Holy crap! This is supposed to be a love ballad and she sounds like she wants to beat the crap out'a whoever she's singing about! No thanks, I'll stay with Lynn Hilary of Celtic Woman rendition. Christ, at least Lynn sounds like she loves the person the song is about.
No haunting mysticism here ..only a pop version to dance to....Listen to the Kate Bush druid mixx..it's not bad...it's just not the right message for this song..
Dear sister it's Me Gweeni hope You are doing well, I love you Thank You for the lovely song. From the U.S. I think of you alot, keep your chin up, we are to serious both of Us. Mother says Hi!
@ulstermourne You have to be kidding. Not even close to the best. She needs acoustics to help her. Listen to Dusty Springfield, Kate Bush & the Corrs. This song was never meant to be a upbeat rock type song. Oh, by the way, even Sinead would tell you that her Idol was Dusty Springfield.
@chee6060 Oh dear, this song was "never meant to be a(sic) upbeat rock type song". This is Sinead's interpretation of her idea of what the song is about. Artistic freedom anyone? The Corrs ffs.
Sinead is a seriously demented individual and I never had any use for her, but then she came out with the album "Sean Nos Nua" and just blew me out of my headphones with the power and passion of every song on it.
I still don't want to hear her opinions on anything, but I very much want to hear her singing the Irish classics in her inimitable style. This song is the best on the album, too. WOW.
@KaptKan1 you misunderstand her if you think she is demented. She has passion for expressing truth above all, even if that truth is misunderstood by others. You should educate yourself about her more.
@KatJaguar1122 But it seems you have heard her true spirit come thru on this album, yet she has MANY. She has an amazing body of work, and is a genuine example of a human being.
@KaptKan1 you misunderstand her if you think she is demented. She has passion for expressing truth above all, even if that truth is misunderstood by others. You should educate yourself about her more. But it seems you have heard her true spirit come thru on this album, but she has MANY. She has an amazing body of work, and is a genuine example of a human being.
John Loesberg in his "Folksongs and Ballads Popular in Ireland, vol. 2" (Ossian Publications, Cork, 1980) states that the words are by Joseph McCahill, set to an old Irish air. (p. 71). I fully appreciate it as a love song, without any political meaning. Loesberg would not try to cover any political meaning up. I think Sinead did a huge artistry with this song, and the "rock" arrangement only adds to the magic of it. I am just sorry that she left out the third verse. Wonderful, anyway!
If u don't think this is a political song then I believe you can only half enjoy it. Listen to words like "steal" and "creep" and imagery like insects, undergrowth and mist. To me it spells out the need for stealth and living in the shackles of oppression. Importantly though, the oppressed are fighting back " in sweet and undertones the song of hearts desire" In my opinion this is a rebel song.
A whole week I'm listening this song...incredible addiction! I discovered her only few time ago and I'm completely found of her. I have read her biography (even incredible...) and I feel in this song all the intensity I read. Thank you (and sorry for grammatical mistakes...)
very interesting version of this song but i really like it i dont know why some people are complaining. very unique. i wish i could get an acapella version of this or at least acoustic the music is too much
Sinéad and her band have lost so much of the longing and beauty of this song. It works OK for a pop/world audience but very much misses the mark on a Gaelic cultural level. I acknowledge that she is a very talented artist nonetheless and no disrespect intended.
The simplicity and introspection expressed by the words and character of the melody gives the song its power. A stadium rock backing pulls it in a different emotional direction and audience. Something's lost and something's gained.
As a native Gael, brought up in that musical tradition, Maureen Hegarty's version hits home far more for the same reasons she sang it the way she did. I make no excuses for my culture, but I do not feel it worthy to "flame" anyone else for theirs.
I don't know what you mean? I take it you're not irish by the use of the work Gaelic, we don't say gaelic. I think the captures the essence of irish culture
pretty beautiful person Sinead. I used to live near her and she's so small it was hard to to step on her on the street. Nothing small about her voice... her heart makes me feel like a dwarf.
Variants of the lyrics go back over a century and the melody probably goes back hundreds of years before that. I once tracked down the full history but have since forgotten much of it. Sinead's version is much shorter than the others, which is a shame since her version is by far the most powerful i've yet heard.
