Sinatras voice was beyond amazing. There's something so spectacular about his music that I love. It reminds me of my grandpa. R.I.P. Frank and Grandpa
PLEASE search " Pray For Thailand Let's Start Again USA " on YouTube to watch a video of students supporting Thai flood victims! If it gets alot of views, it will be featured on Thai television!
Help Thailand flood victims by posting this on other videos! Don't forget to thumbs up this comment. :D
They exist so that we can exist!! and be the diference between the most of easy influential people in world :T, and unfortunately they existed, are existing and will exist O.o perhaps worse ;O
Since I was young I loved the voice of frank Sinatra, one of the best singers around :)
I just don't understand why such a pretty music only has 1.7M of views and a horrible music like the Justin Bieber one has like 600M views! That's why I don't want to live on this planet anymore, such a bad taste of music people have now a days o.o
@dogsrule572 Sorry but I belong to those who really dislike Frank Sinatra and his terribly dated music. About "Over the Rainbow" just try Ella Fitzgerald and Sarah Vaughan, they sing it with so much more class and less syrupy violins and without those horrible backing vocals.
@TheRunner75 Terribly dated? Really? Frank was around and popular during the time when the Great American Songbook ruled the world. If he was alive today, he would laugh and shake his head at the current state of the music industry. It's laughable.
cmon guys..the music now isn't bad.. music isn't bad.. never was..but i still preferred music from the past..i just wish more people could cover these kind of songs or more singers with inspirations from the past :) ahh nostalgia :)
It sucks that this kind of music isn't popular as it used to be, I'm 14 and I grew up listening to whatever was "in" at the moment. But I still love the classics no matter the year.
@redjuggler2040 It's not weird at all. It's hard to believe, but I've been around for a very, very long time. Long enough to remember this. I have to admit I miss the days when you could turn on the radio and here him and all his peers singing true music. But, though you might be sad, you have to remember that firstly, there are absolutely true musicians left, you just have to look for them. And secondly, thanks to the magic of the web, you can enjoy this music forever and ever. Good luck, pal.
@edvinasal i listen to Sinatra, i listen to cradle of flith, slipknot, dimmu borgir, tsjuder. i dont give a damn wat other metal heads think of that is just what i am.
When my family and friends ask me if I want anything for my birthday, I always tell them yes......but I can never have it: I want Frank Sinatra do a live show at some tiny saloon in Hoboken before he was famous........it fills me with tremendous sadness and depression that I can never witness such an event.....
This song will always belong to Judy Garland but Sinatra,with his brilliant rendition moves it into an even greater height. I saw two of his performances in person, and I really got to appreciate not only his singingbut his charm and chariand charisma on the stage. H e was a great personality and my all-time favorite singer.
If frank could see what we call "talent" today, I think he would come back and slap everyone in the face. This is music in its purest form and i wish to God that it would just come back!!
I heard a young lady perform this last spring and I was thinking, "That's got to take a lot of guts to perform the song that Judy Garland NAILED." Perhaps even more so a little later in her life than in the movie version. Search her name and song name.
I really like this version by Frank, too, but one of my all time favorite versions by a male artist is by Israel "Iz" Kamakawiwoʻole. His version with 50 million views includes his funeral where they pour his ashes in the ocean.
Im 18 and I can proudly say I love this song. Music today just seems so gloomy. Its so refreshing to hear a song that can make you feel better :) Bring back Sinatra!
Millions of children around the world are dying due to poverty. They don't deserve sadness. They don't deserve wearing nothing if not muddy clothes to protect their chilling, aching hearts w/ their life living in streets. But children deserve happiness & play all day w/ good food to eat & homes to live. LET'S MAKE A DIFFERENCE & HELP THESE CHILDREN. Pls view in YouTube "Over The Rainbow"-Somewhere by 10 yrs old Meagan Gacayan & help spread my message. Your Thumbs up help this message alive.
Ray Charles liked this video so much that he clicked in the like button 28 times, but I think he didn't realize he was clicking in the wrong button...
Frank Sinatra is one of the best singers of all times!!!I hope his music never dies!!!!I will love him forever!!!!!His music is like gold compared to this stupid 21'st centery stuff!!!!
