OMG! So, Craig Carnellia graduated from my school & so he came to visit 2 years ago...so I thought I'd research him & I find this! This is beautiful. The words. The music. The harmonies. Magic.
Oh my goodness!!! I've been in love with this song for years but only had David Burnham's version (which is wonderful). How amazing to discover this version!
can you really measure who's better between the two? same arrangement. both sets of voices match well together. all the voices have a very clear, crisp tone as opposed to nasal. all four sing well in tune.
if anything, i'd say sutton/megan's broadway background has helped them to sing with more emotion. but that comes just from experience, i think.
all four are great. there can always be a preference. but i dont think anyone can make the claim to who has more vocal talent.
For sure. I never said I didn't enjoy it (in fact these two together I could listen to all day). I was just stating that the B&N version has the best pitch.
stumbled on this, then watched just about every other version of this song on youtube...but this is definitely the best. something about the harmonies just makes it so much more chilling than a lone voice.
Erm, you do know that these two are Broadway actors right? Sutton Foster (Thoroughly Modern Millie, The Drowsy Chaperone, Little Women, Young Frankenstein, Shrek: The Musical) and Megan McGinnis (Les Miserables, Beauty and the Beast, Little Women).
My choir teacher has shown this in both classes i am in to show basically..PERFECT BLEND! THIS IS AMAZING! I told her i have to borrow her cd, Sutton's cd that she got, its beautiful...almost makes me wanna cry
Great duo. Is it just me, or is there something about Megan that makes you just want to protect her? Her music comes from someplace very deep inside her. She is special.
The lady who wrote for the musical Shrek is the one who wrote the songs. If type in youtube Sutton foster keys (scott alan's new cd) there is a whole interview with Sutton about her cd that comes out in feb.
ive been listening to this song for like 2 years off of Josh Young's album...and I had no idea how absolutely gorgeous this can sound as a duet. An awesome job by two awesome people!
Does anyone know how much lower this is when compared to the female solo version? I'd love to sing this as a solo, but the versions I've heard are slightly too high for me to sing comfortably, and I love the key in this version.
hey msict, i wanted to write on your profile, but comments are disabled, just wanted to thank you for uploading all the Sutton videos- particularly grateful since living in Australia means i never have the chance to ever see her perform. So thanks! :)
That was beautiful. Their voices blend so well together. I have seen Megan 4 times in Les Mis and once at Julie Reiber's Creative Seeds benefit but I have never seen Sutton in anything yet.
this gives me goosebumps and i sit and sing it all the time
craig carnelia actually went to my highschool in longisland and one of my friends sang this song in the cabaret at our school and he (craig) sent the arrangement for this
This is such a beautiful and difficult song to sing - unless you have the range for it, of course. Both Sutton and Megan did an amazing job. Those harmonies are beautiful.
i saw them when they were in little women on broadway and the only thing that truely stuck with me from that show was "some things are meant to be". these girls together are amazing.
this is really something. they are such adept musicians, both of them, and have fantastic tone and clarity. this duet arrangement of this song is so beautiful.... thanks for posting this!
oh how i miss my days of musical theatre!
CLDunbar73 2 months ago
are they sisters?
lolipop2119 3 months ago
Tears everywhere.
keepitsteadynow 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I have the sheet music for the duet if you're still looking for it. you can send me an email at dmn5056@psu.edu
tex12588 10 months ago
Anyone else think they would sing the shit out of the score to Side Show? Not necessarily perfect casting for a full production, but....
sleepyguy1717 10 months ago 2
idina menzel and sutton should sing this together
lolipop2119 11 months ago
Our school's show choir is singing this AMAZING!
MaddieLouiseRossetto 11 months ago
i need this sheet music
anyone have it? please
cautionXdamaged 11 months ago
Who ever dislikes this is mental.
tennisgirl95 1 year ago
hey great job you guys!!! ive been looking for the sheet music for a duet for this song and i cant find it anywhere!
could you please get back to me and let me know where i could find a duet sheet music. Thank you :)
karinak7665 1 year ago
@karinak7665
i have the music, i arranged myself a copy cos i was desperate to sing it!
katiesoup86 9 months ago
OMG! So, Craig Carnellia graduated from my school & so he came to visit 2 years ago...so I thought I'd research him & I find this! This is beautiful. The words. The music. The harmonies. Magic.
xxxParisLightsxxx 1 year ago
they are amazing! and this is live! most singers sing terrible live.
