Seems like people are confusing their personal preferences with other things. Regardless of how much you like or dislike this. You really have to respect each of these guys for how hard they've worked.
I try and listen to stuff that I don't understand, most recently some death metal. I may not "like" it as much but I can appreciate other aspects of the music. Just because I don't understand it doesn't make it bad music.
@JazzVideoGuy well, urbie green? :P lol he's dead long time ago, but I dunno, trombone is also a major jazz instrument, cetranly more than the guitar for ex, well at least I think so. It's just sad that I didn't see one in this band. There're quite a few good trombonists, so i'm suprised not to see one in there.
I saw Nicholas Payton play with the Dana Hall Quintet at the Chicago Jazz Fest 2010 and he tore the roof off and we were all outside. He was amazing and I hope he comes to Chicago, be sure to bring the trumpet!
Ah, it's Roger, which means its solid groovy education. Perfect for my Sunday morning. With coffee and croissants. And my girlfriend fussing over the newspapers. Enjoy your weekend, too!
@ezerarias it sounds like you're describing the beginnings of a jazz nerd. Soon they will learn a bunch of chromatic triadic patterns and say they are too advanced for changes or music before 1980 see Jason marsalis says
why do everyone have to argue soo much. Listen to the music. If you like it, great. If not, go to the next video...that simple. Its not even a debatable piece, just a great rendition of a monk tune.
There are idiots who post stupid comments and have no idea what they're talking about. The only reason they're against straight ahead Jazz is because they can't play it well. They stick to fusion and 1/2 chord songs where they can stick with pentatonics only.
@CaptainJazz92 Seriously. The only people that complain (that I have encountered) of straight ahead usually can't play it.
Mainly because they can't play the changes, etc instead of playing in a freer tune and a tune such as impressions with two chords. Not saying Impressions is an easy tune, but a guy who can't play well won't have a hard time soloing over it instead of ...lets see...Giant Steps.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This stuff is just old. It's been done. Nobody impressed me here. You wanted jazz to be a museum piece well here it is. This don't mean much. Alot of HOT air!!!
That is some VERY backwards thinking my friend. What is wrong with straight ahead playing? I listen to all kinds of progressive jazz , stefon harris, christian mcbride, romain collin, and more (and I'm sure many others watching this do as well), BUT there is and always will be room for straight ahead. Just because jazz is constantly moving forward, it doesn't mean we can't take a look back at the past that shaped the music of today. After all, this IS a tribute to Blue Note
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Let me tell you something: this music is tired. Period. It has nothing to do with straight ahead jazz, it's about soul! This music is flat. Nobody here is cooking, Nodody here is innovating in their expression. Nobody is on the edge. The music is like warmed over eggs. White bread with no gravy!!! This puts me sleep. This is Monk's song, but not his spirit...
Blame the musicians here!?they are among the heaviest in NYC right now and you should check them out in other situations. This one is just business-recording business. Charlap had to put up a show which was too tough from the get go-and all the cats knows it. There is no musician from Charlap's generation that can replicate the spirit of Mobley, Tina Brooks, Trane, Tyner, Mabern, Green,Joe Hend, Junior Cook etc'-those were other times man! move on and let the cats do their end of the "Deal".
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
"Heaviest in NYC" - Payton is pretty chubby! People a have a right to their opinion, heck it's the jazz critics along with labels that has handicapped the music. You critics not thinking out the box having names like Bop2thebone. The music is timeless, their interpretation is old!
I am not a critic pitbull-I am a musician..please do not judge people cause of their name or look. FYI, In jazz, I like everything that swings or groove first, but whatever...this is just a tribute album and all you gotta do is-not buying it. Peace.
still upset for being so uneducated a month later?
Here's a valuble piece of advice, instead of leaving stupid and douchy comments on YouTube, go take a jazz studies course so you might have some idea of what you're talking about
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I agree with videolover61, these are top level musicians, who choose to sound like high school and collegiate players because it is safe! Monk was not a safe artist nor was his music embodied in safety, hence why he is great along with Trane, Miles, etc. This is why jazz is basically non-existent, the labels and critics are afraid of change and exploration, because it can't be controlled, thus one is using their minds!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Also, straight ahead playing doesnt simply mean playing Omni book II-V-I's, I was taught that a musician should re-shape a tune harmonically! In other words if this was analogous to sex, they would be considered plain old missionary!
For you cats who don't understand the usage of the safe in this context:
I prefer straight-ahead as well, however straight-ahead shouldn't and doesn't imply being less adventurous, they could simply have stretch the boundaries! End the topic there are more important issues in this world, ie economy, healthcare, AIDS, war, etc. - Later!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
And what with the old grey suits?? Huh? What to play this music you got to look like an undertaker in a funeral home? Ol' Nick Payton looks like Louie Armstrong and he ain't even 40 years old!