If only we could have taken all the good of that time with us into now instead of leaving the good with the bad, we would be much happier. I wish we could have Frank Sinatra back.
Beautiful, music to listening! Amazing! Now, This song is singing by Michel Botton!!! :( But, I think, Paula Fernandes save this music only this Woman
@CardExPerT101 I only used the like/dislike statistics... assuming that the masses that didn't vote were filled with such a violent rage that they abruptly left the video without voting.
@tunafishjoe So I'm gonna assume you're either a genius or really dumb, in which case you have shown to be the latter, after I round off for no apparent reason. Just giving you the 'benefit of the doubt'.
25 people are... stupid! Can I have a Top Comment now instead of someone who came up with an intelligent or witty comment that actually relates to the music?! :D
dobro je,bas je dobro :)
MrBajpas 15 hours ago
It kills me when I'm reminded that I can't watch the greatest musican of all time live... I think I could cry!
idiotguy003 3 days ago
Sinatras voice was beyond amazing. There's something so spectacular about his music that I love. It reminds me of my grandpa. R.I.P. Frank and Grandpa
4EvMetal 4 days ago
no man compare him,, even buble
methuseluth12 6 days ago
this mans voice makes me wet no homo :P
Lei1911 1 week ago
@Lei1911 WOW! Not to be rude, That's a dumb comment.
cwcwful 1 week ago 2
I think it's Charlie Chaplin's theme song
anarbatzoriganar 1 week ago
I can't stop listening. It's so magical
DebsTasha45 2 weeks ago
really beautiful
leolennon1604 2 weeks ago
To jak nie rozumiecie to wam jeszcze po Polsku dopisze żebyście trudniej mieli a języków trzeba się uczyć
smokeeater998 2 weeks ago 2
what does a pimple have to do with this?
KiaraRoxATT246 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Listen to my cover please!! I hope u find it good!!
watch?v=vy5hvTlAY6s
Thanks... :)
unitom13 1 month ago
34 people didnt go over the rainbow
LadyCowbell 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE search " Pray For Thailand Let's Start Again USA " on YouTube to watch a video of students supporting Thai flood victims! If it gets alot of views, it will be featured on Thai television!
Help Thailand flood victims by posting this on other videos! Don't forget to thumbs up this comment. :D
Pray for Thailand! <3
Shark1150 1 month ago
They exist so that we can exist!! and be the diference between the most of easy influential people in world :T, and unfortunately they existed, are existing and will exist O.o perhaps worse ;O
alanzeus 1 month ago
Since I was young I loved the voice of frank Sinatra, one of the best singers around :)
I just don't understand why such a pretty music only has 1.7M of views and a horrible music like the Justin Bieber one has like 600M views! That's why I don't want to live on this planet anymore, such a bad taste of music people have now a days o.o
bokocrew 1 month ago 8
34 people listen to justin biber and have 0 taste in REAL music
EvilGas 1 month ago 4
i love this song reminds me of my childhood simplier time
emilytonyterri 1 month ago
SALAD FINGERS XD
alexandraa1313 2 months ago
He was the best and still is !
MrFrenchaccent 2 months ago
parecce un tanguero italoamericano
TheMrZk 2 months ago
@TheMrZk ni en pedo, parece un musico estadounidense XD
MrTargumon 2 weeks ago
If only i were older and i had lived and known him when he still was there.
Dominodosjoub 2 months ago
32 people are slipknot fans :D LOL
privategun 2 months ago
@privategun I'm a slipknot fan and I love this song :P
crais61 2 months ago 7
@privategun degrading comment, very sad... I'm a metal fan, but also love Sinatra.
nahing 2 months ago 5
How could anyone not like this!
A classic!!frank was the best with an amazing voice!
rosabaca21 2 months ago
So charming, so sweet...
MmeOttoni 2 months ago
@therunner75 you don't know what good music is obviously
bigmanewilson 2 months ago 4
30 people have no wings so they cant fly
MrPsyg0 2 months ago 4
love it
pashtel 2 months ago
i just want to dream when i hear his music.
asmile949 3 months ago in playlist Music!
Doesn't Frank's voice makes you want to float?
