I found this movie on youtube with subtitle but I can't remember how could I found it ?? anyway I though this movie is a good movie,,,,History was written by the victor's view,,,,so I want to see from the defeater's view
Every german must be proud of his past!!! You fight for your country and you were the most powerfull nation in the earth...Germans be proud of your history especially in the francogerman wars ,ww1 and ww2!!!! Be proud becouse of (Bizmark,Rommel and many more)..
Like how at 2:40 you see people walking back in forth, And you have German soldiers standing up right by that window and walking straight away from the window.
And the scene where the Unteroffizier reads his letter from home...his women has left him for a French Prisoner of War. Ha ha ha ha.....all this soldier would have to do was write or tell the authorities about this and she would have been arrested. This movie is a total joke.
My dad fought in WWII as a combat vet. He did not speak badly of the German soldiers. He said most of them were drafted just like him.....as fodder to have their asses, balls and lives thrown away for someone making profits and desiring medals at the expensive of the average guy. During the next war, all soldiers should turn on their masters and blow their brains and balls off! Start from the top and work down with the leadership.
@feroz0307 Its meant to show that the fighting in Stalingrad was very close quarters and had no defined front line. Sometimes no mans land was a wall or the next building over.Gains and losses there were defined in meters, not kilometers. Vasily Chuikov instructed his soldiers to get as close to the Germans as possible, to negate the Wehrmachts air and artillery support.
Perhaps if they were disciplined and professional enough they would have the sense never to march into Russia and try to achieve a totally unattainable objective.
The soldiers did not decide to attack Russia or any other country, Hitler decided that even against the advice of the High Ranking officers of the OKH and OKW. Hitler (the one who decided to attack Russia) was an idiot, but you've got to admit that the Wehrmacht was a very skillful and professional army that was a head of it's time and had officers with excellent grasps on strategy and warfare.
indeed but mother russia still prevailed however hitler proved that he was a terrible leader and basically neutralized any advantages the whermact had by making them go fight in a city house to house man to man they were not ready for that at all they were unstoppable out in the country side because thats where bliztkrieg could be used but in a place like stalingrad they were sitting ducks and hitler basically killed his entire elite army the whermact in a single battle a shame
Airbornerock , the Nazi's hated "slavs", not evey single German did however. The Nazi's wanted to kill all Eastern people and the majority of the war crimes commited were by either Einsatzgruppen's or the Waffen SS. The Einsatzgruppen were essentially 'field SS' that carried out the mass killing of people deemed 'untermenchen'. Roughly 15% of Wehrmacht commited war crimes and about 65% off the Waffen SS (I think this is from memory of a book I read, I could be wrong about the percentage).
I'm not on here to bash the German people. As an American i was fed a steady diet of Bush hatred from other Americans on the tv and with just about everybody i talked to on the street. You wouldn't get away with that kind of talk in nazi germany. The majority of Americans didn't even vote for Bush in the 2000 election yet he became president. So. the american system is fucked up. But at least you dont get taken away by Nazi thugs for speaking your opinion.
Well, maybe she knew he wasn't coming back. Only 5,000 of the 150,000 Germans in the 6th Army ever saw Germany again. But at this point in the movie no one knew. It must have sucked to get news like that.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Bush got rid of Saddam Hussein. Saddam Hussein was just as evil as Hitler in my opinion. the germans blindly followed hilter a man who would kill his opposition. americans made fun of george bush the whole time he was in office. you dont know what you're talking about. germans followed hitler...and if you think bush invading iraq and throwing saddam out of power is comparable to following the Nazis then you're an idiot.
Germans made fun of Hitler as well. The Yanks and the Nazis are an apt comparison. Both went to war on the back of lies, both followed those lies blindly even when there was enough evidence to rubbish their propaganda. As for Saddam being as bad as Hitler.. if you believe that then you are the idiot. Let's remember, it was the US that put Saddam in power.
saddam hussein was just as evil as hitler to me yes. he just didn't have the same amount of power. the americans did not put saddam in power. the americans gave him money to fight against the iranians who had taken american hostages and were backed by communist money. you also forgot to mention the fact that the americans and their allies invaded iraq and took saddam out of power. america and its allies also kicked the iraqis out of kuwait too.
