how come you are allowed to upload what surely are illegal bootleg recordings of live shows i.e. video entitled 'The Knife - Heartbeats live 2006' in Related Videos and not get the audio disabled on those videos, but you have the audio disabled from a video with the original song on which for all YouTube know you just downloaded off the CD you own?
@confinedspace2006 because getting your camera phone out at a festival is a creative interpretation of the original artist's work, whereas this isn't.
AGAIN! this is fucking bullshit YOUTUBE admin. This is half the point of youtube is it not? the peeps who are enforcing the copyright have lost my respect.
i hope the copyright holders realise that i couldnt be fucked seeking the song (or the band for that matter) out now which means less money in their pockets. fuck them
Hello Thom, I don't know what comments u will read but I just wanted to tell u what a pleasure it was to see ur work again! You really are and always have been brilliant. The most beautiful person, inside and out I have ever known. I hope u r happy my love. Ur forever in my heart and in my dreams. I still see ur face so clearly behind my eyes. My comfort is the fact that one day u and I will meet again, even if itn is in another life when we are both cats. Je t'aime mon amour. Eleonore.
i cant believe people actually think deleting the audio track for copyright purposes is a smart thing to do, if anything, it makes me NOT want to listen to the song and only hate the company
youtube removed it because The Knife or their record company wanted it to be removed... try the new Pirate Bay Tube... even Swedish bands will not be able to get their tracks removed there...
Je pense que tu te souviens de la version par Jose Gonzales... mais cette version (l'originale) est fantastique - je l'ai trouve aujourd'hui par hasard - quelle bonne chance, non?
I feel like you captured the essence of what this song should feel like...not like that acoustic cover by Jose Gonzalez. He clearly doesn't understand it.
i think you are very clever it's good this the "silent movie" bits and those quick zoom in bits with gun to head etc. don;t have techie language at my disposal don't waste the talent on booze etc :)
that was really cool, it fit the song really well. it reminded me of the pineapple express trailer with mia's paper planes in the background. that trailer has this weird enchantment on it, like this.
i love the rex the dog remix version, now i found this video, and ask myself...its the original version? ...also i feel exited watching the video but a bit scared, so strange....
O my god i love this video,it's rite up my ally,but wow i REALLY liked it you guys did such a great job and very sexy 5stars...hope you have more vids...
BTW most all great songs are open to interpretation, different meaning to different people. but if you listen to the lyrics, this song is about a cocaine bender...hence "keeping us awake with wolfs teeth" "to cry for hands up above" the first dozen times i heard this song i thought it was about a relationship too.
over all i really liked it. its a great song and i liked the style of the footage with the girl on the bed. although i feel that you could have went above awesome and made it have a small story line. but i still liked it alot:)
Ok, so I made this pretty much, Tom filmed and edited. I am the girl, the one with the ideas,personality, animation, and love for this song. Superwolf, I assure you we are no trust fund kids. Student loans bought me a computer and a camera. My family just lost our home that we have lived in for over 20 years, and my Dad is living with me in my small apartment in SF. So sorry to dissapoint you, but we are poor, and we are creative, and we are fucking good.
No, you are right Sally. I was assuming too much about your personal life. It truly is a shame about your family's home. We've all suffered in some way and we have all been student poor. Now, take that suffering and experience and pour it into your art. Is it safe to assume this piece was made prior to the house burning down? By the way, it's The Knife's song. Gonzalez covered it, not the other way around. Not that it really matters.
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
Don't know who's who in the video, but the black haired girl is kinda cute :)
Anyway, I'm a great fan of The Knife, and to be honest, this video could easily be used for their music video. The visual fits so perfectly to the song and the meaning of the lyrics.
You have done quite a job with this video, I can tell. So I wanna thank you for this video, I enjoyed it :)
But keep on the good work, I would actually love to see more of this kind of stuff from you girls :)
kool. Scenes in the old building, outside and wearing the leather outside are good. Some of the interior stuff does not match. Overall it was awesome if this is your first try. Take a look for Floria Sigismondi, your stuff reminds me a bit...