This hit me about 3 years ago and i still come back ever now and then. I posted tons of info about the history of this song on a site but sadly the site is now down.
This is my favourite version of this song by far.Its just stunning!Plus,good call on including the lyrics.I play and sing this song but when I first learned it,I found it hard to find lyrics becasue there are several different versions!Class song!
So, since there is almost certainly no official video for this song, you imply that we do not want the song on youtube, in which case, we have to wonder what youtube is for? Videos?
Oh,so sorry for that hostile post below! Not everyone feels that way.This is one of my very favorite songs.Thank you for your creativity-the song inspired you.Good for you.The lyrics are very unusual-maybe only the devoted Sinead fan knows them by heart.Useful for others! Sinead forever.
kill the troubles.
Snakey2012 1 month ago
there blows a lilly fair , beautiful , no?
Snakey2012 1 month ago
Holy crap! This is supposed to be a love ballad and she sounds like she wants to beat the crap out'a whoever she's singing about! No thanks, I'll stay with Lynn Hilary of Celtic Woman rendition. Christ, at least Lynn sounds like she loves the person the song is about.
William2020a 1 month ago
I like this version. upbeat .very good.
4everugly 3 months ago
.....And bang goes my self-esteem.
Milesify8 4 months ago
amazing performance.. truely a unique sound that should be heard everywhere
bleeker31 6 months ago
She knows Margaret Barry but she's no Margaret Barry. Barry is still the geatest traditional ballad performer I've heard in 60 years.
alexsandysharp 6 months ago
you all need your hearing fix and a large dose of artistic appreciation tablets.
this is a beautiful song lifted by someone who has more talent and feel than anyone in Ireland or the world.
nickdalmedo1 7 months ago
beauty of heart and soul and features to make the cats cry
dcconsi 9 months ago
No haunting mysticism here ..only a pop version to dance to....Listen to the Kate Bush druid mixx..it's not bad...it's just not the right message for this song..
Cythereaswetworld 9 months ago
@Cythereaswetworld You must be mad if you think this is "a pop version to dance to" Hah. Open your ears and listen.....This is a rebel song.
hearditman 8 months ago
Its not actually about her love of.. LAGER is it....very disappointed.
speedcrane 9 months ago
@speedcrane No, this is NOT Sinead singing "Nothing Compares To A Brew".
Any Other Questions?
KennBurch 8 months ago
What a ruination of a beautiful Irish Ballad.
chee6060 10 months ago
Dear sister it's Me Gweeni hope You are doing well, I love you Thank You for the lovely song. From the U.S. I think of you alot, keep your chin up, we are to serious both of Us. Mother says Hi!
Dianalynn347 10 months ago
Brought a tear to my eye....
Mojave888 10 months ago
the best version of my favourite song of all time.
ulstermourne 11 months ago 2
@ulstermourne You have to be kidding. Not even close to the best. She needs acoustics to help her. Listen to Dusty Springfield, Kate Bush & the Corrs. This song was never meant to be a upbeat rock type song. Oh, by the way, even Sinead would tell you that her Idol was Dusty Springfield.
chee6060 10 months ago
@chee6060 Oh dear, this song was "never meant to be a(sic) upbeat rock type song". This is Sinead's interpretation of her idea of what the song is about. Artistic freedom anyone? The Corrs ffs.
hearditman 8 months ago
Thank you HHulzebos for posting this rendition and photographs, so full of life and hope.
mookins58 1 year ago
For those who think that they might prefer to hear this song sung as opposed to screamed, check out the Lynn Hilary version.
hopfrog5557 1 year ago
@hopfrog5557
It doesn't always have to be sung the same. Sinead emotes in her own way--and puts herself into the song.
frostipagan 11 months ago
total chills; her voice is so effective at stirring emotion
amccann7 1 year ago
finbar fureys versions better
leklekbruva 1 year ago
awesome tune sinead does a wonderful job here
giffworks 1 year ago
Beautiful like Dusty Springfield and Kate Bush's version.
zapme9 1 year ago
This song and singer surely gets my attention as worthy of a repeat listen!
