Added: 4 years ago
From: sylverainukshuk
Views: 66,740
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (231)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I really love this song and the video. Keep up the good work, Tarja~♥

  • Wonderful Tarja! I love it!

    This song is charged of feelings!

  • a very nice song...i still hope thet the old nightwish will reborn..but until then....congratulation tarja you prouve power...sry for my bad english...

  • @MORGANTINA666 The old Nightwish will never come back. Live with it.

  • could someone please help me understand the video? :)

  • Well, this may not be right but I am guessing that it is standing for one that is lost, lost within there self in their mind, feeling others leave them, feeling their hearts get shut in, and then becoming trapped feeling as if none can help them. That is just my guess.

  • I've never heard of her, and I don't know why. She's amazing!!!!

  • "Shut up you toud-spotted lout (RachelKiss123) TARJA was the best in NIGHTWISH!!! And shes from Sweden not Canada you noob!"

    It's FINLAND you dipstick!! And btw I WAS FREAKIN DEFENDING TARJA YOU MORON

  • Fame gets to your head...we would all be guilty of it... I bet even the rest of Nightwish have let it get their heads once in a while... it just hurts people when it can ruin friendships and a really good band.

  • Tarja is a brilliant singer, I love her voice and this song is fantastic :) Cheers to you, Tarja

  • I've just read the Nightwish's open letter to Tarja and is really touching,seems that all of them agreed on firing her and i am sure that it wasn't caused by nothing,when the fame blindfolds you and turns more important than your own band friends and even your fans what else can you expect?, they seemed not to be concerned about the money or fame as much as keeping Nightwish as a creative force to satisfy themselves and their audience and Tarja took a step away from that,i hope this not all true

  • best nightwish song

  • isnt this her solo song?

  • yeah ^^

    i love this song

  • huh?sounds good.

  • this vid is the best wooo

  • I think RachelKiss123 is spamming totaly every word he said is rated as thumb down!

  • sure i am....

  • "Are you talking millions vs. feeble nightclubs in Europe or "feeble" nightclubs in the US and Canada"

    The only reason anyone would even know nightwish in america these days are for the memories of the better days, and if they're looking for a chick, they know they can just call up annette. If you don't fucking like tarja than don't watch her videos asshole!!!

  • Shut up you toud-spotted lout (RachelKiss123) TARJA was the best in NIGHTWISH!!! And shes from Sweden not Canada you noob!

  • I freakin know that! I'm a HUGE Nightwish fan! Annette sucks, Tarja rules. So plz, don't say that i don't know about Nightwish and that i think tarja sucks, when i'm defending Tarja and the OLD Nightwish

  • "TARJA was the best in NIGHTWISH!!! And shes from Sweden not Canada you noob! "

    Yes, she IS excellent and of course the best singer Nightwish ever had, except that she's from Finland, not Sweden.

  • Well...she is from Finland you know...lol I'm not being mean to you...just letting you know that you are not correct...and is everyone saying that there is something wrong with Canada!?

  • "If you don't fucking like tarja than don't watch her videos asshole!!!"

    Watch your mouth little girl..

  • I agree...dont watch just to bash...just leave your comments to yourselves.

  • Minä rakastan sinua!!!

    Tarjaaaaaaa!!! s2

  • i hate her hair, What did she do to it?!

    Is it realy her real hair?!

  • noo

  • In hungary tarja does means a kind of meat. xD

  • Tolles Lied. Super Stimme,

    aber mit dem Lidschatten hat sie ein bisschen übertrieben *g*... ;)

  • good song, she actually surprised me in her solo career. great video too, though she should consider never wearing wigs again, they're just awful :p

  • I think she looks stunning as a red-head ^^

  • maybe it takes some getting used to, but I doubt i'll ever like it :p I like the natural black better :D

  • Hehe she does look beautiful with her normal hair too ^^

    And the poo-poo that rated my comment bad can go stick a rusty spoon in their eye-socket. XD

  • greaaaaat!!!! Tarja you are the best!! I can't stop listening the song

  • Up the Tarja!!!

  • good song but, the video is pretty cheap looking. Really bad choices in wardrobe and makeup, especially when shes portraying the doll.

  • the song is really good and the video too!well done. The only thing i don't like much is her make up...but no matter. :)

  • Tarja's the best singer in the world! =D I really want that album... best album in ages! =D

  • Thank god she sings alone now.

    She is AWESOME! One of the best songs since.... wow...

