Added: 2 months ago
From: TheXFactorUSA
Views: 144,885
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (251)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • don't fucking worry. rachel got a record deal with Columbia Records and a show on Nick. She's probably gonna be bigger than Melanie.

  • I can't beleve she got voted of

  • 1:11 it sounds like steve the host said heared instead of heard!!! LOL :)

  • Nicole knew since that moment it was gonna be tough for her :( but yeah guys!! is not her fault and she didnt even said she doesnt wanted rachel she just "send her home" to make it a draw, and America could decide. she never imagine all the hate she would receive.

  • OMG <3 2:30 that was so sweet what rachel said to marcusss awww big brother and little sister

  • She has amazing talent. You guys don't gotta hate on Nicole anyways, cause we all know Rachel is gonna go far no matter eliminated or not.

  • i vote the host off

  • Her break down was so disturbing, didn't want to hear from her last night on the show's finale. That was so ugly. Her and Astro really blew it! The kid fans are forgiving, but adults will remember all of your follery and be leary of you in the future...

  • you know, it's actually better that rachel was voted off. she'll have all kinds of opportunities waiting for her. if she'd won, she'd've been stuck with whatever deal they gave her.

  • VOTE4MEL.VOTE4MEL.VOTE4MEL.VOT­E4MEL.VOTE4MEL.VOTE4MEL.VOTE4M­EL.VOTE4MEL.VOTE4MEL.VOTE4MEL.­VOTE4MEL.

  • No need to be upset, Rachel is going nowhere. She'll be back on stage for sure, I believe that for a fact. It was definitely a shocker though, I was voting for Marcus and man, I was surprised for sure. Best wishes to the final three.

  • A Love is Melanie

  • MARCUS IS THE ONLY ENTERTAINER ON THIS SHOW..

  • Omg Melanie is in the Bottom 3!! I hope that she's safe again tomorrow night. I know that Marcus is going,

  • Marcus debio irse y punto, Rachel es mas cantante.

  • It went to deadlock. The "nation" decided. Rachel received the lowest number of votes of the five contestents and hence she went home.

  • This reminds me of American Idol, where they voted out Chris Daughtry and Taylor won.(fyi he hasn't sold any albums so far only commercial for last YEARS) I'm sorry, but i honestly don't think Marcus will make it.

  • @MizSalena X-Factor is better than American Idol and more popular (In the latest years) !! Especially after the US version !! But in 2000 - 2005 Idol was better !! IMO

  • Marcus sucks.

  • Even Simon and Paula have used dead locks before on talent shows they've done/ Simon may not have used it yet in this show, but he has gone to deadlock on the UK x factor before. So dont just bash Nicole. Almost all judges have used it to these competition or will use it . If it wasn't supposed to be used then they should never of added that as an option Then the judges wouldn't have it to call upon if they dont want to say no to some young kid. Rachel isnt in because you all didnt vote

  • Look, Marcus Canty won't sell when he goes out of X Factor. IMO You can hate if you want, that is my opinion that's all.

    The only thing keeping him in the competition are the judges who feel he has honesty. I think others have honesty as well, so he doesn't really have much. He's always in Bottom Two so sooner or later he'd be out.

    Rachel... it's The X Factor's loss anyway. She's going to be bigger than most of them anyways.

  • why's Marcus so surprise he's in the bottom two again?

  • If Marcus is so amazing then why has he been in the bottom two for the past THREE WEEKS ?

  • @xoitssteresaaxo True, but he came out a conquerer each of those three weeks. So, someone believes in him. I was one of those. Loved him, but I loved all the contestants. A good cast.

  • @xoitssteresaaxo to let him sing more and get more experience, thats why...

  • At least, Nicole should have let Rachel go to Top 4, it's fair for her, poor little girl.

  • What's the name of the HOST??? ty

  • la didnt vote for the best. he voted fot his own. nicole is another story. I f she cant make a discision then she shouldnt be a judge.

  • @djganew I totally agree with you! she can't make a decision of her own.

  • What is the sence of having a sing off if the judges are not voting for the best. Racheal outsang marcus.

