if u look closely u cud actually see smoke coming from CM's hands which means he's holding cigarette ... it's okay if he does smoke.. i'm fine with it.. but he has to stop once we're married it's bad for our babiesssssssssssssssssssssssssss LOL
he's old enough to do whatever he wants but still, now knowing that he smokes and is destroying his beautiful voice is heartbreaking. i hope he quits.
i think that him smoking is quite recent as in after the lawsuit and all...
i mean wouldn't the cassie's hav seen him smoking in the past years?
I dont blame him, going through the lawsuit and all, and this is around paradise ranch shooting, right? so they hadn't debuted with KYHD, he must hav been nervous, and i hav a friend who started smoking after her parents divorced, apparently it helped her, but now she has quit smoking.
I wish that he and other people would find a better activity to take out their stress on. I'm Asian, but I don't like smoking. I mean, I can't force others to stop smoking, so I hope that they will soon find something else. Changmin/DBSK fighting! :D
I don't blame him for smoking. He's a grown up man, and he has the rights to do whatever he wants. But I'm pretty upset because it might ruin his voice.
Although I am a little shocked that he would do this, I think we need to accept that this is his own decision, and we need to respect his decisions even though some may disagree. I mean, it's one cigarette. Maybe he only does this occasionally. Either way, I'm sure he well aware of the affects of smoking, and it's not like he's going crazy with it and being a rebel or anything. So lighten up a little.
i'm heartbroken more than ever. i'm speechless and blank. yet i can hear my heart shatter like glass smashed i cannot accept the fact that the changmin i love, IS SMOKING!! all these years of praising him, respecting him for his fresh whole image, down the drain. i just..i can't love someone who smokes. i'm so sad and depressed. please changmin, this is the last time i see you hold that piece of shit. i'll ignore it because i love you. please, don't disappoint all your fans ILY <3
So disappointed in myself, Changmin was filming at a place just one hour away from my house in Brisbane I couldn't get there...My only chance to see changmin up close...so disappointed (T_T)
whats the deal if he smokes or not?i know we guys are just worried about his health or something but lets also remind ourselves that they have their own lives and they can handle it themselves..and i do think changmin is in the legal age to smoke..and another thing, if he smokes in the airport he'd be scolded even though he's a star coz its forbidden in the place...^_^
i dont care if he smokes. i love him either way. smoking changmin is hot. non-smoking changmin is hot too. people smoke because they are stress, or some of them just wanted to smoke. like me for instance, i started smoking because, my dad, my friends was smoking and i thought it was fine. also i was under a lot of stress.
well. if you look it closely..you may see him, he have the smoke in his hand, and start smoke when the camera couldnt catch him beacuse of something i dont know.
I always feel offended when people get so mad that one of them smoke >< ugg, it's not THAT BAD. Yes, it's unhealthy. so is eating candy. BAN CANDY EVERYONE. okay, so smoking is worse.... but still.... anywayssss, changmin is so cute in his all black! Hahaha like a lean ninja! thanks for the video :D
Both boys have started smoking (Changmin and Yunho). I understand why, I mean what they're going through is tough. And I think Jaejoong started smoking again too. :L
Can I know when he was smoking in this vid? I keep straining my eyes trying to see but I can't?
And I'm not uptight like some people are about the matter. I think it's pretty understandable in this situation (if it's true cuz no one has yet to actually see him holding a cigarette in his hand and I'm not quick to believe hearsay over the internet without proof).
But anyway, I love this fancam. It's probably the clearest one in Australia. So thanks for sharing this with us. Good job:D
From the very beginning, he's in the smoking area. Its not very clear & the angle is slightly awkward 'cause we had to go into a coffee shop to see it & there were tables and chairs everywhere (obviously).
But yeah, he got off the bus, started smoking .. put it out then checked-in etc and not long after, went to that area and started again.