Mac6274 3 months ago
I don't understand how someone could dislike this
dogsrule572 3 months ago in playlist Frank Sinatra Playlist
@dogsrule572 Sorry but I belong to those who really dislike Frank Sinatra and his terribly dated music. About "Over the Rainbow" just try Ella Fitzgerald and Sarah Vaughan, they sing it with so much more class and less syrupy violins and without those horrible backing vocals.
TheRunner75 2 months ago
@TheRunner75 Terribly dated? Really? Frank was around and popular during the time when the Great American Songbook ruled the world. If he was alive today, he would laugh and shake his head at the current state of the music industry. It's laughable.
DarkCloud126 2 months ago
@TheRunner75 wow i'm sure if you knew anything about music you'd know that is man's music is class
iamdifferent1000 2 months ago
I am 22 And i really Apriciatte Music Like This, Or Louis, Eva, Dean... There is nothing like this today!
ackonish89 3 months ago
There should a 1940/50s themed christmas music video with this song playing over it, that would be wonderful! :D
xQueenOfHearts123 3 months ago 3
cmon guys..the music now isn't bad.. music isn't bad.. never was..but i still preferred music from the past..i just wish more people could cover these kind of songs or more singers with inspirations from the past :) ahh nostalgia :)
MrOldestPerson 3 months ago
Fuck rihana Frank come over her boiiiii
MrHuglz 3 months ago 3
The best song ever with the best voice ever... awesome :D
jairofloress 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Frank Sinatra
29 people can't see the rainbow...
jimnomercy 3 months ago 3
Im only 13 but i felt like i missed the best age of music...a age where real voices shone through the music and auto tune was never discovered
preazike1 3 months ago 6
Over the Rainbow Caroll ♥ Fabrizio 4 EVER !!!
MrFubine 3 months ago
It sucks that this kind of music isn't popular as it used to be, I'm 14 and I grew up listening to whatever was "in" at the moment. But I still love the classics no matter the year.
TheMayhemOfTheWorld 3 months ago
Only a true bad-ass like Frank Sinatra could pull off wearing a hat inside.
ZackMyslinski 3 months ago in playlist Zack's Playlist
Frank did Judy justice both associated with the rat pack , he did the song justice his silky warm voice just like Judy's warm and vibrant.
cinderelmo 3 months ago
Great song
mikeyco89 3 months ago
ol blue eyes.. u r the best now and forever!
BasedLegendd 3 months ago
Damn! What a voice! Frank RULES.
Gabriiel94 3 months ago
WOW........A voice made in heaven.
alondrag28 3 months ago
Is it weird that I feel sad, like I've missed the train of true musicians, as a young man?
redjuggler2040 3 months ago in playlist JakB001's Favorited Videos
@redjuggler2040 It's not weird at all. It's hard to believe, but I've been around for a very, very long time. Long enough to remember this. I have to admit I miss the days when you could turn on the radio and here him and all his peers singing true music. But, though you might be sad, you have to remember that firstly, there are absolutely true musicians left, you just have to look for them. And secondly, thanks to the magic of the web, you can enjoy this music forever and ever. Good luck, pal.
jrgorilla1 3 months ago
I listen to Sinatra, I listen to Gaga and don't give a damn what others thinks.
edvinasal 3 months ago
@edvinasal i listen to Sinatra, i listen to cradle of flith, slipknot, dimmu borgir, tsjuder. i dont give a damn wat other metal heads think of that is just what i am.
darkchtulupk 3 months ago
i'm 17 and i now love 50's music. it's not autotuned or nothing it's their actual voice that's what i love.
amatureactor92 3 months ago 3
Frank is over the rainbow now!
Vahki100 3 months ago
Music has died.... Owl City??? FML
KamikazeScarecrows 3 months ago
Vídeo recomendado: REVELACION NO EXISTE LA MUERTE
gallinitaciegav 3 months ago
When my family and friends ask me if I want anything for my birthday, I always tell them yes......but I can never have it: I want Frank Sinatra do a live show at some tiny saloon in Hoboken before he was famous........it fills me with tremendous sadness and depression that I can never witness such an event.....
StupidLamb251 3 months ago 74
@StupidLamb251 Dont be depress...go to a justin beaber concert!