64berber 1 year ago
Sinead is a seriously demented individual and I never had any use for her, but then she came out with the album "Sean Nos Nua" and just blew me out of my headphones with the power and passion of every song on it.
I still don't want to hear her opinions on anything, but I very much want to hear her singing the Irish classics in her inimitable style. This song is the best on the album, too. WOW.
KaptKan1 1 year ago
@KaptKan1 you misunderstand her if you think she is demented. She has passion for expressing truth above all, even if that truth is misunderstood by others. You should educate yourself about her more.
KatJaguar1122 1 year ago
@KatJaguar1122 But it seems you have heard her true spirit come thru on this album, yet she has MANY. She has an amazing body of work, and is a genuine example of a human being.
KatJaguar1122 1 year ago
@KaptKan1 you misunderstand her if you think she is demented. She has passion for expressing truth above all, even if that truth is misunderstood by others. You should educate yourself about her more. But it seems you have heard her true spirit come thru on this album, but she has MANY. She has an amazing body of work, and is a genuine example of a human being.
KatJaguar1122 1 year ago
great voice,poor performence of this song though,all the nuances are gone,coould have been britney or rhianna tha performed it.no feeling
Godphobia 1 year ago
what a powerful woman
tropicalhusky 1 year ago
This Is AMAZING!!! NO ONE Can Top Sinead!!!
whillyem 1 year ago
The best version of my lagan love, Sinnead beside this beautiful awesome song, you are so pretty.....love you.
pichoni 1 year ago
Ruined a good song.... a damn shame.
TheOperababe18 1 year ago
@TheOperababe18 The hell with you and opera bitch... this is an Irish song and Sinead is as Irish as you get.
solariis888 1 year ago
John Loesberg in his "Folksongs and Ballads Popular in Ireland, vol. 2" (Ossian Publications, Cork, 1980) states that the words are by Joseph McCahill, set to an old Irish air. (p. 71). I fully appreciate it as a love song, without any political meaning. Loesberg would not try to cover any political meaning up. I think Sinead did a huge artistry with this song, and the "rock" arrangement only adds to the magic of it. I am just sorry that she left out the third verse. Wonderful, anyway!
greattoucan 1 year ago
whatever she signs i enjoy..her voice and talent amazing..
fancyredrose 1 year ago
finbar furey does it 123123413 better
leklekbruva 1 year ago
How could anyone do this song better?
cltaurus 1 year ago 4
love it, wish she would do somemore gaelic songs =)
SytheClaw 1 year ago 6
I really love this version, Sinead has such a beautiful and evocative voice, fantastic!!
honeyflowerchild 1 year ago 9
lynn hilary is much better than sinead, well i love much better lynn version bcuz is more peacefuly and her voice is really deep.
waldhemar21 1 year ago
immense
lsdvine 1 year ago
Good singer but you would never feel comfortable if she was around.
yiblon 1 year ago
if this does not move you, you need to check for a pulse....
eusbom 1 year ago
could she actually be any more amazin!!
speccyride 1 year ago
Mary Black's version (with Phil Coulter) is nicer.
btwclassic 1 year ago
@btwclassic
It may be nicer. but it ain't as potent. Sinead sings politically, whack it up selcetor.
hearditman 1 year ago
My Lagan Love is not a political song. I merely stated a preference.
btwclassic 1 year ago
If u don't think this is a political song then I believe you can only half enjoy it. Listen to words like "steal" and "creep" and imagery like insects, undergrowth and mist. To me it spells out the need for stealth and living in the shackles of oppression. Importantly though, the oppressed are fighting back " in sweet and undertones the song of hearts desire" In my opinion this is a rebel song.
hearditman 1 year ago
Its not a song, but poem by Joseph Campbel. And surely political, when he couldnt wrote about his country, he had to call her girl.
jinnyzz 1 year ago 4
I've heard quite a few versions of this song, but for me SInead's is the most resonant, the most passionate & the most eloquent.
auntarcticboosh 1 year ago
I completely adore Sinéad..
Jinnica 1 year ago 2
Surely this is the greatest female singer of all time??
