20090830 亞洲星光大道 評審指定曲 6 蔡梓銘 愛與誠

[aman2060]

而家聽返覺得同隊band 甩到七彩…

[kiki0520King1]

@hidetoize :我覺得你對林峰和鄧麗欣有啲偏見喎!!! ^ . ^""

[xiaoyixihuanluoliwei]

@kiki0520King1 我唔觉得这是偏见，因为他说的是事实

[kiki0520King1]

吳國敬評完未呀!評完林峰和鄧麗欣,今次還評古巨基!

他是否唔抵得那些紅星呀!!??

[hidetoize]

@kiki0520King1 林瘋,鄧走音唔識唱歌 行外人都知

[jackylst]

@kiki0520King1 你聽清楚啦呢個live黎架

唔好搵古巨基既cd version同呀ming比

古巨基唱live邊唱得準d假音位呀

[iDeziel]

高音好像唱的沒有難度... o-o

[leochan1993]

真唔覺得佢唱得好聽基仔= =，

基仔唱到首歌好耐聽...

[913goose]

Ming has big improvement these days, now he has the charasima for a celebrity.....hope his pure and innoncence personality will not be corrupted as he becomes popular .

[luoliweidefensi]

超级巨声的人不够他帅，又不够他好听

[Jadehelam]

唱得非常之非常之好!!!

[ying081094]

不愧係歌神~~~

[almightymflo]

他們星光1班各人好似與世無爭的感覺,很可愛!

[Msfevercherry]

真係好鐘意佢呀!!

佢真係好得意!!♥ ♥ ♥ ♥

次次都比佢笑死`

唱歌又好聽wo!!!

[almightymflo]

司儀又來攪笑一翻!

[higgboson]

I like his variation of tempo in the chorus. I think that is deliberate.

[PhilipChoyKam]

唱得好輕鬆

好聽

[TheEmmalai]

He is No. 1

[betabeth]

best of all 蔡梓銘's ~真係聽得好舒服呀!

[sincere123100]

我真的愛上他們,只覺得認識他們遲一點了.一班真心,純真熱愛音­整樂的年青人.很好聽啊!!!!!!!!!!

[eukokhey]

呢個版本好過菊花仔好多

[almightymflo]

@eukokhey 蔡梓銘的音色及感情好到,他又是那麼年紀,為何可以處理到而菊花­仔唔得???奇怪!最近與鄭苑瑛合唱的[畫沙]也是非常之正!

[cwhh1001]

好激氣點解 ming ming 和星光唱得這麼好,入唔到'yes'新人榜,反而巨聲那個何某和­訐某入選,這是什麼世界.

[98765412301]

有十個good...起碼廿個

[cutierainbow]

live唱得好過古生多多聲!

[cyberbtse]

good singing... the band kinna sucks though

[waikwan27]

good good good

[KIT7732KIT]

聲線好聽 , 好清 , 唱功再要努力 , 加油

[humanip]

因為聲底好清,好透

所以唱高音假音特別好

完全不感到吃力

[bb2791]

Smooth and solid!

Support !!!

[moomin0day]

蔡梓銘把聲有啲乸

[horhoryeah]

佢唱中低音都好好聽=)

可以好man

請放心=)

[guloinchrist]

收皮啦得個講字

[Jennaluen]

Prefer Leo Ku's version.

[Jennaluen]

Prefer Leo ku's version..

[Lwanpang]

可以試下"洗剪吹"

[Jeffreykyle0804]

我buy呢首都唔係好buy佢唱菊花台--

佢呢首真係唱得好聽過古巨基!

仲要超好聽!!!!

[carol1203]

咁搞笑既佢,落街口唱...

[tommykiefer]

我好鍾意佢啊

[Otwinklestar]

Gifted voice, awesome.

[colinIsMe]

live唱得好過基仔喎 ~

[H22268]

佢d假音轉得好靚

[vincentlee3434]

Very good! I never like 古巨基's singing. Being able to sing high pitch with 假音 is a singer basic skill. No big deal! 蔡梓銘's transition from 真音 to 假音 is quite smooth and most important is both 真音 & 假音 sound very similar. Almost can't tell the difference. I can tell right away when 古巨基 is using 假音. What good is that!!!