  • they just shouldn't put children in the show. they do NOT know how to handle it. at all.

  • people who aren't on the show take this show way to serious.

  • Even if both Marcus and Rachel were gone at this point . They'd both still be making deals in the future for albums. Anyone in the finals has a chance to begin their careers in show biz. Astro is one example. He left the show because they offered him a contract to begin right away making his albums. . She may of been crying now but she'll be smiling again in the future. I do like how she said she loved Marcus anyways.

  • Josh is actually the most talented

  • @babymonkey2 Then don't pass the blame. ;)

  • @blueknightez in no particular order. :) so it may not be the case. ^^

  • Comment removed

  • RELAX people rachel would have gone home SOONER or LATER.........

  • @mrchineseraccoon I know.. the final three would've been the same even If Drew or Rachel stayed !! But I wanted Rachel to be in the semi-final (At least 2 more performances from her) !!

  • when rachel teared, i was tearing up too ):

  • People!! It's not Marcus' fault he's saved evrytime. I'm sure he doesnt want to be in that position. Who would want to be bottom 2 evrytime! STOP THE HATE!

  • @charliewantsfood well he wouldn't be in the bottom two if he didn't suck .

  • VOTE FOR MELANIE !

  • I can't believe Rachel went home. This is Marcus 3rd time to be in top 2 urghh.. ...

  • Guess what? It is a voting competition. Every week someone is going to go home until there is only one person left. Deal with it.

  • Last I checked Nicole can feel however she wants and say whatever she wants. She is a JUDGE on the show. If you don't like her opinion that's really so sad for you. You haven't been in the industry selling millions of records for 10+ years so cut it out. I swear people only love Rachel Crow so much because of her age and personality. This is a TALENT competition. SMH

  • @whocaresatallxxx buth she had opionion: both are equal, let america decide. she had the right to do it! like simon earlier

  • seriously? talent ... marcus has talent?! YE BOTTOM TWO AGAIN? COZ HE'S GOT NO TALENT.. COMPARED TO ANYONE ELSE... the judges are the idiots who keep getting back at each other and look like kids fighting over

  • @whocaresatallxxx It is a talent competition and Rachel was clearly more talented than Marcus in the sing-off. Nicole should have instantly recognized that as a professional and actually did her job. As a judge she should have at least given an honest opinion but she couldn't even do that. She also had Dexter singing a Britney Spears song, so I suppose her stupidity doesn't surprise me.

  • @whocaresatallxxx No you see you got it all wrong. You say Nicole is a judge, but she is weeping every time she needs to make a decision. She didn't vote for Marcus because she thought he was better but to avoid making a decision. See the video of her deciding, crying "Oh I can't I can't bohoo" making it all about herself.

    I was never crazy about Rachel's personality and don't care that much about kids. But that girl sings with the soul, depth and emotions most adult musicians can dream of.

  • @whocaresatallxxx But if Nicole was a decent judge, she would JUDGE instead of letting America make the hard decisions.

  • @whocaresatallxxx rachel did have talent. ya she is 13 but for a 13 yr old she has ALOT of talent. im 13 and i cant even sing happy birthday :)

  • @whocaresatallxxx if shes a "JUDGE" then she needs to be able to make decisions, Marcus is always on the bottom 2 was an easy choice. oh and btw dont tell me you are that naive to say that only talented people sell records nowadays, i mean nicole=pussycatdolls=videoclip­s with no cloths on =money. one thing for sure i doubt Simon will invt her again, if she doesnt want to make decisions then leave

  • @whocaresatallxxx LOL !! So you're saying that Marcus is more talented than Rachel ??!

    I love Rachel because of EVERYTHING !! Also just because Nicole was selling millions of records doesn't mean that she is a professional judge !! She said that herself !!

  • @whocaresatallxxx Not to mention that big voice and talent and she's only 13 ;) !! Just imagine how her skills and voice could be 3 or 4 years later...