    I love that song :-)

  • This is amazing!

  • AGREE!

  • truly an amazing video, let alone voice and song. I love her! I think she's better off alone. Great voice Tarja! I wan't to buy that Album! She's s pretty in the video.

  • Muito Lindo!!!

    Very Pretty!!!

  • amazing!!!!!!!!

  • Super!!! i love her voice!!!!

  • wow i like the vid its...creepy

  • When I hear the chorus, it's like she fills everything around me, and she's not using all the power she has! god!.. she's amazing!.. she's back!..

  • I love it!!

    SO SOOOOOO GOOOOOOOOOOD!!!! (l)^^

  • Hmmm I really can't work it out... what's the ' (L)^^ ; thing meand to be.

  • Well if you care about Tarja, good, if you don't, go away. Just stop discussing useless things like Tarja and Nightwish's differences!

    TARJA, YOU' THE BEST!

    Such an amazing voice *o* can't be human s2

  • SOOOOOOOO GOOD *.*!

  • i love the song and hermother gaya appeareance ! i didn't know tarja could write beautiful lyrics like this .... her album is wonderful....still, tuomas holopainen made nightwish unique,not her, and i think anette is great ! i wish tarja good luck in her solo career !

  • Her voice is awesome

  • Why is evryone comparing Tarja to Nighwish? lols are yas stupid? This is her solo thing now Nightwish and Tarja are two SEPERATE THINGS NOW. so stop being stupid and comparing them, her solo career and nightwish are two totally different things. And anyone who says they dont care for tarja's singin but loved nightwish wtf are u smokin? How can u love a band but not like the singers voice hmmm. some silly people on here u either like the song or you don't Nightwish has nothing to do with it.

  • Well, the video is kind of cool, but I could do without the song. I love Nightwish, but I never carred for Tarja's singing much. Don't get me wrong, this song's not bad, it's just nothing compared to Amaranth, Nightwish's single. In the long run, I think it is Tarja who will fall, not Nightwish.

  • why why why? why u leave favolous Nightwish??

  • She didn't leave the keyboard player kicked her out of the band. He was in love with Tarja, but she didn't return his love.

    Then she got married and Tarja's Husband told the keyboard player, look she's my wife now, please stop hitting on her.

    1 month later she was kicked out of the band.

  • AHEM!!!

    That information is totally false. Tuomas Holopainen has said, time and time again, he was NOT in love with her.

    He wants people to stop saying things like that.

    So, for the love of god, have respect for the man. Don't dish out false gossip!

  • just because he says that he wasn't in love with her, doesn't make it true. He's probaly afraid of marcos (her husband). And it's not gossip if it's true, simply stating facts is all.

  • And how, exactly, do you know it's TRUE that he was in love with her? Obviously, it didn't stop him from kicking her from the band ... no special treatment ...

    And if he was afraid of Marcelo ... he wouldn't have kicked him from the management. He would have let Marcelo do whatever. .___.

    And regardless if it is true or not, he is sick of being accused of it.

    So have respect for the man, and drop it.

  • No, i won't "drop" it. A very talented singer got fired from the band inwhich she AND Tuomas started together. And they didn't just have to give her a letter after a great performance, telling her to open it the next day, regardless if he loved her or not. By the time she opened it, it was all over the internet being read by millions of fans....

  • And Emppu, too? -.- And Jukka?

    They were there, too, actually. Oh, wait, they don't matter at all. My bad.

    And what was he supposed to do? Talk it out? I agree with him on one thing: People always think that things can be solved by talking.

    It was the best thing for them to do, IMO. She was going to be gone anyways, after Dark Passion Play.

  • They didn't have to put the fricken letter on the internet before she even read it! She was devistated by the news. By now it's just a he said, she said thing. But people are still taking sides, i've taken mine, and it appears that you've taken yours. And also, why watch it if u hate tarja???

  • One song I can tolerate; but trust me, I'm not listening to it anymore.

    And, yes, she was horrified by the news. Considering her attitude that she 'didn't need Nightwish' anymore, I would think she'd be happy.

    I'm not replying to this anymore; as you said, we've taken sides and we're not changing.

    (And I highly agree with pianoslyv's comment.)

  • "Considering her attitude that she 'didn't need Nightwish' anymore, I would think she'd be happy."

    You believe everything you read on the Internet, eh? Her side of the story is she may have said that to Tuomas in the middle of a heated argument years earlier.

