The Hateful Truth Ep.24: Dungeon Siege III

[bwchudy95]

i always wonder what hes pointing at ;P 1:27

[LightWeightBro]

I wish Phil showed game footage with his Hateful Truth reviews.

[punkdude777]

Dam short RPG with cookie cutter type character building.

[DivineForcesBro]

Dude, you look nothing how you sound lol.

[albinopenguinzz]

@DivineForcesBro haha i know i thought he was way younger

[DivineForcesBro]

@albinopenguinzz Yeah lmao, I thought he was like 16 - 17 lol.

[flawns]

@DivineForcesBro you should hear me then ...HAHA

[bwsofly]

key word old. Old games old people...

[Mannetasi]

@bwsofly and your point is?? ? ??

[bwsofly]

@Mannetasi lolz that was three months ago i don't no guess umm...the will appeal old school gamer instead of new class gamers 

[TWIZTIDstateOFmind]

@bwsofly key words, new games. mentally challenged people

[bwsofly]

@TWIZTIDstateOFmind Hey U no wat they say old men dream dreams and young men have visions...Shouda coulda wouldas lolz!!!

[12345678927164]

um thay have pics now awsome!!!!!

[darkmaggot]

@notverycreative1 I believe this game is only on consoles.

[jmr2903]

So when is the HT on Witcher 2, Phil? We know you gave it a 7, but never when into full detail as to why that as. And now I'm especially curious since you gave a very basic dungeon crawler game the same score you gave a very detailed and complex game, The Witcher 2.

[brightsuperstition]

@jmr2903

Detail and complexity does not necessarily make a good game. The first Mario and Sonic games were incredibly simple in both detail and complexity, and yet, they still remain some of the greatest games ever made.

[jmr2903]

@brightsuperstition true, but within this context Phil discusses RPG elements universal to many RPGs. For example, he mentions in this video that Dungeon Siege III's story shifts and changes depending on the choices you make in the game, however the witcher 2 does this but goes into more detail to the point where the places you go, the story itself ENTIRELY changes depending on your choices. its direct comparisons like this that make me wonder how he can rate the two games the same.

[GinToYura]

if DSP had played dragon age 1 this video would be The Hateful Truth: Dragon Age 2

[911isfun]

I loved DS1-2, and this is not what I wanted for DS3, it seems like they took advantage of fads and mashed them into a dungeon crawler hoping for a sale on a big name. I miss looking about and finding hidden side dungeons with odd twists and hidden areas within them. The nearly pitch black maze, the pyramids in the desert, and the entirely hidden area (overly similar to cow world in D:2) chicken area, where you got the " best ranged weapon" the Chicken Gatling Cannon. As a fan i am disappointed.

[911isfun]

Seeing the gameplay at E3 made me sad. I crumpled into a ball and wish for my chicken gun shortly after.

[mrakobes79]

I am tottaly agree Dungeon Siege 3 is non comperable to 1 and 2 part, which were

on Pc . Sad but HateFull Thrue :(

[Volkovic7013]

Long story short: Wait for Skyrim

[MW2istheBOMB]

Still loving your reveiws Phil

[lisdo]

i'd love if phil play a lot more sports games but the chanel stil rocks

[crossxfuse]

i like how you keep comparing this game to Dragon Age 2 when you bashed the shit out of the ending of it

[CookieXmonstaZ]

Hold 7 and Dsp is having a nice Shake

[MrCodfan09]

@CookieXmonstaZ what the fuck does that mean? people say things like "hold 4 for fun" wtf? plz explain?

[twistedplayers]

@CookieXmonstaZ 7777777777777777777777777... Shake It Baby!

[gdubb78]

I'm glad i didn't get this game. I loved the first 2 games.

[stucazz989898]

phil you should fire over a couple hateful truth videos to machinima as part of your partnership.

[RoninOkami]

hey phil sorry to bother ya but a long time ago you posted what type of camcorder you used for your vids if you don't mind could you post that again please...



[PlayStop1992]

hi.

[TheFunnyWeasel1]

a black guy with a parrot walks into a bar, the bartender says "wow that is really amazing where did you get it?" "Africa!" says the parrot

[SnugOFP]

only 11 hours :( That's a bit of a let down. ill prob pick this up when it goes down in price though.

[Lasvegasflight99]

keep up the good work DSP! we <3 what you do!

[ivarra5]

I want a Hateful Truth t-shirt ><

[LookBehindYou88]

I like that HTF TRUTHS are done more often.