Whether you want to believe me or not is completely up to you.
haha thanks :D i put in lots of effort to see him ^^
He is smoking in this video. If yo ulook in the beginning of the video around 0:06 - 0:07, you see smoke coming from his hand. It isn't coming from any other angle BUT his hand. Then a bit later, you see his hand coming from his mouth. and a bit of smoke all over the place. And besides that, he's in a smoking area. :/
we are all debating the rights and wrongs of smoking. some of you can accept it, and some of you are disappointed and think your hearts are breaking.
but ultimately, all i hope is...that no matter what, people will not let this turn them away from him, and will still always love and support him because he is a wonderful person, and this does not take away from that at all. he is not a lesser person just because he smokes.
i still love him. can any of you still say that? pls do.
I definitely still love him. I personally totally accept smoking. But he is such an excellent singer that I can't control myself to worrying about his amazing pitches.
I do!!!... I'll always suport and love him! and all the DBSK boys, no matter what ... like you said he's an amazing person and this smoking thin is not gonna change him...LOVE CHANGMIN!!..
He knows what he's doing yes, but he's ruining his voice. Smoke destroys the voice and makes it raspy. If he smokes, it's just going to destroy his voice. To the point where he can't even reach those amazing pitches. If he knew what he was doing, he wouldn't be smoking. He's smart but I think this choice is stupid.
when i knew about Jaejoong,Yoochun and Yunho smoking along time ago..i already thought about Changmin or Junsu would smoke one of this days..and i think this is a day for Changmin-since this is the only video i/we have seen him smoking...or maybe he does smoke in their dorm or whatever..he's been around with people who smoke-not only the other 3 members mentioned but also the staff they are working with...sorry just my opinion..1st-hand smoking is better than 2nd hand smoking--LOL
Actually..I take that back..If you look at the beginning of the video, you notice some smoke coming from his hand so it comes off like he has a cigarette. Then you see his hand coming from his mouth some how a bit later. He smokes..I never expected him to smoke. He's human but yeah, I never thought Changmin of all people would smoke D:. Do you think that shows signs of stress?
@i4Cuz yeah...maybe bcoz of stress he's having recently though i'm quite surprised knowing him smoking.we'll nvr know why he started smoking.. gotta ask him then..but changmin-ah , there's lot of ways to relieve stress rather than destroying your own body
He's not only destroying his body, he's also destroying his voice. I mean, I guess you can't blame him since if you were under stress and the cig's were there, you would experiment with them to if other things didn't work. But once you're a singer, it's one of the worst things to do. You're just ruining your voice. And your voice is the reason why you're a singer in the first place.
at the beginning of the video you can see that he was like he is holding something and it's the cigarette since that's how most smokers hold their cigarette and i have been to brisbane and that's their smoking area
we all got to the airport and were surprised when he began smoking after he got off the bus. an hr or 2 later he went to that area (at 0:24) and started again.
if u look closely u cud actually see smoke coming from CM's hands which means he's holding cigarette ... it's okay if he does smoke.. i'm fine with it.. but he has to stop once we're married it's bad for our babiesssssssssssssssssssssssssss LOL
rafaelellazo 1 month ago 4
how come no one approached him !? :( i wouldve pretended i was in line checking in and walked behind him and secretly took a photo :L dammmnt
FreddyTakai 1 month ago in playlist More videos from angel0914
its ok if he do it sometimes but dont be too often its no good nice song btw
neromydog 2 months ago
he's old enough to do whatever he wants but still, now knowing that he smokes and is destroying his beautiful voice is heartbreaking. i hope he quits.
guardiangelrae 2 months ago
i think all tvxq members maybe except junsu began to smoke after the lawsuit...
bubsbubsoohlala 3 months ago
i think that him smoking is quite recent as in after the lawsuit and all...
i mean wouldn't the cassie's hav seen him smoking in the past years?
