pretty good list. was a lot better than most peoples. only thing is I put chris maclister at CB and zach thomas over urlacher. also dwight freeney. matt stover at k or rob bironas.
We could argue all day about whether Brady or Manning is better, but both quarterbacks are in different systems with different players, so it's not that easy to compare them. All that matters is that both will be in the HOF and on the list of the top 10 quarterbacks of all time.
@Allistar123 When Brady started with the Patriots they weren't that great, nobody expected them to even make the playoffs, yet as soon as Brady replaced Bledsoe they started winning and won the superbowl.
thats a good list...tech alumni keith brooking holding it down for us tech fans...and ole champ bailey repping the 912...but jeff saturday has got to one of the best centers of the last ten years...thats the only thing im going to disagree with you about.
but again teams win superbowls not qbs peyton manning was the best qb this decade i mean you switch the qbs you will see peyton with 4 and brady with maybe 1
thats hypothetical i mean we really do not know that. Peyton on the patriots when all they had was Troy Brown and Deion Branch who really are just decent receivers at best and no running game. And put Brady on the Colts with Edgerrin James, Reggie Wayne, and Marvin Harrison. I mean we saw what Brady could do with a Good receiver he goes and throws 50 touchdowns its really hard to say that manning would have won 4 superbowls on the patriots if they switched.
you got a point only this season proves that manning can do it with any receivers. most of them are all young first time starters and he is making them look like pro bowlers and is on pace to win the another mvp award after most experts have written of the colts as potential SB contenders. so again peyton manning over brady don't let the jewlery distract u peyton manning is the best qb of this decade
Peyton Manning always has a great regular seasons its the post season that confuses everybody and if you really look at it i do not think the colts haven't really played anyone who's even a contender other than the patriots. At the end they are going to have to choose
the man with 3MVP and 1 Superbowl
or man with 1 MVP and 3 Superbowl
If manning wins this year this will no longer be an arguement hes the all decade QB vice versa for brady
what do you not grasp about that teams win sbs not qbs. manning when he started out had a very bad team when brady started it out he had a really great team. and that's why people would ride the colts off as contenders because they didn't have the defense to win. you switch the qbs peyton would probably win more than 4 while brady would probably stuggle to win 1
i really dont think the Colts have a as bad of a defense as everyone says they do they have alot of stand outs of defense and we do not know how Peyton would have done with WR like Troy brown and Deion Branch. The hall of fame voters who choose the all decade QB will care about the rings. Again what u are saying is all hypothetical Manning hasn't been able to channel his great play in the regular season to the playoffs. Brady has. That first superbowl did u see the spread for that game?
the hall of famers would vote peyton manning cuz they know football and know teams win rings not qbs an entire defense playing well will stop a qb ex. giants vs patriots Superbowl the defense whooped brady. who is anthony gonzales who is pierre garcon who is austin collie who is hank baskett? seriously peyton manning is on pace to having an mvp season with these guys as recievers so that whole argument about brady having no receivers and still winning is flawed.
Brady been playing with no receivers his entire career and also ppl still know Reggie Wayne ppl still know dallas clark manning cannot win without those 2. He still favors those 2 more than garcon. You act like that entire team has rookies when they still have 2 pro bowlers still to throw to. I dont like these debates where you blame the team for the loss. Manning beat the teams he loses to in the playoffs in the regular season. Why can't he redo what he did in the regular season the the playoff
lol wut? who do blame the loss for the fans? the cheerleaders? teams win games and lose games that has never changed. and so what if he has reggie wayne and dallas clark he still making garcon and gonzales look like pro bowlers and putting up mvp numbers brady never did that until he got welker and moss so you entire argument is flawed.
What im saying is when COLTS win Manning gets all the credit but when colts lose its the teams fault. You hear this a lot okay not even exaggerating on this. What you mean so what? it matters Wes Welker was a nobody until Tom Brady had him what about that? Wes Welker was a player getting cut from teams and written off as a nobody and Tom Brady made him a pro Bowler so iono what your talking about.
Im just not willing to acknowledge this one year knowing that Peyton manning has had really good players his entire career had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, and cant put games away in the playoffs. Tom Brady gets alot of crap because his team has a good defense but if the patriots were as destructive as everyone says Brady shouldnt have to drive them down the field with 2:00 left because their defense failed to stop the offense every superbowl.
He still not gonna be as great as Joe Montana whether u think its important or not Winning a Superbowl is a incredible feat and many writers and everyone will choose the guy who has won 4 superbowls and 2 MVPs over the guy who has won 4MVPs and 2 superbowls. Tom Brady's regular season career might not be as good as Peyton Manning but his Postseason career is enough to get him the nod over manning for the all decade team.