[Gustave154]

great detailed review

[LASVEGASBEAST]

great review 

[B1LLVANILYBOY]

So it's like a Bioware R.P.G.

[BobTheBuilder20247]

I couldn't happen but notice you didn't say the F word once throughout this video. lol

[punkdude777]

Good review as always, the looting sounds good and I'll definitely rent this.

[HaruhiGamer]

I got Dungeon Siege for the co-op, and I was vastly disappointed by it. It was a huge let down for me.

[MYILMAZ01]

holy fuck 64 parts?

[D4gI3]

@MYILMAZ01 have you seen the final fantasy playthrough? this is nothing lol

[halofan545]

@D4gI3 how many videos for final fantasy?

[D4gI3]

@halofan545 dude look at his main channel its way over 100

[supertaco54]

@halofan545 FF XIII has over 200 videos containing more than 30 hours of video. Other games don't compare to the length of that game.

[PeeEssThree]

@supertaco54 Yes.. but the game didnt need to be that long. It dragged on and on, alotof that time was spent grinding.

If they did everything right, it would be about 20 hours long.

[McAwesomeMan42]

@supertaco54 30 hours of shit is still shit :/

[TheKrwlng]

@MYILMAZ01 It was 77

[UnrealStyrofoam]

phil, marry me?

[darksydeparks]

Wow, Phil being an asshole replying to comments that are true. Just like usual.

[YUGIOHZEXAL5D]

@darksydeparks "faceplant"

[xElEmEnTxBlOoDx]

@YUGIOHZEXAL5D Umm, Don't you mean *facepalm*?

[dragonquestking]

I think that dungeon siege 3 is maybe a 6 or a 7. its good enough for a buy and maybe if your a couple playthrus since it looks like there could be a evil ending. You could kill everyone and become a ruler of the world. If you look at it as a stand alone game without the other games in the series then its really good dungeon game.

[obscurumbm]

great review dude I would agree with you.

[Jakylgamer]

7 is a good score considering the only replay value " IS " to try the different types of characters and possibly change your answers to the choices you make.

[IraqiDude321]

would you say this game is a good rent DSP?

[MicroScope888]

good review ill rent it. thanks dsp!

[irishmist1794]

pause it at 00:00 funny facial expression.

[Spriggs77]

Phil, please remind me, when you mean control scheme, you mean the control layout and how it interacts with the game? And then when you mean, easy control scheme, is when it's easy to control the character, and it's not tedious for anyone, even the casual player, can easily get it without mastering the controls. Am i correct?

[Xdeser1]

lol at the flamewar below me, If you like a game, you like it. if you dont, you dont. Dont argue about pointless things your not going to change their opinion,

[brianboytonto]

I think you have found your niche here Phil you are an awesome reviewer.

[MrFlavorman]

i like that Phil does a hateful truth right when he finishes the game. Hopefully he keeps it up.

[coolcoollo]

11 hour RPG? That doesn't....seem like my cup of tea. It does seem my fair if I'm co-oping it like Baldur's Gate types.

[MetaWolfakaZERO]

7 is a good score I agree, I don't know why everyone keeps bringing halo into a conversation let's move on in this gaming generation and let legendary games rest in peace and hell yes halo and fallout are legendary games

[inbadcompanyX2]

Duke Nukem: Forever has been my favorite game of the year. Why? IR BROUGHT BACK THE HATEFUL TRUTH!!!!

[millitery]

good job phil :) great playthru and review.

[iostream71]

Dungeon siege 1 was horrid with its auto battle system. Never bothered with the 2nd.

[Hollowstorm69]

it would be awesome if phil made walkthrough of old games too like for gameboy advance and shit like that a good one would be castlevania aria of sorrow(most favorite game on advance)

[dudetotalypsn]

@UpTehCooch You also hav to take into account that halo and dungeon seige are completely different genres. for the fps genre halo reach wasn't a shitty game but it wasnt amazing by any means. and a 7? for dsp thts a decent score for a decent game, which halo was. And dungeon seige i didnt watch his playthrough but from wat i'm hearing its a decent game for an RPG not amazing.

[dudetotalypsn]

@desudser10 i am already subscribed. Think about it, if he posts it ther sure he's not making money from it but it will get more people interested in his channel and thus more subscribers.

[BladeNecro]

Long story short: If you expected the old DS games you will be dissapointed. If you came into the series not knowing what the series is then you might like it.

[brought2war]

why did I get an ad for Bambi?

