Very good performance, though it feels like you´re inconsistent with the tempo which I think you should fix cause it's a fugue that should flow without pauses. But it's just my opinion.
Very good performance, though it feels like your inconsistent with the tempo which I think is necessary to fix because it's a fugue, otherwise nice tone and good overall.
I am currently studying this piece and found your performance to be slightly on the romantic side for me. however it is beautifully played with good expressive control. I hope I can perform it as convincingly!
You aré amazing!!! I enjoyed very very much. Bach is hard to play and you play it with a lot of understanding about feeling. Please never loose that feeling and congratulations. I teach at the National Conservatory of Mexico. Some time i would like to play as free as you. Sometimes the moré you learn, the more unexpressive you get and that is not alwasy good and you gave me a big refresh. Regards from Mexico and sorry about mistakes on my writing. Lol
Very very nice playing, especially considering your age. I really enjoyed listening to you. A few comments:
I missed a bit of bass sounds, I personally feel the trebles need a little more support and to bring more depth to the overall sound.
I would work on the flow of musical lines as well, some you do beautifully, others are a bit "jumpy" or just don't flow to the end, I'm sure you know what I mean.
anyway, you played a difficult piece well and you did it live, well done!
Great Simon. Thankyou for sharing that video. I'm pianist and I'm working that piece on piano(!!!Fuck the music academy!!!!) since I saw you play it here
Forget omyeru and his certainties.
Bach was a man and certainly played music with the feeling of a moment and not like a robot. He was a man and Omyeru thinks he was a statue.
Guys like Omyeru, make Bach died for the second time.
yes, that`s true, but the spirit of the fugue isn`t on the frazing, is in the whole fugue, and my comment is to let you know that you need too much work in this piece, and i think you know it, "critice is the best way of grow up", so grow up¡¡
your interpretation is without feeling, you don`t feel the spirit of this fugue, please listen julian bream, and learn something, if i be judge i will run away.
Very impressive, Sounds wonderful, nice phrasing. I am currently struggling through this piece and so appreciate a good performance of it all the more. Beautiful!
Great performance!! either natural talent, 100000 hours of practice or both, but im kind of pick up on the banjo vibe too, probably sounded EPIC live though, PROPS!
well this is one of the best renditions of this piece,bachs fugue "as it is" out of the lute suite book.of all the fugues on u-tube this one,julian breams and simon dinnigans are the best.did you win btw:)
Hey man!!! Great, great performance man :) Very touchy, chill, and very relaxed!! And dynamic is excellent too! I play this peace too, and I've found that we have very similar style in playing Bach! Best wishes!! :)
very good, i like your very subtle tonal variations and good dynamics changes, also very good separation of the voices, you created a good texture, 5 stars from me, good luck
I love your playing.....
henkhopmangitaar 5 months ago
fault at 1.22? but that s good !!
rafourasta 10 months ago
Great performance. Love the ritardandos and accelerandos that you put here and there. Very romantic and deeply felt rendition.
AlvarezCutaway 11 months ago
you are just very good, not very lucky
eineScheibeBrot 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very good performance, though it feels like you´re inconsistent with the tempo which I think you should fix cause it's a fugue that should flow without pauses. But it's just my opinion.
JPmax89 1 year ago
Very good performance, though it feels like your inconsistent with the tempo which I think is necessary to fix because it's a fugue, otherwise nice tone and good overall.
JPmax89 1 year ago
im playing it in a minor alos :D
TheJWKK 1 year ago
I am currently studying this piece and found your performance to be slightly on the romantic side for me. however it is beautifully played with good expressive control. I hope I can perform it as convincingly!
spats19711 1 year ago
Congratulations.
Great perfomance.
You really feel J.S. Bach and that's amazing.
eddiek2206 1 year ago
one of the best performances of the fugue that i've ever heard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!how many years have you been playing the guitar??
danny7cris 1 year ago
He plays like a pupil........ 3 stars r enough
theodor28uzunov 2 years ago
@theodor28uzunov Well then wheres your critique? I think this performance is great. He plays on a professional level, no doubt.
Jazzman1985 2 years ago
This is not professional level.This is good student level but not professional.He still has serious technical problems
theodor28uzunov 2 years ago
@theodor28uzunov I'm still waiting for examples ;-)
Jazzman1985 2 years ago
Are u?:)I didnt know that.Keep waiting....:)
theodor28uzunov 2 years ago
Definitely incredible !