Remember this: you glorify the past, then the future dries up!!!
I don't get it..what happened to Criss Cross?..Monk would roll over in his grave...and Ravi Coltrane listened so much to Brecker he sounds like...Bennie Wallace!
gosh..ive been looking for something like this...its hard to find a combo like this without going back 30-50 years. All the wynton days of putting amazing combos together for an album are done.. it seems in jazz, recording hasnt really produced anything of import lately.
I was fortunate enough to see this group last night. It was spectacular! If you have an opportunity to see them, I can't stress enough how enjoyable the concert will be.
Great performance!
kevin4795 1 month ago
great video,,hot jazz
nutsocket 3 months ago
@nutsocket I really enjoyed shooting this. Some of best live music I've heard in a long time.
JazzVideoGuy 3 months ago
Al Hirt makes Nicholas Payton sound like a grade-schooler.
This abstract jazz just doesn't have enough form for me. Then again I'm from the Maynard Ferguson School of Jazz..:D
CaiaphasFlag 5 months ago
What a big fat yawn-this is so fake I'm gonna puke right after i turn my computer off.
Parker didn't die for this sellout crap. f*** off!
BashuUp 7 months ago
Comment removed
BashuUp 7 months ago
Taste...
Seems like people are confusing their personal preferences with other things. Regardless of how much you like or dislike this. You really have to respect each of these guys for how hard they've worked.
I try and listen to stuff that I don't understand, most recently some death metal. I may not "like" it as much but I can appreciate other aspects of the music. Just because I don't understand it doesn't make it bad music.
Anyways...love this.
thelbronius 8 months ago
why no trombone WTFFF?!!!!11111111
SergioBizzle 9 months ago
@SergioBizzle What trombone player should have been in this group?
JazzVideoGuy 9 months ago
@JazzVideoGuy well, urbie green? :P lol he's dead long time ago, but I dunno, trombone is also a major jazz instrument, cetranly more than the guitar for ex, well at least I think so. It's just sad that I didn't see one in this band. There're quite a few good trombonists, so i'm suprised not to see one in there.
SergioBizzle 9 months ago
@JazzVideoGuy Eubanks!
toofastforlovemasha 4 months ago in playlist Blue Note 7
great!! Some people think its easy to play jazz,its not
dreadtodred 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
these interviews are gay. nice try
pik1andlik1 10 months ago
Whats the name of the song that starts at :38 secs?
TonyF273 11 months ago
@TonyF273 Grant Green's "Idle Moments." You can hear it on YT in fact......
Westcoasttony 8 months ago
This is great mastery ( got you intrepidpooch, big lol )
benjudrums 1 year ago
I saw Nicholas Payton play with the Dana Hall Quintet at the Chicago Jazz Fest 2010 and he tore the roof off and we were all outside. He was amazing and I hope he comes to Chicago, be sure to bring the trumpet!
msteras 1 year ago
Ah, it's Roger, which means its solid groovy education. Perfect for my Sunday morning. With coffee and croissants. And my girlfriend fussing over the newspapers. Enjoy your weekend, too!
flauschkatz 1 year ago
holy shit .
Gettin this album.
if there is one?
Jordainio 1 year ago
These guy's are truly magnificent,
johnharris61 1 year ago
@ezerarias it sounds like you're describing the beginnings of a jazz nerd. Soon they will learn a bunch of chromatic triadic patterns and say they are too advanced for changes or music before 1980 see Jason marsalis says
tripp45 1 year ago
That piano player is boss.
MrEdwardLyons 1 year ago
bill charlap sure is one weird guy.
flipadiddle 1 year ago
jazz cool music
Dvareckas 1 year ago
why do everyone have to argue soo much. Listen to the music. If you like it, great. If not, go to the next video...that simple. Its not even a debatable piece, just a great rendition of a monk tune.
phillytalented 1 year ago 3
would expect a more thought provoking arrangement from these guys
scirabbor 2 years ago 3
everyone patting each other on the back...somehow that doesn't seem very modest
tromboneJTS 2 years ago 4
this is a great video with great musicians.
There are idiots who post stupid comments and have no idea what they're talking about. The only reason they're against straight ahead Jazz is because they can't play it well. They stick to fusion and 1/2 chord songs where they can stick with pentatonics only.
ezerarias 2 years ago 3
You can't play free jazz unless you're already a solid straight ahead player.
You got it man.
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago 3
@CaptainJazz92 Seriously. The only people that complain (that I have encountered) of straight ahead usually can't play it.
