Though its a little messy at parts but cant blame them as they are still young and that is their greatest asset, the ability to improve. I'm sure they are so much better now.
@darkwen028 other secondary schools can play quite good too, though they are the same age as them...it's just a matter or practising til perfection...
This song is relatively easy. And definitely fun. This CO got way too many people, and i don't think two PaiGus are needed. Plus the snare lagged at the first 24 bars
though its fast and the number of members is huge , but the rythem for this song are all out of place . can be improve . this is my school SYF song for last year which gets only a bronze because it's messy too but i'm sure that my chinese orchestra members of last year did their very best .
well, i didnt get into NAS, but i was in NAPCO, in erhu section, seating 2nd row extreme right, anyone remembers Edmund? lol Conductor Goh i missed him man
damn i was trying to find anyone for NAPCO, i missed those days, was erhu and was seating 2nd row extreme right nearest to audience, anyone remembers Edmund?
yea, i agree to lsg5200..pan yao tian's songs arent easy to play the year 2009 chinese orchestra SYF songs is written by him..and its extremely difficult..
basically, the whole orchestra is quite big. nice sound effects, but i think that the conductor's going too fast, and doesn't bring out the exact feel.
i think the result of rushing is that they never look at the conductor,keep looking at the score sheets and never count. maybe they should memorize the score sheets so they can look at the conductor and not keep rushing..
hmm.......... but i think overall effect quite good liao ler the tan bo yue can louder a bit and the suona rocks!!!!! dun even have that kind of suona standard in my school lol...
cant believe there's so many ppl. which year one? im in nasco. nasco=ngee ann sec chinese orchestra(in case u dun know). now is a different conductor from that video. i hate the current conductor:p
i have to say..this is really too rush..haven maintain a bit in the song..like rushing for tou tai like that..hahax..joking..anyone its quite nice..just that cant hear timpani..and xuan yue..tan bo also quite soft..
lol.. come on.. nasco used to be the most huge and most zai one.. used to be like 500+ members when first yr and 2nd yr.. the vid u see.. i think.. 2nd + newbie NY competition batch.. when i was sec 2 and stuff.. =) not to forget all the fun stuffs...we most zai ok.. when we were tat time.. miss all the good times of long de quan qi and long teng hu yue.. i hope you li drops his gu qui more times =x
btw there are fakers in the huqin section. noobs. they shame huqin and the whole orchestra. go see during the first time that there is the cresendo and increasing speed semi quavers
wow... this is... fast... too fast in fact...拍子有问题... i played tis when i was in primary sch but i dun rmb that this song is that fast or messy...
TheDoreamon01 2 months ago
And the 西洋镲 forgot to come in SO MANY TIMES at the back of the song.
lsg5200 2 months ago
err... not that good...
lsg5200 2 months ago
Are they on an accelerating train or what? Man it gets faster and faster. Lost the whole meaning to the song.
rulkubara 1 year ago
I just joined Chinese Orchestra in this school , lets hope my batch can play as well :DDD
haradamagurosan 1 year ago
@zcbm1928 yup, I agree. Other secondary schools are better but none of them could really synchronized to the level of perfection..
darkwen028 1 year ago
too crowded, too squeeeeezzy, stage too small....
zcbm1928 1 year ago
Though its a little messy at parts but cant blame them as they are still young and that is their greatest asset, the ability to improve. I'm sure they are so much better now.
darkwen028 1 year ago
@darkwen028 other secondary schools can play quite good too, though they are the same age as them...it's just a matter or practising til perfection...
zcbm1928 1 year ago
my sch... syf piece for 2011.. the kuai ban i ply until going die le.