  • @whocaresatallxxx totally agree with u

  • @whocaresatallxxx umm rachel is so talented she can sing so idk what ur tl=alking about!! ans yes she is a JUDGE which means she need to be professional ans not cry everytime she needs to make a decision!!! selling records has nothing to do with judging soo why dont you just stfu rachel was so much better in the sing off then marcus and nicole should of saw it an been professional i love nicole but if shes gunna cry everytime she shouldnt be a judge!! love you rachel<3

  • @whocaresatallxxx that lil girl has more talent than u will ever have booboo

  • its obvious that 'Melanie' will win the x factor 2011 why else would Simon bring her back ?-.-

  • @StayInMyMemoryx I'M NOT COUNTING MY CHRIS RENE OUT ! HE IS THE DARK HORSE !

  • MARCUS. i hate you. he's always smiling like its no big deal. ugh, RACHEL SHOULDN'T HAVE GONE HOME.

  • not like rachel or marcus even have a chance they should have sent them both home and just give the win the Josh already!

  • Rachaels last performance the night before was not as good as marcus's last performance I thought, they say you are only as good as your last performance, unfortunately Nicole made a poor decision when it's part of her job to send someone home, especially when rachael clearly should have stayed - CHRIS RENE has the whole x factor, go Chris, u are going to win this thing, we love u from new Zealand xx

  • I lost intrest after astro went

  • god when she broke down and cried it was heartbreaking i dont think she thought shed go considering marcus was in the bottom twice before.

  • i'm from Croatia and i've been watching this whole show...i just can't believe that America votes rather for Chris Rene than Rachel or Marcus, and i know what I'm talking about because i'm in music business for a while now.

    Chris Rene is not bad, but he will not sell as many records as Rachel or Marcus and he's definitely not as interesting and lovable as Rachel...c'mon people this kid got the X FACTOR.

  • @rupatg69 i am GENUINELY not trying to be mean or negative, but i believe that chris rene WILL sell many, many, many records. in america especially, his type of music is really relevant and emotional and his story relates to what a lot of people are going through (drug abuse). chris may not be a cute teenage girl or a fresh young guy with slick dance moves, but hes got a real passion and hes very, very talented at writing his own music. CHRIS RENE HAS GOT THE X FACTOR<3 so VOTE PLEASE

  • @chatterboxleah maybe the market in USA is different than this in Europe..but i tell you Rachel will be known and respected world wide

  • @rupatg69 Your wrong , absolutele wrong...Poor comment

  • thank god, no way she would make it, chris rene needs to win this!

  • look the Rachel Glance at 0:35, because he said : Nicole !

  • 2:08 ... marcus, u scared me:O

  • Don't hate on Marcus. The people didn't vote for Rachael. Marcus is my favorite, but i'll miss Rachael.

  • i think the decision must be given all to the voters and none for the judges because the voters knows what pure talent is and not those selfish judges..

  • @JhingObz how come you did not vote for rachel???? the decision to send rachel home was made by you voters not nicole. stop hating on the judges and vote for the contestants.

  • true we saw it with idol if u dont vote they leave.. and i said chric reane is in from the pitty votes i supportt the cause of getting better and change but stepoutside yourself and know as soon as that peson isnt watching him he will go back.. the MIGHT DOLLAR RULES..and lord knows if he wins its a wrap

  • and people in the world young and old who knows the business and dont that is my point of course rachel is gonna make it but shes not ready yet.

  • the host is hot.

  • I don't normally watch this show. I just saw the crying fit on the morning news. So I decided to watch both her and Marcus' songs on Youtube. The only difference is Marcus is more current. Singing hip hop sells! Rachel can sing but her voice wavers a bit off key and has pitch issues. But both reaked of desperation in their songs. Her crying fit looked like a Pageant brat "mommy you promised..." It showed that she is not ready for the gross misfortunes of the music industry.

  • I am so sick of these comments!

    Marcus Canty and Rachel Crow were both in the bottom 2 because of the people who didn't vote.

    These beautiful people have every right to be in the top 5, they earnt it.

    Blaming Nicole doesn't bring Rachel back. She left the decision to America. Plus, what's the bet that she cries at every elimination from now on?

    These people are artists, they all get along with the competition. Marcus refers to Rachel and Drew as his little sisters. Falsehate.