BILLYBELFORD1 1 year ago 38
More like banshee.
BandBoxParade 2 years ago
Do you know what a ban si is?
barryjohn1 1 year ago
This is from a website:
"In Scottish Gaelic a "leannan-sidhe" is a Faery Lover. This type of Faery Lover
often takes a person's love and then leaves. He or she goes back where they came
from (Faery Land?) leaving the human pining for their lost love. The poor
mortals in the tales of leannan sidhe often died of sorrow. DS,BG""
GuntyManth 1 year ago
A whole week I'm listening this song...incredible addiction! I discovered her only few time ago and I'm completely found of her. I have read her biography (even incredible...) and I feel in this song all the intensity I read. Thank you (and sorry for grammatical mistakes...)
kennetandersson 2 years ago
My mum listened to this as I grew up, I love it.
shaeso 2 years ago
very interesting version of this song but i really like it i dont know why some people are complaining. very unique. i wish i could get an acapella version of this or at least acoustic the music is too much
Tilara 2 years ago
@Tilara Celtic Woman sings an acapella version of this
cwfannumber1 2 years ago
Different style but filled with emotion.
tinkerbells101 2 years ago
Check out Charlotte Church's version. It is the best by far.
stile1973 2 years ago
Oh,no.You've just forgotten that nothing compares to Sinead.
respitesearcher 2 years ago 23
Why does this tune remind me of Sandy Denny's "Quiet Joys of Brotherhood?"
sujeffay 2 years ago
@ sujeffay I think it is exactly the same tune
peskirabbit 2 years ago
she means it
jackcairns 2 years ago
Great tune & Her voice is an utter diamond..I'm not keen on the plinky plonky pop beat either though! S'ok tho..the song is great so it survives
Mrsjessywessybessy 2 years ago 2
Sinéad and her band have lost so much of the longing and beauty of this song. It works OK for a pop/world audience but very much misses the mark on a Gaelic cultural level. I acknowledge that she is a very talented artist nonetheless and no disrespect intended.
Marchawc 2 years ago
I have heard Kate Bush is is going to record a version of this song.
I have to say I totally disagree with your commentary.
Can you explain what would have made the song hit the mark on a Gaelic cultural level?
It's so easy to flame you for what you wrote..but, I'd rather hear you explain.
JewishVegan 2 years ago
The simplicity and introspection expressed by the words and character of the melody gives the song its power. A stadium rock backing pulls it in a different emotional direction and audience. Something's lost and something's gained.
As a native Gael, brought up in that musical tradition, Maureen Hegarty's version hits home far more for the same reasons she sang it the way she did. I make no excuses for my culture, but I do not feel it worthy to "flame" anyone else for theirs.
Peace.
Marchawc 2 years ago
"My Lagan Love"(along with "Burning Bridge") appears on the B-side of Kate Bush's 12inch EP "Cloudbusting" of 1985.
Kate uses her own lyrics and sings so beautifully here. Enjoy.
watch?v=vHG1MwSN5eE
Marchawc 2 years ago
I don't know what you mean? I take it you're not irish by the use of the work Gaelic, we don't say gaelic. I think the captures the essence of irish culture
ailish086 2 years ago
What a butch!
magpie4321 2 years ago
a softer version would suit, she is amazing, but this version is too loud to capture the sensual spirit of the lyrics written to me...
wryguy007 2 years ago
Soo Talented will ye be at the next Celic Connections??
Murrin 2 years ago
the "crickets singing stone" is about the Quislings who sold out the cause.
hearditman 2 years ago
This is a heavily disguised or at least deceptive rebel song. I love it, whack it up selector..........
hearditman 2 years ago
i know this song as sung much softer but i totally love this version
malwida 2 years ago 2
I agree. It stays with you a long time! In a very pleasant way. Spirited!
mairez1 2 years ago
pretty beautiful person Sinead. I used to live near her and she's so small it was hard to to step on her on the street. Nothing small about her voice... her heart makes me feel like a dwarf.
miley5566 2 years ago 2
One of the best songs Sinead has ever sung. Brilliant.
hearditman 2 years ago 4
it's everyone's who's had the balls to sing it's best song
miley5566 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wrong sound for this hauntingly beautiful song.
kate18234 2 years ago
WOW
so very intense
rodica69 2 years ago
No life I own, nor liberty.