    What it comes down to is Tuomas felt like smearing her in order to gain sympathy for himself. I'm not of those that swallowed his sob story..

  • very true

  • "And Emppu, too? -.- And Jukka?

    They were there, too, actually. Oh, wait, they don't matter at all. My bad."

    I'm sure he could have turned the rest of the band against her during the times she wasn't there.

    As far as talking, it's too bad more people don't try doing it more often, as it often avoids inreversible errors in judgement.

  • Amazing, the inside track you have, Rachel. How do YOU know all that is true? Perhaps they were tired of talking and not being able to complete their thoughts any other way. If you /really/ respected the band, you'd respect ALL the members, not just one. Her actions and lack of same were detrimental to the whole; she deserved what she got. Tarja is NOT invincible or irreplaceable.

  • No she's not, they just replced her with a dipshit singer. And i never respected the band afetr what they did to tarja. I don't care what she did, no one should be treated like that, no one. NightWish used to have their own concerts where millions would come, now they play in feeble little nighclubs. Big change after they fired Tarja, huh?

  • Are you talking millions vs. feeble nightclubs in Europe or "feeble" nightclubs in the US and Canada, where they never sang with Tarja because the venues weren't big enough and didn't pay enough, in her opinion? Yes, that IS a big change. For the better. They give a GREAT concert, and the more they're known over here, the bigger their venues will be here, too. What did Anette do to you to merit your calling her a "dipshit singer"? Yet, you dismiss the band for letting Tarja go for cause. Hmm.

  • "Are you talking millions vs. feeble nightclubs in Europe or "feeble" nightclubs in the US and Canada, where they never sang with Tarja"

    Hey Einstein, Nightwish and Tarja DID tour the US and Canada back in 2004.

  • "He's probaly afraid of marcos (her husband). "

    Her husband's name is Marcello, and it IS true him and Tuomas never really "hit it off" well. I tend to agree with you that Tuomas was highly jealous of Marcello, and it tore him up to see Tarja and Marcello together.

  • I always thought that there was more than just a mutual friend relationship (feeling wise, at least from his side.) between her and Tuomas...just the way he looked at her every time I saw them together...and I have followed with Nightwish for 3 years now.

  • I respect this musically.. but besides that is boring.. she is lost. and nightwish 2..

  • omfg...i like the song n the video....but i dont like how she look ¬¬...she is so beautyfull to look that...

  • AMAZING :D

    so deep and so true!!!

  • nightwish is now pathetic without tarja,

    they are left with an average singer who bores people to tears,

    tarja is creative and artistic...

    nightwish will fail.

  • gochic makyaj..superrrr

  • Maybe this video would us tell that Tuomas and Marco should burn in hell?

  • in this video he looks like the singer of within temptation with her maku up and dress :(

  • Tarja was a real bitch in NW...but I love her voice anyway...and this song. I think its great. I like amaranth too, though...but I hate Anettes voice...pretty average, IMO.

  • UFFFF! ese pelucon pelirrojo la mata!!!

    Con lo guapa que está de morena.

  • Artistaza!

  • La cancion está bien, mejor q esas q sacó de villancicos..esta es mas del estilo q hacia con nightwish, esperemos q siga asi y q venga pa España!! jeje

  • Is this song a cover? It sounds to me very similar to a another song in spanish, but I can`t remember its name now

    Well, I think Tarja could be a full-time Opera singer, I don't like her voice in pop songs like this

  • Me alegra que siga adelante a pesar de todo lo ocurrido viva tarja y tambien nightwish = )

  • Personally, I don't really like this song. I liked it better when she was in Nightwish. It's a little boring. She repeats I walk alone too much...

  • Of course, that's the song "I Walk Alone."

  • Yes, I think too, "keep all the roses I'm not dead"...

    great song, wonderful voice...we still loving you !!

  • Hello,

    it might be my fould, but it just looks likes like she says in the text that the whole Nightwish was wrong accept for one person:

    Go back to sleep forever more

    Far from your fools and lock the door

    They're all around and they'll make sure

    You don't have to see

    What I turned out to be (something good)

    I just don't like the idea that this whole song is made to give a message to NW.. And i also think that bye bye beautiful, DIE DIE beatiful is kinda mean 0_0..

    Byee

  • how would you feel if you were fired from a band that you made?

  • Tarja didn't start Nightwish. Tuomas was the one who created Nightwish. He and Jukka or Emppu invited Tarja to join, and she agreed.