[jaiwhite205]

@danrulesleft4dead Thats not his style.

[incredicassio]

@danrulesleft4dead giving a game a 10 means it's perfect, with no flaws. He just listed several things that could have been better. He doesn't over-inflate the scores like all the other websites.

[danrulesleft4dead]

@incredicassio i know and i respect it , im just saying he makes mistakes, as we all do but he blames the game and not himself, what im saying is that ive played games with no glitches no flaws no nothing they were straight great games that if i made playthroughs and game reveivs i would give them 9's and 9.5's , thats all i meant, jesus u took it seriously.

[DSPGaming]

@danrulesleft4dead maybe, in the very distant time, I won't get asinine comments like these on my videos. but not likely.....

[pantscheese]

@DSPGaming Phil, I know this isn't related to this video, or your comment, but could you tell me the program you used to test you PC? I just bought a gaming PC and I want to know what it's capable of.

[notagoodsitrep]

@pantscheese *Random advice from not-DSP*

Try out 3D Markvantage. Its used by professional Tech reviewers. I really don't completely recommend capability testing programs. Some of them can give false scores and not even recognize certain hardwares. The best way to test a PC is simply to install and try to run games at max settings. You'll be able to see any flaws. Be sure not to choose PC-friers like Crysis or Battlefield Bad Company as testers.

[pantscheese]

@notagoodsitrep Yeah, I'm not going to really rely on the testing program. My PC comes with two free games, so I can test with those, but I still want to see what the program says. Thanks.

[skaterx4708]

@DSPGaming Dick. How are you gonna reply like that when YOU YES YOU PHIL miss so much content in games?

[ColePhelps545]

@DSPGaming Only when your fanbase won't consists of 13 year olds.

[pwnrofldairyqueenbbq]

@DSPGaming Phil, you are truly my idol - you are a great example of harnessing pure hatred and using it in a productive manner as motivation. Haters keep on hating, Phil keeps on winning.

[IGotAPagina]

@DSPGaming hehehehe.

[Z0HEN]

@danrulesleft4dead did he do that? I don't think so. The game kinda sucks...

[Genjustice92]

@danrulesleft4dead I think you should never review a game because giving this game a 10 is retarded. Giving any game a perfect 10 is hard to do.

[danrulesleft4dead]

@Genjustice92 i didnt say this game is a 10, what i ment was i watch all dsp videos-LITERALLY-and he always blames the game when he is just making mistakes.

[TheEIvanGod]

@danrulesleft4dead so you think this game is a 10?

[dwlgregory]

@danrulesleft4dead dude you would be crazy to give a game a 10

[dwlgregory]

@danrulesleft4dead 

[erin210992]

@danrulesleft4dead lol phil pwned you

[Mahan1372]

Another excellent review Phil! Great job!

[damaninthayhouse]

@UpTehCooch It was Phils honest opinion, if he does a 7 or more, he likes the game.

[FrankoTrent]

@damaninthayhouse But he gave DNF a 6.5, and he loved the game :P.

[Verkili]

@FrankoTrent He also outright admitted that he added .5 to the game because he is a hardcore Duke fanboy, and that a truly objective score for it would have been a six.

[damaninthayhouse]

@FrankoTrent He said 6.5 because it had alot of bugs.

[FrankoTrent]

@damaninthayhouse Yes but you said he gives at least a seven if he likes the game. My point was he loved DNF but gave it less than a seven. So your original statement is invalid.

[damaninthayhouse]

@FrankoTrent Whatever, he dosen't rate only by his love for the game, he also rates it if it has bugs/glitches etc....

[kodster33clumsy]

Nice review Phil.

[Mumbleinggaming]

@UpTehCooch i completely agree, its not at the same level as halo, halo is lower. as much as you like it, its just another generic fps. This actually has a better story and is not as a generic.

[bigz21311]

@Mumbleinggaming im not trying to be a troll this is an honest question since you said you didnt like halo so do you like cod or something like it im asking this because the cod and halo fans hate the other games usually

[darkmaggot]

@Mumbleinggaming And why are we comparing an FPS with an RPG?...completely different beasts.

[colonelfrost8]

@UpTehCooch halo 3 @ odst were  just boring halo 1 @ 2 were OK but not great. halo reach had a decent sp campaign the whole series gets a 7.0 from me.

[linkman355]

@UpTehCooch I hope you know that when DSP rates a game 7 or more, it means he thinks it's Decent/Good, if he really hated the entire Halo series, he would have rated it 6 or below. And if he REALLY hated it, he would of rated it Epic Mickey, which is 3, know your details before you comment.