Mainly because they can't play the changes, etc instead of playing in a freer tune and a tune such as impressions with two chords. Not saying Impressions is an easy tune, but a guy who can't play well won't have a hard time soloing over it instead of ...lets see...Giant Steps.
ezerarias 2 years ago 3
Hahah, exactly, it just pisses me off when people are that stupid and ignorant about this great music!
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
Wow...lots of red negative numbers here on such a great video. Lets listen to the music guys. :)
BassicallyChristian 2 years ago
I love how the drummer's articulation at 7:50 with those cymbals. Simple and brilliant little thing added in there.
woodencardboard 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This stuff is just old. It's been done. Nobody impressed me here. You wanted jazz to be a museum piece well here it is. This don't mean much. Alot of HOT air!!!
videolover61 2 years ago
That is some VERY backwards thinking my friend. What is wrong with straight ahead playing? I listen to all kinds of progressive jazz , stefon harris, christian mcbride, romain collin, and more (and I'm sure many others watching this do as well), BUT there is and always will be room for straight ahead. Just because jazz is constantly moving forward, it doesn't mean we can't take a look back at the past that shaped the music of today. After all, this IS a tribute to Blue Note
epasurr 2 years ago 19
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Let me tell you something: this music is tired. Period. It has nothing to do with straight ahead jazz, it's about soul! This music is flat. Nobody here is cooking, Nodody here is innovating in their expression. Nobody is on the edge. The music is like warmed over eggs. White bread with no gravy!!! This puts me sleep. This is Monk's song, but not his spirit...
videolover61 2 years ago
Blame the musicians here!?they are among the heaviest in NYC right now and you should check them out in other situations. This one is just business-recording business. Charlap had to put up a show which was too tough from the get go-and all the cats knows it. There is no musician from Charlap's generation that can replicate the spirit of Mobley, Tina Brooks, Trane, Tyner, Mabern, Green,Joe Hend, Junior Cook etc'-those were other times man! move on and let the cats do their end of the "Deal".
Bop2thebone 2 years ago
Whatever...it's just my opinion. It's kinda tired on many levels to me...it's just ok...
videolover61 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"Heaviest in NYC" - Payton is pretty chubby! People a have a right to their opinion, heck it's the jazz critics along with labels that has handicapped the music. You critics not thinking out the box having names like Bop2thebone. The music is timeless, their interpretation is old!
knowpitbull 2 years ago
I am not a critic pitbull-I am a musician..please do not judge people cause of their name or look. FYI, In jazz, I like everything that swings or groove first, but whatever...this is just a tribute album and all you gotta do is-not buying it. Peace.
Bop2thebone 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you sir, are jazz inept
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You sir can kiss my ass!
videolover61 2 years ago
well at least my ass has more taste than your whole self so you might beniefit greatly from it
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I know that is false. You elitist jerk. You got your opinion and I have mine. So there.
Im just wondering why you are getting so upset...hmmm....
videolover61 2 years ago
@videolover61 elitist simply means he's better than you. everyone who uses the "elitist" argument is usually inferior.
ezerarias 2 years ago
Nope you dope. Elitist means pompous know it all, that never did!! Like those egg head critics that you listen to.
videolover61 2 years ago
@videolover61 I was being sarcastic, not pompous, lol.
ezerarias 2 years ago 3
Oh ok...just like I cant smell bad breath over the internet...uh, im talking about yours! LOL
videolover61 2 years ago
@videolover61 heheheheh, I don't believe in mouthwash.
ezerarias 2 years ago 2
Ahhhhhh!!!!! Thought so!!! LOL
videolover61 2 years ago 2
You sir should shut da f**k up!
videolover61 2 years ago
Hahahaha
still upset for being so uneducated a month later?
Here's a valuble piece of advice, instead of leaving stupid and douchy comments on YouTube, go take a jazz studies course so you might have some idea of what you're talking about
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
Oh I know what im talking about...you better believe that...and if you dont who gives a f**k!
videolover61 2 years ago
Okay, buddy.
Whatever lets you sleep at night
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree with videolover61, these are top level musicians, who choose to sound like high school and collegiate players because it is safe! Monk was not a safe artist nor was his music embodied in safety, hence why he is great along with Trane, Miles, etc. This is why jazz is basically non-existent, the labels and critics are afraid of change and exploration, because it can't be controlled, thus one is using their minds!
knowpitbull 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Also, straight ahead playing doesnt simply mean playing Omni book II-V-I's, I was taught that a musician should re-shape a tune harmonically! In other words if this was analogous to sex, they would be considered plain old missionary!