Saddam was a Freemason a feellow member of the secret brother hood in UK, America and most of the western Europe
its is becoming clear to those with the courage to see that our planet is controlled by a few secret societies determined to establish a new world order add the cost of exterminating your family to achieve this
Bro if you are an ounce intelligent then you would know Evil and Good dont exist. There is always a grey line. Hitler wasnt evil...Everyone of those dictator was led by either insanity or rationality.
In Hitler's case I dont see what differentiates him from Napoleon.
Napoleon exterminated enemies, opened camps, executed summarily etc.
And during the middle ages and before in Europe everybody was a little Hitler.
So dont judge Its just the nature of man Some let it out like Hitler some dont
I like your views but there should always be people who keep the megalomaniacs and the sadist killers in check, the masses, the population of a country should do that in case of a leader of state but they are just to occupied for that. Ppl think only about their own family, or about being the perfect consumer slave.
Evil and Good don't exist you say??? That is precisely the belief system that led to Hitlers rise to power in the first place. Evil triumphs only when good men stand by and do nothing....
Of course Manstein, a far more capable officer and Paulus' superior as commander at the time of Army Group South, is also responsible: he could have himself ordered a break out or surrender but didn't. The Prussian nobility set up her own downfall bound as it were by oaths and tradition. The perfect military tool placed in the hands of a madman led to to its own demise.
ellin40... have you read the book "The Last 100 Days" by John Toland??? A must read and the most factual book i've read on WW2. It tells of Paulus and other commanders like Kesselring, Donitz et al, and their relationships with Hitler. It tells of why many fell out of favor and were replaced. But the book is mainly about the German retreat back to Berlin and the final surrender.
I have to look up my history again but I think Paulus replaced another commander who had fallen out of favor--von Bock? List? I'm not sure. Up to that point he had had a colorless career as staff officer. He was selected for command of the 6th Army based on his OBEDIENT NATURE, not for any particular command talent.
Yet, and after having been the main protagonist in the unnecessary deaths of thousands of his men due to privation, Paulus did not have any qualms about willingly joining Stalin's traveling troupe of oh-look-at-how-happy-I-am-now-with-papa-Stalin ex-Wehramcht personnel and be awarded the highest hospitality in S. Union.
To compound the Stalingrad disaster, the Germans started 1943 with Kursk during the battle of which they lost most of their armour, never to be replaced again. After Stalingrad and Kursk, it was all done and said on the Ostfront.
On the other hand, Stalin did not permit the evacuation of Russian civilians from Stalingrad but they did not provision them either thus securing extreme hardship for over 1.5 million civilians.
And the northern and southern flanks were guarded by undermanned and under-equipped Hungarian and Romanian units that simply disintegrated under the armored punch of "Uranus" allowing the encirclement to happen. Hitler never cared for his soldiers, Paulus was a "yes-man" egged on by that slimy worm, Schmidt.
Not quite. Hitler promoted Paulus to field marshall knowing that no Prussian field marshall had ever surrendered to anyone. He did this in the hope Paulus would fight to the last man and then take his own life in Stalingrad. It didnt work. Paulus disobeyed. You are right Hitler did not care about any other human being. He only saw strong and weak irrespective of nationality. His final words were that the Germans did not deserve victory against the stronger race from the east.
Well, yes, Hitler was a master manipulator but this also entails a willingness to let become manipulated on behalf of the interlocutor. It was, no doubt, a complicated relationship. But do not kid yourself: Paulus did not disobey willingly, he was forced by circumstance. At that point the fate of his army had been sealed with about 1,000 German personnel dying every minute in the last three weeks of the affair, most of them due to lack of medical care and hygiene.
Quite right what you say about Paulus. But Hitler´s last words were more like "If the German folk is not able to beat the drossy eastern folks they only deserve to die......they wanted it like that"
Messiah Complex 'I came to save these people, to lead them to a promised land, but they betrayed their great leader, so deserve whatever fate befalls them because of their treachery' - that sort of nonsense
In 1942, throwing the whole of 6th Army (close to 200,000) out there by themselves was just crazy. They really didn;t think the Russians were good for anything militarily but at the same time they had NO IDEA of the immense manpower gathering in safety at the Urals.
Well, they also messed up operationally, lost the industrial competition to the US, and had a racist ideology that alienated most civilian populations that could have been their allies against Stalin.
