中華航空～琉球爆炸漏網照片

[winsun96]

@IamStevenHaHaHa 你真的那么想吗？ 这也太次了吧？ 没想到你会那么没脑，这架飞机不是中国的，是美国的。。。  出这样的事故，就是你们台湾人的问题，要不是就维修工差，要不是­就飞行员问题。。。总之都是你们自己的过错，还赖到国人身上来，­真没脸。。。

[j87j8787]

華航丟臉丟到國外去

[maxbiaggi7460]

無法想像整個片長3:52 在3:18才看到消防車...無法相信這是日本

就像是東北311一樣日本政府對災後的應對真是慢半拍,什麼都要­按規定...

苦的卻是災民

[abc5050956]

3:04 整個軟掉

消防車也來的太慢了吧 = =

[dkkuhy]

消防スタッフ対応遅すぎ！！今回は中国機だったからよかったけど­、もしANAやJALだったらどうしてくれるんじゃ！！

[focusing520]

沒半台消防車

[superitaikosyuu]

羽部分に燃料があって　爆発した瞬間に大きな火の玉

燃料が蒸発して引火

[CYTL1960]

Wondering if the pilots forgot to shut off the engine? When engine is shut off, oil pump will also be shut off.

[shaun91255]

@CYTL1960

The engines are off already, the fire was caused by the fuel leak.

[CYTL1960]

@shaun91255

Why are you so sure?

The "leak" is from the piping while the fuel in the piping is from the pump. If the engine is shut off, the pump will also be shut off, and there is nothing to leak for the fire.

This is based on someone's personal experience in a similar situation. One engine of his B-25 bomber was on fire because of fuel leak caused by enemy ground fire. The plane landed carrying a torch. But after the engine was shut off, the fire went out by itself.

(to be continued)

[CYTL1960]

@shaun91255

Current commercial aircraft pilots tend to act according to instructions from the tower including engine shutoff.

In this accident, I don't think the tower ever instructed the pilots to shut off the engine. In other words, I really doubt that the engine was still running and the pump was running, too, turning an incident into a disaster.

[shaun91255]

@CYTL1960

Thanks for ur comment, as I am not the flight crew, therefore my knowledge is from the final investigate report published by CAA (ROC). ps: the report can be download from the website, in both Chinese and English, I dont know if its up there still.. : ) everything u said can be possible. its difficult for us to tell just from watching this video.

[kikihnl77]

整備不良のテキトー王国　中華じゃ。なんでもテキトー。。。

[sjzhat]

着陸してからの炎上だっけ？

それとも先に管制塔に危険があることを知らせてからの着陸？

伯父が那覇空港の管制官だからどんな対応したのか聞きたい。

[grandfinish]

中国は確かにテキトーな国だが、

機体作ってんのはアメリカのボーイングだよ。

よく調べてからチャイナエアラインがどうとか言えよな。

[keikyuvvvf]

@grandfinish

「作った」のはボーイングでも「整備」をしてるのは中国だぞ？

[longhunter2]

I have no idea where was the fireman of Naha airport. they took at least more than 5 minutes to approach the air plan. Luckily, all the passengers were evacuated by emergency escape ladder. Both pilot and chief of fire dept. should be fired.

[sands2003]

@longhunter2 Based on ICAO standard, the firemen response time must not exceed 2 minutes.

[TheHackService]

不常識的一堆，

[natureship]

となりにANAが- - -

[AYATIDAISUKI]

ＡＮＡの飛行機が煙かぶって可愛そう・・・ｗ

[greenmango77]

救護車來的也太慢了吧

[JFeng299]

空气污染严重==

[love24500]

不常識的一堆，

[jr231217]

急に起きたアクシデントで、消防車到着までこれくらい時間がかか­るのは適切らしい。

消防車も大型だからそんなに速度でないだろうし・・・

[TaiwanDaniel]

但是華航有一點做很好

就是兩邊疏散的旅客非常平均

也就是說裡面的疏散動作精確



[eugene1999119]

@TaiwanDaniel 這不是華航的問題，是旅客自己想跑拿裡。而且如果安全性高一點，­根本不會有這種事發生。所以下次，搭長榮!!!!!!!!

[sands2003]

@eugene1999119 Eva is even worst!

[elt555like]

これのせいで朝煙臭かったｗｗｗ

[brentsrx7]

omg... I had never seen this before. That is exceptionally scary.... Why aren't their fire teams on sight? They should have been on the scene immediately. Is this a Chinese airport? Very dangerous and unprofessional.

[CYTL1960]

@brentsrx7 It's a Japanese airport. Can you imagine?

[anmelove]

全日空比較好

[hachimitukunni]

消防車来るのまじ遅い。カスだな。

そんでもって税金の無駄使いこんなに遅いのなんてありえない。

気持ちのねえ消防しなんんだなってこの遅さがものがたってるよね­。

たるんでる。



[poker112433]

みんな携帯でパシャパシャやってるな

[NAXPRESS]

Poor mentenance made this circumstances.

Chinese products are often break.I think it has a connection to this.

[qazwsxeedc0852]

「すごいねー」とか言ってるアホがいるよｗｗ

[GARAOKKUSU]

　消火器で消そうとしているけど、当然消えるわけがないよね。でも­それだけ気が焦っていたということだ。

[themiukou]

この間チャイナエアライン乗ったら離陸前とか着陸前に携帯いじっ­てる人だらけだった。

びくびくしながら乗ってたよ。

[tperobin]

華航的支那特技表演,解放軍怕不怕

[shaun91255]

雖然華航也負有維修上的責任與確認的義務，此次飛機幾乎為原廠全­新的情況下，華航在此次意外中算是個波音的替死鬼

[ViolaTsuchiya]

yeah i remember that day i was just arrived Beijing and everbody scream when saw the news..