lilybianca 1 year ago
@lilybianca they really have to be good live; they're stage actors, so it's kind of a requirement.
swhizzy 10 months ago
THIS SONG is like a drug for me...can't get enough....
johnnysnyder4 1 year ago
The single most beautiful duet I'll ever hear. The lyrics are priceless and they're wonderful together.
johndobee1 1 year ago 2
the single most beautiful duet I'll ever hear. The lyrics are priceless and they're wonderful together.
johndobee1 1 year ago
Absolutely heavenly.
musique281 1 year ago
I definitely enjoy Megan's voice over Foster's. Both are good, but... yes.
krisdestiny 1 year ago
how do they fucking do it.
simply gorgeous.
pennylane90 1 year ago
Oh my goodness!!! I've been in love with this song for years but only had David Burnham's version (which is wonderful). How amazing to discover this version!
musicalmeg19 1 year ago
They sound gorgeous together, but personally, I prefer Megan's tone. :-)
EmeraldSky33 1 year ago
i lovee this song. the harmonies are amazingg.i just sang it for a benefit
MuSiCisLIFE2479 1 year ago
Do they do voices for disney movies?
louiswilkinson10 1 year ago
@louiswilkinson10 Not exactly. Sutton Foster is one of the most prominent talents in the world of Musical Theater.
VocalEdgeTV 1 year ago
Love this!
bwayguy45 1 year ago
Threre is a song book called Contemporary Cabaret that supposedly has the sheet music :)
bh1222 1 year ago
thats pretty much the best thing ive ever heard
wickedbway 1 year ago 4
If you could sing this is how you would want to sing.
billyflynn2 1 year ago 6
This is gorgeous. I don't even know how to describe their harmonies. But they're beautiful. Thanks for posting.
loveuJhonny 1 year ago 5
Does anyone know where sheet music or a pdf file can be found! I have been looking for ages
moravinedu29 1 year ago
This is one of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard. I know it was written as a solo, but it is SOOO much better as a duet.
Chishannicon 2 years ago 3
beauty.
PURE beauty.
EmShrayyy 2 years ago
this is so beautiful
Sutton foster is my idol!
singlikeno1listening 2 years ago 2
wow this is amazing ^_^ what musical is this from?
slowdance100 2 years ago
It's actually just from a composer named Craig Carnelia, no musical. He has a song book and this song is written as solo repertoire
choirjunkie01 2 years ago
@choirjunkie01 oh :( that's upsetting. it would be so nice if it was from a musical, and then i could do it for festival
partyandahalf 2 years ago
Dear Sutton Foster,
OH MY GOD YOU'RE AMAZING!!
Love,
Carolyn.
carolynbiery 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
These 2 cant hold a candle to Natalie Hawkins and Courtney Stokes. Sorry girls.
italchck 2 years ago
can you really measure who's better between the two? same arrangement. both sets of voices match well together. all the voices have a very clear, crisp tone as opposed to nasal. all four sing well in tune.
if anything, i'd say sutton/megan's broadway background has helped them to sing with more emotion. but that comes just from experience, i think.
all four are great. there can always be a preference. but i dont think anyone can make the claim to who has more vocal talent.
dropbeatsnotbombs26 2 years ago 2
what musical is this from?
Mayzinegrace 2 years ago
Have you heard the version of Natalie Hawkins and Courtney Stokes.
Mayflower1357 2 years ago 4
yeah I think this one is better..
Getsirius91 2 years ago 3
Me too.
islayedvoldy 2 years ago
it is truly amazing!!!
caseex8 2 years ago
I like the Barnes and Noble version of these two probably the most though. This version is pitchy all over the place.
tggold 2 years ago
pitchy, I think not.
draw09nowsinglater 2 years ago
No, you're right tggold. Even the album recording wasn't as good as it could be...but there's no doubting that they are amazing together.
carolinestrange 1 year ago
For sure. I never said I didn't enjoy it (in fact these two together I could listen to all day). I was just stating that the B&N version has the best pitch.
tggold 1 year ago
Well I went to take a look at that one and it IS better than this one. :)
carolinestrange 1 year ago
Its time for Megan's solo CD
ethedavie 2 years ago 25
they sing togother so well. gives me shivers... :-)
potterh07 2 years ago 34
marvelous
sharksbombers 2 years ago
OMG , can´t stop listen to it ! Soooooooooo beautiful !
