Why the need to visit his grave? In my opinion its bordering on the behaviour of the superstitious. For me it has parallels in visiting Mecca or the grave of a Christian saint. Carl Sagan was an amazing man and I credit him with pulling me out of the haze of religion, but I would argue that the time and money spent on visiting where his body is interned would be better spent on learning more about the cosmos or donating to a charity or organisation that Carl would approve of.
I have an old photo of his gravesite before the stone was placed where a young child, I assume, had placed a radio telescope constructed by Legos. Now that was moving.
I would think a man like Carl Sagan deserves a better grave stone. He should have a museum with a statue dedicated to him. Greatest man to ever live.. he personally inspired me. R.I.P
Agree, he should have had an awesome grave, hes the reason I got into astronomy, I now own 4 telescopes and too many books to count, including all carls books. Its sad that many people dont even know who he was.
I did feel uncomfortable about that. However, Carl would be the first one to point out that the dead are unaware and therefore probably take no offense.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Dear YouTube friends: Mr. Carl Sagan was a genius. His death was premature. He had a lot to give to mankind, to enlighten people. Never mind. I do think he is in Heaven with billions of animals, people, and the stars he loved so much. Unfortunaltely, I was not able to meet him. Perhaps, one day I will have the pleasure and privilege. GOD BLESS YOU!
Thanks for this, so strange to see his grave, I've driven from Niagara Falls to New York must have passed near Ithaca, if I get in range again, I'll definitely go. It's odd this desire us humans have to feel a physical presence of the dead, not sure I'll take a marble, possibly getting a bit mystic for me, but having said that, if a saw a dandelion seed nearby, I would just have to sit next to his grave and let it go in the breeze.
Not mystic, just sentimental. :-) You understand - as evidenced by your dandelion seed reference.
As a hardened skeptic, I see nothing wrong with being sentimental. Or hoping that we're wrong. Who among us, when hearing the end of the song "When Carl Sagan Died" does not start to cry at least a little?
Pale Blue Dot - Great music. Found you via Jeff Williams site. Heard a nice quote from Carl Sagan the other day. I yo want to make an apple pie "from scratch" you need to start by creating the universe.
Lakeview Cemetery in Ithaca, NY. Which is off of Wyckoff Rd./Ave. I hope i'm getting the spelling right there. Google doesn't have detailed images of Ithaca (which is outrageous!). At some point i'll get GPS coords for Carls grave to help admirers find him.
yes harry poter is dead, i also shot a vid on direction to the grave site and unbenounced mine is just like yours. i think ill just let you be the guide as i my voice makes me sound gay
Great video and great tribute for a great man and teacher
chikito72 6 months ago
Why the need to visit his grave? In my opinion its bordering on the behaviour of the superstitious. For me it has parallels in visiting Mecca or the grave of a Christian saint. Carl Sagan was an amazing man and I credit him with pulling me out of the haze of religion, but I would argue that the time and money spent on visiting where his body is interned would be better spent on learning more about the cosmos or donating to a charity or organisation that Carl would approve of.
AstronomySetMeFree 1 year ago
This is one of my personal goals in life - to visit this man's final resting place.
yu244720 1 year ago
did carl sagan have kids?
prankmakers95 1 year ago
@prankmakers95 He has one that I know of. Nick Sagan.
thesmart358 1 year ago
wow alot of people sure like to dance on the mans grave, iv seen coulntless videos like this.... What Would Sagan Do?
i wonder if he would stand on a mans grave.
1a2b3cdf3 2 years ago
What are you talking about?
mandolinroad 2 years ago
harry potter is buried in Ithaca only in the book, right? The real harry potter is buried in Israel..?
Autostream 2 years ago
I have an old photo of his gravesite before the stone was placed where a young child, I assume, had placed a radio telescope constructed by Legos. Now that was moving.
caseyg5 2 years ago 6
Did you take that photo yourself? Or find it online?
SardonicusRexx 2 years ago
I did a newsletter where I wrote an obituary of Carl and a subscriber sent a couple of grave site shots not long after burial.
caseyg5 2 years ago
Was his name Dave B.?
SardonicusRexx 2 years ago
Correct.
caseyg5 2 years ago
He really was and is still something.
ericsbuds 2 years ago
I would think a man like Carl Sagan deserves a better grave stone. He should have a museum with a statue dedicated to him. Greatest man to ever live.. he personally inspired me. R.I.P
ignorant13 2 years ago 5
Agree, he should have had an awesome grave, hes the reason I got into astronomy, I now own 4 telescopes and too many books to count, including all carls books. Its sad that many people dont even know who he was.