I dont blame him, going through the lawsuit and all, and this is around paradise ranch shooting, right? so they hadn't debuted with KYHD, he must hav been nervous, and i hav a friend who started smoking after her parents divorced, apparently it helped her, but now she has quit smoking.
anyways, he knows what's good for him...
changmin oppa FIGHTING!
princessfittja 4 months ago
He is smoking, you can see the cigarette smoke in the first seconds. Hope he's not doing it anymore T_T
KatShil23 4 months ago
i don't see him smooking???
TheBabynara 5 months ago
I wish that he and other people would find a better activity to take out their stress on. I'm Asian, but I don't like smoking. I mean, I can't force others to stop smoking, so I hope that they will soon find something else. Changmin/DBSK fighting! :D
digitallyzer0 5 months ago
I don't blame him for smoking. He's a grown up man, and he has the rights to do whatever he wants. But I'm pretty upset because it might ruin his voice.
xboredBITCH 6 months ago
Fuck. Changmin, no:( Sigh...oh well, it's his body and life.
TearsForLosers 8 months ago
lmao. Some of the comments are so melodramatic! Seriously, he's a grown man, and he can do what he wants....
greenring01 8 months ago 3
funny how he's a health freak and he smokes.
I'm not complaining, just laughing at the irony.
I still love him tho. Just disappointed.
vollygirl59 8 months ago
Although I am a little shocked that he would do this, I think we need to accept that this is his own decision, and we need to respect his decisions even though some may disagree. I mean, it's one cigarette. Maybe he only does this occasionally. Either way, I'm sure he well aware of the affects of smoking, and it's not like he's going crazy with it and being a rebel or anything. So lighten up a little.
KingMichaelForever 10 months ago
cutiegirlz93 10 months ago
So disappointed in myself, Changmin was filming at a place just one hour away from my house in Brisbane I couldn't get there...My only chance to see changmin up close...so disappointed (T_T)
Sammy02161 11 months ago
whats the deal if he smokes or not?i know we guys are just worried about his health or something but lets also remind ourselves that they have their own lives and they can handle it themselves..and i do think changmin is in the legal age to smoke..and another thing, if he smokes in the airport he'd be scolded even though he's a star coz its forbidden in the place...^_^
ravensuichiro03 11 months ago
so the whole group smokes
rubbishyt 1 year ago
I actually heard that many asians smoke. And lots of idols smoke too
FindSS501 1 year ago
i dont care if he smokes. i love him either way. smoking changmin is hot. non-smoking changmin is hot too. people smoke because they are stress, or some of them just wanted to smoke. like me for instance, i started smoking because, my dad, my friends was smoking and i thought it was fine. also i was under a lot of stress.
BABAAYhana 1 year ago
well. if you look it closely..you may see him, he have the smoke in his hand, and start smoke when the camera couldnt catch him beacuse of something i dont know.
anindhitadixelle 1 year ago
U can see on 0.07 there was smoke coming out from his hand..
qwesdsxfhjj 1 year ago
he...... smoke TT_TT
really truly crying at that.
why? stress that bad?
sigh. when did you start minnie? i thought you would be able to resist the temptation. guess not. </3
BrisingerButterfly 1 year ago
I always feel offended when people get so mad that one of them smoke >< ugg, it's not THAT BAD. Yes, it's unhealthy. so is eating candy. BAN CANDY EVERYONE. okay, so smoking is worse.... but still.... anywayssss, changmin is so cute in his all black! Hahaha like a lean ninja! thanks for the video :D
mocha7 1 year ago 3
Both boys have started smoking (Changmin and Yunho). I understand why, I mean what they're going through is tough. And I think Jaejoong started smoking again too. :L
ChromaticScreams 1 year ago
i dont really mind if he smokes or not
but thats not good
he is ruining is voice that way
and killing himself )=
nastypussbomb 1 year ago
Can I know when he was smoking in this vid? I keep straining my eyes trying to see but I can't?
And I'm not uptight like some people are about the matter. I think it's pretty understandable in this situation (if it's true cuz no one has yet to actually see him holding a cigarette in his hand and I'm not quick to believe hearsay over the internet without proof).