Um. Wow this I think was good until the middle and then the towards the end was the best part. Visually interesting that's for sure - and you two are very good at poses and there were definately consistancies and continuity in editing style. The parts that were humorous sort of through in off in parts like when the girl is dancing in a kitchen or something - i thought that could have been left out. Other than that great work.
Fuckin great. I hope the Knife see's this and likes it. True to form though, the Knife's music is so bad ass that no video, no matter how bad, could make the song suck. I am just so happy to have my image associated with a song that I like so very much. P.S. put my name as a tag word, after all joint footage mon. LUV U TOMMY!
Tip for you, why don´t you just replace the audio track with something else? (youtube has an option for that)
Zeiramsy 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
YouTube.com
/watch?v=4SknBY37dVg
ROCK VERSION ^^
LaurieBuchananMusic 3 months ago
ERASE it though!
dernierutilisateur 9 months ago
the copyright shit makes me sooooo fucking angry right now.. i wann punch someone..
effeXxX 1 year ago
how come you are allowed to upload what surely are illegal bootleg recordings of live shows i.e. video entitled 'The Knife - Heartbeats live 2006' in Related Videos and not get the audio disabled on those videos, but you have the audio disabled from a video with the original song on which for all YouTube know you just downloaded off the CD you own?
confinedspace2006 2 years ago
@confinedspace2006 because getting your camera phone out at a festival is a creative interpretation of the original artist's work, whereas this isn't.
Am I getting mixed up again? :-/
thefrettinghand 1 year ago
Comment removed
thefrettinghand 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
AGAIN! this is fucking bullshit YOUTUBE admin. This is half the point of youtube is it not? the peeps who are enforcing the copyright have lost my respect.
gwuthie9090 2 years ago
i hope the copyright holders realise that i couldnt be fucked seeking the song (or the band for that matter) out now which means less money in their pockets. fuck them
TheBrowndawg 2 years ago 2
Hello Thom, I don't know what comments u will read but I just wanted to tell u what a pleasure it was to see ur work again! You really are and always have been brilliant. The most beautiful person, inside and out I have ever known. I hope u r happy my love. Ur forever in my heart and in my dreams. I still see ur face so clearly behind my eyes. My comfort is the fact that one day u and I will meet again, even if itn is in another life when we are both cats. Je t'aime mon amour. Eleonore.
elie3053 2 years ago
i fucking hate copyright its such a joke
iCgalz 2 years ago 12
very nice video! I think it's way better than the original...
just play the music in the background while watching :)
* * * * *
llzerollfuckyou 2 years ago
Comment removed
mikeygormley 2 years ago
i cant believe people actually think deleting the audio track for copyright purposes is a smart thing to do, if anything, it makes me NOT want to listen to the song and only hate the company
nxePremium 2 years ago 13
It's almost like they want us to download the track illegally...
mikeygormley 2 years ago 4
certainly so. Fucking stupid label. I hate!
abysmalcretin 2 years ago 3
if the knive are responsible for the missing audio track: FUCK THEM!!! if its the record company: well fuck them too but what do you expect.
its a good thing to know that these people will go down the next years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Antillektuell 2 years ago 3
i like the visuals very much - dont care about the sound , nice woman and effects in that vid, great job!
jarid666 2 years ago
Funny how the other 5600 hits for this song ARENT disabled. HINT: Take out or add to the first few seconds, it confuses the filters.
I like how you shot this, im still giving it 5*
CalicoatMaker 2 years ago 2
fuck you wmg. WHY DONT U JUST REMOVE THE VIDEO. omg.
avaxxsamantha 2 years ago
youtube sucks for deactivatin the audio track. the world is open source suckaaas!?
get with it
2ndsB4 2 years ago 2
youtube removed it because The Knife or their record company wanted it to be removed... try the new Pirate Bay Tube... even Swedish bands will not be able to get their tracks removed there...
mhenke64 2 years ago 2
pirate bay forever!
