Okay...ummm...what are the judges talking about? I have nothing against Siobhan, but this was terribly awful, as are all of the other performances I have seen of hers. And SHE was considered the shocking elimination of the season?! This proves that Season 9 sucked eggs...she has a really small voice and the only thing it seems she can do well is screech. Sorry Siobhan, but I am not a fan.
I think American Idol shouldn't be aired anymore. Or, as another 'option', Simon and Kara should be fired, and a new judge should be on the panel. The final option is... BRING BACK SIOBHAN!!
The judges tried as hard as possible (on and off the show) to get her away, even though she had the most talent and style. It worked. What a shame that they stole her spirit and confidence. She brought life and creativity to the show, something I don't see any other finalists doing. She should be brought back...
it just seemed a little slow and woulda been boring if it weren't siobhan singing it...glad she made it work :) so sad she's gone!! like really, how did she go before aaron?
lol ellen "way to pull the shania train into the station" ... *facepalm*
@LVMindblown28 --alot of Siobhan haters are coming on all of her sights claiming to be fans and then condemning the heck out of her. There are quite a few of them on all of her sights.
I truly love her voice, performance and style!! And I really don't think it was an easy song!!!! And it hard not to sing like karaoke with this song, but she did it, as she ALWAYS do! She is smart about music!!!
awful
anyalify 3 weeks ago
I wish Shania was a judge instead of J.Lo. :/
Ikurun 2 months ago
Comment removed
nooneveryimportant 3 months ago
Shania doesn't look too happy...and she has good reason to be
existentialism1 6 months ago
Okay...ummm...what are the judges talking about? I have nothing against Siobhan, but this was terribly awful, as are all of the other performances I have seen of hers. And SHE was considered the shocking elimination of the season?! This proves that Season 9 sucked eggs...she has a really small voice and the only thing it seems she can do well is screech. Sorry Siobhan, but I am not a fan.
punkinnugget 8 months ago
is she giving BIRTH at 2:30? i love siobhan so much, but really... wow!
sashiANDgracie146 10 months ago
She deserved better than 6th place.
crazyasianman07 10 months ago 2
Don't really like Siobhan's singing It sounds like she is screaming most of the time
1flakky 11 months ago
i completely forgot about kara, at first i though it was shania on the panel !
weeemma92 11 months ago
Well, they had their lowest amount of views the next week, if that makes things better. I wasn't watching either lol, except for the finale
IanROX22 1 year ago
Big Mike, Casey & the youngster was horrible .
BurningPotatoe 1 year ago
siobhan is so much better than big mike, as proven in the freaking recap, he was boring
wtf america
qg6ff 1 year ago
THIS IS A SUPERB voice
XPUPA 1 year ago 3
I think American Idol shouldn't be aired anymore. Or, as another 'option', Simon and Kara should be fired, and a new judge should be on the panel. The final option is... BRING BACK SIOBHAN!!
koyamagen 1 year ago
@koyamagen well they both quit. now its jennifer lopez, some guy (whos' very famous) and randy
celebstory101 1 year ago
@celebstory101 the guy is Steven Tyler of Aerosmith
MistaRichardz 1 year ago
nice quality vid! thanks for uploading! This makes Siobahn more beautiful, visible, and quirky, =)
tobertz8 1 year ago
The judges tried as hard as possible (on and off the show) to get her away, even though she had the most talent and style. It worked. What a shame that they stole her spirit and confidence. She brought life and creativity to the show, something I don't see any other finalists doing. She should be brought back...
Simon and Kara should also be fired.
evilportrait 1 year ago
to me she resembles demi lovato.. i dont know if its her smile
26442941 1 year ago 4
This is the greatest karoke contest in history!
stableshadow 1 year ago
it just seemed a little slow and woulda been boring if it weren't siobhan singing it...glad she made it work :) so sad she's gone!! like really, how did she go before aaron?
lol ellen "way to pull the shania train into the station" ... *facepalm*
dramatizetheworld 1 year ago
2:30 was such a fail..
sickrides 1 year ago
@sickrides no, she did that on purpose...awesome!!
osahju914 1 year ago
i love how shania twain dresses...it's cool
mzyAngel01 1 year ago
she deserved to go home after all. HAHA~
anwarhanapiah 1 year ago
horrible, now she is gone. Thank goodness!
mlduree 1 year ago
just a waste of time watching american idol, it is SCRIPTED! too bad for siobhan magnus, she should have won if the voting is fair,
meowcute93 1 year ago
i don-t know how to watching this show anymore,
please don-t give up,Siobhan we love you.
cheoxi 1 year ago
I'm so pissed she got sent home. Stupid America. ._.
Vyxihd 1 year ago
lol simon it was like u were giving birth u r too funny
cpenguin29 1 year ago
My favorites are "think" and "Paint it Black"
FHOAEchos 1 year ago 9
@LVMindblown28 --alot of Siobhan haters are coming on all of her sights claiming to be fans and then condemning the heck out of her. There are quite a few of them on all of her sights.
toomuchflesh 1 year ago
Siobhan did good
alyroxx2010 1 year ago
the real test is to close your eyes and listen to the performance. would you want to hear this on the radio? the answer is NO!
VCHAGZ 1 year ago
im a big fan of siobahn, but this performance sucked ! i really dont like it at all ! sorry siobhan
n0rmax85 1 year ago
Ryan to Simon..."When were you ever at a birth?!?!" Too funny!!!
grindingear 1 year ago
I truly love her voice, performance and style!! And I really don't think it was an easy song!!!! And it hard not to sing like karaoke with this song, but she did it, as she ALWAYS do! She is smart about music!!!
mgimk 1 year ago 6
ugh... not good.
Shmee202 1 year ago