dont diss them! i dont see you with tens of thousands of fans, i dont see you with CDs out i dont see you on TV almost everyday for more than 2 years so i really dont think you should be saying anything
he's amazing and so are the rest of them so shut up.
everyone has their right to discuss and comment whatever they like. are you gonna be mad and take everything seriously when someone disagree with you and your belief?
arguing on the internet is like running in the special Olympic.
you can stfu too cuz i aint coming back when you comment more.
of coz they hv their right to discuss , but i dont see ppl hving da right to judge them. that's so stupid to compare n i do reali think he's a gud singer.nobody forces u to listen ..
唱的好因為聲音高
smo757 1 month ago
看到樓下某人的話,覺得有點好笑,同時覺得小祿挺可憐的。
superwoman5181 2 months ago
批評個屁呀...
Shut up and listen to the music!!!
罵你也是浪費口水~3~
edward19950625 2 months ago
不要拿他跟原版比 每個人都有每個人的特色
7Liar11 6 months ago 4
轉音已經很好聽了
7Liar11 6 months ago
小祿唱的不錯啊!為什麼要一直批評他?比他會唱的,就去唱啊
Jennifer74221 8 months ago 5
@Jennifer74221 有人批評他不多不少是因爲有部分他的迷大言不慚地說他唱得比曹格好,說實在他唱得比我想象中好,但那些迷在這個公衆地方公開說他唱得比曹格好這樣誇張的話,難免會惹起不是他的迷的人的批評。
superwoman5181 8 months ago
E04 超好聽
m52116 9 months ago
唱歌除了天份還有後天的努力。。。
在唱歌方面的天份我覺得小祿有了。。。只要再努力,小祿會越唱越好的。。。
不同類型的節目當然會有不同的需求,小祿現在參加的不是歌唱比賽的節目,就算是參加唱歌比賽的節目,如果你一開始就唱得很完美,到後期時人家又會說你沒有進步。唱歌可以是一門很深的學問,也可以很簡單,只要你愛唱歌,就盡情的唱吧。。。
心疼小祿在一進棒棒堂開始就一直不斷地被批評,不是說他靠姐姐就是說他不好看,但我相信時間能證明一切,小祿的才華與努力是有目共睹的,不只歌聲不錯,舞也跳得不錯,還蠻喜歡看他和戴家昀一起 locking 的!~
希望小祿要加油,未來會越來越美好~
p/s : 題外話:那天看范范的婚禮片段,容嘉真的是正翻了~堂主也是美翻了~大家都要繼續加油噢~
ahsan9334 9 months ago 9
給那些給負面評語的人,你們自以為是誰啊?
你(妳)算哪根蔥??
總是喜歡拿小祿和曹格比,喜歡唱歌一定要好聽嘛?
小祿又不是像曹格有發專輯的人,有一定要這樣挑三撿四嘛?
你們以為你是誰?你以為你是韻玲姊或者是小胖老師嗎?
你們不是專業的評審,也沒有資格胡亂給予負面批評~覺得不喜歡就不要聽!別嘴賤!!!
Sagettarius1123 9 months ago
給那些給負面評語的人,你們自以為是誰啊?
你(妳)算哪根蔥??
總是喜歡拿小祿和曹格比,喜歡唱歌一定要好聽嘛?
小祿又不是像曹格有發專輯的人,有一定要這樣挑三撿四嘛?
你們以為你是誰?你以為你是韻玲姊或者是小胖老師嗎?
你們不是專業的評審,也沒有資格胡亂給予負面批評~覺得不喜歡就不要聽!別嘴賤!!!
Sagettarius1123 9 months ago
沒有必要批評吧, 畢竟他只是個新人, 總是要學習啊
0983493811 10 months ago
哪會好聽阿
hou617 11 months ago
其實他是誰? 聲音真的一直在抖, 唱得中規中矩,首歌很難唱,只有曹格唱得最好聽!