Randorotica 2 years ago
great song!! :)
crcjchacon 3 years ago
Does anyone know where i can find a hat like hers? Or even what those hats are called so i can find one! Thanx
niamhlovespink 3 years ago
u did it by urself? its a great video!!
n u gals r hot!!
beer811 3 years ago
the starting lokked like "the ring"
beer811 3 years ago
I must say it... this video is better than orginal. The spng is great, love it.
jas17min 3 years ago
I think I am more fond with the original video.
scalawaggywakyman 3 years ago
I love it :)
I think the original video should of been more of something like this.
TeamKillerS28 3 years ago
oh, great job! the song goes really well with the footage :)
browniephage 3 years ago
j ai l impression que cette version est differente , je me trompes ou pas ?
FRANCDESTRUCTEUR 3 years ago
Je pense que tu te souviens de la version par Jose Gonzales... mais cette version (l'originale) est fantastique - je l'ai trouve aujourd'hui par hasard - quelle bonne chance, non?
:-)
andyr8005 3 years ago
cool video but what´s about the "Reichsadler" and the pussy spread at 2:48 LOL......
derhenri 3 years ago
love love love. really well done.
zephed6980 3 years ago
Great Video!!
Ramur113 3 years ago
you did the video on your own ? great !
vancomycin87 3 years ago
reminds me of madonna
kadeb 3 years ago
cool=))
JuliBlumenkuss 3 years ago
wow i really dig it :)
hott!
minikobe 3 years ago
Beautiful work. It captures a lot. I really like it.
Mairtg 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is so cool.
ElectricxFeel 3 years ago
I feel like you captured the essence of what this song should feel like...not like that acoustic cover by Jose Gonzalez. He clearly doesn't understand it.
FMFunkyRadio 3 years ago
andando de calcinho num lugar todo pixado?
deve ta cheio de malaco na parada, moh vacilo
huahuahuhau
zik667 3 years ago
this is just wrong
PuLse285 3 years ago
i think you are very clever it's good this the "silent movie" bits and those quick zoom in bits with gun to head etc. don;t have techie language at my disposal don't waste the talent on booze etc :)
ChrisAlexT 3 years ago
One girl's naughty is another girl's nasty...
eye-poppin' vid, kids
Raymantico 3 years ago
Very good. The more abstract, leas narrative images worked best with the music. Fine selection though. Brava.
shakiMiki 3 years ago
that was really cool, it fit the song really well. it reminded me of the pineapple express trailer with mia's paper planes in the background. that trailer has this weird enchantment on it, like this.
Chowbogan 3 years ago
really well made film; eerie
shortnbitter 3 years ago
i love the rex the dog remix version, now i found this video, and ask myself...its the original version? ...also i feel exited watching the video but a bit scared, so strange....
rickxacler 3 years ago
... =) ...
iffrithda 3 years ago
creepy nice.intense yes.
unsettling.amazing.nost-
algic.i felt like i was
dreaming and you woke me
up to this place that only
exists in the knife.love you
spareparts303 3 years ago
O my god i love this video,it's rite up my ally,but wow i REALLY liked it you guys did such a great job and very sexy 5stars...hope you have more vids...
j3ohnny 3 years ago
That girl is gifted! Especially in the physics - man, that butt...
Nice video, a mix of sketches as it can be telled.
VebseLover 3 years ago
that was intense..right on!
bruz202 3 years ago
this is so strange
edbangergirl 3 years ago
I love this song!