For love is Lord of all.
irishcoins 2 years ago
Nor life I owe* :)
At least that's according to my sheet music
nighthawk734 2 years ago
I concur!
shazzer1976 2 years ago
I learned, "No life I own, nor liberty
For love is lord of all."
kate18234 2 years ago
Oweing and owning are one root. For example, if you owe a debt (of love) you belong to whom u owe.
irishcoins 2 years ago
This is amazing and wonderful. Dusty Springfield also did a version of this lovely song from 1967 - totally different - check it out here.
Nicklas4500 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Either you like Sinaed or you don't. I definitely don't!
babaloula 3 years ago
Could anyone tell me what a 'leannan si' is, please? :) Thank you
GuntyManth 2 years ago
Leannan= Darling
MartinaBC1963 2 years ago
thanks :)
GuntyManth 2 years ago
Comment removed
GuntyManth 2 years ago
a "lovesick leannan si" is um...i'll tell you:
supremeorder666 2 years ago
What's the historical significance of this song? I've seen several well known Irish artists sing it.
norm1964 3 years ago
Variants of the lyrics go back over a century and the melody probably goes back hundreds of years before that. I once tracked down the full history but have since forgotten much of it. Sinead's version is much shorter than the others, which is a shame since her version is by far the most powerful i've yet heard.
SaganAppreciationSoc 3 years ago 2
i agree that voie fucks me ,love it
iainlonuk 3 years ago
It seduced me also. I haven't been able to stop listening to her for the last four days. She has the most unique voice I've ever heard.
norm1964 3 years ago
This hit me about 3 years ago and i still come back ever now and then. I posted tons of info about the history of this song on a site but sadly the site is now down.
SaganAppreciationSoc 3 years ago
Thank you for the response. You're right, this is a very intense song.
norm1964 3 years ago
beats any 0898 fapline.
kaaeyl 3 years ago
oh sinead what a goddess you are
sineadiloveyou 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yuo must be gay
ziggy6007 3 years ago
ar u lookon in the mirror?
hearditman 3 years ago 2
Tickle me, I forgot to laugh. The beurrifull Corrs, no way. Pop music for muppets. Senoid is an artist.
hearditman 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Best Version Is By The Corrs..!!! x
TaniaDevlin94 3 years ago
rock it up selector?
cathar1962 3 years ago
Whack it up selector.
hearditman 3 years ago
No conocía a esta cantante... me ha dejado alucinada su voz...
Silgare 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nice version... much prefere niamh parsons version tho!
drumfingers 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
best version of this is by siobhan owen!
sugarpuffsandwich 3 years ago
para mi la mejor voz femenina,impresionante,sinead es pura magia
chicadory 3 years ago
I was looking for a very long time for this version! Much thanks for making this possible!!
Finally...
stonehenny 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
worst version i ever heard.
Wolfe tones version is much better.
macker33 3 years ago
This is my favourite version of this song by far.Its just stunning!Plus,good call on including the lyrics.I play and sing this song but when I first learned it,I found it hard to find lyrics becasue there are several different versions!Class song!
solus2 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you think we want to see pictures ? We already have the song , moron
verbod 3 years ago
So, since there is almost certainly no official video for this song, you imply that we do not want the song on youtube, in which case, we have to wonder what youtube is for? Videos?
Idiot.
thesublimemoment 3 years ago
verbod) What an idiot you are. No wonder you don't have a country.
travelphotographer 3 years ago
Is that off of "She Who Dwells?"
TheresaWalsh 3 years ago 2
One of the highlights from one of my favourite albums.
Many thanks for posting.
thesublimemoment 3 years ago 3
Oh,so sorry for that hostile post below! Not everyone feels that way.This is one of my very favorite songs.Thank you for your creativity-the song inspired you.Good for you.The lyrics are very unusual-maybe only the devoted Sinead fan knows them by heart.Useful for others! Sinead forever.
respitesearcher 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
stupid pictures. We already have the song, dont post that crap
verbod 3 years ago