[colonelfrost8]

lol i just noticed dsps t shirt looks like its fliping you off

[McAwesomeMan42]

fuck square enix

[MrMarkless]

6.5 was duke nukems score but this gets a 7.0? What the fuck?

[Geolink2349]

@MrMarkless .5 difference is much to you?

[supertboi123]

@MrMarkless duke nukem wasn't as good as this, duh!

[MrMarkless]

@supertboi123 But he rated this BARELY better than duke nukem

[darkmaggot]

@MrMarkless Phil mentioned that he is a Duke Nukem Fanboy over and over in the review so that was a big factor in his score. Nothing wrong with that in my opinion.

[MrMarkless]

@darkmaggot Yeah but hes supposed to give honest reviews. Not fanboy reviews.

[darkmaggot]

@MrMarkless And that is an honest review, reviews are opinion based and he was honest in telling us that. He would have given it an even higher score just because of that fact but he didn't, he didn't find the game to be horrendous and that is why he gave it that score.

Also again, why are you comparing an RPG with an FPS he is rating them based on other games in the same genre not any other game.

[MrMarkless]

@darkmaggot Yes I know it is an opinion based thing. But you think this game is a 7.0 even when compared to Duke Nukems 6.5? I think if a game that is so bland and basic as duke nukem gets a 6.5 than this game should at least be a 7.5 or an 8.0. But oh well my opinion, everyones entitled to their own. I mostly listen to Phils reviews based on what he says, not the final score, this score just was odd to me but oh well.

[darkmaggot]

@MrMarkless Good argument man, and I do agree that it might be weird but again comparing an fps score to an rpg score really doesn't seem right.

[MrMarkless]

@darkmaggot Why dosent it seem right? isnt a game a game regardless of genre?

[MrMarkless]

@darkmaggot Yeah true but isnt a game a game? Regardless of genre?

[supertboi123]

@MrMarkless well i think thats about right. i dont see why thats a big deal.

[billytamer]

@MrMarkless good question. this game is shit

[thumbcraze]

DSP I respect you and everything you do but this new law in California and several other states is bull crap. Violent video games cannot be sold to minors even with a parent with you when buying the game. The law struck this morning and I don't know if they're being serious or not but all I know is I'm still gonna get a violent video game when it comes out. My opinion, just another law to try to help the youth a little too late

[StMarciano]

@thumbcraze Where have you been?They already came to a conclusion that video games offer the same mental effect on children as movies or tv shows.As such minors can buy violent video games now by LAW.Of course this only applies to California.

[thumbcraze]

@StMarciano I was off somewhere else, but this is good news now I can go to gamestop and buy an M rated game without my dad being there

[JordanJ370]

Where is the catchy intro?

[DSPGaming]

@JordanJ370 there hasnt been an intro for the hateful truth in over a year. get with the times.

[LookBehindYou88]

@DSPGaming

and shouldn't there be one ?

[MrNeoshredder]

@DSPGaming

Can you bring back the old one? :D

[ChaoticProductions1]

so..basically dungeon siege 1 was basically a final fantasy game? >.>

[McAwesomeMan42]

@ChaoticProductions1 no, it didn't suck.

[ChaoticProductions1]

@McAwesomeMan42 only ff11 12 and 13 sucked

[McAwesomeMan42]

@ChaoticProductions1 also 8, the main character in 10 ruined the game. and 7 was horribly overrated. Also 10-2 was an abortion of a game.

[chatomairi]

Yes!! 16 minutes. Will watch completely.

[Hit2be]

It looked sort of like Champions of Norath to me... though i only watched the first couple play throughs.

[79selym]

online sucks btw watch yogscast and ull see

[KassRedFox]

That score sounds a little bit of overinflated ... I though that a 6 would be a "No replay content" game.

A 7 sounds like "It's a good game, I recommend it to everybody"

[DSPGaming]

@KassRedFox maybe you should leave this comment on Game Informer's review. they gave it an 8.5. my review is honest.

[darkness007666]

@DSPGaming I rate it a 7.5

[pantscheese]

@KassRedFox I think a 7 more says "It's a good game, but not everybody will like it."

[nano69ify]

I just lovethese hateful truths. Right after hes done he just does it. Awesome.