Hellogoodbye113 3 years ago
this is so good! you shud totally get paid for this,
shirinchawla 3 years ago
BTW most all great songs are open to interpretation, different meaning to different people. but if you listen to the lyrics, this song is about a cocaine bender...hence "keeping us awake with wolfs teeth" "to cry for hands up above" the first dozen times i heard this song i thought it was about a relationship too.
funhunter671 3 years ago
Why is there so much confusion about the original writer of this song?????? it should be very clear by now
FFDC you do a gr8 job, your hard work will be rewarded, over 33k have already seen it, so your off to a good start,thanks
funhunter671 3 years ago
just awesome!! and, btw the original version is by the knife, gonzales' is a cover
timk0st 3 years ago
Professional! Good job!
imSarahWoo 3 years ago
i want to get the frames as in pics, i luv them
RZheretic 3 years ago
its better than the original music video. But some of the shots could have been taken out. Namely the ones with no effects.
CRKimling 3 years ago
over all i really liked it. its a great song and i liked the style of the footage with the girl on the bed. although i feel that you could have went above awesome and made it have a small story line. but i still liked it alot:)
IndieBitch 3 years ago
Please put down the camera, trust fund kids.
Flat and pretentious.
superwolf76 3 years ago
Trust fund?!?!?
Man I wish I knew I had one of those earlier.
I guess now I can BUY your comments so you don't look like such a dick. Hmmmm . . . neat.
codeforcontra 3 years ago 3
Ok, so I made this pretty much, Tom filmed and edited. I am the girl, the one with the ideas,personality, animation, and love for this song. Superwolf, I assure you we are no trust fund kids. Student loans bought me a computer and a camera. My family just lost our home that we have lived in for over 20 years, and my Dad is living with me in my small apartment in SF. So sorry to dissapoint you, but we are poor, and we are creative, and we are fucking good.
Love,
Sallie Smith
fatfacedotcom 3 years ago
No, you are right Sally. I was assuming too much about your personal life. It truly is a shame about your family's home. We've all suffered in some way and we have all been student poor. Now, take that suffering and experience and pour it into your art. Is it safe to assume this piece was made prior to the house burning down? By the way, it's The Knife's song. Gonzalez covered it, not the other way around. Not that it really matters.
superwolf76 3 years ago
I adore you!
Inagi 3 years ago
great video!
NoxNoctisUmbra 3 years ago
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
xXstellalunaXx 3 years ago
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
xXstellalunaXx 3 years ago
i love it!!! i liked how u used different pixels,colors, and scenes. the setting was awesome to. the girls were good actresses. can u guys make another music video to the songs: one for you by The Knife,marble house by The Knife,triumph of a heart by Bjork ,and it's not up to you by Bjork? Great video you guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -sincerely xXstellalunaXx
xXstellalunaXx 3 years ago
Don't know who's who in the video, but the black haired girl is kinda cute :)
Anyway, I'm a great fan of The Knife, and to be honest, this video could easily be used for their music video. The visual fits so perfectly to the song and the meaning of the lyrics.
You have done quite a job with this video, I can tell. So I wanna thank you for this video, I enjoyed it :)
But keep on the good work, I would actually love to see more of this kind of stuff from you girls :)
Thank you!
Sheelac 3 years ago
good job guys
kingchef666 3 years ago
the video is really really good. like it very much :) ... btw sallie is hot :D
kettenfett 3 years ago
Thanks Kettenfett.
fatfacedotcom 3 years ago
I love what you did visually with this video. It fit wonderfully with the song.
dancemaniac98 3 years ago
superrrrrrrrrrrrr brilliant.
short5 3 years ago
That was quality. Love that song and the video fit perfectly with it. Very moving.
liamanewton 3 years ago
That's feally really good!!!!
m0thland 3 years ago
i like it :)
yolennart 3 years ago
Really good video, really enjoyed it :)
eisesmit 4 years ago
really interesting, especially the beginning and the end
theRixen 4 years ago
very good interpretation of the song. pretty damned fantastic actually. Thank you
terraform242 4 years ago
it's actually the original version
theRixen 4 years ago
I meant that "visually" it was a good interpretation of the song.
terraform242 4 years ago
mmhhkay, sorry for that
theRixen 4 years ago
that...outfit....sexy! lol the song is great as well.