Notice the lack of winter equipment. And this is the German Army's SECOND winter in Russia. Yet nothing still although it must now be (in this part of the movie) October.
it´s only a film but so it was really in the war.I´m a german child and my grandmother´s brothers were at the war an they told that was the hell on earth!!!
weiß nich mit dem scharfschützen, besonders weil die stimmung da in den laden nich kaputt ging weil einer erschossen wurd, ich denk da fehlt was und der scharfschütze hat nochma umgeschwenkt
Filmfehler bei 5:08 ^^ man durfte keine Sachen mit Mohnkochen (wurde extrem hart bestraft -> Konzentrationslager.....) wurde verboten weil man daraus Morphium für die Soldaten hergestellt hat...
der hält seinen arsch hin und die alte geht zu hause fremd. da will man nach hause und diesem franzosen und de ralten den hals umdehen und kann nicht 8/
Soldiers fight for what they believe in, they fight for their country. I served in Afghanistan because I was ordered to, from 05-06. Because my president is a republican, am I one as well? Remember that not all Germans are Nazis and not all Amis are demos or repubs, nor all Russians Communists. My grandfather and great grandfather both served 'in Namen den Fuhrer und Vaterland.' Both died.
i have no idea what they are saying by i still watch cause its a good film! :)
pranker121 3 months ago
I do not expect a better HD I just need subtitle
I found this movie on youtube with subtitle but I can't remember how could I found it ?? anyway I though this movie is a good movie,,,,History was written by the victor's view,,,,so I want to see from the defeater's view
MickeyMH1 3 months ago
Are they being served mushroom soup ?
biggrigga 4 months ago
Ich mag den Schwaben :D
MrFendtvario900 5 months ago
Subtitles in Chinese, Spanish and English please !
0puest0 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Every german must be proud of his past!!! You fight for your country and you were the most powerfull nation in the earth...Germans be proud of your history especially in the francogerman wars ,ww1 and ww2!!!! Be proud becouse of (Bizmark,Rommel and many more)..
amirturist 6 months ago
Like how at 2:40 you see people walking back in forth, And you have German soldiers standing up right by that window and walking straight away from the window.
heino320 7 months ago
1:01 its vassily ziatsev LOL
frizey75 8 months ago
And the scene where the Unteroffizier reads his letter from home...his women has left him for a French Prisoner of War. Ha ha ha ha.....all this soldier would have to do was write or tell the authorities about this and she would have been arrested. This movie is a total joke.
rmcnnlly 10 months ago
My dad fought in WWII as a combat vet. He did not speak badly of the German soldiers. He said most of them were drafted just like him.....as fodder to have their asses, balls and lives thrown away for someone making profits and desiring medals at the expensive of the average guy. During the next war, all soldiers should turn on their masters and blow their brains and balls off! Start from the top and work down with the leadership.
rmcnnlly 10 months ago
wiso ist den dein kanal gesperrt ?
BingoBongo1995 10 months ago
dose this movie comewith sub titles because not knowing whats going on is a bitch.
warhearts92 10 months ago
Damn it now she writes me again she had a boy.
I wanna know if the cow did have a calf.
Well she allways was a bit soft in the head, but she's sweet though.
O if I would only know about the cow.
Damn it some POW's stole all the eggs from the henhouse.
They should hang em all
helmuthoorn 1 year ago
I LOVE GERMANY !!!!!!!!!!!!
jonasBMG 1 year ago
kakalin kakaling kakalin i love the iwan or in english the russia
mrtimo1199 1 year ago
part 4 deleted . . . why ? mmmh
flieger315 1 year ago
i cant believe how bad looking this war was
that sucked ass so bad
puerkola 1 year ago
Go To My Channel , The Entire Movie Is Re-Uploaded In Beter Quality!
EdgarEmigholz 1 year ago
part 4 of the movie is deleted by youtube....
AtomWofW 1 year ago
@AtomWofW go to my account , the entire movie is re-uploaded with better quality and in full lenght
EdgarEmigholz 1 year ago
@EdgarEmigholz should youtube delete your videos again, would you please upload them with English subtitles ? :)
biggrigga 4 months ago
Partz2000 -
"How name song russian in minute 4.28??"