For you cats who don't understand the usage of the safe in this context:
Safe - Unwilling to explore!
knowpitbull 2 years ago
@knowpitbull I disagree. I personally prefer straight ahead but can play fusion/latin/free just as well. Straight ahead characterizes jazz though.
ezerarias 2 years ago
I prefer straight-ahead as well, however straight-ahead shouldn't and doesn't imply being less adventurous, they could simply have stretch the boundaries! End the topic there are more important issues in this world, ie economy, healthcare, AIDS, war, etc. - Later!
knowpitbull 2 years ago 4
If these guys sound like high school players lets hear your video, jiveass!
intrepidpooch 2 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And what with the old grey suits?? Huh? What to play this music you got to look like an undertaker in a funeral home? Ol' Nick Payton looks like Louie Armstrong and he ain't even 40 years old!
Remember this: you glorify the past, then the future dries up!!!
videolover61 2 years ago
Comment removed
epasurr 2 years ago
@epasurr very well said
0lfo 1 year ago
Steve Wilson lookin' kinda old...like an old school teacher...
videolover61 2 years ago
Very passionate style of playing in such modern times of Jazz!
morereese5 2 years ago
Wow Ravi sounds amazing in this his playing is so different and unique in this session. I love this!!!
Jazzbasssmd13 2 years ago 2
I don't get it..what happened to Criss Cross?..Monk would roll over in his grave...and Ravi Coltrane listened so much to Brecker he sounds like...Bennie Wallace!
olivierbarjot 2 years ago
i heard them play this live and it sounded a million times better
bossface009 2 years ago
he so wouldnt!!!!
Mattytheman91 2 years ago
THAT'S IT !
sergiodal1 2 years ago
the drummer blows my mind
TheBassguitarlover12 2 years ago 7
Lewis Nash!
JazzVideoGuy 2 years ago 4
I'd rather hear a few soloists stretch out. I know this is a showcase, but damn! One chorus?
futboler454 2 years ago 4
burning alto solo
fishytank1land 2 years ago
Virtuosos of music, Gods of jazz!
pajaroloqo 2 years ago
beautiful!
arhada 2 years ago
yoooooo...is Ravi playing John's old Balanced action!!!!??? The thought gives me shivers man, not in a bad way, just because..
nateo5 2 years ago 2
I dunno if I'd want that out on the road with me, if I were him I'd put it in a museum, or at least some kind of shrine at home! :)
CaptainJazz92 2 years ago
mért nem lesz már soha semmi olyan, mint 50 éve
hvikk 2 years ago
drz grbz hrj nzdjk 42 wjclwck
jimbo1066 2 years ago
awesome vid...thx for posting
Bballfan729 2 years ago
will see them this month at Birdland, cant wait. I saw Nicholas, 10 years ago. Was hanging out at a club in New Orleans.
salitre3 2 years ago 3
Saw this group last night at Dartmouth - followed by an informal discussion with Bill and Lewis. SWEEET.
devodesk 2 years ago
Saw them live in Boulder, CO, FABULOUS! I got to meet them backstage and take pics and get autographs, too! One of the best groups EVER.
stalzz 2 years ago
gosh..ive been looking for something like this...its hard to find a combo like this without going back 30-50 years. All the wynton days of putting amazing combos together for an album are done.. it seems in jazz, recording hasnt really produced anything of import lately.
ttukumoe 2 years ago
I always have to stop and say thanks for everything you do...
MzIsis08 2 years ago 2
me too man, what would we do without the one and only jazz video guy......
mcoli2720 2 years ago 6
Thank you so much for these great videos!
aleksgarlieTrumpet 2 years ago
doug ramsey mentioned this vid today in his great jazz blog, "rifftides".
chalone2 2 years ago
I saw them in Yakima! That's where Doug Ramsey lives! He introduced the band!
bobaiyun 2 years ago
thanks a lot.
Steph.
Tsutsomu 2 years ago
I was fortunate enough to see this group last night. It was spectacular! If you have an opportunity to see them, I can't stress enough how enjoyable the concert will be.
trumpetman369 2 years ago
May the Blue Note 7, Charlap & Co thrive and jive forever! The gig at Zellerbach (UofCal) last month was beyond belief!
hutc66 2 years ago
A wonderful combination of some excellent musicians playing a great piece which captured the spirit of Theloniois Monk. Thanks for posting this.
a
gsco82 2 years ago
Going to see them tomorrow night in KC, MO!
telewacked 2 years ago
Heard these guys play in Napa last month, absolutely fucking unreal how good the concert was.
Lahi53 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm a fan of all that
If you wouldn't have spoiled the first 90 seconds with TALKING I wouln't have deleted you
THIS IS SPAM
ankhaton 2 years ago
Blue Note 7 is the fo' shizzle.
Soulnik 2 years ago
yeaaaaaaa
invisiblekid14 2 years ago
Goosh, that'z really one of the dream teams in my head!!!
hongkongjazzdrummer 2 years ago 2