nadja1316 2 years ago 4
this is hauntingly beautiful, thank you
Allshookup1 2 years ago
does anyone know where to get this sheet music or the solo version transposed? i can only find the craig carnelia book.
singerinkansas 2 years ago 5
Wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!
zstar558 2 years ago
stumbled on this, then watched just about every other version of this song on youtube...but this is definitely the best. something about the harmonies just makes it so much more chilling than a lone voice.
tomakeyoumylamb 2 years ago
their voices blend so well.... absolutely beautiful. They are both amazing!
iloveicecreamlots 2 years ago
Sensational.
belladharma 2 years ago
I love Megan McGinnis insanely. And Sutton is just Sutton. That is all I can say.
ObsessedwithBroadway 2 years ago 2
Chills
mystrongestsuit 2 years ago 2
wow you guys are sooo good! you both remind me of either the good witch from wicked or niki blonsky from hairspray.
Lizzie471 2 years ago
Erm, you do know that these two are Broadway actors right? Sutton Foster (Thoroughly Modern Millie, The Drowsy Chaperone, Little Women, Young Frankenstein, Shrek: The Musical) and Megan McGinnis (Les Miserables, Beauty and the Beast, Little Women).
WickedRENThead20 2 years ago 4
oh haha my bad.. i need to catch up on my broadway actors. haha. they still sound like the good witch though.
Lizzie471 2 years ago
my guess is it's because they all sing brightly, with very forward placement.
bwv971 2 years ago
Amazing!!
hsnare0218 2 years ago
This is so magical. This is such a great arrangement!
TRoderick 2 years ago 3
chills throughout the entire song...holy shiz
lawlzerskates 2 years ago
soooo pretty
somarlanh 2 years ago
what key is this in?
stardancer98 2 years ago
this is one of the most beautiful song arrangements ive ever heard
chenofan7 2 years ago 2
I am dying to get my hands on the sheet music for this arrangement if anyone knows where I can PLEASE let me know!
eeli1 2 years ago
there isn't any sheet music that I could find....we posted a video response with the version we did by ear. it's in b minor if that helps :)
katierose927 2 years ago
There is a book now containing the music called Contemporary Cabaret: 31 Songs in Today's Repertoire
Caponnuknuk 2 years ago 2
i looove this
ExAxLxPx12 2 years ago
some of the most beautiful hormony ive heard in life
theaterzmylife 2 years ago 4
what musical is this from?
clovisdancer 2 years ago
It's not from a musical. It's just a song, by Craig Carnelia.
WickedRENThead20 2 years ago
i get chills everytime.
waaahtina 2 years ago
so pritty
BrieGirl07 2 years ago
Very smooth performance. I could see this performed when someone is ice skating. Awesome song!
gamalmack 2 years ago
Comment removed
jeabarr 2 years ago
that would be totally awesome... especially a pairs routine... imagine lifts around 1:10.....
jeabarr 2 years ago
T____T
^^That is what I looked like after watching this....
YES!! AMAAAAAAAAAZING... The BEST I've heard this song done.
cougarthespian 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The way their voices blend gives me chills! Absolutely beautiful!
Thegirlin14g 2 years ago
Comment removed
Thegirlin14g 2 years ago
My choir teacher has shown this in both classes i am in to show basically..PERFECT BLEND! THIS IS AMAZING! I told her i have to borrow her cd, Sutton's cd that she got, its beautiful...almost makes me wanna cry
AFILANW 2 years ago
does anyone have the duet sheet music of this?
lovelossandcandybars 2 years ago
I have no idea. It's a fairly new cd...like it just came out a week ago, but you may be able to find the sheetmusic on the interent, idk.
AFILANW 2 years ago
has anyone found it by any chance?
bwaybaby55 2 years ago
Comment removed
aftershocksxo 2 years ago
I am in desperate need of the duet arrangement, also, so if anyone has it, I'd be so grateful!
aftershocksxo 2 years ago
oh my word i want this song. Do i really have to wait until the 17th!! grr lol. its like a drug! xx
twinklefudge 3 years ago 3
Sh-K-Boom has been mailing them out already if you order direct from them.
msict 3 years ago
Great duo. Is it just me, or is there something about Megan that makes you just want to protect her? Her music comes from someplace very deep inside her. She is special.
rlakins 3 years ago 5
does anyone know if her album is going to be on itunes?