This Song Is Called "Темная Ночь"(Dark night)
IIKainII1 1 year ago
poor guy's just a kid. horrible. . . as all wars are. . . only America dares glorify the horrible. . .
FilipinoZeroFighter 1 year ago
THIS MOVIE IS AWESOME!
The Drama, the action, the horror!
Sereniama 1 year ago
only a real asshole dumb fucken cunt would compare bush to nazi mass murderers.
meishern 1 year ago
how name song russian in minute 4.28??
como se llama la musica rusa en el munuto 4:28?
Partz2000 1 year ago
how name song russian in minute 4.28??
como se llama la musica rusa en el munuto 4:28?
Partz2000 1 year ago
so this is where medal of honor allied assault got there stalingrad online MP map....cool =)
Holyhitman173 1 year ago
@Holyhitman173 not so cool in real life
capenati 1 year ago
Argh, Teil 4 wurde von YT gelöscht GRRR
EvilBlitzkriegNICK66 1 year ago
Laggfest Why Is This Video Slow =[ o well there wasnt any shooting or action so no real prob
5NailsToTheNeck 1 year ago
im going to upload the complete movie again soon!
EdgarEmigholz 1 year ago
Ein Krieg in den nur die Kämpfen die in angefangen haben, dass währe doch mal was.
MsMatze83 1 year ago
Did he get the 'Dear John' letter?
the82spartans 1 year ago
yeah, his wife ran off with a frenchman.
erloriel 1 year ago
Damn.
To think of Vichy France and then switch backwardly to the new Western Front after D-day...
Strange War.
RIP all warriors.
the82spartans 1 year ago
gutes film
eigentlich wann ist dass ganze geschehen ?? das Stalingrad nd soo
mematti42 2 years ago
1942-1943 im Zweiten Weltkrieg ^^
dc8poker 2 years ago
Stalingrad war 1942-1943, so ziemlich die Wendezeit im Krieg.
erloriel 1 year ago
was willschtn? die singe doch scheen!
toller film
1993heavenshallburn 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why cut in pieces ? wanted to see the hole movie
stupid idiot
KillaChillaZylos 2 years ago
then just buy it idiot, poor idiot thinking every movie is to be found on youtube
EdgarEmigholz 2 years ago
if u watch the hole movie together and then u post it on youtube its gonna take to long to load the hole thing on
julili5454 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
let's kill some commie scum!
UFCMania98 2 years ago
I bet you will not say that in front of your WW2 veterans
9K58 2 years ago 2
I LOVE THIS FILM
ICH LIEBE DIESEN FILM
2TapeKilla 2 years ago 16
the part with the sniper was cool
outskool100 2 years ago 3
The ecoed singing is moving and chilling all at the same time
toby4700 2 years ago
a very good war anti war movie!
MeisterSchnitter 2 years ago
Were those people peeking from the windows at 2:22 supposed to happen? They dont look like soldiers...
feroz0307 2 years ago 11
@feroz0307 .
yeah, is sad but maybe is watching the food, please read history books, in the hearth of soldiers russians is not Stalin.
0puest0 6 months ago
@feroz0307 Its meant to show that the fighting in Stalingrad was very close quarters and had no defined front line. Sometimes no mans land was a wall or the next building over.Gains and losses there were defined in meters, not kilometers. Vasily Chuikov instructed his soldiers to get as close to the Germans as possible, to negate the Wehrmachts air and artillery support.
nagglfar 2 months ago
again subtitles would be nice
THEDUCKMAN52 2 years ago
LOL @ 2:22 look at the window :D:D
ThrakYr09 2 years ago
laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaags
Martin1983CSS 2 years ago
2:22 can you see people at other side of the windows lol
BAYGAN12 2 years ago 2
Fucking Adolf Hilter Burn in hell
GUITARKID101x 2 years ago
Anyone know what song the russians were singing
toby4700 2 years ago
Comment removed
buenissen 2 years ago
SONG - Тёмная ночь [Tyomnaja Notch] - dark night (it is dark outside)
rusmatube 2 years ago 6
Thank you
toby4700 2 years ago 2
Thank you man, i been looking for the name of the song
fuel223 2 years ago 3
auf myvideo sind die anderen teile online ;)
xoggyX1 2 years ago
This movie is a poor representation of what actually happened. They did not show that mother and child being gunned down when crossing the street.
architectdesigner11 2 years ago
architectdesigner11 there is 2 things about the woman and child
1: Not all Wehrmacht would kill Russians straight away (otherwise that kid would be dead).
