Anyone else immediately think that the "young elf lord" is a reference to Legolas? I really hope that I am wrong, but then again the fact that Itaril is a character at all is completely against the book so you never know what other major changes they'll make.
@Lotrgecko That's what I'm afraid too. I hope PJ wouldn't commit such a crime. If they want to add made up characters and storyline into The Hobbit too bad. But at least they should leave Legolas character as he is.
OK everyone, if you're not sure if you like this Itaril idea, search "Hobbit Fans Against Itaril" on Facebook, and like the page. If enough people do it, maybe someone with some decision-making power will notice!
@tylerfh2012 Exactly! I don't get why Rebekah can't just come out and mention that most fans are upset about this. Is this torn jumping on the bandwagon of "yes for more twilight romance"? Why can't they put their foot down and mention what the viewers feel?
@darthclide maybe there has yet to be a substantial fan uprising because the info. just hasn't been out that much. To change that, I've made a facebook page: "Hobbit Fans Against Itaril." Maybe if we get enough people to join it, we can get the attention of some people in charge.
Just curious, are we a minority who think that this female elf warrior is a horrible decision on pj's part? I mean, I am sure he will work magic to make it fit in the film, but where on earth is this warrior mentioned in the hobbit? And where on earth was there a love story in the Hobbit? Sounds like a bunch of Hollywood romance crap yet again.... Does Rebekah or any other big name forum users mention this problem on the board discussions? I cannot see how anyone is eager for this cast decision
@darthclide No,we are not in minority.There is a poll on The Hobbit Movie com if Itaril should be in the movie or not and 67% people voted "no".There is "Don't put Itaril Into the Hobbit" group on Facebook.Fans tell their objections and disagreements every time an articles,speculations,rumors...about this character or S.Ronan appear on the internet.Many fans have issue with this character.
We had a great time celebrating Tolkien Reading Day at The Marion E. Wade Center in Wheaton, IL. About 70 people showed up for readings, music, food, and a Tolkien trivia contest. It was lots of fun, and we're starting up a Tolkien Society as well!
The questions for this contest were haaard. I didnt get the one about Weta releasing a book in a universe, other than that im sure the others were right...that Bag-End sculpture is beautiful
I've actually just started reading The Two towers again for about a half a month ago because last time i read the first and 2nd book was like 3-4 years ago now and i'm slowly hyping up to The Hobbit movie :) I've read The Hobbit as well when i was 12-13 years old which is 8-9 years ago and i'm defintely gonna read it ago so i'm prepared for the movie !! :)
Could someone with access to Peter Jackson please tell him that he'd better not screw this classic, beloved story up with a cheesy, manufactured romance? Please don't ruin it for all of us true fans.
Are they adding the Itaril romance so that women will go see the movie? Tell me, do they stick random action/adventure scenes into romantic comedies so that more guys will go? NO! Guys will go because 1) their girlfriend takes them, or 2) they like that kind of thing o_O
Girls will see The Hobbit for the same reasons: they want to go already because they love the story, or their boyfriend takes them. And this type of movie is more universally appealing anyway; it doesn't need the love story.
If Itaril is a minor role that shows up a little, that's OK within artistic license, but if they're going to invent a whole new character's story to follow as in-depth as Bilbo's, it will really drag the story down. There's plenty of extra material going on with the back-story of the Dwarves, and the White Council, and Sauron in Dol-Guldur to make it interesting without inventing characters no one cares about. When the audience doesn't care about the characters, there's no point.
@tylerfh2012 Apparently, the information about the character Itaril on the casting call sheets said that the role would be "a lead".....Don't know if they plan on sticking to that information or if they'll make the character a more minor role.
Great job as always, Rebekah and Will, etc! I especially like the channeling of Bobby Badfingers. Just one note: Tolkien is actually pronounced "Tol-keen" with an equal stress on both syllables.
why is jackson adding characters the hobbit is perfect and so was the lord of the rings book, i hated almost every change jackson made last time so why is he doing this crap again. Jackson needs to stick to the book.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY BILBO BAGGINS!!!! (Sept. 22)
allendupras 5 months ago
I am afraid that many people expect just EPIC movie from Hobbit...
Kjoep 6 months ago
Get to the meat already!
sgoodell99 7 months ago
Rebekah Platt? More like Rebecca Black. They even look similar.
duckwark 10 months ago
Damn!!! Where did you get that shirt Rebekah?????
It's AWESOME!!!! I WANT IT!!!!!!
petraizzg 10 months ago
I live in Hobbiton :D the set is about 5 mins drive down the road from me :) Matamata, New Zealand. WOO! Can't wait til all the stars get here!
xxfirexxphoenixxx 10 months ago 2
@xxfirexxphoenixxx You, lucky, lucky person...
bookercreator 7 months ago
Anyone else immediately think that the "young elf lord" is a reference to Legolas? I really hope that I am wrong, but then again the fact that Itaril is a character at all is completely against the book so you never know what other major changes they'll make.