223wychiu 1 year ago
1分54秒,小祿很爽我們都懂!!
ycs51788 1 year ago
降KEY是必然的吧... 你以為每個人音域都跟曹格一樣= =
online1589 1 year ago
有降KEY..聲音一直抖..真的很普通
egg1080 1 year ago 2
只能說唱得比我想象中好,但我就絕對說不出唱得比曹格好這樣誇張的大話,哈哈!!
superwoman5181 1 year ago 3
@superwoman5181 同意!比曹格好聽?也太抬舉了吧!
topeverley 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@superwoman5181 同意!比曹格好聽?也太抬舉了吧!
topeverley 1 year ago
為什麼這樣說很好聽呢= =
qszwax92 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@qszwax92 說的忠肯
jeff51552 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唱的很不錯~~不過所謂會有沒有好不聽~~是差在經歷~~他唱的好聽有感覺是對年輕人而言~~對經歷人生愛情一大段日子的人而言就只是好聽卻無法打動心靈~~不過還是位夢想打拼的年輕人加油
shaitanfax 1 year ago
唱的很不錯~~不過所謂會有沒有好不聽~~是差在經歷~~他唱的好聽有感覺是對年輕人而言~~對經歷人生愛情一大段日子的人而言就只是好聽卻無法打動心靈~~不過還是位夢想打拼的年輕人加油
shaitanfax 1 year ago 2
明明就好聽 我不懂為什麼有人要攻擊他
他唱歌也不是要跟誰比
你不喜歡他的聲音是你的事
你沒有情緒是你的事
誰的唱歌技巧是完美的
誰沒有破音過
你說誰誰誰唱得更好
誰誰誰怎樣怎樣
沒必要貶到他的歌聲到這種程度吧
MEIZZ0716 1 year ago 9
我觉得这首歌他比曹格唱的还要好听。百听不厌。真的很感动。小禄加油!
CuteDiuki 1 year ago
@CuteDiuki 我跟你相反.聽一次就膩了.他如果去星光大道會死很慘
egg1080 1 year ago 2
good man ..
got improve
MrIamlengend 1 year ago 2
聽咁多次都超好聽呀,LOUIS ^.^b
izumi208 1 year ago 4
他唱歌都沒有吸氣聲很特別
29898008 2 years ago 13
棒棒糖的 小昱弱掉了~ 看來他才是棒棒糖最會唱歌的!!
small780327 2 years ago 28
所有音都對了~
勁!!!!
ronnietamspspspsp 2 years ago 22
This has been flagged as spam show
@ronnietamspspspsp 非也.
整首歌也偏低了一點.
特別是每一句的頭及尾的字. 都偏低.
gogoldgoal 2 years ago
以這首歌的高難度來說
已經唱的很好了
高音略顯單薄
一些小細節再修飾會更好!
鼓勵!!
litzchia 2 years ago 67
原唱不知作何感想...
alexandxu 2 years ago 26
超爱 小禄
mmmxsoysauce 2 years ago 29
This has been flagged as spam show
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. wat a joke!
tnf1986 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't like the vibrato he's making at the end of every sentence.
faith520 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
go back home u cannot sing boya
tsukishiro23 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唔係唔好聽既...
但又唔係好好聽...
d尾音太長喇...
唱得ok啦...
BBoxCM 2 years ago
只要說到宅男塾的歌王的話
我相信粉絲們應該不會不投小祿一票吧
雖然我不是他的粉絲
但是我覺得他已經唱得不錯了
tidus1804 2 years ago 112
有批評才會有成長阿 更何況他已經唱的很棒了
tsfrank706 2 years ago 15
he is so good
r940204 2 years ago 10
很明顯 這首歌她還沒唱到很熟
不夠穩
不過她很有天份
在多練一陣子 相信會有紅的一天
u121511706 2 years ago 6
為甚麼是''她''= =
jaychoulun 2 years ago 11
我不是棒棒堂的粉丝。
不过我觉得,他只是在很认真很努力的在唱歌。
虽然很多人认为有瑕疵。
但是这对年轻的他来说,根本不算什么。
还有很大的进步空间。
没有必要一味的批评。
MVP0719 2 years ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
不用每句都抖音吧
應該會更好
superman60009 2 years ago
你們就不要再批評小祿了
雖然我不是他的粉絲﹐
但是我覺得他已經唱得很好了
還有不要拿他跟曹格比啦
他們都有不同的風格﹗
kristinngyanyui 2 years ago 32
是會抖音沒錯
但是不難聽阿@@
我怎麼覺得超好聽的...
vul3xjp6 2 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
下很多key 的啦!!!