2: Even if they did want to kill them, the Wehrmacht soldier was smart and disciplined enough to not fire so he wouldn't give away his position.
Dauserofdasite 2 years ago
Perhaps if they were disciplined and professional enough they would have the sense never to march into Russia and try to achieve a totally unattainable objective.
architectdesigner11 2 years ago
The soldiers did not decide to attack Russia or any other country, Hitler decided that even against the advice of the High Ranking officers of the OKH and OKW. Hitler (the one who decided to attack Russia) was an idiot, but you've got to admit that the Wehrmacht was a very skillful and professional army that was a head of it's time and had officers with excellent grasps on strategy and warfare.
Dauserofdasite 2 years ago 6
indeed but mother russia still prevailed however hitler proved that he was a terrible leader and basically neutralized any advantages the whermact had by making them go fight in a city house to house man to man they were not ready for that at all they were unstoppable out in the country side because thats where bliztkrieg could be used but in a place like stalingrad they were sitting ducks and hitler basically killed his entire elite army the whermact in a single battle a shame
WrestleFan1993 2 years ago 2
that is true the wehrmacht were their to fight not kill innocent.the shutzsraffel did that.
TheRangersleadtheway 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yes they were. The German bible hated Russian "Slavs". All Germans wanted to kill, do you not do your research before talking?
Airbornerock 2 years ago
Airbornerock , the Nazi's hated "slavs", not evey single German did however. The Nazi's wanted to kill all Eastern people and the majority of the war crimes commited were by either Einsatzgruppen's or the Waffen SS. The Einsatzgruppen were essentially 'field SS' that carried out the mass killing of people deemed 'untermenchen'. Roughly 15% of Wehrmacht commited war crimes and about 65% off the Waffen SS (I think this is from memory of a book I read, I could be wrong about the percentage).
Dauserofdasite 2 years ago
kanal ist geschlossen und teil 4 und 7 fehlen gänzlich
Stechor 2 years ago
Wo finde ich Teil 4?!
Verhoeven1980 2 years ago
jop frag ich mich auch aber ich kann seinen kanal auch nich töffnen
bimbolino14 2 years ago
muss mir DVD kaufen!
misterviolator 2 years ago
actually, saddam was a puppet on a string......
MrTriggr 2 years ago
naya
Lukastaker123 2 years ago
When was this made?
insanekillamonster1 2 years ago
I saw theis in Austria when came out around 1992-1993
Vulpecula101 2 years ago
1993
BlitzKreigFilms 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stalingrad muss wohl die Hölle gewesen sein und ein Massengrab für deutsche Soldaten.
Ruhet in Frieden !
tuerkischeRassisten 2 years ago 4
4:40 Whats the name of this song ? Wie heisst diese Melodie ? Kako se zove ta pjesma?
RakoRakan 2 years ago
Dieses Lied heißt die "Dunkle Nacht" Темная ночь(Russian) watch?v=9dkAEHgmtWM
vukru45 2 years ago
Ich danke Dir vielmals....mnogo hvala(jugo)
RakoRakan 2 years ago
Тихая ночь.
hhhhhhhuuuummmmeer 2 years ago
Comment removed
diramonsky 2 years ago
The american self rightiousness makes me sick though...Like they think they are better then everybody else
XTREMNIK 2 years ago
You mean fatter then everybody else....
diramonsky 2 years ago
Better like what?
DEADin10 2 years ago
its a stereotype. as anything else is. I live here and I'm sick of it too.
LowBasslin3 2 years ago
ah , but in America you CAN get hauled off by police for speaking your opinion
DrDieterVon 2 years ago 2
yes it's dumb, but, although opinions are good, it's important to be careful not to take the plunge into reletavism
Milhouse224 2 years ago
when?
