They all have that raw emotion feel in their songs and i love it. Pearl Jam will live forever.

  • McCready looks like a zombie in the solo....:)

  • can anyone upload the studio version of his song? it's nowhere to be found on youtube, which is really disappointing

  • @bonnertom032 so what live music will always be better than studio versions

  • @bonnertom032 Do yourself a favor and just buy Vitalogy...you might as well listen to the entire album it only costs like 10 bucks and the album packaging is amazing. Vitalogy is probably the last CD in history that shouldn't be downloaded.

  • Pearl Jam is such a great band.

  • BOUTCH...

  • Some say that this song is about Kurt Cobain? Is that possible?

  • @N7Crazy Don't know that much about Pearl Jam but i'm pretty sure it's not

  • @N7Crazy i don't think it is, It was written before Kurt died I think.

  • @Jackstanford7 Eddie already had the basic sketch for the song,then made some adjustments after Kurt died.That's what I remember reading somewhere awhile back.

  • @orangewizard Ah, but the first time it was played was the day Kurt died I thought? In Boston I think, the same show Eddie exited the stage by digging a hole jumping through it

  • i remeber eddie telling he had writhin this song for kurt

    its a great song

  • hehe jammin in his jammie pants \m/ike owns

  • My favorite PJ song! So haunting, so poignant and SO fucking beautiful

    FUCKING AWESOME SONG!

  • and there i was, travelling throught out the web.. while Mr Mike McMcready was playing god in this little window.

  • I really don´t like how Gossard changed the solo.... :S I prefered if he played the original one....

  • @StaredSound you know Mike McCreedy plays the solo in this song right?

  • @LateralisUndertow fail! I dont know Pearl Jam´s elements that muchm I thought it was Gossard. xD Anyway, I prefer the original solo...not this one... :b

  • Stone is one of five to ten...

  • "Holier than thou, ha"

  • i like the other version best. this is so good. but... i donno... i could paint the moon u know?

  • Orgasm. We want Dave Abbruzzese back!!

  • @Togonzalez TRUE!!! 

  • Comment removed

  • I'm married with 3 kids but as far as man-crushes go, there are none bigger than us men have for Ed. Long live Vedder.

  • TEMÓN!

    quien pudo haber puesto negativo?

  • oh my God.

  • i love how mccreadys wearing pajama pants

  • i was there... amazing show

  • Cigar box on the floor... Kurt Cobain.

  • I love this song!

  • i better get to see pearl jam in concert again...

  • santiago 23 de nov 05, cancha , con las pulsaciones mil escuchar un pedazo de solo de mike ..... no tiene precio

  • soave a tratti Hendrixiano.... Un vagabondo ha trovato casa E un desiderio a cui aggrapparsi. Ma c'è una botola nel sole...Immortalità

  • good road song no job finally leaving the 'zone ripped up clothes beat up car $100 in my pocket new mex, mex, tex, memphis, nashville goin back east immortality grapes of wrath

  • why do people always start wars under pearl jam and nirvana videos about who is best? is this a sport?

    they both are awesome, stfu already.

    and lol at vedder screwing up the lyrica at 2-3 places xD

  • Much better than seether's version, which is good too.

  • @21stCenturyDeadline which is the original ?

  • @DarkMetalKnight69 Pearl Jams version ofcourse.

  • really...this performance is wonderful...

  • what did people do before youtube?

  • PJ The King!

  • One of my favs by PJ....thanks so much for sharing..

  • @ApostastyUK Nov. 2005

  • the best (actually) band in the world

  • Even In a huge crowd Eddie makes yu feel like hes singing Just for you ...PJ is awesome..Thanks for keping this on so more people can see them Live, they rock!

  • shhhh....children. one of the best bands on earth performing....thanks g sock for sharing this masterpiece

  • Pearl Jam = genious.

  • Favorite pearl jam song. I change by not changing.

  • the gargantuansock, thank you SO much for posting all those brilliant PJ vids, much respect for that mate. just saw them playing hyde park last week and forgot how much they enjoyed performing. keep on spreading the jam! :)

  • @tubescreamer92

    No worries mate, I was at Hyde Park too... what a great band.

  • sweet volume swells Mike

  • I just saw them play this on Cleveland. No words...

  • @fobiaplastico i was at that concert too. best night i've had in a long time

  • if anyone would compare to zep in the nineties. it would have to be them.

  • @MgHq I think they're more like the who

  • Pearl Jam The best band ever

  • awesome, but is it my comp or does part of it skip at the end?

  • LOVE PJ 4 EVER !!!!