Jayfans91 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唱得像机器人。。。
reipohmee 2 years ago
我覺得小祿唱得很好聽
他的聲音很特別,很厚
有一種特別的磁性
唱低音特別好聽
而且他換氣很好
完全聽不到他換氣的聲音
我覺得他唱得很棒 =)
icehanna 2 years ago 33
比棒棒糖的其他人好多了
雖然唱的技巧要加強
但是 是好聽的
因為原唱唱的太好了 難免有對比太大
不過 他在棒棒糖 算是很強的!!!!
magsung1112 2 years ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
我知他有蠻多粉絲 但請不要盲目支持
亂說他唱得比曹格好
請去聽一下曹格的LIVE
watch?v=VzBd22wXOSo
klaus1121 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
假音太造作
ZZPtsang 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
歌唱技巧還可以,,
但可惜欠缺了感染力:(
janice23000000 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
這較好聽 我朋友都苦以當神了
fhs0205 3 years ago
哈哈。。如果你们觉得小禄的歌声都不ok的话,那棒棒糖就真的没有人会唱了。。
520hejunxiang5566 3 years ago 18
well.. you're absolutely correct..
none of them can sing..
okevino 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
u think?
rainhk12 2 years ago
dont diss them! i dont see you with tens of thousands of fans, i dont see you with CDs out i dont see you on TV almost everyday for more than 2 years so i really dont think you should be saying anything
he's amazing and so are the rest of them so shut up.
JaZzINuPUrWoRLd 2 years ago
everyone has their right to discuss and comment whatever they like. are you gonna be mad and take everything seriously when someone disagree with you and your belief?
arguing on the internet is like running in the special Olympic.
you can stfu too cuz i aint coming back when you comment more.
okevino 2 years ago
of coz they hv their right to discuss , but i dont see ppl hving da right to judge them. that's so stupid to compare n i do reali think he's a gud singer.nobody forces u to listen ..
mexia0999 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
u think?
rainhk12 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
會唱可是不需要造作啊...完全無法感動我~也不覺得這樣子唱歌算是歌手~
kevinkevin008 2 years ago
Xiaaao Lu ROCKS!! <3
Bebiih4sho 3 years ago 11
這叫唱歌 !?
kaitokazuki 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
decent only,not really that good.
trilian83 3 years ago
compared to the rest, he is good alr
iamdemvp 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
唱情歌是讓聽者聽到最後流一滴眼淚這才是真正唱情歌的最高境界
小祿聲音好但是我完全沒被感動到
tidus1804 3 years ago
不會啦
我覺得超好聽的~
karzfree 3 years ago 7
precisely. he suck. especially the last word in every sentence, dragger.
wongkokmun 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
erm.. its not even nice la. wtf.
bananatea 3 years ago
老實說只是還好而已
a911921006 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
這樣也叫好聽?
哈哈
chiyip617 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
這首歌不適合他吧我覺得
他聲音太薄了
再拉長音的時候會覺得很不舒服
不過他真假音轉換還蠻順的
就真的他不適合唱這種拉長音的歌
thefinal8 3 years ago
Comment removed
thefinal8 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
其實...真的不好聽.......只要聽過原唱....就知道誰是歌手....誰是明星......
wcferic 3 years ago
聲音好...但沒有感情是致命傷!! 聽起來完全沒有感動啊
pat1023n 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
太刻意去抖了吧...
Eeyore0913 3 years ago
不是喇..
是不知道為什麼他唱歌會很抖.
不好聽嗎?好聽啊:)
tsz10 3 years ago
也沒有說到不好聽
但是....
真的很..抖~~
Eeyore0913 3 years ago 5
he have a vry beatiful soul
1992melissa1992 3 years ago 9
尾音 需要多加修正
lonlykuma123 3 years ago 4
抖的有些厉害。。。不过声音不错
逗趣个人
dontl1etom3 3 years ago
他ㄉ尾音一直是他ㄉ問題
gohome461 3 years ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
為什麼唱歌都不張嘴呀?
kay1812 3 years ago
他有張嘴啊 只是畫面霧霧看不清楚
love223228 3 years ago 8
畢竟不是真正的歌手 。 還好
wuzhens 3 years ago 15