@missionbears peyton manning/ tom brady played at the sametime and were the greatest of their time. dan marino/ joe montana played at the sametime and were the greatest of their time. all four of the best. tom brady won superbowls while manning threw for more yards and TDs. joe montana won superbowls but marino threw for more yards and TDs. prett much seen another montana/marino in brady/ manning. now maybe we will see rodgers/ryan but they wont be as good.
@TheShootTruth10 RODGERS/RYAN?! r u kidding me thats not even a competition... Rodgers if he wins this superbowl will have the Yards, Tds, and Superbowls. Matt Ryan is overrated in my opinion.
@missionbears I said they wont be as good. who right now can do what montana and marino did or brady and manning did. NO ONE. but these guys are the two best we have in young QBs right now. matt ryan and falcons never won a meaningful game. they couldnt beat the saints at the end of the season. I knew they were overrated. flacco will never win a superbowl.
Ur an idiot Ed Reed is a fs not a ss
goozmachine 9 months ago
@goozmachine hes known to play both.....
hipo250 7 months ago
Hall over Hester? Hall is great but Hester is the best hands down! Manning is over Brady for sure !
cuzodave 1 year ago
pretty good list. was a lot better than most peoples. only thing is I put chris maclister at CB and zach thomas over urlacher. also dwight freeney. matt stover at k or rob bironas.
TheShootTruth10 1 year ago
We could argue all day about whether Brady or Manning is better, but both quarterbacks are in different systems with different players, so it's not that easy to compare them. All that matters is that both will be in the HOF and on the list of the top 10 quarterbacks of all time.
ledzepfan7575 1 year ago
@Allistar123 When Brady started with the Patriots they weren't that great, nobody expected them to even make the playoffs, yet as soon as Brady replaced Bledsoe they started winning and won the superbowl.
ledzepfan7575 1 year ago
ed reed is a free salfty
potatosackk 1 year ago
palamalu is not reeds backup.
xplay101 1 year ago
Rodney Harrison should have been safety
pugamahone 2 years ago
thats a good list...tech alumni keith brooking holding it down for us tech fans...and ole champ bailey repping the 912...but jeff saturday has got to one of the best centers of the last ten years...thats the only thing im going to disagree with you about.
southernsportsweekly 2 years ago
what about joey porter?
missionbears 2 years ago
devin hester ran 4 games with 2 tds
chiefs
broncos
rams
lions
and first to run a td on opening kick of superbowl
davidisraw 2 years ago
ya but he couldn't consistantly keep that pace, he had one and a half great seasons. Hall was unbelivable for a 5 year period
hipo250 2 years ago
That might be enough Jerry Rice started in 1985 and made the all decade team
missionbears 2 years ago
i have to agree with tom brady as the QB because the man in the last decade attended 4/10 of the superbowls and won 3 of them thats crazy.
missionbears 2 years ago
but again teams win superbowls not qbs peyton manning was the best qb this decade i mean you switch the qbs you will see peyton with 4 and brady with maybe 1
Allistar123 2 years ago
thats hypothetical i mean we really do not know that. Peyton on the patriots when all they had was Troy Brown and Deion Branch who really are just decent receivers at best and no running game. And put Brady on the Colts with Edgerrin James, Reggie Wayne, and Marvin Harrison. I mean we saw what Brady could do with a Good receiver he goes and throws 50 touchdowns its really hard to say that manning would have won 4 superbowls on the patriots if they switched.
missionbears 2 years ago
you got a point only this season proves that manning can do it with any receivers. most of them are all young first time starters and he is making them look like pro bowlers and is on pace to win the another mvp award after most experts have written of the colts as potential SB contenders. so again peyton manning over brady don't let the jewlery distract u peyton manning is the best qb of this decade
Allistar123 2 years ago
Peyton Manning always has a great regular seasons its the post season that confuses everybody and if you really look at it i do not think the colts haven't really played anyone who's even a contender other than the patriots. At the end they are going to have to choose
the man with 3MVP and 1 Superbowl
or man with 1 MVP and 3 Superbowl
If manning wins this year this will no longer be an arguement hes the all decade QB vice versa for brady
missionbears 2 years ago
what do you not grasp about that teams win sbs not qbs. manning when he started out had a very bad team when brady started it out he had a really great team. and that's why people would ride the colts off as contenders because they didn't have the defense to win. you switch the qbs peyton would probably win more than 4 while brady would probably stuggle to win 1
Allistar123 2 years ago
i really dont think the Colts have a as bad of a defense as everyone says they do they have alot of stand outs of defense and we do not know how Peyton would have done with WR like Troy brown and Deion Branch. The hall of fame voters who choose the all decade QB will care about the rings. Again what u are saying is all hypothetical Manning hasn't been able to channel his great play in the regular season to the playoffs. Brady has. That first superbowl did u see the spread for that game?
missionbears 2 years ago
the hall of famers would vote peyton manning cuz they know football and know teams win rings not qbs an entire defense playing well will stop a qb ex. giants vs patriots Superbowl the defense whooped brady. who is anthony gonzales who is pierre garcon who is austin collie who is hank baskett? seriously peyton manning is on pace to having an mvp season with these guys as recievers so that whole argument about brady having no receivers and still winning is flawed.