STARZxx3 1 year ago
SO nice the pai zi are very good the the hand movements for all are good thats the main point good!
sherinfairy 1 year ago
This song is relatively easy. And definitely fun. This CO got way too many people, and i don't think two PaiGus are needed. Plus the snare lagged at the first 24 bars
0RlGINs 1 year ago
I can play faster LOL
wenhong541 1 year ago
though its fast and the number of members is huge , but the rythem for this song are all out of place . can be improve . this is my school SYF song for last year which gets only a bronze because it's messy too but i'm sure that my chinese orchestra members of last year did their very best .
huishanl0lx 1 year ago
@huishanl0lx u from which co? Srsco?
kaixian1996 1 year ago
@kaixian1996 Nope . from one not very popular secondary school .
huishanl0lx 1 year ago
our syf song for 2011 now still dunno how to play
xiaotong9778 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我昨晚才演出这首歌,好好听~笛子~~
JTLY0424 2 years ago
anyone can explain why this orchestra is so huge?
Bryanzzzz 2 years ago
nice song, is our syf song ^^
whitefox2506 2 years ago
you from srsco?
smartiepants555 2 years ago
nope. im not.
whitefox2506 2 years ago
well, i didnt get into NAS, but i was in NAPCO, in erhu section, seating 2nd row extreme right, anyone remembers Edmund? lol Conductor Goh i missed him man
spitzfir3 2 years ago
damn i was trying to find anyone for NAPCO, i missed those days, was erhu and was seating 2nd row extreme right nearest to audience, anyone remembers Edmund?
spitzfir3 2 years ago
Yes,that time when i was in nasco after this performance,we were talking among ourselves that the beat was too fast (read --> rushing)
neoweisiang 2 years ago
太快了.......有些地方不齐
lacarlotta1993 2 years ago
LOL i dun lyk chang ge-.- lyk funeral music... HAHAHA
95sharpay95 2 years ago
agree ! ;D
MElodyflows 2 years ago
Crazy..the speed was like 160 all messed up my scholl plays 128 how nice...
LightzPuppii 2 years ago
tis song is surpose to be fast...lol.but if u hear sco fen yong,they are very slow but effects are awesome^^
jaggerxxjack 2 years ago
cphps: the 2009 set piece wasn't difficult, it's easy but difficult to execute it without any flaws.
0RlGINs 2 years ago 2
Make way for the shengs! Er hu play too loud! Shengs need to be heard!
fiego94 2 years ago
听多次后, 发现到对伍不齐!cello,扬琴乱!定音鼓太小声!小拔打得没力!笙solo part那边cello太大声了!吊拔慢了半拍!我给4/10。
bluebear4896 2 years ago
This is NASCO in which year?
Pur3DeX07 3 years ago
very rush...it was too rush the original was better.
bobo7200 3 years ago
too many ppl. too fast. erhu is not sitting properly. no emotion at all
animania1994 3 years ago
i dun tink they can play tat fast.. very messy.. so many yang qin yet so soft?? hmm.. should listen to BDSCO...
kiimonatiic 3 years ago 7
@kiimonatiic in tis song the ying qin should be soft i played tis song in SYF too the yang qin is only for accompany
sherinfairy 1 year ago
吊拔后面有点慢。定音鼓很小声。扬琴真的好多人啊!请问这在哪里举行?
bluebear4896 3 years ago
还不错,定音鼓在前面时不够大声。小扒在第44小节应该分大小声才好听。
bluebear4896 3 years ago
这乐团真的太多人了,光是扬琴的人就是我们整个弹拨乐的人数,二胡的人有我们整个乐团人数这么多,太夸张啦!!!
lsg5200 3 years ago
拍子太快了。谱子上写的是120,奏起来像150。人多势众是好事,但因为人太多不整齐,动作也不一致,显得杂乱。乐团似乎想以速度表现出水准, 但没有成功。演奏者都没在看指挥,只顾着把曲子弹完,让人看了没有想奋勇前进的感觉。
2325281108 3 years ago
你的评论真专业啊。。。但曲子是名作曲家潘耀田写的,他的歌都不怎么好奏啊。他们需要多努力就是了,但这速度可能也是他们指挥想要的吧,有时候指挥想改速度啊。可是这个乐团的扬琴太多了吧,好像有十二个。。。
lsg5200 3 years ago
yea, i agree to lsg5200..pan yao tian's songs arent easy to play the year 2009 chinese orchestra SYF songs is written by him..and its extremely difficult..
cphphs 2 years ago
erm which 1?chan ge?if u mean chan ge,tht song is dam easy....
jaggerxxjack 2 years ago
it's easy but boring. D; our syf song for 2009.
