There is no way I can choose... They both sound so good, but all I do when I hear either version is think of how sad it is that they are singing the parts that were written for the other to sing. I love the song, but think it will always stir up memories of sad times. They need to do a new happy song when they reunite... "CAN Stand You Now"
it is always too hard to choose between them..in my opinion this song suits carl a bit better....i think.. :D off course, the best sounds when they perform it together.
Pete all the way
oasxdeadly 3 months ago
I would never put a vs. between those two names
sean9057 5 months ago 3
Carl
R0CKnR0LLRALPH 5 months ago
@drugsinmybody sorry i wasnt saying that to you, just in general
TheSnapperfish 6 months ago
@TheSnapperfish dont worry.
drugsinmyb0dy 6 months ago
Its not a contest, they have completely different voices, but Petes is more suited to this song
TheSnapperfish 6 months ago
@TheSnapperfish I never said that. This is just a fan stuff, I love them and miss them too. Chill out :S
drugsinmyb0dy 6 months ago
pete wins easy but when there together its ten times better. i prefer petes voice
joefrench555 1 year ago 4
choose? it's a draw i think, both versions are very well done.
dessinoriginal 1 year ago
It has much more soul and meaning when Carl sings it.
Rrrayas 1 year ago
I think that they are both genious. Nevertheless I think that Doherty is a bit better - but it's really hard to choose !
Babyshamble01 1 year ago
There is no way I can choose... They both sound so good, but all I do when I hear either version is think of how sad it is that they are singing the parts that were written for the other to sing. I love the song, but think it will always stir up memories of sad times. They need to do a new happy song when they reunite... "CAN Stand You Now"
bevyk777 1 year ago 3
pete's version is defo the best but have to agree its never better when they are together
WARRIORUGG 1 year ago
BOTH! I like Pete's voice better though.. but they're both great!
xiimena17 1 year ago 2
Carl
Lisa9274 1 year ago
great quality of the recordings, great idea of yours to put 'em together! :)
likelylassofArcady 1 year ago
both ♥
sandriomusic 2 years ago 2
obviaamente lso prefiero juntooos <3
decidir es demasiado dificiiil
aparte el sonido en la version de Carl es malo
iguaal y a mi me gusta mas la voz de Carl,
la de Pete s un poco mas dulce no see
pero amooo a Pete<3 por sobretodas las cosas y creo k es un genioo
entonces es imposible!
pork no pueden reunirse otra veeez! D:
krn611 2 years ago
both of them together
that crushes every single version of can´t stand me now
@ardiweezybaby ... i was about to cry
valadez191 2 years ago
Peter
BombardWithMuffins 2 years ago
Pete without a doubt. I much prefer Doherty's voice. But I love them both. In an ideal world they would still be singing and performing together.
KidBk313 2 years ago
There are better carl versions of this, the sound quality is pretty poor here...
SamAG99 2 years ago
the point is not who's the best... the question is : when will they get their kicks back together?
yewtreesinerewhon 2 years ago 14
Both are great .
Peter's voice is better for me but cannot wait for Barat's solo album ;)
Drinksomegin 2 years ago
I like it they work together. I dont really think this works.
WrightMusicH 2 years ago
♥ beautiful
soccerholic101 2 years ago
they should do it together, i cant pick one of them...
getsicksoon 2 years ago
petes easily the best. both amazing but petes up there with morrisey and ray davies ect
frenchielcfc 2 years ago
THIS JUST MAKES ME SAD. :|
ardiweezybaby 2 years ago 3
Where can I find the Barat version?
v1m 2 years ago
The song loses some of its meaning when sung solo. Separately they're bout the same
Kerem1903 2 years ago
Peter, hands down.
bilo1404 2 years ago
it is always too hard to choose between them..in my opinion this song suits carl a bit better....i think.. :D off course, the best sounds when they perform it together.
suncica1hinet 2 years ago 16