It's such a beautifull master piece.. it would make anyone cry. the interesting part is axl wrote it before the appetite for destruction.. when he had a piano near him he used to play the first chords.. tracii guns always asked why do you always play that? and axl used to say "one day i'll finish this song.. and its gonna be something great" well.. he was right.. It is something big!
Read Reckless Road, November Rain (this version) is listed as part of the Sound City demos, parts of which were released to the public (an authorized demo by Geffen, since the band was taking too long to find a producer) hence the reason why we have pretty clean sounding demos floating around out there.
does it truly matter which year this version is from? whether it was first recorded in 86 or 89, it's wonderful. and a lot more honest than the version we know. it's wonderful. thanks for finding this.
@Brownyy123 Not the management, the rest of the band. November Rain is an incredible song, but does NOT fit in with the tempo, pace and sound of AFD AT ALL.
@Brownyy123 lololol. ok. I read the book too pal. But before the book even came out it was well known that Slash or nobody else in the band wanted November Rain on Appetite. Furthermore, even though Axl was annoyed by this, he ultimately agreed for two reasons. 1, it wasn't right for Appetite. 2) he didn't feel the band was ready at the time for the song in order to get it the way he wanted it. There's a lot more info in the world than Slash's book. The stories date back 20 years before the book
@Brownyy123 3) The reason the band wanted 2 separate releases was, at the time, for the fans. I remember hearing a live radio interview with the band before the albums came out. Axl said they had all these songs they wanted to put out, but if they released a double album it would be over $20. So they thought a kid and his buddy would both go in, one buys one, one buys the other, then they could go home and copy from each other. This of course pissed off the label, but GnR had total control then
@Brownyy123 2) On top of that GnR signed a pretty exclusive deal for their first album. They talked to several different companies, but ultimately decided to go with Geffen because Geffen promised them complete control over their material. That means managers had no say over what went on the album. To this day Axl still has the same deal. That's also why UYI 1 and 2 had so many songs and was a double release. Geffen wanted to release it as a double album. GnR said no and made 2 separate releases
@ChrisMaciel88 lololololo. November Rain was something Axl had for years, even before GnR. Axl wanted on AFD but the rest of the band didn't think it was right for the album they were making at the time. Axl of course was pissed about it, but at the time they were more democratic in their decision making and the majority won.
que voz por dios, este tio en el estudio era un genio, y en el escenario el mejor show man, aunque su calidad vocal bajaba mucho, igual los mejores de la historia del rock y de la musica
omg.. it's so beautiful, it almost made me cry..
love this version ♥
MrsBruh4 1 year ago
AXL IS THE MAN ..
brunoblood 1 year ago
It's such a beautifull master piece.. it would make anyone cry. the interesting part is axl wrote it before the appetite for destruction.. when he had a piano near him he used to play the first chords.. tracii guns always asked why do you always play that? and axl used to say "one day i'll finish this song.. and its gonna be something great" well.. he was right.. It is something big!
95danielcosta 1 year ago 6
Beautiful...
BrunoGuedes666 1 year ago
good song
bathorymk 1 year ago
November rain, una de las mejores 'rocker-ballads' que existen,la amo, y el video (lo admito) me hace llorar u.u
paulyGNR 1 year ago
Damn Music!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -__-
kjk9737 1 year ago
Fuckin Asshole Music. -_-
kjk9737 1 year ago
it'll make me cry, so sad, so sad version...
eriktorres 2 years ago 4
1986 is the year where this comes from
pesmith8768 2 years ago
Read Reckless Road, November Rain (this version) is listed as part of the Sound City demos, parts of which were released to the public (an authorized demo by Geffen, since the band was taking too long to find a producer) hence the reason why we have pretty clean sounding demos floating around out there.
pesmith8768 2 years ago
does it truly matter which year this version is from? whether it was first recorded in 86 or 89, it's wonderful. and a lot more honest than the version we know. it's wonderful. thanks for finding this.
anirak90 2 years ago
I really think this is from 1989 instead of 1986
The only songs from Illusions that really existed before Appetite was YCBM, Don't Cry, Back of Bitchie and more 2 or 3 rockers, but not november rain.
ChrisMaciel88 2 years ago
According to Slash in his book this song DID existed before Appetite.
madcicken 2 years ago
@ChrisMaciel88
Not correct. Sorry, but NR should be on AFD, but the Management decided that one ballad (sweet child) was enough.
Brownyy123 2 years ago
@Brownyy123 Not the management, the rest of the band. November Rain is an incredible song, but does NOT fit in with the tempo, pace and sound of AFD AT ALL.
bandit7498 1 year ago
@bandit7498
I have taken this out of the slash biography...
Brownyy123 1 year ago
@Brownyy123 lololol. ok. I read the book too pal. But before the book even came out it was well known that Slash or nobody else in the band wanted November Rain on Appetite. Furthermore, even though Axl was annoyed by this, he ultimately agreed for two reasons. 1, it wasn't right for Appetite. 2) he didn't feel the band was ready at the time for the song in order to get it the way he wanted it. There's a lot more info in the world than Slash's book. The stories date back 20 years before the book
bandit7498 1 year ago
@Brownyy123 3) The reason the band wanted 2 separate releases was, at the time, for the fans. I remember hearing a live radio interview with the band before the albums came out. Axl said they had all these songs they wanted to put out, but if they released a double album it would be over $20. So they thought a kid and his buddy would both go in, one buys one, one buys the other, then they could go home and copy from each other. This of course pissed off the label, but GnR had total control then
bandit7498 1 year ago 2
@Brownyy123 2) On top of that GnR signed a pretty exclusive deal for their first album. They talked to several different companies, but ultimately decided to go with Geffen because Geffen promised them complete control over their material. That means managers had no say over what went on the album. To this day Axl still has the same deal. That's also why UYI 1 and 2 had so many songs and was a double release. Geffen wanted to release it as a double album. GnR said no and made 2 separate releases
bandit7498 1 year ago
November Rain was first written in 1983. Axl didn't finish it until around 89', but the basic music was written in 1983.
bodhi3323 1 year ago
@ChrisMaciel88 lololololo. November Rain was something Axl had for years, even before GnR. Axl wanted on AFD but the rest of the band didn't think it was right for the album they were making at the time. Axl of course was pissed about it, but at the time they were more democratic in their decision making and the majority won.
bandit7498 1 year ago
Goosebumps! This feels even more emotional than the final version.
youtubablecarlos 2 years ago
i have this on my mp3 player
jimihendrixtribute 2 years ago
It's better than the final version, IMO.
maxxoccupancy 2 years ago
Me gusta mas la version original, anuq esta está muy bien tambien
superterminatorr 2 years ago
are you sure that this is from 1986?
fnattila 2 years ago
really beautiful
pauzud 2 years ago
que voz por dios, este tio en el estudio era un genio, y en el escenario el mejor show man, aunque su calidad vocal bajaba mucho, igual los mejores de la historia del rock y de la musica
MadeInHeaven0 3 years ago 3
q lindo tema por dios....me encanta esta version
tomyhomps80 3 years ago 3
si no saves tocar la guitara nno tokes
Anibal0831 3 years ago
now this is beauty
pingponggun 3 years ago 16
Thank you for putting this up
sammartin1983 3 years ago 9