Rundm3p 2 weeks ago
This song will always belong to Judy Garland but Sinatra,with his brilliant rendition moves it into an even greater height. I saw two of his performances in person, and I really got to appreciate not only his singingbut his charm and chariand charisma on the stage. H e was a great personality and my all-time favorite singer.
gyniest 4 months ago 2
Although I am 100% Judy Garland when it comes to this song, I do love Frankie's version.
ImInBetween 4 months ago
If frank could see what we call "talent" today, I think he would come back and slap everyone in the face. This is music in its purest form and i wish to God that it would just come back!!
SassyCass1507 4 months ago
Sinatra is a legend!
15swampthing 4 months ago
It sounds like a Disney song, maybe Christmas special
MrHPPF 4 months ago 108
@MrHPPF from TOm & Jerry ;)
SmirnoFF1225 3 months ago
@MrHPPF The wizard from Oz.
Robbobgray 1 month ago
@MrHPPF I forgive you.
2011littlejohn1 1 month ago
@2011littlejohn1 Why do you forgive me????
MrHPPF 1 month ago
@MrHPPF yeah and like old cartoons, music was good back there thats why
Migas128 1 month ago
@MrHPPF in espanish please
m4n3xg3nu4 2 weeks ago
@MrHPPF i dont understan
m4n3xg3nu4 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i just dont understand how this can be disliked, i mean, HELLOOOOO!? ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR FUCKING MIND!?
rosacutiepie86 4 months ago
Now I just wanna go back in time, just to see him perform in an club and just to see how the people lived then ;)
princessx3jona 4 months ago 3
Only one word comes to mnd when I hear him sing this song: Amazing!!!
racecarruss 4 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG IS MY FAVORITEE!
ldr98 4 months ago
I heard a young lady perform this last spring and I was thinking, "That's got to take a lot of guts to perform the song that Judy Garland NAILED." Perhaps even more so a little later in her life than in the movie version. Search her name and song name.
I really like this version by Frank, too, but one of my all time favorite versions by a male artist is by Israel "Iz" Kamakawiwoʻole. His version with 50 million views includes his funeral where they pour his ashes in the ocean.
MountainMan41 4 months ago
like being old with all the benifits
nysurfer727 4 months ago
Free you tube is all i need
nysurfer727 4 months ago
Classic Song + Frank Sinatra Vocals = Absolute Perfection.
caitob32207 4 months ago
BEST...SINATRA SONG...EVER!
timcarbone007 4 months ago
29 people what don't like are crazzy.. no know the music good.
LukasOFICIAL 4 months ago 2
i like all the versions
zpeedrunner 4 months ago
Heavenly!
beatlequeen06 4 months ago
I haven't actually been born yet and I still love this music so much more than Justin Bieber and all the other modern day stuff.
yehudalindowmagician 4 months ago
@yehudalindowmagician Its called having good taste. :)
sysanlots 4 months ago
Dislike maybe Thislike. ^^
deviltarnza 4 months ago in playlist Over the Rainbow
The 29 people that dislike this are to young to understand true music and have had their brains spoiled by Rebecca Black and Justin Bieber :]
EmilyDeets 4 months ago 2
Im 18 and I can proudly say I love this song. Music today just seems so gloomy. Its so refreshing to hear a song that can make you feel better :) Bring back Sinatra!
MrFireupchips 4 months ago
Doing homework is actually enjoyable when you listen to Sinatra :)
kevintothe11 4 months ago
I wanna live their time...such a magical years
UnitedPlovdiv 4 months ago 3
Millions of children around the world are dying due to poverty. They don't deserve sadness. They don't deserve wearing nothing if not muddy clothes to protect their chilling, aching hearts w/ their life living in streets. But children deserve happiness & play all day w/ good food to eat & homes to live. LET'S MAKE A DIFFERENCE & HELP THESE CHILDREN. Pls view in YouTube "Over The Rainbow"-Somewhere by 10 yrs old Meagan Gacayan & help spread my message. Your Thumbs up help this message alive.