MElodyflows 2 years ago
u from srsco?
kaixian1996 1 year ago
nope, i'm from evgco. both pri and sec. ^^
MElodyflows 1 year ago
oops, 2004. :x
MElodyflows 1 year ago
oh btw the orchestra is jux too big but the pai gu only have 2! as it i jux cant feel the tempo strongly!
kll298 3 years ago
Sorry but i lye bedok sec one a little bit more. Jux find it not coordinate.
kll298 3 years ago
omg, the yangqins.
basically, the whole orchestra is quite big. nice sound effects, but i think that the conductor's going too fast, and doesn't bring out the exact feel.
-have no idea how to explain the 'feel'-
justin93633 3 years ago
赶拍子too much
SunyeyeYT 3 years ago 2
好多扬琴哦!!!!
4995315 3 years ago 2
2 paigu players and 12 yangqins? omg
yoyohihi940 3 years ago
the timing of their CO is rigged,all not coordinate,thats the disadvantage of a hugh number or people..go BDSCO 1
zhengwei1105 3 years ago
ya lor
galzparadise0916 3 years ago
i played this for 2008 SYF chinese orchestra competition. I was from Poi Ching School. They played till very nice.
galzparadise0916 3 years ago
omg so many people how many are there? 200? theres like 12 yang qin 8 suo nan and 2 drummer omgomg
SGMaple94 3 years ago
lol but the max is 80 ppl only leh
luvsjeanette 3 years ago
as they say, too many cooks spoil the broth! they have TOO MANY people on stage omg! a little messy! but still nice! :D i love this song.
alienbanana 3 years ago
i would really like to know what they got for SYF.
9995 3 years ago
9995, they got GOLD for SYF in 2007.
cutegal253 3 years ago
LOL. haha, good improvement.
9995 3 years ago
omgosh, the amount of people on stage is crazy. they have like 49 erhus, 12 yangqins, 14 dizis, 14 cellos, 6 double basses, 7 suonas!!
cheekytoot 3 years ago
i think the result of rushing is that they never look at the conductor,keep looking at the score sheets and never count. maybe they should memorize the score sheets so they can look at the conductor and not keep rushing..
cutegal253 3 years ago
cello abit rushing... everyone gt rush... and not really coordinated
xtriia 3 years ago
and hor, wad year is this one ar??????
cutegal253 3 years ago
hmm.......... but i think overall effect quite good liao ler the tan bo yue can louder a bit and the suona rocks!!!!! dun even have that kind of suona standard in my school lol...
cutegal253 3 years ago
this standard better than my school LOL.......so much ppl and the music keep rushing......like my school's one LOL........
cutegal253 3 years ago
jin* ps
luvsjeanette 3 years ago
u all should go c BDSCO de fen yong qian jing darm gd los .
luvsjeanette 3 years ago
lol...where school is this?? which state??lol..
The ppl so much..siao.. anyway.. zhong hu and cello nt bad..bt too fast le la..the music cant come out .
leonoh1 4 years ago
cant believe there's so many ppl. which year one? im in nasco. nasco=ngee ann sec chinese orchestra(in case u dun know). now is a different conductor from that video. i hate the current conductor:p
miich0211 4 years ago
严重的拍子问题,非常不齐,弦乐音准不好,每一套排鼓的定音必须一致
wongwonghappy 4 years ago 3
人太多,拍子问题,乱。
只是视觉还不错。
johe07 4 years ago 6
i hate NASCO. they suck. not coordinated. lousy dudes.