OceanSunRise4 3 years ago
It is on iTunes. I bought it yesterday. It's amazing!
hypeactress23 2 years ago
absolutely perfect.
claireify88 3 years ago
amazing ! Wonderful ! Perfect !
kiaketa 3 years ago
does anyone have any idea how to get the sheet music for this?
absolutely amazing.
bwaybaby55 3 years ago
did you find the sheet music by anychance?
lovelossandcandybars 2 years ago
I can't get over how beautiful and pure Megan McGinnis' voice is! I could listen to her sing all day.
25Maz25 3 years ago
OMg i love it!!!!!
pinkbapprincess 3 years ago
what is this from??
broadwaybound36 3 years ago
I love this! Is it on her CD? When does it come out/is it available at all now?
meagabetic 3 years ago
God, this is gorgeous!! I can't wait for Sutton's CD to come out!!!! :) Their voices blend so well together! Amazing.
Carbear65 3 years ago
oh my god. this is amazing.
a1994r 3 years ago
L <3 V E
Thanks so much for posting this.
U2Bwatcher 3 years ago
who is singing the melody?
theaterzmylife 3 years ago
Megan.
sleepyguy1717 3 years ago
but Sutton is singing more of the melody
SamuelXavier427 3 years ago
No she's not, she's harmonizing under Megan. They both sing melody at one point or another, but the majority of it is sung by Megan.
sleepyguy1717 3 years ago
Does anyone know if they wrote the duet arrangement on their own? I've only ever heard this song done as a solo.
muffins313 3 years ago
The lady who wrote for the musical Shrek is the one who wrote the songs. If type in youtube Sutton foster keys (scott alan's new cd) there is a whole interview with Sutton about her cd that comes out in feb.
OceanSunRise4 3 years ago
This is on Sutton's new album, "Wish"!
MbeeTeen 3 years ago
Really?? Is it out yet? Google here I come!
EnchantedSilence 3 years ago
no I think it's out in February
MbeeTeen 3 years ago
does anyone know where to get the lyrics for this? can't find them anywhere!
TheJesster003 3 years ago
the song is in the craig carnelia songbook. i don't know if you can find the lyrics online... but it's a good book to own nonetheless.
derrickcrash 3 years ago
I think about 700 of this video's views go to me. I keep watching this video! It's so addicting. I love this duet! Simply beautiful!
whatwouldkirado 3 years ago
i agree, LOVE this song, and these two women!
eventsid 3 years ago
Does anyone at all know where I can get the sheet music for this duet version?
EnchantedSilence 3 years ago
ive been listening to this song for like 2 years off of Josh Young's album...and I had no idea how absolutely gorgeous this can sound as a duet. An awesome job by two awesome people!
JennaLeighhh 3 years ago
I love the way they sound together, they blend so well.
The only thing I don't like about this video is that Sutton's arm looks broken during the first minute, its really weird.
SpamSpope 3 years ago
I know! What great blending in a duet!
MbeeTeen 3 years ago
I cannot wait for January so I can get WISH!
bxrgirl 3 years ago
same here!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dramaqueen4evur 3 years ago
some of those harmonies are just breathtaking. their voices are really beautiful together as well. this is great! thanks for posting :)
eilidhw 3 years ago 2
Does anyone know how much lower this is when compared to the female solo version? I'd love to sing this as a solo, but the versions I've heard are slightly too high for me to sing comfortably, and I love the key in this version.
SoMuchBetter44 3 years ago
absolutely unreal. like angles coming down to give us all a glimpse of what heaven might sound like.
minarik01 3 years ago 3
FIERCE
reddhedd314 3 years ago 3
i can't stop listening to this song.
it's beautiful...
anyone know where i can get lyrics/sheet music?
dionnadoo 3 years ago
does anyone know what key this is in?
jazzer802 3 years ago
F Minor
YummyZak 3 years ago
actually i think it's B minor
luna46789 3 years ago
I love this so so much.
Where can I get the sheet music to this version?
ohdarlingkenz 3 years ago
i die
MylifeIsShows 3 years ago
IM GONNA GET WISH!
achorusline83 3 years ago
I think I just came...that was amazing!!!!!!!!!!
djp423 3 years ago
hey msict, i wanted to write on your profile, but comments are disabled, just wanted to thank you for uploading all the Sutton videos- particularly grateful since living in Australia means i never have the chance to ever see her perform. So thanks! :)
25Maz25 3 years ago
one of them sounds like Lisa brescia hmm
IRBM 3 years ago
this song is going to be on Sutton's album, Wish!!
ferrybeachgal 3 years ago
I'm so excited for Wish- February cannot come soon enough!