[OverTheEdgeGaming1]

somebody is cold :p

[krp72390]

Dsp has the best reviews of all time

[XxWolfpack247xX]

this is more like diablo ... which is a dungeon crawler with story but its randomly generated areas and random loot ( alot of loot ) it has arch types but there are more than just like 5

[wildbillycobra]

You know what is the best game ever fallout 3

[jtgtjtgt]

@wildbillycobra We all have our opinions . Obvious your a gamer of this gen if you think that . Personally i liked mass effect 1 more than fallout 3 . DSP actually agrees with me on that one . NOT mass effect 2 though .

[pantscheese]

@jtgtjtgt When has he ever said that? Mass Effect 2 is objectively better than Mass Effect 1. Fallout is a completely different style of game and can't sensibly be compared to Mass Effect.

[jtgtjtgt]

@pantscheese He's made it clear multiple times he liked mass effect 1 more than 2 . Me1 fanboys all the time say me2 was gears of war with speech options it didn't further the plot any and was filler . Watch his goty 2010 awards . Me2 was a dumbing down of the series . instead of improving it it removed content and was a shallow rpg if you could even call it that . Which is why bioware is adding back me1 features because fans were complaining . Did you even play the first one

[darkmaggot]

@jtgtjtgt Yet to me ME2 was fine with all the changes, less clutter in the weapon, armor, etc. Screens. Not going to say that I don't miss all the different armors for each species in ME1 but the game needed to be simplified in that aspect.

[darkmaggot]

@jtgtjtgt "Obvious your a gamer of this gen you think that" FO3 and ME1 came out in the same gen of consoles fyi.

Phil agrees in regards to the story in ME2, but he loved everything else.

[jtgtjtgt]

@darkmaggot Obvious your a gamer of this gen if you think fallout 3 is the best game ever was what that statement meant . Also me2 took away the level up system , the atmosphere and music was completely different , less side missions and no exploration are just a few of the things wrong with me2 . Instead of fixing what was wrong with me1 they abandoned things . Overall from phils perspective iv'e heard him say as a whole me1 was better. He also liked fallout new vegas more than fallout 3

[darkmaggot]

@jtgtjtgt Oh roger that.

You still assign points after leveling up, isn't that a leveling system?. Well that is your opinion, the music and atmosphere looked and felt similar to me. By less exploration you mean the rover missions? those where amazingly boring.

I don't know about Fallout 3 vs New Vegas, to me FO3 felt more tightly paced but that is my opinion. Also the glitches really killed the mood for me in NV, and the setting well to me DC was more interesting to explore.

[jtgtjtgt]

@darkmaggot I agree with you on Fallout 3 . But in phils hateful truth of new vegas he said personall he liked it better . I have very good memory when it comes to these things . And like i said above those rover missions and exploration instead of being fixed were abandoned in me2 making it a much more shallow experience . Also the level up system in me1 was much better it was an rpg system like fallout had .

DC vs New Vegas . New Vegas was boring imo FO3 had a much better atmosphere

[pantscheese]

@dudetotalypsn Why should he?

[brandoncooper17]

@dudetotalypsn

Listen to one of his latest ask the kings there is no point to do so due to broken system of machinma uses he makes enough money here. 

[1111naruto1111]

phil talking about rpg gave you ever tried world of warcraft

[boullionk]

thumbs up if DSP should stream his playthroughs on jtv or twitch etc etc

[GamingHighrise]

phil is pretty dedicated to these hateful thruths he may not like it but i think he should do hateful truth for every game they're so much better than ign or any others...and he has actually played ALOT of games but still doesn't compare every one to call of duty...

[XxWolfpack247xX]

he has a busy schedule .. he only does hateful truths on single player only games

[BloodHuman3]

@XxWolfpack247xX

He does Hateful Truths on games with multiplayer also.

You probably didn't listen, but he said how he's going to do a Hateful Truth on Duke Nukem: Forever, FEAR 3, etc. when he plays the multiplayer.

[SuperUSA21]

DSP tries it : smoking weed with me

[pilsener13]

asking for thumbs up is lame

[KassRedFox]

@pilsener13 I see what you did there

[crfraph]

there will be no THT for FEAR 3? Regards, really enjoy watching your videos.

[razarsenal180]

@crfraph He said he won't do one now as he hasn't tried the online play, so can't give it a fair shake. I'm pretty sure he will do one once he has done it.

[dodjever76]

@crfraph He will also have to play the story mode as Fettel

[DANSTERsss]

hmmm. A company taking over a pc based game and changing it completely... rings a bell.