TheMeaganda 4 months ago in playlist somewhere over the rainbow 5
THE VOICE lives on
buckbangerful 4 months ago 3
Awesome version.........
irazzaf 4 months ago 3
Brilliant song... but there is nothing that will ever come even close the beautiful perfection of Judy Garland's voice. <3
FleetStreetPhantom17 4 months ago
@FleetStreetPhantom17 Frank could, and Frank did.
guitarhero1346 4 months ago 4
@FleetStreetPhantom17 - ouça a versão de Israel "IZ" Kamakawiwoole
PaulM5171 4 months ago
THUMBS UP FOR THE BEATLES AND FRANK SINATRA
porchthebeatles842 4 months ago 6
He should have played Dorothy.
QuantumZebra 4 months ago 6
You're the man, Frank!
70sCher 4 months ago 6
Anyone have Bing Crosby doing it?
miketallica665 4 months ago
pure voice... why can't we have this music now...
meritz59 4 months ago 102
@meritz59 because there is NO talent now a days.
heats1 4 months ago
we do. as a matter of fact even a broader selection than back then, you're just not looking in the right places :)
Zickestzam 4 months ago
@meritz59
For the same reason we don't wear olden day clothes.
Natural evolution.
Bigboomar 3 months ago
@Bigboomar By the way we dress today.... I wouldn't say evolution....
Historicaladdicted 3 months ago
@Historicaladdicted
Hahah, good point.
Bigboomar 3 months ago
3,259 likes, 28 dislikes
lennartkns 4 months ago
Beautiful! I would have to subscribe to anyone and everyone who is a fan of old blue eyes. "Simply the Best."
kcsfann 5 months ago
28 people got lost on the other side of the rainbow...
libbylit 5 months ago 5
You can hear the beautiful melody of this song when Frank Sinatra sings it.
nleytman 5 months ago
Whoever disliked this is stupid they dont know real music when they hear it....
coolfunnygirl123 5 months ago
Ray Charles liked this video so much that he clicked in the like button 28 times, but I think he didn't realize he was clicking in the wrong button...
Skkaparenvalla 5 months ago
What a classic! Great job, thanks for sharing it.
labsrus1 5 months ago
No one has ever, or will ever compete with Franks voice. He was in my eyes, the best to happen to music. Ever
Burtybearr 5 months ago 2
Ahh his voice still give me butterflies and still find myself sighing after it was over like a little school girl <3
danigrl1217 5 months ago 2
if i had a voice like this.......
nikliebster 5 months ago
@L4LEGEND I know what you mean:/, i'm only 15, and i love stars like louis armstrong, judy garland etc......
DebsTasha45 5 months ago
I feel like back in 70's. Thank you Frank Sinatra
RaciouS91 5 months ago
@RaciouS91 This was way before 70's son
UrANoobGtfo 5 months ago
@UrANoobGtfo really? I was born 90's :P
RaciouS91 5 months ago
@UrANoobGtfo Lol yeah, it's more like the 40's
ItsLeanneHunny 5 months ago
ive always wished i lived in these decades....im 16 :(
L4LEGEND 5 months ago 5
Agreed 100%. I'm 19 and what I would give to see this man
youslydevil 5 months ago
God, I wish I could do that...
MOTACJ 5 months ago 4
28 peoples speakers are broken.
BoLTGaming 5 months ago 5
/drools/
333333Spectrum 5 months ago
28 people are lacking a real life lol.
ShroudedFury 5 months ago 2
gorgeous
bollxd 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬(ஜ۩۞۩ஜ)▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬(ஜ۩۞۩ஜ)▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
619kade 5 months ago
i jus found out this song was sinatra and i feel dumb cause now its so obvious
ckchico 5 months ago
26 people were probably looking for a rainbow but got caught in a thunderstorm
TheAzharuddin 5 months ago
I absolutely love when the like bar looks like a blade of grass.
jmcrack12 5 months ago
Now this is music!
bradgandy02 5 months ago
My Mother sang this to me x
marpahela 5 months ago
I can't stand people making dislike jokes all the time
Just shut up and enjoy the music
Gandyware 5 months ago 7
Comment removed
jmcrack12 5 months ago
like this if u cant see the dislike bar
14kack14 5 months ago 6
This has no Audio for me and almost everything else does ...
signaturehelper 5 months ago
25 people are going to hell and under the rainbow.
Black675430 5 months ago 6
one of the countless versions of the song.....