Patty1917 2 years ago
I'm not on here to bash the German people. As an American i was fed a steady diet of Bush hatred from other Americans on the tv and with just about everybody i talked to on the street. You wouldn't get away with that kind of talk in nazi germany. The majority of Americans didn't even vote for Bush in the 2000 election yet he became president. So. the american system is fucked up. But at least you dont get taken away by Nazi thugs for speaking your opinion.
dong604 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WitzOfTheReich is a child-molesting cannibal and shit-eater
RammjaegerJesus 2 years ago
true
CDUVerbieten 2 years ago
Well, maybe she knew he wasn't coming back. Only 5,000 of the 150,000 Germans in the 6th Army ever saw Germany again. But at this point in the movie no one knew. It must have sucked to get news like that.
ellin40 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
250,000 were real number.
BlitzoftheReich 2 years ago
BlitzoftheReich: 250,000 was the total for the 6th Army but it included Italians and Roumanians as well. The Germans were 150-180,000.
ellin40 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh then that case you are indeed right my friend :) i thought you meant the total number.
BlitzoftheReich 2 years ago
I think the number with Romanians, Italians was nearer 300,000
Lyndon1947 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
his wife cheat him with a french prisoner
he is not amused about it
maltroc 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anyone know the translation of what is the matter with that German who is shouting at the end?
SakuChanofthesand 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2009 and I'm watching a film in far worse quality than a 20 year old VHS
Woopee 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The video quality HERE in Youtube is low but the actual movie is great!
nyipnyop 2 years ago
woodman 19 you are damn right
UlyssesMcFuck 2 years ago
Hollywood is at variance with doc. film of German soldiers - betterlooking and fitter than these.
AAWXXDD 2 years ago
all those americans in here who criticize germans are hypocrites!
why didnt you openly disobey Bush when he was invading nations? Answer: because your sheep following the herd, like Germans were
cant change human nature, 95% of people do what they are told by authority.
woodman19 2 years ago 21
nice analogy {Thumbs Up}
dday1304 2 years ago 4
thank you, even im impressed when I look back and read it :)
woodman19 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
didn't we throw out Bush and his party?
mkreisel 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nope, you voted for him twice.
you no doube would of voted for him a 3rd time had your constitution allowed it
woodman19 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
disobey bush?
here in America its ok not to obey Bush. Lots of peole did disobey. And the ones who didnt where at to kill so Tallheads
HolstadMX 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well spoken mate!
SakuChanofthesand 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bush got rid of Saddam Hussein. Saddam Hussein was just as evil as Hitler in my opinion. the germans blindly followed hilter a man who would kill his opposition. americans made fun of george bush the whole time he was in office. you dont know what you're talking about. germans followed hitler...and if you think bush invading iraq and throwing saddam out of power is comparable to following the Nazis then you're an idiot.
dong604 2 years ago
Germans made fun of Hitler as well. The Yanks and the Nazis are an apt comparison. Both went to war on the back of lies, both followed those lies blindly even when there was enough evidence to rubbish their propaganda. As for Saddam being as bad as Hitler.. if you believe that then you are the idiot. Let's remember, it was the US that put Saddam in power.
Gaudd 2 years ago
saddam hussein was just as evil as hitler to me yes. he just didn't have the same amount of power. the americans did not put saddam in power. the americans gave him money to fight against the iranians who had taken american hostages and were backed by communist money. you also forgot to mention the fact that the americans and their allies invaded iraq and took saddam out of power. america and its allies also kicked the iraqis out of kuwait too.
dong604 2 years ago
No, Saddam was a puppet Government for USA
asingus 2 years ago
Saddam was a Freemason a feellow member of the secret brother hood in UK, America and most of the western Europe
its is becoming clear to those with the courage to see that our planet is controlled by a few secret societies determined to establish a new world order add the cost of exterminating your family to achieve this
godscuttingyoudown 2 years ago
and theres nothing you can do about it!!! muahahahahaha!
BlitzKreigFilms 2 years ago
Bro if you are an ounce intelligent then you would know Evil and Good dont exist. There is always a grey line. Hitler wasnt evil...Everyone of those dictator was led by either insanity or rationality.
In Hitler's case I dont see what differentiates him from Napoleon.
Napoleon exterminated enemies, opened camps, executed summarily etc.
And during the middle ages and before in Europe everybody was a little Hitler.