I guess the jury did the right thing !
nikosz66 2 years ago
I love this Fugue... Great performance!
arinaburceva 2 years ago
You aré amazing!!! I enjoyed very very much. Bach is hard to play and you play it with a lot of understanding about feeling. Please never loose that feeling and congratulations. I teach at the National Conservatory of Mexico. Some time i would like to play as free as you. Sometimes the moré you learn, the more unexpressive you get and that is not alwasy good and you gave me a big refresh. Regards from Mexico and sorry about mistakes on my writing. Lol
Sergio
checogilmour 2 years ago
Very very nice playing, especially considering your age. I really enjoyed listening to you. A few comments:
I missed a bit of bass sounds, I personally feel the trebles need a little more support and to bring more depth to the overall sound.
I would work on the flow of musical lines as well, some you do beautifully, others are a bit "jumpy" or just don't flow to the end, I'm sure you know what I mean.
anyway, you played a difficult piece well and you did it live, well done!
docdoc 2 years ago
im working on this peice right now. i gotta say. its so much harder than what it sounds like. and it sounds insanely hard. nice job man.
GIJoeM14 2 years ago
Hermoso sonido y muy buena interpretación!
felicitaciones
Pere Salicrú
SAMARCANDAS 2 years ago
Great Simon. Thankyou for sharing that video. I'm pianist and I'm working that piece on piano(!!!Fuck the music academy!!!!) since I saw you play it here
Forget omyeru and his certainties.
Bach was a man and certainly played music with the feeling of a moment and not like a robot. He was a man and Omyeru thinks he was a statue.
Guys like Omyeru, make Bach died for the second time.
Bravissimo and good luck for you.
GeneralFatalError 2 years ago
Yeeeeaaaahhhh!
GeneralFatalError 2 years ago
Fine Fellow !!!
Gusakov 2 years ago
don't listen to him, this is truly incredible
thejugglenaut91 2 years ago
Very nice indeed. And I agree with your self criticism down there, the rubato was liiiittle bit much. But hey, we're all a little romantic at 17 =)
There's some Brazilian music in my channel if you're interested.
kriox 2 years ago
not much of a competition was there.. kidding!!.. it was.. nice, yeah :)
frndstr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too much ego, you need more experience, that`s my last words.
keep working...
omyeru 2 years ago
i think we all see who has the ego. Chill out man, he played it great, especially considering he was only 17 at the time, live and learn.
orbiterred 2 years ago
yes, that`s true, but the spirit of the fugue isn`t on the frazing, is in the whole fugue, and my comment is to let you know that you need too much work in this piece, and i think you know it, "critice is the best way of grow up", so grow up¡¡
by the way i have listened glenn gloud...
omyeru 2 years ago
your interpretation is without feeling, you don`t feel the spirit of this fugue, please listen julian bream, and learn something, if i be judge i will run away.
omyeru 2 years ago
I'm absolutely speechless.....
Bigevilcrow 2 years ago
Most enjoyable! You made it sounds like it was written for the guitar!
jawdim29tu 3 years ago
Im working on this one now. Its kinda hard, I use a power tab file for the tabs. Did you tab this out by yourself?
Great playing
Chris93Rock 3 years ago
Very impressive, Sounds wonderful, nice phrasing. I am currently struggling through this piece and so appreciate a good performance of it all the more. Beautiful!
matt7937 3 years ago
Bravo!
mariomilunovic 3 years ago
vel, jeg kan bare si at du er utrolig flink:-D
PaulAndreasFoldalAam 3 years ago
I didn't mean to sound like a jerk. You're a good guitar player, nice work.
rodriguezclassical 3 years ago 6
Great performance!! either natural talent, 100000 hours of practice or both, but im kind of pick up on the banjo vibe too, probably sounded EPIC live though, PROPS!
buttclogpin 3 years ago
The tone sounds questionable. It might be the camera picking up the tone but your guitar sounds like a banjo at times.
rodriguezclassical 3 years ago 8
well this is one of the best renditions of this piece,bachs fugue "as it is" out of the lute suite book.of all the fugues on u-tube this one,julian breams and simon dinnigans are the best.did you win btw:)
jojimbo44 3 years ago
Yes i did. It's in my discription of the video if you press more info. And yes i won three prizes. :)
Svendegon 3 years ago
Hello
This is the best perfomans in the youtube bach videos.
thank you the name of may ears
ardamey78 3 years ago
goooood !
mones6 3 years ago
Hey man!!! Great, great performance man :) Very touchy, chill, and very relaxed!! And dynamic is excellent too! I play this peace too, and I've found that we have very similar style in playing Bach! Best wishes!! :)
mirzoni86 3 years ago
very good, i like your very subtle tonal variations and good dynamics changes, also very good separation of the voices, you created a good texture, 5 stars from me, good luck
davidclassg1 4 years ago 2
Thanks! :)
Svendegon 4 years ago
great vid ! cheers
jacquillo 4 years ago
Sweet man.
audioglass 4 years ago