    JUST VOTE!

  • @jazzmineafitux some times people think someone is too good n safe, that why we have judges. I LOVE: MARCUS's personality, RACHEL's positive side+deep voice at a young age and Drew's uniqueness in the music industry. I also LOVE Nicole as an singer, as an artist and as an artist, but not as an judge. very sorry Nicole. (everyone has to admist, people at something, but not all) Frankly, Nicole is not gd as a judge (though I lover her), even I can call a tie (it's easy). lets face the fact 

  • @pplove214 sorry the computer has some problem, I'll post again

  • @jazzmineafitux yeah but NICOLES job is to be a judge thats why shes there therefore she fail to do her job and thats why she ssuucckkss

  • @jazzmineafitux well said

  • @jazzmineafitux AGREE

  • @jazzmineafitux Preach, lol

  • definitely stupid for blaming nicole

  • He can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't singHe can't sing he can't sing

  • sooo next week Marcus will go home :I then Chris *sorry if you like him D:*:I last two will be Melanie and Josh....i hope Melanie wins though <3

  • I AM SO EXCITED TO SEE RACHEL GO HOME YIKES :)

  • love nicole you've wrong but i love you by italy !

  • please change the judges ..

  • It wasn't Nicole's fault at all, she coudn't make a decision because herself had gone through a talent contest and knows what being htere feels like. She thought the puclib would choose Rachel and she left it to deadlock. We all could see in everyone's face this was not the result we all hoped, but it's not Nicole's fault, it's America's fault for not voting for her and taking her for granted.

  • Marcus,  God is not through with you yet. Know that God's favor beats man's approval on any given day. Your character and resilience are awesome. But your voice is what's going to take you places. Forget the haters and press on to your destiny.

  • wow all of u bashing marcus like he needed to go home: he can sing slow and fast songs, and he can dance.....multitalented right? can rachel do that? Rachel is talented too with a voice like that coming out from a lil girl either way she would have gotten signed

  • I watched this program hoping the judges would stop competing with each other and focus not just on the best singer, but the singer with the most X FACTOR! They forgot the title of their own show. Simon, be there for Rachel....you know the dark place she's heading for.

    Maybe all the judges can check their ego at the door and come together (without Nicole) and fix this mess. As for me, I'm gone until you get it right!

  • Wow, that little girl is an old soul - so humble, mature, kind and talented. I don't even know how to chose - Josh and Chris are SO different, but equally talented. M & M are really good, (Marcus is just adorable!), I just don't think they are as unique as J & C, and The X factor is all about bringing something new and unique to the table. Here's an idea - maybe people commenting can stop being so cruel & rude! I can't believe some of the immature comments - mean people suck :(

  • Marcus always smiles no matter what. I like this guy's positive attitude! :D

  • I think Simon really sucks as a judge in this show. He is so biased. ACTUALLY ALL of them are biased. This show is basically Judge VS Judge trying to get there singer through >_> That's why this show sucks.

  • guys it's not nicole's fault it's your guys fault for not voting for her. She even said that she thought that Marcus was going to be out from the deadlock so she didn't want to be the one saying it. I don't even think Marcus or Rachel are going to win anyway.

  • Who the hell is voting on x factor!!!! Marcus has nothing on Rachel!!! And Nicole Grrrrrrrrr you should be off the show. If you can't judge get the hell off!!!!

  • no good ... Marcus Canty had to leave

  • People are saying thay Nicole thought Marcus would go home, but you shouldn't assume AND if she thought that, she should of just sent him home.

  • American voters wake up lots of talents are going one by one come on Rachel deserve to stay

  • Every week and she's very arrogant. I don't understand why marcus is in the bottom 2 all the time, he's the best performer, rachels very talented for her age, chris is very talented, writing his own songs and playing guitar and Josh is probably the most genuine of them all.

  • I don't like Melanie, I don't think she that amazing, yeah she has a good voice, but she's boring, she sings slow sings

  • @Nuttydoglover crap

  • i love rachel i am so sad she was eliminated

  • Marcus really surprises me,when it comes to judges they vote for him,when it comes to DEADLOCK ,there goes Marcus,I LIKE HIM.