So dont judge Its just the nature of man Some let it out like Hitler some dont
XTREMNIK 2 years ago
I like your views but there should always be people who keep the megalomaniacs and the sadist killers in check, the masses, the population of a country should do that in case of a leader of state but they are just to occupied for that. Ppl think only about their own family, or about being the perfect consumer slave.
diramonsky 2 years ago
Evil and Good don't exist you say??? That is precisely the belief system that led to Hitlers rise to power in the first place. Evil triumphs only when good men stand by and do nothing....
xXU2BerXx 2 years ago
at 1:36 those are U.S. cans lol
dock534 2 years ago
Of course Manstein, a far more capable officer and Paulus' superior as commander at the time of Army Group South, is also responsible: he could have himself ordered a break out or surrender but didn't. The Prussian nobility set up her own downfall bound as it were by oaths and tradition. The perfect military tool placed in the hands of a madman led to to its own demise.
ellin40 3 years ago
ellin40... have you read the book "The Last 100 Days" by John Toland??? A must read and the most factual book i've read on WW2. It tells of Paulus and other commanders like Kesselring, Donitz et al, and their relationships with Hitler. It tells of why many fell out of favor and were replaced. But the book is mainly about the German retreat back to Berlin and the final surrender.
insut07 3 years ago
I have to look up my history again but I think Paulus replaced another commander who had fallen out of favor--von Bock? List? I'm not sure. Up to that point he had had a colorless career as staff officer. He was selected for command of the 6th Army based on his OBEDIENT NATURE, not for any particular command talent.
ellin40 3 years ago
Yet, and after having been the main protagonist in the unnecessary deaths of thousands of his men due to privation, Paulus did not have any qualms about willingly joining Stalin's traveling troupe of oh-look-at-how-happy-I-am-now-with-papa-Stalin ex-Wehramcht personnel and be awarded the highest hospitality in S. Union.
ellin40 3 years ago
To compound the Stalingrad disaster, the Germans started 1943 with Kursk during the battle of which they lost most of their armour, never to be replaced again. After Stalingrad and Kursk, it was all done and said on the Ostfront.
ellin40 3 years ago
On the other hand, Stalin did not permit the evacuation of Russian civilians from Stalingrad but they did not provision them either thus securing extreme hardship for over 1.5 million civilians.
ellin40 3 years ago
And the northern and southern flanks were guarded by undermanned and under-equipped Hungarian and Romanian units that simply disintegrated under the armored punch of "Uranus" allowing the encirclement to happen. Hitler never cared for his soldiers, Paulus was a "yes-man" egged on by that slimy worm, Schmidt.
ellin40 3 years ago
Not quite. Hitler promoted Paulus to field marshall knowing that no Prussian field marshall had ever surrendered to anyone. He did this in the hope Paulus would fight to the last man and then take his own life in Stalingrad. It didnt work. Paulus disobeyed. You are right Hitler did not care about any other human being. He only saw strong and weak irrespective of nationality. His final words were that the Germans did not deserve victory against the stronger race from the east.
archeronfoot 3 years ago
Well, yes, Hitler was a master manipulator but this also entails a willingness to let become manipulated on behalf of the interlocutor. It was, no doubt, a complicated relationship. But do not kid yourself: Paulus did not disobey willingly, he was forced by circumstance. At that point the fate of his army had been sealed with about 1,000 German personnel dying every minute in the last three weeks of the affair, most of them due to lack of medical care and hygiene.
ellin40 3 years ago
Quite right what you say about Paulus. But Hitler´s last words were more like "If the German folk is not able to beat the drossy eastern folks they only deserve to die......they wanted it like that"
machierl 3 years ago
Messiah Complex 'I came to save these people, to lead them to a promised land, but they betrayed their great leader, so deserve whatever fate befalls them because of their treachery' - that sort of nonsense
anthonythirteen 2 years ago
In 1942, throwing the whole of 6th Army (close to 200,000) out there by themselves was just crazy. They really didn;t think the Russians were good for anything militarily but at the same time they had NO IDEA of the immense manpower gathering in safety at the Urals.
ellin40 3 years ago
Well, they also messed up operationally, lost the industrial competition to the US, and had a racist ideology that alienated most civilian populations that could have been their allies against Stalin.
ellin40 3 years ago
Notice the lack of winter equipment. And this is the German Army's SECOND winter in Russia. Yet nothing still although it must now be (in this part of the movie) October.
ellin40 3 years ago
guess that's why they lost then.
just2w4tch 3 years ago
whats the name of the song at 4:38???