[Rtorve]

@vincentlee3434 It doesn't mean that it's not good when 真音 & 假音 sound different...好聽就沒所謂啦！

[vincentlee3434]

That's what I meant. It doesn't sound good

[yoyo2603]

好好聽喎!

[ken3331]

"awesome"

[Cantoner]

蔡梓銘d 混合音好好 聲靚 有potential!

[cyh9144]

good!

[4426204]

基仔本身真係唱得好差.唔好過基仔?

[conanchang]

只是18歲! 大把前途!

[felice2012]

不太好,,,,

[carolyuetman]

我覺得唱得好過基仔,尤其係高音假音好好,不過真係拍子唔係好得­

[yeeman07]

唱得好過古巨基好多喎

[sport3888]

wow this is his best performance yet! Seriously think he sang even better than original! amazing falsetto and very smooth!

[kane1228]

我覺得自己唱得仲好過呢個人 /_\'

[Wuloy88]

寫到無哂feel,好似練歌咁

又甩拍字...想點?

[sieeewky]

好難聽,好聽過基仔,我想嘔,嘔哂白泡

[mandymsm]

better than original

[clhhk2302]

佢唱得幾好. 有potential. 而且感情比較自然.

[kelvincheungkk]

我覺得佢成日好似就快跟唔上個拍子咁,仲有有D歌詞好嘔出黎咁,­同埋假音令我好唔舒服,但係呢D感覺好主觀,可能大家taste­唔同啦....不過,佢都好有唱歌天分既!!

[Nancyrainbow]

我要同SUPERTIGER12345678講聲sorry~~­因為本人禁錯左為poor comment~~其實本人應該係禁good comment~~sorry............

[orphanrafe]

他唱這首歌被古巨基的唱腔影響太多了，沒必要跟守原唱的

[SUPERTIGER12345678]

0178=陳志雲,,呵呵^^大家明曬啦,,,^^

[stephenkk2009]

果個tvb奴才cherry0178,夠鍾食藥哪,死番去哪.

[lildragon]

he's really good.

[051C25]

cherry0178 收皮la

[Naorichan]

佢高音同假音 switch really niceee

[greeniemina]

羅識唔識唱廣東歌架

講國語又唔得

陰功

[greeniemina]

好正聽得好舒服! 好過羅同亢

又高又幾靚仔

好過羅啦

[doraemon64]

19 years old, cool

[hkbeople]

唱得太薄, 又flat,

拍字又捉得唔好, 要band夾佢.

而高音方面, 就keep住假音為主.

真假轉換及不原唱者多變

不過把聲好靚. 有潛力. 個人buy佢多過羅力威

[xestnawi2006]

香港90年代中開始，的唱片監制同歌手都唔知搞乜鬼，突然間好似­撞邪，所有新晉歌手唱歌都大力又大聲咁抖氣。我諗好多選手唱成咁­，都係因為由細到大都係聽呢種唱法。

[xestnawi2006]

你聽何詠深那小妹妹，她一唱Greatest Love of All 時，抖氣聲即刻少哂，可能就係因為原唱冇囉。

各位評審點解完全唔評點這現象呢？難道你地都認為咁唱好聽？

蔡梓銘如果去掉那些索氣聲，你話佢呢首歌幾好聽呢！仲有我願意，­菊花台都係！蔡梓銘，快D留意下啦，我睇好你第日挑戰孫楠架

[qinwangxuhuang]

靚聲王

[SUPERTIGER12345678]

佢高音同假音都好正,,出面班所謂歌星行開一邊啦^^

[fantszshun]

佢d 音有d 飄

[ciciszeto123]

好好聽 good

[wong2406]

少年周華健

[lahahahk]

好好聽

[vbol2009]

唱live都好過原唱者錄音

[kobi125]

beautiful voice:)

個人認為比原唱唱得更好聽

[470666470]

聲線不錯, 但總欠點壓台的感覺.

[MrMrsyam]

好得呀!!! 有樣、高大、靚聲、學歷好!! 大好前途 <3

[vivibosco]

oh, gorson, it's time to have more versatile image, change the jeans, haha, I have seen u wore more than 3 times, and maybe add a jacket or wear some gold or silver wordings tee, I trust that u can carry a lot nice style too.