But anyway, I love this fancam. It's probably the clearest one in Australia. So thanks for sharing this with us. Good job:D
pammiej85 2 years ago
From the very beginning, he's in the smoking area. Its not very clear & the angle is slightly awkward 'cause we had to go into a coffee shop to see it & there were tables and chairs everywhere (obviously).
But yeah, he got off the bus, started smoking .. put it out then checked-in etc and not long after, went to that area and started again.
Whether you want to believe me or not is completely up to you.
haha thanks :D i put in lots of effort to see him ^^
angel0914 2 years ago
@pammiej85
So cool. I'm glad you got to see him. I know it couldn't have been easy from reading tons of fan accounts. You have a good aim and good camera.
pammiej85 2 years ago
with such stress pressure on him these months, smoking is reasonable, just hope things will get better and he'll quit smoking
changmin510 2 years ago 3
If he is smoking it's his business i will not love him any least but wish he wouldn't it could mess up his voice.
queenie2kool 2 years ago
so much talk about the smoking thing...
may i ask something ??
have you actually seen him smoke ???
just wondering ...
cause i am sure he is not smoking in this vid ...
allase 2 years ago 8
um , i saw him when he got off the bus. i didn't get to fancam it 'cause i was in a hurry to see him.
& in about 0:24ish onwards he's in the smoking area. i guess you cant really tell by the angle of the vid.
angel0914 2 years ago
Hmmm you actually saw him with a cigarette ? Hmmm i try to defend him :P
dunno what to think...
anyways thank you for answering
and providing us with the fancam ^^
i just hope he is healthy, nothing else
allase 2 years ago
He is smoking in this video. If yo ulook in the beginning of the video around 0:06 - 0:07, you see smoke coming from his hand. It isn't coming from any other angle BUT his hand. Then a bit later, you see his hand coming from his mouth. and a bit of smoke all over the place. And besides that, he's in a smoking area. :/
i4Cuz 2 years ago
we are all debating the rights and wrongs of smoking. some of you can accept it, and some of you are disappointed and think your hearts are breaking.
but ultimately, all i hope is...that no matter what, people will not let this turn them away from him, and will still always love and support him because he is a wonderful person, and this does not take away from that at all. he is not a lesser person just because he smokes.
i still love him. can any of you still say that? pls do.
berthillon88 2 years ago 4
I definitely still love him. I personally totally accept smoking. But he is such an excellent singer that I can't control myself to worrying about his amazing pitches.
kissmax88 2 years ago
I do!!!... I'll always suport and love him! and all the DBSK boys, no matter what ... like you said he's an amazing person and this smoking thin is not gonna change him...LOVE CHANGMIN!!..
marhavet 1 year ago
I am realy worried it may ruin his amazing voice, crying...
kissmax88 2 years ago
is his life...he can do whatever he want...smoke is not a crime....
hope that he feel happy this days...u_u
changminHyung 2 years ago
Stop it baby...im very worry abt ur health
very worry...
neera2007 2 years ago
I can understand it but i'm still be shocked!
Guess minnie is also smoking. That's WEIRD.
kissmax88 2 years ago 2
he's smoking but it don't really care, he's a big boy n_n and know what he does, rite?
thanks for sharing ^_^
coldheartbaby 2 years ago 3
He knows what he's doing yes, but he's ruining his voice. Smoke destroys the voice and makes it raspy. If he smokes, it's just going to destroy his voice. To the point where he can't even reach those amazing pitches. If he knew what he was doing, he wouldn't be smoking. He's smart but I think this choice is stupid.
i4Cuz 2 years ago 3
everybody have differents opinion. and yeah I know that what he's doing is wrong.
coldheartbaby 2 years ago
I understand that everyone has different opinions. I was just stating mine LOL. Sorry if I came off in a bad way.