RyonAnthony 4 years ago
The new classical pop groupe. Excelent! I'd love The Knife!
claudiofrocha 4 years ago
i hope they have more than one good song like most bands.........
transworld20 4 years ago
all their songs are great!
iLoveiBook 4 years ago
kool. Scenes in the old building, outside and wearing the leather outside are good. Some of the interior stuff does not match. Overall it was awesome if this is your first try. Take a look for Floria Sigismondi, your stuff reminds me a bit...
Parsifal1973 4 years ago
you have to make more videos like this
dodahdoodoo 4 years ago
This video is perfect for the song. It's ultra trippy and sexy at the same time. Nice job.
stefang813 4 years ago
this is one of the best videos i've ever seen... on one side it is full of sex... and on the other side it's kind of frightening...
wow...
purzelmella 4 years ago
i like!
is nice!
limaq 4 years ago
i think we need to hang out
mikeezz 4 years ago
i really love this video i think its very out there and sexy, plus its set to a fantastic song
dodahdoodoo 4 years ago
1:20 wrecks the scene set before
YooChube 4 years ago
like it alot. just didnt like the kitchen scene and you use the scratchy quality a lil too much. idk i think its awesome ideas etc and editing tho
jerzkid87 4 years ago
so nice
ammini73 4 years ago
j'aime bien.
antekel 4 years ago
I think its excellent you are both very beautiful. A++++
kraftdinner35 4 years ago
love the video...suits the song better than the original video...until the idiot comes in!!
bebhinn17 4 years ago
+ fuck what everyone else says
sapoleada 4 years ago
crzy you girls are out there
sapoleada 4 years ago
Cool vid
Very stylish and sexy and intriguing
jools182 4 years ago 4
the vid is funky but i could of done with out
the clumsy blonde !
sokolski1986 4 years ago
the vid is funky but i could do with out the clumsy blonde
sokolski1986 4 years ago
Some parts are more enjoyable than the original music video. I like it!
ivambo77 4 years ago
GREAT VIDEO!
you guys have a great eye....
jfs77 4 years ago
Almost as messed up as The Knife themselves. Great video, superb song choice. Well done.
Lyonzy 4 years ago 3
looks like you let catwoman out of the bag, great video, - his comment sounds like crap in my ears
glitz606 4 years ago
it's ok Sally N., he was comenting on the song. The original version of the song was sung by Jose Gonzales. VIVA LA SALLY N!!!
fatfacedotcom 3 years ago
no it really wasn't if your going to try get cocky then at least be right idiot!
lukethekidd 3 years ago
this isn´t good folks!!? compare this whit José Gonzales , Man this sounds like crap in my ears : /
0akman 4 years ago
This was like, really oool!! I'm extremely critical of videos too... and i though this was totally cool.
surgeongen 4 years ago
Great job...love the filters you used on the video.
Have you heard the Jose Gonzales version of this song? it's damn good as well...
I'm the videographer for 30 Seconds to Mars, so check out the podcasts I'm doing for the Taste of Chaos tour starting on Wednesday.
skeeterou 5 years ago
Splendid!
domkaos 5 years ago
Interesting! Goes with the song, almost perfectly.. Check out my video of my version of heartbeats by the The Knife.. ; )
nellyha77 5 years ago
Um. Wow this I think was good until the middle and then the towards the end was the best part. Visually interesting that's for sure - and you two are very good at poses and there were definately consistancies and continuity in editing style. The parts that were humorous sort of through in off in parts like when the girl is dancing in a kitchen or something - i thought that could have been left out. Other than that great work.
TheVirginTerror 5 years ago 2
Fuckin great. I hope the Knife see's this and likes it. True to form though, the Knife's music is so bad ass that no video, no matter how bad, could make the song suck. I am just so happy to have my image associated with a song that I like so very much. P.S. put my name as a tag word, after all joint footage mon. LUV U TOMMY!
fatfacedotcom 5 years ago
this is the first time i have ever seen this and am blown away cool as fuck absolutley
shaneocean8 5 years ago