Martin and Rose - Broken

[Xij29y6]

Zomg, why is this not on my favourites list? *adds*

[Shardspirit]

Well if you're trying to make me cry, then you're doing a good job with this video! It's a shame that Rose had to die. Really good video! ;)

[EowynEnna]

this is so sad

rose don't die!

don't worry martin, someday you will be one of the greatest warriors that ever lived

i'm sure he's be even better with rose at his side

[AquaberryxWildnose]

I still cry everytime I think of when Rose died, the show got me into the series.

Poor Martin, we all feel your pain. (cries)

[jrrtolkia]

sad! *sniff* . I love your Redwall vids!

DEATH 2 BADRANG!!!!

[Xij29y6]

You have that magic touch to your AMVs I've seen in so few others (e.g. Hethrin, eyebal) and I for one just can't find in myself

[Scumtripe]

Martin The Warrior is my favorite book and when I think of Martin and rose's

relationship I can't control myself from crying. And im a guy. Its just too sad for me.

[theboywonder2010]

i agree its one of m favs too and even though i haven't read the book in years i always wished that they didn't kill off rose in the end

[Scumtripe]

Well it's sad i know. But hey, just think if rose lived, Martin would have lived wih her in noonvale and never gone south to mossflower. If he did not go south, Tsarmia the wildcat would have ruled mossflower and there would have been =

NO REDWALL ABBEY IF ROSE LIVED

[SunflashTheMace676]

That's nice (seriously). I mean, it would be better if Rose didn't die, but that is what makes the book so touchingly sad and wonderful.

[StefaentheWarrior09]

It is so sad that Rose had to die, but of course, if she hadn't, the whole series would be different, and would probably not be as good. Great vid, by the way.

[MaryMurr]

Thank you =)

[Mouseshadow15]

@StefaentheWarrior09 In a way I wish what had happened was that Boggs (the fat weseal i think thats what he is lived) came back with an army and tried to destroy Noonvale there were survivors including Rose, Martin, Rose's brother, the badger, the rabbit, and others. They left and came to Mossflower and helped those creatures to destroy that evil cat and build redwall that might have been a happier ending

[drunkambrose]

It's been four years since i read martin the warrior, and when someone mentions her i still tear up, and im a guy. sad, huh?

[TheNewChaos25]

Okay first of all... Awsome job!!! I've been a Redwall Fan for 6 years now and The death of Rose is to me the most tragic death in the series. The video was pretty well put together and the song is exelent overall a perfect 5/5

[Laterosemary]

супер!мне очень понравилось))

[MaryMurr]

Tnx))

[XxXBlackXxXWatersXxX]

so sad...i can't believe he killed her off in the book though!!

[Patzilla777]

I hate Badrang, he destroyed a beautiful relationship

[wildstar5359]

were do you get the clips at?

[MaryMurr]

rip them from DVD

[ducky418]

aww redwall can be so sad at times! but I ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ it!!

[wildstar5359]

do you read the books?

[ducky418]

yeah. I've read 13 of them so far.

[jrrtolkia]

I read all 21 books 3 times.

Too much time on my hands?

[ducky418]

@jrrtolkia maybe heh. but oh my I havent been reading redwall for months and I'm in the middle of two of them. not enough time on my hands? ;)

[Gerbilkit]

@jrrtolkia only 3 times?

[Songbreeze123]

great job! i love this song now

[Jublenarris]

Made me want to cry. So beautiful, I agree. Rose & Martin made a perfect pair, I think. *nods*

=) Nice job

[Atherist]

Very good. I love this video. <3 You did a very good job making it sad. I thought Martin and Rose made a good couple.