haha ben kenney is definitely the better musician. dirk is still a sick bassist though, but as musicians they are on different levels. Ben play pick, fingers and is very competent at both. Can groove it up on the drums, shred on the guitar. Sing lead and do harmonies. Bass playing wise he is more creative with his use of effects, chorus and overdrive etc. Plus I dig his tone much more too, it cuts through really well. Plus his use of chords is really tasteful. Even when he wanks, hes tasteful
Dirk did cool stuff on science sure, but he isn't even close to Ben's skill level. Ben plays slap, finger style, and with a pick, and actually writes his own bass lines for incubus's music. Dirk didn't, which is not a secret as Mike has admitted in interviews that he wrote many of the bass lines as well as the guitar parts. Ben Kenney can play every instrument, and sing better than Dirk. He is just a far better musician, and comparing them is like comparing Jack White to Jimmy Page.
he plays like a guitarist BECAUSE HE IS A GUITARIST, look into his solo albums and you'll see, he is VERY talented on a guitar, his style kinda transferred over to bass i guess you could say
He is not really a guitarist, well he is but he played drums and bass before playing guitar, and plays alot other instruments than guitar. And I dont think he plays like a guitarist(only when playing guitar) I admire his bass style very much, and love his solo projects and guitar stuff too.
@santerlund i understand but i was saying that if you can notice his guitar influence with his bass style i would completely understand it because he is a phenomenal guitarist also, on his solo projects he is much more prevalent in his guitar playing that his bass playing
people talk alot of shit like he plays like aguitar player this and that , u know what people ?????? go and learn a bit more about bass the instrument itself and his wide open posibilitties as an instrument . please bass guitar is more than playing a sick funk groove i mean i love funk but bass is more than those kind of tasty funky solos
for those who say ben plays too much like a guitarist... okay, maybe during his bass solos... but playing lead on a bass is bound to sound like lead guitar. his playing during the songs is still very much that of a bassist, not a guitarist.
Ben Kenney is a sick fucking musician and just to give my opinion in a non bashing way I will say that I think hes more of a guitarist that also plays bass. I don't see him ass a bass player only because hes plays bass as if its was a guitar in my opinion. Well rounded though, dirk fit better for incubus, espefially in its earlier days and im more of a dirk fan but Ben is still sick with his shit. Sings, drums, guitar and bass. Hes got skills and hes good at everyone of them.
if you go to most videos they have ben and dirk arguements too its hilarious how many people are arguing this, just shows how great the band really is even tho ill admit it here im a dirk fan, but i like ben as a musician hes a brilliant dude but as skill in the bass dirk is the better bassist, but ben is a better musician, dirk has the upper hand in bass skill, for instance ben doesnt even slap his bass, he using only one technique of playin bass
i dont think its a matter of ben "lacking skill" he just doesnt prefer to slap, he mentioned on his FB that its just not his style and he would feel fake trying to please all the dirk fans out there, but calling him a weaker bassist doesn't make sense either. slapping is like 1/10000000000000000000000 of being a bassist just like using double bass is like 1/100000000000000000 of beng a drummer. The fact that this guy (ben) gets free basses and gear from Lakland and Mesa tells me enough....
Dirk's a really...REALLY good bass player, Ben Kenney is a very well rounded musician. I know I sound very redundant when I say you can really compare them but it's true
You gotta be a serious musician with crazy chops in all styles of music to be in the Roots. Him being in that band plus this ill solo proves how skill he is. I think that's all dude meant by "Go Ben.....show me why you were in the roots". God why does everyone on youtube determined to start arguements lol???
he can play 235698349539639546 different instruments and sing. And he chooses the bass.... I FUCKING LOVE THIS GUY!!!!!!!!!!!
newbass28 4 months ago
This guy is awesome!
Lainey37 6 months ago
love this performance, . .it's on my look alive dvd. . .he's so versatile, he can do jazz, he can do funk, he's really good. . .