  • Well, I must say that in a way sergioprasca is right, after all the band made their fame over Tarja´s image!

  • Thank you

    And from what i heard tarja was the responible for the braekup her husbend told her that she was to much for the band and that she deserbed more and she start actong arrogant and all the NW members culd not take that bullshit any more so they fired her

    A by the way listen the NW video bye bye bautifull is the answer to tarja vidio = ) very good

  • You only know one side of the story. Search for the answers her husband gave to the fans´ questions to know more.

  • and nightwish wouldn't be this famous with her i think. it was the combination of an amazing composer and a magnificent operatic voice that made nightwish such a huge band.

  • reffering to emmis117

  • Beautiful video and very lovely song, too! This is better than the other songs by Tarja on her solo career i've listened to.

  • lol! ginger tarja!!!

  • How can we know who's the bad guy here? I don't like it that she left the band, just because her voice and Nightwish can't break. Anette is a good singer but she is not a Nightwish member for me. Besides, now she is with Nightwish the whole musicstile seems to have changed. I also like the new Nightwish, but it's so differend from the old that they could better re-name themselves..Byebye..

  • I like this song and video. I believe and hope that Tarja will succeed on her own. I will for sure buy her cd and the new Nightwish cd too.

    If you want to hear other great Finnish bands, check out Passionworks. You can watch Passionworks video "Falling" here on youtube.

  • I love how all the Tarja fanboys say that Nightwish is too poppy now, which is absolutely not true, and they ignore the fact that Tarja is pretty much pure pop with a slightly nicer voice than average.

    Still, I must say I was pleasantly surprised by this song. Her voice is actually a lot nicer and less strained than on Once, and it's quite a nice song. So although tragic in some ways, I think splitting up was good for both Nightwish and Tarja.

    Anette totally effing rocks though.

  • Tarja is sopran...no a popy singer...

  • right, anette is sweety and poppy ... tarja will go her way! love her, she has a strong will.

  • Tarja , Congratulations , love ur video and your voice , U are the best , simply the best

  • As always, this girl with her angelical voice...NW have no f*** isdea of what they lost...and changing Tarja for a pop singer, give a break....

  • you're one of those nightwish-haters, who just love tarja and have never ever considered their music

  • Anette is no pop singer. You and a bunch of other people are only saying that because Anette's voice is much softer than Tarja's voice. Tarja's voice is operatic, and Anette's voice is rockish.

  • er I'll say it's more accurate to say pop-ish but oh well...

  • Perfeito.

  • i didn't like the videoclip very much

    but it is a nice song though

  • Magnifica como siempre... No saben los de Nightwhis lo que han perdido... Su voz es unica!! Seguro que su disco sera todo un exito!! ^^

  • wow people need to grow up well any way great job tarja loved the song the video nice clip

  • Nice clip, partially the makeup is a bit overloaded but costumes ftw! Also the LoTRish scene with zombie carnage is really leet :]

  • I like Anette's voice. She isn't as unique as Tarja was with the band (although starting from Century Child, Tarja's voice wasn't as marvelous as it used to be on Oceanborn and on Wishmaster), but I think her singing matches the new songs better than Tarja's would. And it's also a fact that she sings with more pleasure than Tarja.

    Voice isn't the only factor in a band that has a 10-year-old history, but also the positive attitude.

  • well, Tarja wouldn't fix in the new NW, CUZ SHE IS NOT A POP SINGER, she is a more serious singer, and not a Swedish Madonna...

  • Maybe she is the most wonderful singer in whole Europe but if it's true, then why did she join a band which likes to change their vocalist from an angelic diva to a 'Swedish Madonna'?

    I didn't write new Nightwish but SONGS. The band itself hasn't changed and neither Tuomas who wrote all masterpieces. He is the head and he knows what he does.

    And it wasn't Tarja who left the band. She was kicked out 'cause of her doings. (Like the concert which had to be cancelled 'cause she changed mind.)

  • That concert in Norway HAPPENED!!! Go check her press conference and you will see how the letter signed by the band made the facts seem twisted!

  • I only mentioned 1 thing. And I've checked few sources after my comment. Yes, the concert happened: delayed. Funny, isn't it? :)

    I have personal experiences: the Hungarian NW homepage asked meet'n'greet with the band before a concert and Tarja was the only one who didn't show up. It was the same after the concert: all the 4 male members came out to meet the fans except her.

    She wasn't a true NW member then, just a guest singer.