WickedRENThead20 3 years ago
really???!! YAY!!!
25Maz25 3 years ago
OMG this song has always been specail too me but this version omg...
<3
donttellmex17 3 years ago
If they did Side Show again, I think they could be the sisters.
blue1297 3 years ago 3
I think I just had a heart attack! lol
tjvids7 3 years ago
They both have such BEAUTIFUL VOICES!
25Maz25 3 years ago 2
does anyone know where i can find the sheet music? i'd really love to learn to sing this!!
These two harmonize amazingly well! I love the duo
ThruAcceptingRules 3 years ago
anyone know where i could find lyrics to this? thanks!
by the way, this song is BEAUTIFUL
emptyXwords 3 years ago
They are AMAZING together! Especially in Little Women the Musical...amazing! :]]
mariskaANDmadtv 3 years ago 2
That was beautiful. Their voices blend so well together. I have seen Megan 4 times in Les Mis and once at Julie Reiber's Creative Seeds benefit but I have never seen Sutton in anything yet.
lckysvn777 3 years ago 2
fantastic. :]
danrosales1 3 years ago 2
knowing the original solo song so well, this made a brilliant piece even more amazing and I didn't think it could be possible!
JoeKool2k9 3 years ago 4
love it but i like it as a solo. :]
JenniferFoster 3 years ago
This is awesome! Sutton Foster is my favorite!!
KatieGermano 3 years ago
Please tell me that this is going to be on Wish. They harmonize so well with one another!
WickedRENThead20 3 years ago 3
fucking fantastic
aberhottie99 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Melvin Tunstall a CCM does the best version of this song.
AsuCmo808 3 years ago
this gives me goosebumps and i sit and sing it all the time
craig carnelia actually went to my highschool in longisland and one of my friends sang this song in the cabaret at our school and he (craig) sent the arrangement for this
MarilynMonroe6 3 years ago
where are you on long island? lol cuz i live on long island too. and you think you could get me a copy??
illbeastonishing16 3 years ago
This is such a beautiful and difficult song to sing - unless you have the range for it, of course. Both Sutton and Megan did an amazing job. Those harmonies are beautiful.
kylejb 3 years ago 7
is this a song from a braodway show?? it's amazing! I saw Megan as Epponine,and she must have had an off night, but in this she's AMAZING!
Broadwaymusialzz 3 years ago
i saw them when they were in little women on broadway and the only thing that truely stuck with me from that show was "some things are meant to be". these girls together are amazing.
Violetsoul6 3 years ago
soooo amazing, i like this is better as a duet than a solo actually!
astarisxborn 3 years ago
stunning! i love sutton!!! i dont know much about megan. this is the only thing i know her from. but i really love her from what ive heard!!!
Singerchick106 3 years ago
This is magic <3
kns726 3 years ago 2
I honestly think I've watched/listened to this about 50 times by now. What an amazing arrangement and performance...
franzliebkind 3 years ago 4
this is really something. they are such adept musicians, both of them, and have fantastic tone and clarity. this duet arrangement of this song is so beautiful.... thanks for posting this!
mrkevinwade 3 years ago 5
i loved their voices together in little women and this is even better!!!
ThoroughlyObsessed22 3 years ago 4
wow. this the best rendition of this song i've ever seen.
CHSPAD08 3 years ago 5
i can't stop watching this.
freakin' phenomenal.
amateurmusician 3 years ago 3
this is great, i absolutly love their voices together, its so good
dlp06 3 years ago
you're right. she is pretty incredible =]
illbeastonishing16 3 years ago
will this be on sutton's solo album?
illbeastonishing16 3 years ago
I can't actually get over this.
Betheshoe 3 years ago 2
the girl on the left (right side of the stage) is so focused...really good
stitchgrl777 3 years ago
Sutton Foster is amazing. :)
allycrombie33 3 years ago 2
so amazing.
i need the sheet music for thisss
illbeastonishing16 3 years ago
wow that was amazing!
miketiek1 3 years ago 2
What an original and hauntingly-beautiful take on an already-beautiful song! Thanks so much for posting this!
all4mikey 3 years ago