Lotrgecko 10 months ago
@Lotrgecko That's what I'm afraid too. I hope PJ wouldn't commit such a crime. If they want to add made up characters and storyline into The Hobbit too bad. But at least they should leave Legolas character as he is.
loveatrej 10 months ago
Fun 1st of april joke.
Eirmar 10 months ago
OK everyone, if you're not sure if you like this Itaril idea, search "Hobbit Fans Against Itaril" on Facebook, and like the page. If enough people do it, maybe someone with some decision-making power will notice!
tylerfh2012 10 months ago
@tylerfh2012 Exactly! I don't get why Rebekah can't just come out and mention that most fans are upset about this. Is this torn jumping on the bandwagon of "yes for more twilight romance"? Why can't they put their foot down and mention what the viewers feel?
darthclide 10 months ago
@darthclide maybe there has yet to be a substantial fan uprising because the info. just hasn't been out that much. To change that, I've made a facebook page: "Hobbit Fans Against Itaril." Maybe if we get enough people to join it, we can get the attention of some people in charge.
tylerfh2012 10 months ago
Rebekah looks better every video. Dayam
livvi67 10 months ago
I took part in Tolkien Reading Day by going to my Tolkien class!
hpdramareader91 10 months ago
who composed your intro/end music? It's really neat!
Oh and nice job on the entire vlog btw!
hdeditor 10 months ago
@hdeditor The music is from a music library that we bought from Digital Juice. The song is called "Dominis" and composed by Michael Gary Brassell.
hobbitin5 10 months ago 2
@hobbitin5 Thank you for that information! Didn't know Digital Juice offered music as well!
hdeditor 10 months ago
Just curious, are we a minority who think that this female elf warrior is a horrible decision on pj's part? I mean, I am sure he will work magic to make it fit in the film, but where on earth is this warrior mentioned in the hobbit? And where on earth was there a love story in the Hobbit? Sounds like a bunch of Hollywood romance crap yet again.... Does Rebekah or any other big name forum users mention this problem on the board discussions? I cannot see how anyone is eager for this cast decision
darthclide 10 months ago
@darthclide You're absolutely right! and I'm frustrated that no one is even acknowledging that many fans are angry about this!
tylerfh2012 10 months ago 4
@darthclide No,we are not in minority.There is a poll on The Hobbit Movie com if Itaril should be in the movie or not and 67% people voted "no".There is "Don't put Itaril Into the Hobbit" group on Facebook.Fans tell their objections and disagreements every time an articles,speculations,rumors...about this character or S.Ronan appear on the internet.Many fans have issue with this character.
loveatrej 10 months ago
@loveatrej I couldn't find that Facebook group, so I made my own:
"Hobbit Fans Against Itaril"
tylerfh2012 10 months ago
I celebrated Tolkien Reading Day by finishing the Hobbit. Man, I love that book!! :D
Can't wait for the movie to come out!!! *squeals with excitement!* :D
RoseBaggins 10 months ago
i love your installments i go all week looking forward to every friday, thank you rebekah oh and your hot.
tuber7071 10 months ago
We had a great time celebrating Tolkien Reading Day at The Marion E. Wade Center in Wheaton, IL. About 70 people showed up for readings, music, food, and a Tolkien trivia contest. It was lots of fun, and we're starting up a Tolkien Society as well!
laurielfrodo 10 months ago
The questions for this contest were haaard. I didnt get the one about Weta releasing a book in a universe, other than that im sure the others were right...that Bag-End sculpture is beautiful
Leaf0fLorien 10 months ago
Woot! Keep them reports comin'. X3
rockfootfootfoot 11 months ago
WHERE DID YOU GET THAT SAURON SHRT!!!??
anonymousLeroy 11 months ago 4
@anonymousLeroy That is another WETA T-shirt
chrispirrotta 11 months ago
@anonymousLeroy Yep, @chrispirrotta is completely right on! Courtesy of Weta Workshop! You can get one for yourself at wetanz.com!
rebekahH5 10 months ago
@rebekahH5 I checked, and at 25$ it's an amazing price! But alas, New Zealand shipping only. Blasted! I would have bought 4...
anonymousLeroy 10 months ago
fingers crossed on the sculpture :)
thirsokewl 11 months ago
I've actually just started reading The Two towers again for about a half a month ago because last time i read the first and 2nd book was like 3-4 years ago now and i'm slowly hyping up to The Hobbit movie :) I've read The Hobbit as well when i was 12-13 years old which is 8-9 years ago and i'm defintely gonna read it ago so i'm prepared for the movie !! :)
copymizer 11 months ago
I don't know about Itaril...I'm kind of disliking the idea.
jrrtolkia 11 months ago 4
Wow no child warrior elf please that is so pathetic.
bloodgunslinger 11 months ago 35
I answered 79 too! :[[[[[
YoseMiteEmery 11 months ago
Don't worry, I'm almost done ranting.