Bloodwyn1991 3 years ago
Are there a stalingrad with subtiles on youtube?
Nefus2 3 years ago
geiler film!
thetekker 3 years ago 3
good film I feel sorry i sold this for £2 at a car boot sale, I should have kept it.
zaohad1 3 years ago
it´s only a film but so it was really in the war.I´m a german child and my grandmother´s brothers were at the war an they told that was the hell on earth!!!
Gazastreifenmann 3 years ago
i need to see this movie
johnnnyyBoy9369 3 years ago
war is hell..its just so dam easy in games to kill people and do other horrible things.
Upseeri10 3 years ago 6
I hate wars
juanleon213 3 years ago 11
me too
hdydrheyj 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I dont now why but was shit^^
Ivane76 3 years ago
one of the best films ever made, "thin red line stands" by to that film
omnigenicus 3 years ago 2
War is hell
piipaapuu 3 years ago 18
der schwäble ist der hamma
182port 3 years ago 5
weiß nich mit dem scharfschützen, besonders weil die stimmung da in den laden nich kaputt ging weil einer erschossen wurd, ich denk da fehlt was und der scharfschütze hat nochma umgeschwenkt
Chrisiiiix3 3 years ago
I speak german! Don't know what they've said just ask me!
Lilpaydofo187 3 years ago
Filmfehler bei 5:08 ^^ man durfte keine Sachen mit Mohnkochen (wurde extrem hart bestraft -> Konzentrationslager.....) wurde verboten weil man daraus Morphium für die Soldaten hergestellt hat...
Imperrator 3 years ago 2
ich glaube es ist einfach keinem aufgefallen dass er ihn abgeknallt hat.
000000AEA000000 3 years ago
achso
Gnomiron 3 years ago
das versteh ich auch überhaupt nicht.
Gnomiron 3 years ago
Filmschnitt?
SirMarshalHaig 3 years ago
hey silly question for anyone who might know what is that they're eating?
Vicksburg63 3 years ago
looks like oatmeal and their standard bread ration
basedeal 3 years ago
they call it horse shit
eisenkreuzmusik 3 years ago
its always soup. normally they put vegetables in it, meat is seldom.
doofinovi 3 years ago
der hält seinen arsch hin und die alte geht zu hause fremd. da will man nach hause und diesem franzosen und de ralten den hals umdehen und kann nicht 8/
TAURUSger 3 years ago
a russian concentration camp, well i think so.
DerBesteJohnny 3 years ago
my mums uncle was at stalingrad, he was 15 years old!
DerBesteJohnny 3 years ago
Did he survive the war? Did he spend time in the gulags?
Saracenkiller 3 years ago
yes, he survived, but the he was in siberia as a prisoner of war for the next 10 years!
im sorry i have no idea wht a gulag is...
DerBesteJohnny 3 years ago
A gulag is a special soviet style prisoner work camp.That's the simplest explanation.
Saracenkiller 3 years ago
they were smoking to "cool" down
DerBesteJohnny 3 years ago
It is very strange that many soldiers were smoking altough it is bad for health.
Omaja555 3 years ago
Yeah, like being in Stalingrad was GOOD for their health?
coalbanks 3 years ago 2
calms you down
eisenkreuzmusik 3 years ago
darf ich mal fragen warum ihr alle englisch schreibt?
KingMajet 3 years ago
weil das eine internationale videoplattform ist^^
GERMANIVS 3 years ago 3
I will never believe that germans whould not kill russian kid and that they will bve so kind to him! bullshit!
P.S> kid speak terribly russian!
skyraptor 3 years ago
why?
Vinzbert 3 years ago 4
Soldiers fight for what they believe in, they fight for their country. I served in Afghanistan because I was ordered to, from 05-06. Because my president is a republican, am I one as well? Remember that not all Germans are Nazis and not all Amis are demos or repubs, nor all Russians Communists. My grandfather and great grandfather both served 'in Namen den Fuhrer und Vaterland.' Both died.
qlancer 3 years ago 7
ow sure the germans are all evil soldiers with no heart...
thats why 1 gets angry couse his wife is sleeping with a french P.O.W -.-'
alexhaas 3 years ago