MightyFartBomber1 5 months ago
gorgeous.......... :)
energizerbunnyspaz 5 months ago
such a difference in his voice from old and young.
yet still good both ways
Gill601 5 months ago
Everytime i hear Sinatra sing my heart stops a bit . What a voice .
DameHollywood 5 months ago 2
Some songs just never die. Thumbs up if you agree with me.
dbratoff 5 months ago 234
Frank Sinatra is one of the best singers of all times!!!I hope his music never dies!!!!I will love him forever!!!!!His music is like gold compared to this stupid 21'st centery stuff!!!!
1800joemama 5 months ago 3
Ol' blue eyes :D
SgtTraceur 5 months ago
If only we could have taken all the good of that time with us into now instead of leaving the good with the bad, we would be much happier. I wish we could have Frank Sinatra back.
MrSurfingdreamer 5 months ago
i think i came when i heard sinatras voice..
6mustangs 5 months ago
Comment removed
6mustangs 5 months ago
i love this version of this amazing song..
misscherrymarie 6 months ago
Was Frankie boy too young when this song was recorded? His voice sounds different, why is that? age or something?
luckynbloody 6 months ago
@luckynbloody, he changed his voice to fit in with the tone of the song
hipcrio2 6 months ago
Wow.
jamesluc256 6 months ago
Beautiful, music to listening! Amazing! Now, This song is singing by Michel Botton!!! :( But, I think, Paula Fernandes save this music only this Woman
Gabrielaestu 6 months ago
Beautiful, music to listening! Amazing! Now, This son is singing by Michel Botton!!! :( But, I think, Paula Fernandes save this music only this Woman
Gabrielaestu 6 months ago
i'm very emotioned hearing this artist
massimiliano1988 6 months ago
Beautiful.... simply beautiful!
bree1878 6 months ago in playlist somewhere over the rainbow
Awww Frankie <3
fenderguitargirl 6 months ago
Too fast for my taste but I still like Sinatra a lot, among the best.
Zarenthar 6 months ago
I like how Frank did a completely different rendition from the original Ray Charles' version, really gives the song a breath of fresh air. Golden.
Mootinie1 6 months ago
@Mootinie1 Ray Charles didn't write this...
supu6 6 months ago
it's not techniques, it's the natural timbre of his voice.. something that mother nature has endowed him. Superb.
hansquad 6 months ago
legend!
TGSM19 6 months ago
25 trouxas
masterlalala 6 months ago
Damn it just made me love Sinatra even more!
Sinatra Forever man!
AcesVideos132 6 months ago
i love this song! this man was a genius!<3 God bless him :(
georgiromanian 6 months ago
.00000194% of people that have watched this didn't enjoy it. That makes me think the world isn't such a bad place after all.
halfbakedlamma 7 months ago 157
@halfbakedlamma I hope you're not an engineer with those mathematical skills of yours O.o
V6MattGW 5 months ago
@halfbakedlamma It's more like .8%. That's more like 1 in 100. That's a lot.
tunafishjoe 4 months ago
@tunafishjoe Dislikes divided by the views. Not everyone clicks the like button.
halfbakedlamma 4 months ago
@tunafishjoe How does your math work??
CardExPerT101 4 months ago
@CardExPerT101 I only used the like/dislike statistics... assuming that the masses that didn't vote were filled with such a violent rage that they abruptly left the video without voting.
tunafishjoe 4 months ago
@tunafishjoe Then where would you put those who had no opinion on the video? oh and by the way, 0.8% is less than 1 in 100. 1% is 1 in 100.
CardExPerT101 4 months ago
@CardExPerT101 I just assumed everyone either hated it or loved it. And yeah, I was just rounding up... giving them the benefit of the doubt.
tunafishjoe 4 months ago
@tunafishjoe So I'm gonna assume you're either a genius or really dumb, in which case you have shown to be the latter, after I round off for no apparent reason. Just giving you the 'benefit of the doubt'.
CardExPerT101 4 months ago
@tunafishjoe I didn't vote because, of course I liked it. How could anybody not? What's the point of voting when you know the result already?
rohricwl 4 months ago
25 people are... stupid! Can I have a Top Comment now instead of someone who came up with an intelligent or witty comment that actually relates to the music?! :D
LordSperith 7 months ago