25napster 8 months ago
who says ben cant groove? he kills
tetsusixx 9 months ago
haha ben kenney is definitely the better musician. dirk is still a sick bassist though, but as musicians they are on different levels. Ben play pick, fingers and is very competent at both. Can groove it up on the drums, shred on the guitar. Sing lead and do harmonies. Bass playing wise he is more creative with his use of effects, chorus and overdrive etc. Plus I dig his tone much more too, it cuts through really well. Plus his use of chords is really tasteful. Even when he wanks, hes tasteful
tetsusixx 1 year ago
Ben isnt bad he is a great great great greatttttt musician.
I dont hate.
I just dont see him as strong as a bassist as a musician.
But thats what he is aiming for, and madd madd madd mad mad mad props to him for that.
AlexKalicinski 1 year ago
Dirk did cool stuff on science sure, but he isn't even close to Ben's skill level. Ben plays slap, finger style, and with a pick, and actually writes his own bass lines for incubus's music. Dirk didn't, which is not a secret as Mike has admitted in interviews that he wrote many of the bass lines as well as the guitar parts. Ben Kenney can play every instrument, and sing better than Dirk. He is just a far better musician, and comparing them is like comparing Jack White to Jimmy Page.
deanthebassfeast 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
AlexKalicinski 1 year ago
he plays like a guitarist BECAUSE HE IS A GUITARIST, look into his solo albums and you'll see, he is VERY talented on a guitar, his style kinda transferred over to bass i guess you could say
fredodp 1 year ago
@fredodp
He is not really a guitarist, well he is but he played drums and bass before playing guitar, and plays alot other instruments than guitar. And I dont think he plays like a guitarist(only when playing guitar) I admire his bass style very much, and love his solo projects and guitar stuff too.
santerlund 1 year ago
@santerlund i understand but i was saying that if you can notice his guitar influence with his bass style i would completely understand it because he is a phenomenal guitarist also, on his solo projects he is much more prevalent in his guitar playing that his bass playing
fredodp 1 year ago
Comment removed
AlexKalicinski 1 year ago
people talk alot of shit like he plays like aguitar player this and that , u know what people ?????? go and learn a bit more about bass the instrument itself and his wide open posibilitties as an instrument . please bass guitar is more than playing a sick funk groove i mean i love funk but bass is more than those kind of tasty funky solos
thefuckinfish 1 year ago
Comment removed
AlexKalicinski 1 year ago
for those who say ben plays too much like a guitarist... okay, maybe during his bass solos... but playing lead on a bass is bound to sound like lead guitar. his playing during the songs is still very much that of a bassist, not a guitarist.
unccharris 1 year ago
:47 on out...
Whooo!
What a soulful rockin' surprise!
I didn't know Ben did this!!
I really like this.
Tasteful and soulful.
This solo SAYS a lot.
I'm feelin' him.
1.
tedbrookins 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
DIRK > BEN. conversation finished, now can we get on with our lives?
bigrawbio 2 years ago
Ben Kenney is a sick fucking musician and just to give my opinion in a non bashing way I will say that I think hes more of a guitarist that also plays bass. I don't see him ass a bass player only because hes plays bass as if its was a guitar in my opinion. Well rounded though, dirk fit better for incubus, espefially in its earlier days and im more of a dirk fan but Ben is still sick with his shit. Sings, drums, guitar and bass. Hes got skills and hes good at everyone of them.
Deftoneskid1 2 years ago
i also think that since he has joined the bad, they have gotten a lot they all have improved musically as a whole. but dirk was still awesome.
JMorr1029 1 year ago
Man I've heard bass solos before but I've never heard anyone make a bass wail like that. Screw the Ben Kenney haters. That cat's got soul.
TheFretDancer 2 years ago 11
wooooooooooo
that mother fucker was getting down!!!!!!!!!!!
bassdubman 2 years ago
Comment removed
proceedband 2 years ago
ben kenney is your new hero? hes a good musician...but hes no dirk...u see dirks vid playing with willie nerve clinic...ahhh its godly
Dynamiteskillsx 3 years ago
I like Ben Better! But some people like dirk.
xicanoster 3 years ago
Oh come on!