  • Let's put it this way Melanie has the best voice/ Marcus I would go to see in concert/ Chris I would by his album just for the lyrics/ and Josh umm not so sure he good just not the kind of style I'm into

  • Marcus deserves more credit than he gets i mean the man has been in the bottom 3 times and he always comes out strong and sings his heart out he never gives up

  • lol love the way Marcus said in the bottom 2 again !!!

  • rachel is so strong ... she' awesome

  • You gotta love Marcus tho.. not just that he sings good but he has a great strong spirit!

  • Comment removed

  • RACHEL♥ :'(

  • Marcus will be remembered as 'the bottom two guy' on the fist x factor usa.....

    ;\

  • oh American!

  • Chris will win :) !!

  • WOO MELANIE!. but they better put rachel marcus is ok but not as good at rachel and the fact he's still in bottom 2 shows he's not workin to potential but rachel is

  • if marcus was in the bottom two again, people obviously want him to go home ...

  • last week was Drew now's Rachel... >.<

  • @monalizza89 i know ryte...:'(

  • Dont you just hate the adverts!! :@

  • NO more Rachel Crow NO x factor usa for me

  • @sonic50116able really? there's still Disney for you i guess

  • @sonic50116able same way that i felt when drew went home...

  • @sonic50116able i lost intrest after astro went.

  • Melanie is my SoFlo gurlll!!! She lives like 5 miles away from me!! Why the hell was Rachel sent home?!?! Marcus been in the bottom 3 weeks in a row!! Usher wannabe! Don't gt me wrong he can sing but 3 times is 1 too many! I'm surprised Chris went through bt he was gud!

  • He is a usher wannabe

  • @AVERYOBRYAN just because marcus looks like usher, dosent mean hes a wannabe of him. grow up.

  • Melanie Amaro!!!!!!!!

  • @SlightlyBlitzd I disagree. It is about vocals and everybody can't sing. Chris Rene is like a shade tree mechanic or a jack of all trades. He can do a lot of things but none really well. When I hear a song on the radio that I like, it's the vocals that gets my attention. I could care less who wrote it

  • Marcus out, please :( :/

  • chris renee doesnt have vocals like all the other acts.

  • @Ashleymw1224 its not about vocals...anyone can sing...its about originality and being an artist...and thats wat chris rene does have

  • @Ashleymw1224 THANK YOU! Finally someone else sees what i see!

  • Why does MArcus keep ending up in the bottom two? I think he's amazing!

  • 1st -Melanie

    2nd-Josh

    3rd- Chris (even I dun wish to)

    4th- Marcus

  • @kyo1223 chris rene is best :)

  • Comment removed

  • Now, it will an adult fight!!

    No more crying babies!!

  • NICOLE...if you can read this... When I saw you cry in X-Factor today, it just broke my heart... Its not your fault that Rachel Crow got eliminated, the fans should have voted more... Pls don't blame yourself...

  • I feel bad for both of them :(

  • Marcus hands down should have gone home. I still don't understand how Chris is there... Melanie and Josh all the way!

  • @SandraBeatlesFan1963 Are you serious? Chris is the only contestant left i'd pay money to see. Melanie is a great singer, but Very boring, maybe that's simon's fault. Marcus i think is a great entertainer.. Josh has a great voice for Ballads like Melanie.. Boring...

  • If she thought he was going home then its her fault she didnt just say so she is a wimp she has no balls and therefore is a horrible judge she cant be straight up and truthful so why be a judge

  • It's really not Nicole's fault...She probably thought for sure Marcus would be going home.

  • @kakalapoo she still should have done her job...its her job to be a judge and she did not do that job :( sorry...just my opinion

  • @warvics actually her job is to judge and select who she wants and doesnt want....she did do her job, Its YOUR and other rachael fans fault she went home...you want her to stay? then vote for her.

    sorry but blaming nicole for sending her home is stupid!

  • @warvics you have not done your job to vote,so why are you blaming nicole.she did not want to send anyone home,what is your excuse?