9995 4 years ago
the tempo not stable at all....the paigu keep wanna "chase" the tempo....gosh~
Jason1114 4 years ago 3
tooooooo .... FAST ,tempo no good
herocefiro 4 years ago
Overall effect is not bad. but the result of too many ppl: quite messy at some parts.. errr.. zhonghu-cello solo rock!!!!
gnodnumde 4 years ago
too fas........but wow.... so many ppl
melvinwah 4 years ago
i have to say..this is really too rush..haven maintain a bit in the song..like rushing for tou tai like that..hahax..joking..anyone its quite nice..just that cant hear timpani..and xuan yue..tan bo also quite soft..
zildjianwham 4 years ago
Are you serious about the numbers???
How about other CCA group.HAHA
destiny20062006 4 years ago
guo chang suo owns
PungSaiBoy 4 years ago
eh is not guo chang suo leh
genzox 4 years ago
the song is mainly for percussion based,
but... the drums quality like so sux =x
HoshiNoTobira 5 years ago
hear already can get heart attack.. keep rushing? then somemore some parts quite messy.. and yar.. man4 ban3 not you1 mei3 enough..
wen1125 5 years ago
nasco was shen! was shen. but not anymore.
sopdjik 5 years ago
hmm.. recentlly.. the orchestra has changed a lousy conductor =D and he sucks.. =D
kyorind 5 years ago
lol.. come on.. nasco used to be the most huge and most zai one.. used to be like 500+ members when first yr and 2nd yr.. the vid u see.. i think.. 2nd + newbie NY competition batch.. when i was sec 2 and stuff.. =) not to forget all the fun stuffs...we most zai ok.. when we were tat time.. miss all the good times of long de quan qi and long teng hu yue.. i hope you li drops his gu qui more times =x
kyorind 5 years ago
can only hear chuida...
lger 5 years ago
somemore too many ppl liao... lol and timpani put there like only put fer fun... like no sound 1.. lol xD so fast fer wad all kan pai zi.. lol
poohphua 5 years ago
can siam ?? ying all like kana sai.. lol haha xD
poohphua 5 years ago
there are fakers in the huqin section
jimmyngjm 5 years ago 2
btw there are fakers in the huqin section. noobs. they shame huqin and the whole orchestra. go see during the first time that there is the cresendo and increasing speed semi quavers
jimmyngjm 5 years ago
YO nasco shenz! hai accomplishments not for nthing one hor.
zombyre 5 years ago
where is nasco....i love the amount of suonas they hav there...i play suona..tts why..haha
BUT
FOR EVERY SECTION...
THERE ARE SO MANY PPL!!
OMG...my school co is less than half
InitialKeLw 5 years ago
i didn't really like this.. kepy rushing and rushing.. slow parts not you1 mei3 enough..
wen1125 5 years ago
wads nasco ars ?
superzhi 5 years ago
When I was in sec 3 LOL...now I am already 22... haha
axerine 5 years ago
this was taken from which year?
LYwong 5 years ago
i miss nasco.. aww..
aLiVeGaL 5 years ago
Not together, but quite ok.
Zozox 5 years ago
I agree that there some parts that the orchestra was not together but I like the feeling, I mean it makes me feel excited...weird...
JAceDZ 5 years ago
omg.. i miss this nasco.
the one now is.. don wna tok bout it -.-
zombyre 5 years ago
its was held some time ago...abt 5 or 6 years back...lol...
saruwarren 5 years ago
when was this held? recently? i agree, not really gd.. the orchestra rushing like mad.
roykun 5 years ago
l0ls.. n0t veri gd l0ls.. as in the orchestra playing this song.. the whole orchestra was not together some play fastere.. like the er hu..
forzenfire 5 years ago