Allistar123 2 years ago
Brady been playing with no receivers his entire career and also ppl still know Reggie Wayne ppl still know dallas clark manning cannot win without those 2. He still favors those 2 more than garcon. You act like that entire team has rookies when they still have 2 pro bowlers still to throw to. I dont like these debates where you blame the team for the loss. Manning beat the teams he loses to in the playoffs in the regular season. Why can't he redo what he did in the regular season the the playoff
missionbears 2 years ago
lol wut? who do blame the loss for the fans? the cheerleaders? teams win games and lose games that has never changed. and so what if he has reggie wayne and dallas clark he still making garcon and gonzales look like pro bowlers and putting up mvp numbers brady never did that until he got welker and moss so you entire argument is flawed.
Allistar123 2 years ago
What im saying is when COLTS win Manning gets all the credit but when colts lose its the teams fault. You hear this a lot okay not even exaggerating on this. What you mean so what? it matters Wes Welker was a nobody until Tom Brady had him what about that? Wes Welker was a player getting cut from teams and written off as a nobody and Tom Brady made him a pro Bowler so iono what your talking about.
missionbears 2 years ago
Im just not willing to acknowledge this one year knowing that Peyton manning has had really good players his entire career had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, and cant put games away in the playoffs. Tom Brady gets alot of crap because his team has a good defense but if the patriots were as destructive as everyone says Brady shouldnt have to drive them down the field with 2:00 left because their defense failed to stop the offense every superbowl.
missionbears 2 years ago
The results are in and i think the HOF writers chose Tom Brady over Peyton Manning Winning those superbowls did say alot i guess.
missionbears 2 years ago
@missionbears Peyton is still better though he will win this sunday and solidify his position of greatest QB of all time
Allistar123 2 years ago
He still not gonna be as great as Joe Montana whether u think its important or not Winning a Superbowl is a incredible feat and many writers and everyone will choose the guy who has won 4 superbowls and 2 MVPs over the guy who has won 4MVPs and 2 superbowls. Tom Brady's regular season career might not be as good as Peyton Manning but his Postseason career is enough to get him the nod over manning for the all decade team.
missionbears 2 years ago
@missionbears peyton manning/ tom brady played at the sametime and were the greatest of their time. dan marino/ joe montana played at the sametime and were the greatest of their time. all four of the best. tom brady won superbowls while manning threw for more yards and TDs. joe montana won superbowls but marino threw for more yards and TDs. prett much seen another montana/marino in brady/ manning. now maybe we will see rodgers/ryan but they wont be as good.
TheShootTruth10 1 year ago
@TheShootTruth10 RODGERS/RYAN?! r u kidding me thats not even a competition... Rodgers if he wins this superbowl will have the Yards, Tds, and Superbowls. Matt Ryan is overrated in my opinion.
missionbears 1 year ago
@missionbears I said they wont be as good. who right now can do what montana and marino did or brady and manning did. NO ONE. but these guys are the two best we have in young QBs right now. matt ryan and falcons never won a meaningful game. they couldnt beat the saints at the end of the season. I knew they were overrated. flacco will never win a superbowl.
TheShootTruth10 1 year ago
@TheShootTruth10 Sam Bradford is better competition than matt ryan is. Aaron Rodgers is going to take Peyton Manning's places as the next big thing.
missionbears 1 year ago
@missionbears ok lets just say rodgers will take manning and bradys place.
TheShootTruth10 1 year ago
@TheShootTruth10 Rodgers and Roethlisberger is a better competition than Ryan and Rodgers
missionbears 1 year ago
how can hester be the backup????? He broke the record for return tds 2 times!!!!!!!!
karlwinfried 2 years ago
Damn I was like wtf how come Julian Peterson (98 bitches) ain't on the list, then i saw him as BACKUP for Brooking??
Matteo24 2 years ago
matt stover instead of jason elam
bmoreravens12 2 years ago
peyton manning back up: tom brady
SDsoowoo59 2 years ago