Carcass1701 2 years ago 4
He didn't strike me as the kind of guy who would want a huge monument. He was just a human albeit a thinking one.
mandolinroad 2 years ago
why did you step on his grave??? man that is so uncool
makedonas86 2 years ago
I did feel uncomfortable about that. However, Carl would be the first one to point out that the dead are unaware and therefore probably take no offense.
SardonicusRexx 2 years ago 9
billions of stars in billions of gallaxies is the recipy for my tranquility... many thanx Mr.Sagan
Floydfan717 3 years ago 2
Dude, that was nice of u to go there. I want to go myself, can u tell me what the cemetery is called or what the address is?
darmokandgalad 3 years ago 2
i find it sad that he has not been honored in a more public way, one of the true enlightened human beings of our time
squishydemon 3 years ago 5
Last summer's issue of the Ithaca Times had, IIRC, a poll on which Ithacan the public would most like to see a statue of on the Ithaca Commons.
Carl won.
SaganAppreciationSoc 3 years ago 3
We're working on convincing the USPS to issue a Carl Sagan Forever stamp.
SaganAppreciationSoc 3 years ago 5
Muchas gracias.
HONOR A QUIEN HONOR MERECE.
hdtvlat 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dear YouTube friends: Mr. Carl Sagan was a genius. His death was premature. He had a lot to give to mankind, to enlighten people. Never mind. I do think he is in Heaven with billions of animals, people, and the stars he loved so much. Unfortunaltely, I was not able to meet him. Perhaps, one day I will have the pleasure and privilege. GOD BLESS YOU!
(PEOPLE PLEASE STOP KILLING ANIMALS!STOP EATING MEAT! STOP WEARING FUR/LEATHER!ThankyouAdemar)
delpoz09 4 years ago
Except he was Atheist.
DonsonJack 3 years ago 2
Which was a good thing, u fuck.
darmokandgalad 3 years ago 2
Very moving. Thanks for posting. It allow those who can't personally go themselves, to "visit" the resting place of a great man.
reuven1967 4 years ago 10
Thanks for this, so strange to see his grave, I've driven from Niagara Falls to New York must have passed near Ithaca, if I get in range again, I'll definitely go. It's odd this desire us humans have to feel a physical presence of the dead, not sure I'll take a marble, possibly getting a bit mystic for me, but having said that, if a saw a dandelion seed nearby, I would just have to sit next to his grave and let it go in the breeze.
thingsihaveseen2 4 years ago 11
Not mystic, just sentimental. :-) You understand - as evidenced by your dandelion seed reference.
As a hardened skeptic, I see nothing wrong with being sentimental. Or hoping that we're wrong. Who among us, when hearing the end of the song "When Carl Sagan Died" does not start to cry at least a little?
SardonicusRexx 4 years ago
Pale Blue Dot - Great music. Found you via Jeff Williams site. Heard a nice quote from Carl Sagan the other day. I yo want to make an apple pie "from scratch" you need to start by creating the universe.
DaftNotStupid 4 years ago
Thanks for posting that video.
Where is that place? city
I'll ask you to do me a favor. Could you please go to google earth and try to find satellite images of that place.
stormguy110 4 years ago 3
Lakeview Cemetery in Ithaca, NY. Which is off of Wyckoff Rd./Ave. I hope i'm getting the spelling right there. Google doesn't have detailed images of Ithaca (which is outrageous!). At some point i'll get GPS coords for Carls grave to help admirers find him.
SardonicusRexx 4 years ago
yes harry poter is dead, i also shot a vid on direction to the grave site and unbenounced mine is just like yours. i think ill just let you be the guide as i my voice makes me sound gay
darkpheonix262 4 years ago 2
Thanks for posting SardonicusRexx. Carl's legacy lives on.
ParadiseEarth1 4 years ago 3
I hope to upload another Carl-related video within 24 hours. Be on the lookout our just subscribe.
SardonicusRexx 4 years ago
If you remain alive in the hearts of those you leave behind, you never really die.
ZachsMind 4 years ago 4
Thaks for sharing this video.
polimero 4 years ago 2
Good commentary. Good tour guiding. Still strange to think he's left us - but your video shows us all too clearly that he has.
midhrifs 4 years ago 2
Very well done!
dadoodaidy 4 years ago