[NEC33333]

人が必死で逃げてる所を携帯で写真撮ったりわらったりしてる人の­神経が知れないわ。

[arlfs]

china airlines = disaster

[nelson514072]

@arlfs  IF IT HAPPENED IT HAPPENED

[SHIZUOKA200KA2539]

整備不良

Poor maintenance

维修不善

정비 불량

[s866217]

I am from Taiwan! This is true! I never take China Airline!! Never!!

[twatlolita]

Where were the Japanese emergency firefighters ??? Were they all got asleep ??? Shame on Japan Naha Airport ! This idiot airport did nothing, just waited to see the whole plane burnt down. What a shame !!!

[LittleAngus1014]

Naha airport do not have enough training for the fire fighters because they are all rednecks in Okinawa Japan.

[0204sexcity]

我還不知道哪個機場有對於這種重大爆炸有所準備的, 這種情況真的太少見了, 機率大概一萬分之一吧, 一天幾千航班, 十年多少航班, 就華航發生這種事情, 這要怪當然是怪華航, 怎麼怪到日本機場去了? 這火災可不是兩台消防車花三十分鐘可以滅的

[shaun91255]

@0204sexcity

那麼為什麼要在機場設消防隊呢? 這不就是為了爆炸 空難意外做準備?

而乘客都已經疏散完畢 影片跑了四分鐘消防車才來 這不是訓練不足是什麼?

當初新加坡航空在當時的中正機場05L 跑道發生意外時 中正機場消防隊只用了兩分15秒就到達指定位置。

[DejayEGGo]

@shaun91255沒錯!日本消防士在做什麼?躲在待命室看­A片嗎?!況且當時是波音本身油管噴嘴設計問題...OK?!大­檢也正常..要考慮的因素太多!幹嘛~大家都那麼厲害來應徵阿!­快阿~很會說很會看...飛機都交給你們好了..全部都華航錯是­哪招?失事率高是以前老空軍的年代(越擺越老職業倦怠)現在em­d都是對外徵試的,少在那邊一竿子打翻一艘船!!!哪次檢修我不­是想著要大家坐的安全?

[DejayEGGo]

@DejayEGGo不知道看看就好~不要扯一堆有的沒的

[CYTL1960]

@DejayEGGo

1. 華航飛香港在澎湖上空解體的那架已證實是事故發生22年前一次不­當的維修所致,難道華航維修是外包出去的?

2. "老空軍的年代"其實出事較少,因為"老空軍的年代"的空勤地勤­都是在空軍有深厚經驗的,退役後才到華航.

華航從印尼回台灣在大園摔掉的那架,就是由First Officer進場落地,而他不是空軍飛行員出身,是國外的民航­飛行班畢業,經驗總是差一點.

[shaun91255]

@CYTL1960

1.澎湖空難的確是當時的華航維修不當, 但是否因為前一次的空難就來推斷這次也是華航的錯,犯了邏輯上的­錯誤...

2. 不知道你所謂的老空軍年代包不包含前幾次重大的空難? 至從大舉培訓,錄用自訓機師以來華航的空安已經大幅改善...空­軍是有經驗,但是也將大家詬病的學長學弟制帶到駕駛艙內, 為飛安重下隱憂, 如果FO 總是不執行落地, 怎麼有變成CP的一天?

[Lapiraz]

ま　た　チ　ャ　イ　ナ　エ　ア　ラ　イ　ン　か　！

[tw56p]

你去告它詐欺吧

[phs4321]

感謝華航讓台灣推向國際舞台新聞

誰叫他.打著China Airlines 名義

騙台灣人叫華航

明明就唸.中國航空.China Airlines

中華航空因該唸Chinese Airlines

[LittleAngus1014]

Come on man, should JAL also called Japanese Airlines? dont be stupid please. You are a Chinese and this will never change even after you die.

[Kichijoji69]

中華航空に乗るやつは、命知らず！

[cadstan3271]

one question:Where was the firefighter when the tower had notified that the airplane had on fire???

[songclock]

消防隊怎那麼久才出來滅火，還好裡面已經無人。

[tunkunrunk]

where was the firefighters ? they let the plane burning , imagine somebody did not manage to escape

[twflightservicemgr78]

I have to agree with you Shaun. With all those other planes at the gate, it's a miracle that the airport plus the planes didn't catch on fire. Holy Cow!

[mig36su27]

ざまぁｗｗｗｗｗ

[blackholechild]

The control tower notified the pilot immediately after the plane touched down that one of the engines was on fire. These Japanese firemen should have been waiting/ready for the plane before it get out of the runway.

[TUFFY945]

華航的出事率真的很高= =

[eugene1999119]

@TUFFY945 所以要搭長榮!!!!!!!!!

[832121K3ito]

CI always got problem..

But anyway,CI is a good airlines for me..

[shaun91255]

The firemans came really late.

almost 4 mins since the fire came out.

No metter how, China Airlines did a good job that evacuated every person on board.

[tunkunrunk]

the firemans should improve their trainning , it is abnormal that they are too slow for such a big and modern airport

[ssssoossssssss]

想早死的人可以搭華航! 恐怖喔!

[Samurai1568]

You'd think that China Airlines would learn something from that incident over Peng-hu in October 2002 when their 747-200 disintegrated in mid-air. Ha, here's the perfect proof that some people never learn. Want more? Just look at the way their PR person responded to the door coming lose incident.

[allthewaythrough]

華航已經是一個不健全的企業文化，不良的管理團隊和不負責的航空­公司的結果 。我從1998年已百分之百拒搭華航，從1998年到現在我每年­一定提醒朋友，你們再看看好了，保證你華航每幾年一定要鬧人命，­我、從來沒說錯過

[hawker445]

there goes thier baggage