Could someone with access to Peter Jackson please tell him that he'd better not screw this classic, beloved story up with a cheesy, manufactured romance? Please don't ruin it for all of us true fans.
tylerfh2012 11 months ago 3
Are they adding the Itaril romance so that women will go see the movie? Tell me, do they stick random action/adventure scenes into romantic comedies so that more guys will go? NO! Guys will go because 1) their girlfriend takes them, or 2) they like that kind of thing o_O
Girls will see The Hobbit for the same reasons: they want to go already because they love the story, or their boyfriend takes them. And this type of movie is more universally appealing anyway; it doesn't need the love story.
tylerfh2012 11 months ago
If Itaril is a minor role that shows up a little, that's OK within artistic license, but if they're going to invent a whole new character's story to follow as in-depth as Bilbo's, it will really drag the story down. There's plenty of extra material going on with the back-story of the Dwarves, and the White Council, and Sauron in Dol-Guldur to make it interesting without inventing characters no one cares about. When the audience doesn't care about the characters, there's no point.
tylerfh2012 11 months ago
@tylerfh2012 Apparently, the information about the character Itaril on the casting call sheets said that the role would be "a lead".....Don't know if they plan on sticking to that information or if they'll make the character a more minor role.
rebekahH5 11 months ago
Nice T-shirt!
cla728 11 months ago
I finished reading The Two Towers and getting started on ROTK.
coachlong023 11 months ago
@Grunge1991Cory No,he isn't.It's April fools joke:)
loveatrej 11 months ago
Aw, I wanted to see a picture of Richard!
Ladygwenea 11 months ago
Nothing says "Mary-Sue" better than Itaril. Hearing about the storyline made my stomach twist a little.
Elainiwen 11 months ago
Comment removed
Elainiwen 11 months ago
Comment removed
Elainiwen 11 months ago
No Itaril please!!!
loveatrej 11 months ago 2
I'm glad you're not Rebecca Black.......
Michaelmop 11 months ago 5
@Michaelmop it's friday, friday, friday
Zyclon3000 11 months ago
@Zyclon3000 Gotta make my mind up.. Which seat can I taaaaaaaakkkeee?!...
Hahaha.
Michaelmop 11 months ago
@Michaelmop hahaha your comment cracked me up dude
Zyclon3000 11 months ago
who else thinks the prize for the contest should be a date with rebekah?
Go for a romantic walk through middle earth and then maybe later back to the shire for some desert ! :)
EverybodyLovesAnto 11 months ago 38
Serkis in the ping-pong suit. Now it feels real.
Klamath2046 11 months ago 2
i guessed the puzzle right but harumph, i wasnt one of the first 3 :( so sadddd.
BUT i entered the Bag End giveaway contest! :) hope i win *fingers crossed* tho it's a a really, reaaaally long shot. hihi.
c00kiechip 11 months ago
I am Tony, but I never got an e-mail back about winning...
ItsThatGuy8669 11 months ago
@ItsThatGuy8669 We'll be emailing everyone back for contact info soon.
hobbitin5 11 months ago
@hobbitin5 Ok thanks!
Side note: Didn't mean to come off as ungrateful, just confuse. ;) Trust me, I am beyond thrilled and very thankful.
ItsThatGuy8669 11 months ago
i am in love with you Rebekah
iamthedarklord1314 11 months ago
Comment removed
EverybodyLovesAnto 11 months ago
adding a lot of characters? not sure if want
Wierdoinc 11 months ago
Thats a really cool shirt, where can I get one????
nico1644 11 months ago
:D
NedrevikOWNS 11 months ago
i guessed the puzzle correct, how come i never got a prize? :(
comeondown12345 11 months ago
@comeondown12345 Sorry, we awarded the first three people to respond. We might go with a random drawing next time we do a contest on the show.
hobbitin5 11 months ago
@comeondown12345 me tooo!
YoseMiteEmery 11 months ago
awww i was so close to winning, i only guessed peters age
koopaatroopa 11 months ago
Ah.. Friday News <3
MsMaeAngela 11 months ago
Great job as always, Rebekah and Will, etc! I especially like the channeling of Bobby Badfingers. Just one note: Tolkien is actually pronounced "Tol-keen" with an equal stress on both syllables.
jwbraun1 11 months ago
I really want to see more elven presence in the movie so i am happy with the adding of new charecters
93kirov 11 months ago
why is jackson adding characters the hobbit is perfect and so was the lord of the rings book, i hated almost every change jackson made last time so why is he doing this crap again. Jackson needs to stick to the book.
Deveed411 11 months ago 3
"Let's light this candle"? Have someone been listening to the Dennis Miller Show? Good on you. ;)
ErikNorseman 11 months ago
You have to most beautiful eyes in the whole world babe.
DamnKuschel 11 months ago
yo quiero esa replica¡¡¡ :D
Aragorn522 11 months ago