i4Cuz 2 years ago
don't worry dear n_n
coldheartbaby 2 years ago
when i knew about Jaejoong,Yoochun and Yunho smoking along time ago..i already thought about Changmin or Junsu would smoke one of this days..and i think this is a day for Changmin-since this is the only video i/we have seen him smoking...or maybe he does smoke in their dorm or whatever..he's been around with people who smoke-not only the other 3 members mentioned but also the staff they are working with...sorry just my opinion..1st-hand smoking is better than 2nd hand smoking--LOL
mangdongi 2 years ago 3
omg! i love changmin so much and i never expected him to smoke..
i cry when i see him smoking..
i never expected him to smoke..
i just cant accept the fact that he smoke..
sorry guys i just cant accept it..*crying hard*
yes i know that he is a HUMAN but why did he wanna kill himself with the cigarette??
lynnChangmin 2 years ago 25
@lynnChangmin we all eventually die, honey.
it's not a big deal, and I'm sorry if you think it is.
just try to considere it as .. he needs it not to crack down.
cybergonz 2 years ago
maknae.... is.... smoking??? D:
why bb whyyyyyyyyy??? *cries*
yusan2 2 years ago 3
Actually..I take that back..If you look at the beginning of the video, you notice some smoke coming from his hand so it comes off like he has a cigarette. Then you see his hand coming from his mouth some how a bit later. He smokes..I never expected him to smoke. He's human but yeah, I never thought Changmin of all people would smoke D:. Do you think that shows signs of stress?
i4Cuz 2 years ago 4
@i4Cuz yeah...maybe bcoz of stress he's having recently though i'm quite surprised knowing him smoking.we'll nvr know why he started smoking.. gotta ask him then..but changmin-ah , there's lot of ways to relieve stress rather than destroying your own body
mikieyta 2 years ago
He's not only destroying his body, he's also destroying his voice. I mean, I guess you can't blame him since if you were under stress and the cig's were there, you would experiment with them to if other things didn't work. But once you're a singer, it's one of the worst things to do. You're just ruining your voice. And your voice is the reason why you're a singer in the first place.
i4Cuz 2 years ago 23
That's what I am worrying. His amazing voice...crying...
kissmax88 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
kissmax88 2 years ago
I don't see him smoking. It looks more like he's scratching his nose or something o_o.
i4Cuz 2 years ago
yeah, i guess it could be that too.
idno, thats just what i assumed he was doing. idno if anyone else saw him smoking.
but he was smoking once he got off the bus.
angel0914 2 years ago
i dont think he was smoking.. are you sure that he was smoking?
luvyanicky 2 years ago
im pretty sure.
he was smoking when he got off the bus too.
angel0914 2 years ago
when does he smoke?
yeahitsmeleslie 2 years ago
at the beginning of it. from about 0:24 - 0:37. i'm not too sure when he finished.
angel0914 2 years ago
@yeahitsmeleslie
at the beginning of the video you can see that he was like he is holding something and it's the cigarette since that's how most smokers hold their cigarette and i have been to brisbane and that's their smoking area
PRINIK13 2 years ago
oh ok i see now awh its weird that he smokes...-_-
yeahitsmeleslie 2 years ago 2
does anyone know since when he's smoking? it's the first time i saw him smoking or heard that he's smoking O.o did he start it in australia? O.o
Shame92 2 years ago 6
no one knows.
we all got to the airport and were surprised when he began smoking after he got off the bus. an hr or 2 later he went to that area (at 0:24) and started again.
angel0914 2 years ago
it may have been fake...maybe for his part in his drama or something??
mangopango44 2 years ago
when hearing the song i didnt even recognise it was changmin singing/
SuperSHINeelove 2 years ago
omg changmin really does smoke
PRINIK13 2 years ago
@PRINIK13 , wen does he smoke? i don't see him smoking
mangopango44 2 years ago 5
at about 0:24 him and the other cast members are outside. He was smoking to begin with, but i'm not sure exactly when he stopped.
angel0914 2 years ago
thanks for sharing your views of changmin!
koreamom 2 years ago