[A92069995]

好一般者

[davencms]

捉返d拍子

7字頭都有啦

[polaris0125]

把聲靚~

[kingkong2048]

仲有, 我覺得歌裡面, 其實唱者是有點憎恨個女朋友的. 但因為在愛情當中, 愛和根是交集的. 恨又會帶來愛或自責.

點都好, "憎恨"/"受夠"的元素, 我未係好聽得到. 音就真係好靚喇.

[kingkong2048]

高音的確好smooth, 好過古巨基, 古的感情有點夾硬. 無計.

但係, 再好D: 我覺得呢首歌有一種內心的掙扎係度, 而且唱的人是好孤獨的. (給我的感覺至少係咁) 但是我唔係咁聽得到呢種掙扎感出嚟. 後段某幾句就有d. (感情已死但面唔面對好) 或者有日失吓戀自然就唱到出嚟...

加油~! support.

[Wuloy88]

joey D透氣聲不嬲大..聽慣左

但係基仔不嬲無乜透氣聲

宜家呢個參賽者D透氣聲

令到首歌有D唔順耳...

[Wuloy88]

佢D透氣聲好大聲

[saukingtsang]

近年容祖兒在唱 現場 d 透氣聲仲大, 而且很剌耳, 他把聲幾好!!

[chan3824]

容祖兒,唔係偶像派,亦唔覺係實力派.....

[futurefighter2008]

you're right. 容祖兒 is JUST THERE.

[itllouis]

把聲好特別, 好好聽, 好舒服, 加油!

[hassler1010]

基本上他不是很好，但絕對有潛質；

p.s. 古巨基雖然唱功了得，但感情認真麻麻

[elleprestige]

我好鐘意佢把聲, 佢亦都夠氣唱一d高音同轉音位, 唱得好順. 不過, 我都認同佢係有瘕疵: 如感情唔夠, 錯拍子. 但係以佢既年紀, 我相信佢一定有進步的空間. 佢把聲真係好似神仙咁好聽, 佢出碟我一定買.

[lovona09]

his voice is too high

[joycelai1]

給意見請中肯些，不要說太難聽的話~

梓銘努力以赴！

[ARMANLEE0701]

老實講...我又唔覺得真係咁好聽姐....

一般囉...

我覺得佢把聲好高音...好多位其實都唱高左...

只係有時唱高左key...無唱低個key咁難聽姐..

同埋感染力不足...

唔明點解會話佢唱得好過基仔....=-="

應該激動既位...唱得唔夠力....

聲係靚...但唱功有待改進!!加油啦...

[arionchoy]

把聲唔夠厚，好多時佢一上唔到就入假音，呢個係好大問題（佢唱菊­花台係一個好例子），唔知點解Ｄ　ＪＵＤＧＥＳ成日都無講，同埋把聲太娘娘腔，拍子感要多ＰＲＡＣ­ＴＩＣＥ，最大問題係性格，每當佢自覺唱得好，總會冷笑一下，暫­時仲未做到「真正」歌星的要求！

[fookie1984]

無爆點...

[samchoy108]

佢沒有了古生的生梗做作

但是似乎同隊band 有少少唔夾bor

不過整體唔錯

同埋我覺得佢仲可以有好大的進步空間

[pruho]

very good.

[TheKsinger]

好過羅力威好多啦....我唔係好明點解佢會低分D。

把聲靚，高底音都聽得人咁舒服。唔駛改音都極有自己風格，呢D先­叫識音樂，識點唱歌。

呢D咁o既比賽，成日都唔係唱得最好果個拎第一.......

ANYWAY, 你掂，撐硬你﹗不過你輸硬，因為呢D比賽係唔會公平O既....­.佢地俾開羅力威高分，點都會繼續....煲熱佢為止.....­.可惜可惜...

[Ungulata]

CharmlessMan7：其實你把口都幾臭。怪唔知得你要起­個甘既名，真係 fit 曬你。

[imcmw]

梓銘繼續加油呀 .. 睇好你架 ..

p.s. 你講野真係好得意 .. "老人" .. 哈哈 ..

[kitman]

好靚呀把聲........

[sasasaiming]

假音王!

[onionwilson]

條友成日都抓唔準拍子

[Apt192]

As the Taiwanese say: 好油條! But he sure does have a good voice... just need more good vocal training.