  • Yes! She was the guest singer for 9 years and the one that made them famous!

  • They haven't become famous because of the singer but their music. NW started with a _female_ singer in 1997 and that was more unique than the fact that Tarja was also an opera singer. It was just a plus, any female singer would've made them famous.

    I don't deny Tarja has a talent to sing. That's also a fact. But without Mr Holopainen's music she doesn't sound that great.

  • So, you´ll be happier watching to the videos of NW concert in Tavastia since who the singer is doesn´t really matter to you, right? ;) Go there and be happy!

  • cause she wanted more money, but that`s no true... the other members were earning more money than her.. AND SHE WAS THE VOCALIST

  • And where did you hear that from?

  • i read it in a web page... i dont remember, when i find it ill send it to u.. add me as ur friend

  • they kicked her out because of Marcelo.

  • And yes, the makeup is horrible, she looks like the witch of narnia in blue :P

  • i listen to this song a few times now...and Tarja´s voice is still amazing but i think the melody of the song is nothing special, so very boering.

    I also agree that she is looking a bit like Sharon den adel...ôO the make up...

    she can do it better...i prefer the songs at tajas nightwish era...

    the song is ok but i miss sth special!

  • agree, the song is slow, it can be better! maybe slow at the beggining and then faster like nightwish!

  • I've listened to it a few times. The song is pretty but has nothing in particular. (The electric guitar is quite disturbing in the background.)

    Tarja looks like Sharon den Adel but she hasn't got soft enough face for this make-up, so Sharon-Tarja: 1-0

    Peace :)

  • Amazing video... I love her voice and love this violoncello in the background

  • 1:43 I believe that is a direct reference to Michelangelo's "Pieta" look it up if you don't know.

  • Olaaaaaaa"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!11

  • Nao gostei... pronto falei...

  • nem eu :S

  • Que Instrumentalzinho sem vergonha!!!!

  • Por isso mesmo que não gostei... pq a musica poderia ser mais bem produzida na parte dos instrumentos... A voz dela ta otima, mas o q deveu foi realmente os instrumentos

  • E o Ciaran´s Well, vcs curtiram? Cara, eu achei aquela música o apavoro de foda!

  • WOW!!

    Tarja 4 Ever!

  • lol

    another lulaby for childs get sleep

    baddd

  • Your just mad because you could not afford make up ass!

  • fortunately

  • She's so beautiful!!! Make-up like Sharon den Adel, but Tarja is more soft for this, Sharon is

    mammy :D

  • It´s awesome!!!

  • The song is dedicated for the fans,

    we are her "Winter storm"

  • *-* waaa I love her voice and everything!!

    I like very much the song!!

    cannot wait to listen more of Tarja n_n

  • coonfuuttaatis... chulo guiño

  • Fantastic Song! I hope the rest of the CD is this good! \m/

  • Snow Queen!

    Tarja...........blond?

  • hermosaaa!!

    excelenteee!!

  • The video is okay, her voice is good as always, but the lyrics and the melody suck BIG time.

  • Amazing song!.. but Tarja can sing better! I hope that she'll not give up and will bring us much more perfect songs than girl from alyson avenue!

  • Great, after amaranth everything is like gold...

  • :))

  • Ela eh realmente mais que perfeitah!

    esse video estah muito mai muito bom!

  • *-*

    Muito bom.

    Sério, ela é perfeitaaaa.

    /o/

  • Perfect!!!!!!!

  • She is perfect LOL ^^

  • Tarja is just amazing!!!

  • I don't like this song. Tarja might sing well, but there's nothing special about this song. It's lame and the lyrics are only trying to revenge Tuomas. I won't remember this song tomorrow, it's not good enough. I wish we could return to the old Nightwish-times.

  • Tarja ruleeeeeeez!!

  • Oh yeah she does...Go Tarja!!!

  • Awesome video. Superb cinamatography! This song is fantastic.

  • I really like the song, I'm glad she didn't go into just doing classical pieces, it's got a bit of rock in it, which is great!! Wish her all the best

  • Très beau clip, et voix... parfaite.

    Beaucoup mieux que les nouvelles chansons de Nightwish.

    GO TARJA ;)

  • BEAUTIFUL SONG!

  • beautiful video and beautiful tarja

  • Great Song and Video! Can't wait to hear the rest.

    Anette is such trash compared to Tarja.

  • Harvinaisen huono kipale

  • i didnt like the video

    sorry

  • Great song, great video ^^