He's ripping the shit outta that bass! with his fingers! no pick!
at least i think ben's better than dirk.
theflash4490 2 years ago 4
dirk who
heya234 2 years ago
you can't compare kenney and dirk together, their totally in different leagues.
Kitsuji 2 years ago
Dirk distastefully overplays. Ben kills!
ricvdb 2 years ago
yeah but ben actually doesn't need the guitarist to right his music lol
Zellps0 2 years ago
if you go to most videos they have ben and dirk arguements too its hilarious how many people are arguing this, just shows how great the band really is even tho ill admit it here im a dirk fan, but i like ben as a musician hes a brilliant dude but as skill in the bass dirk is the better bassist, but ben is a better musician, dirk has the upper hand in bass skill, for instance ben doesnt even slap his bass, he using only one technique of playin bass
Dynamiteskillsx 2 years ago
that's not true
search
Ben Kenny Slap Bass
KenuThePirate 2 years ago
yeah this recent tour they wanted to play the classics the original way and ben worked at it and he know slaps for a couple songs
Dynamiteskillsx 2 years ago
i dont think its a matter of ben "lacking skill" he just doesnt prefer to slap, he mentioned on his FB that its just not his style and he would feel fake trying to please all the dirk fans out there, but calling him a weaker bassist doesn't make sense either. slapping is like 1/10000000000000000000000 of being a bassist just like using double bass is like 1/100000000000000000 of beng a drummer. The fact that this guy (ben) gets free basses and gear from Lakland and Mesa tells me enough....
frobro14k 2 years ago
Dirk's a really...REALLY good bass player, Ben Kenney is a very well rounded musician. I know I sound very redundant when I say you can really compare them but it's true
jiggrgermy 2 years ago
dang
hes good
frobro14k 3 years ago
Ooooh impresionante
bsstoner18 3 years ago
eu achava o dirk melhor...mas hj em dia percebo que o ben eh mais completo
brandonbalzary 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
prefiro o dirk lance!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
goio87 4 years ago
yeah me 2
polishpirate123 3 years ago
You gotta be a serious musician with crazy chops in all styles of music to be in the Roots. Him being in that band plus this ill solo proves how skill he is. I think that's all dude meant by "Go Ben.....show me why you were in the roots". God why does everyone on youtube determined to start arguements lol???
PhunkyFaroah 4 years ago 4
0:10 i think i saw something...
RauruV 4 years ago 14
XD XD XD
FancyFunkFool 4 years ago
I wish they would re-release Drive with Ben singing and playing .. he's the man.
risetotheheavens 4 years ago 2
Ben is freakin awesome!
Lynni06 4 years ago
hell yeah. i was at that concert and he tore that solo up. jose's drum solo was F-ing awesome 2. Ben Kenney is the SHIT!!! END OF STORY!!!
DPettiet 4 years ago
HE IS MY IDLE! ben kenney is my idle and inspiration (along with flea) to playing bass!
he is soo creative and awesome!
"go ben, show me why you were in the roots"
haha!
hysteria116 4 years ago
me to...they's my favourites...
unclejomofo 4 years ago
Man that was fucking sweet, rock bass it it's finest damn sweet bends too.
maximusflea59 4 years ago
OMG!CAN U FEEL IT?
rafaelp3688 4 years ago
DANG, HE KILLED IT! WHEW! I KNEW HE WAS GOOD IN HIS BANDS AND BY HIMSELF [Maduro], but DANG! I DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT HIS SOLOING SKILLS!!!
draa4love 4 years ago
ok first off! FUCK YOU AND YOUR MOTHERFUCKING DONKEY!!!
and yes...sadly ur right
i mean holy shite man
its been 4 years since the absence of dirk nd theyre still fercking with ben and his amiazing guitar infulenced bass riffs....*sighs*
chestnut02 4 years ago
Great clip! Ben is such an amazing musician.
1woman 4 years ago
That was my favorite part of the song!!!! I was standing right in front of hime!!!! Amazing...
mcculc 4 years ago