[kidd52346]

感情唔夠

[ki826]

佢把聲好溫柔 好舒服

好smooth

最後個句唱得好好呀!有自己感情

希望佢第時可以出碟!

[paggyik]

我唔比較同佢同原唱者啦

但聽咗咁多集，我覺得佢真係咁多個參賽者之中嘅假音王～

佢啲假音係聽嗰個聽得舒服，唱嗰個，我睇落去佢都係舒服唔係勉強­嘅～

加油呀！

[futurefighter2008]

個人覺得距唱得好聽過古生。啊古生個腔口十年不變，真係好厭。

[saturn19940616]

講真,唔覺古巨基唱歌好聽lor..........

[f2l0a0s0h]

周生講錯咗啦~~...對佢係完全冇難度~~

[agnes10001]

真的....轉了假音也不知道...這大概是最高境界吧!

[joycelai1]

努力，加油！

真的進步很多！！喜悅聽你唱~

是否壓力見到臉上長出青春痘喇！

好好保重，實現你的夢想！

[allstemfromu]

感覺佢進步左,,,, 肯用下力~

[Sweetytitybabe]

得wor...我覺得

真假轉音都not bad

如果要話古kk個feel好D...根本不成立

古kk人生經驗一定豐富過梓銘, so佢地唱出尼個feel理所當然是不會exactly一樣

[pakchunhoi]

1:56果下明顯係甩左

說得係唔錯

真音假音轉換的確好出色

唯一唔同意係佢把聲真係唔覺靚

同埋佢歌入面d感情係無故事

[ki826]

佢歌入面d感情係無故事

同意。

得幾句係feel到佢既感情

要贏羅力威 就要係依度下功夫.

[vincentchui]

好聽...靚聲!! 有potential~~

[stephenkk2009]

他每一次都有進步,而且又有台型,羅力威的最大勁敵.

[amyyau1973]

好聽!

[sbs2008i]

Good add oil.

[edithtse1]

我覺得佢唱得好聽過原唱lor... 我現在開始喜歡這首歌

[damonbird]

贊同. 佢淨係得假聲, 感情都係一般. 佢把聲好靚, 唱菊花台好正, 但之後揀d歌未能發揮到佢優點, d音仲有少少不太穩....... 但都算好好聽.

[stephenkk2009]

tvb的奴隸,夠鍾食藥哪.過住哪.我們只要有質素及公平的評語­.

[leonid821]

多个K？ 什么意思

[stephenkk2009]

古巨基 KKK

[peach19880721]

最後有點油條~

[TheZoetam]

oh, I love the way he sang this song, never been better.............Gorson has been improving all the way through the contest, and this is a good one!!!

[y9782670]

鼻音好重..周華健咩

只能講2個都咁un耳

不過古生個新k腔更誇張失真

[witnesso]

真系有d like周華健的feel

[hajime2006]

咁又唔好講「你又唔去參加」之類的說話

因為識得評唔等於本身識唱,

但係又唔講點解差,我就接受唔到

[rawrr1101]

唱得好好呀！  加油！

[ryanng2002]

好聽！我心目中的4強之一 加油啊~~~

[ChopinPreludes]

To: emiltsuimunsang

你正on居，

不知所謂。

講真，

連你會不會唱歌也不知。

懂唱歌的一定不會像你這樣沒品！

Gorson 加油！！！

[magicmistie]

我覺得唱得好聽過原唱wo

[yandy82]

to : emiltsuimunsang

不如你試下參加呀?

咁又係, 勁都唔洗o係道留言踩人啦~

[j53773]

真係唱得舒服過古巨基好多

古巨雞唱得好un耳

[KobeMvP24444]

好怪

[catcatcatcat1207]

聽到我起雞皮!

你地成日話佢唱得好!

唔該!聽番佢唱(小城大事)呀!

講真呀!我真係覺得佢唱得唔好囉!

[suggestme1234]

同意

[dannyip1229]

果首唔好

呢首好其實冇衝突

[catcatcatcat1207]

唔好意思,我個人意見!

我覺得冇一首唱得好囉!

佢把聱有d令人覺得好怪既感覺!

[newkidcc]

sing really really well, deserve to get more than 70 me thinks

for all i care,this atv show is much better than tvb's

[futurefighter2008]

咦？無綫打手？