  • Troppo bella!!!

  • thks ivan for let me discorver this song

    pearl jam great group

    i m french and i m a big fan

  • I Love This Song

  • Great performance. Gotta live Mike's solo, incredible sustain. Great song, great band.

  • This is a shot to the soul.Goddes!!

  • Ainda me arrepio quando escuto essa música..

    Adoro esses caras salve Pearl Jam!!!!

  • la mejor cancion en concierto que he visto en mi vida la inspiracion del guitarrista es impresionante parece que hubiera ido al espacio por 2 minutos y volviera que cancion que concierto felicitaciones santiago de chile

  • 1:23 .... its Eric ClaptoN! xD

  • crap your right lol

  • Fucking awesome solo. Jesus the sustain on the harmonic was spectacular.

    Great song - greater band. The lyrics are

    about Kurt Cobain arent they? Does anyone know for certain?

    They sound like they could be.

    Either way - wow.

  • @DEVGRUFIVE Yup you've got to love them. Still rocking out too. There's not many bands of that era still going. I read an interview with Eddie Ved. He stated no to song being about Kurt. It doesn't matter though as the lyrics are pretty fitting nevertheless.

  • my favorite live performance of immortality... but the south america concerts were all really great, I love those bootlegs!

  • concordo com você! todos os shows na América do Sul foram muito bons.. eu fui em 1 apenas e tenho boas recordações daquele dia 30 de novembro de 2005, Curitiba... uuuuu.. ;-)

  • the great thing about pearl jam is that they're not a one-dimensional band. They're not, "i'm sad" or "i'm angry" or "i'm cool."

    they're just what they are, and that's what I love about them

  • +1 to Mike McCready.

  • Omg look at that solo!!! shit omg!!

    Hands down ..

  • That Les Paul really shows its sustain here

  • STONE GOSSARD IS SO UNDERRATED !!!

  • @27hextall completely agree, he is one of the best gunge guitarists of all time(rythym wise at least), it was him and and ament who wrote pretty much all of Ten

  • el solo de mike no estuvo tan bueno creo

  • con todo respeto creo no tienes idea de lo q hay q hacer para q esa girbson suene de esa manera, un solo no tiene q tener mil notas por segundo para q sea un buen solo escucha el feeling, el tono, la improvisacion.

  • coincido con vos... muy prolijo

    pupe

    LA JOYA

  • a ver cuando viene a peru no??????? una de mis bandas favoritas

  • Soofuckinperb!

  • having seen pearl jam live was one my life s greater experiences...wish i was a bit older so i could have seen them in the 90 s,with all the grunge wave and stuff and eddie even youngier and crazier:P..trully talented guy with great spirit

  • love this song!!!

  • impresionantee gran cancion !

  • realmenteee lindoooooo ,

  • This song is so fucking awesome live. I have seen them about 15 times and this song and Indifference still give me chills when I am luckily enough to hear it live. PJ rules the day.

  • I get my chills from "Better Man"

  • I LOVE YOU PEARL JAM!

  • Great song!i!i!i!i!i!i!

    Pearl Jam forever *****

  • INCREIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Haha someone tokin some MAJOR reefer right in the middle of the audience at 3:16! Hell yeah!

  • hahahahahaha,,, kurt cobain was great,, his lyrics sounds amazing, i used to love nirvana, but i really think just because i was 13 years old, ,,, actually im 30 and i really think nivanas lyrics was for teenagers,,,,,,,,pearl jams song is for all ages,,, thats my opinion

    eddie is an artist

    haha come as you are, hahaha, yhea rebelion against my teachers hahah,,,,teens pretending become in bad boys

  • donde fue eso?????

  • bueniiiisimo, yo estuve ahí, las dos noches, el mejor concierto de la historia...

  • at this very moment i cannot comprehend what i just witnessed. These man exceed the imagination of our minds

  • beatiful...i went to 4 pj concert but i've never heard this song live...i hope to listen it in Berlin in August.....

  • È foda""""""""""

  • Bloody brilliant! Thanks for sharing.

  • Mike the man!!!!!!

  • eddie vedder is a brilliant singer..

  • haha HUGE understatement

  • very intellectual comment there mojo :D

  • i guess the idiot that said mat cameron is not the best drummer they had clearly doesnt listen to the drums in all these songs..and to say that it actaully depresses you makes me want to rape your family.

  • U guys should also go check seether acoustic cover of the song they did it at one cold night truly sounds amazing aswell

  • I agree. Really not a Seether fan until I heard that version and some other great covers.