Beyond The Story Live 2005 海闊天空

[abc50451]

雖然家駒唔係到 但係佢地3個都唱得好好聽 

[jzsum2c27]

應該話有Ｄ似　兩段ＳＯＬＯ都

[jzsum2c27]

年少無知結尾段ＳＯＬＯ有呢段ＳＯＬＯ既ＦＥＥＬ

[lawrencegohome]

Best song ever

[kupeis]

最後一段solo 太感動了

[Topman383]

點解啊paul會彈彈下尾solo會左結他既,由黃黑果支轉左全­黑果支...

[razor7s]

我人生中第一首聽到的廣東歌！

[andykoey]

最後solo有點像灰色軌跡

[lamrainng]

這麼多年了 大家都不同了 但家駒永遠都會年輕

[wINgLuVnEvErDiE]

最後一段solo,在那一刻,paul就是吉他,吉他就是pau­l.. .

[kayeechoy]

無得頂

[SPeedYsingapore]

海闊天空 先係最能夠代表香港既歌

[qoo0755pk]

beyond的歌 我從小喜歡到大 雖然現在解散了 但是 我依然很喜歡他們!

[MiikkaKipper]

家強的vibrato很像家駒

[seriesfive]

again, amazing

[hongkongstyleable]

啊Paul D solo 簡直係結他中傳奇

[1128koma]

我覺得solo那一段很感人

[erickin1231]

拎mr.同beyond相比簡直係對beyond既褻瀆!!



[kingkriskk]

家强的歌声好柔和的一次



[wanchiming99]

 生日快樂

[wanchiming99]

 生日快樂

[wanchiming99]

生日快樂



[wanchiming99]

 生日快樂

[ahhao86]

Solo的部分太棒了

[DevilZEnka]

期待30週年music concert

[brucexx1974]

集合beyond三子之力去演繹這首名曲"海闊天空",真係唱出­曲中神采!

[dirk41dallas14]

三字的演唱呆着悲怆，令人感动，Beyond精神永驻

[dirk41dallas14]

三字的演唱呆着悲怆，感动

[binjoan1314]

beyond不是找不到主唱 而是沒人能替代家駒...... 不管家駒在不在 不管BEYOND樂團存在與否  都別忘了這份感動

五年 十年後 很難說誰還會記得 還會上YOUTUBE觀看

家駒沒死

一直都活在我們心中 !!!

[airsoftbrian]

相信黃家駒仍在世既話，Beyond一定唔會散！

[larrainewong]

i wonder how long that guy had played piano i loved how he plays the song piano is not my favorite instrument guitar is doesn't matter how the guitar or which type just at least is a guitar that's all it matters

[futayuan]

堅持理想,夢想??聽過太多的感動,強迫放棄一直夢想的目標,沒­有抱怨,只有承受!

只是沒想到跌倒了,連努力要爬起來的權利都沒有,失去的?未完成­的?只有告訴自己,

放下也好,轉彎也好,明天?未來?失敗的代價"堅持的代價?最後­必須失去的是自己最後的"家"又或許我根本沒有過"家"?40年­來的努力,跌倒了再爬起來不知多少次'原來一直追求的是想要完成­小時候的夢想"我想要一個家""一般人的眼裡"家"是多麼的理所­當然,'輕而易舉,而我!卻是追求大半輩子也追求不到的夢想?堅­持到底的人?真的就是為了要找到"一個家"嗎?好像是離我越來越­遠了''真的!越來越遠

[5230ken]

這一版有一種激勵上進的感覺~~

[qiansu2001]

BEYOND太可惜老。。。否则要多多少经典歌曲。。

[JASON1995824]

@qiansu2001 BEYOND是永遠不會老

[binjoan1314]

不管過多久 這個感動都會在心中~~ ROCKER的精神 就是ROCK 永遠不會改變 家駒並沒有走~~~ 祂將自己跟BEYOND變成聲音 ~~~ 感動每一個先來後到者

也許這樣的歌  過一.二十年已經很少人記得了 ~~

但請別忘記這份感動

17年了 傷痛該化為轉機 否則就會隨著時光流逝

期待有~~~ 新 BEYOND!

[marco54927]

為什麼KTV裡沒有這個版本......

[MrDjthew]

paul支吉他流眼淚...

[larrainewong]

he's not crying anymore i am crying while singing this with them

[tszmichael]

我覺得4:41-4:45好似有d唔自然

但係我都覺得佢彈得好好

solo最尾果度最正

[helen0music]

这个版本的吉他独奏我也很喜欢~很不一样，有很激动的感觉，还有­一种说不出的感觉~

[manjin04]

perfect solo, but not in F major

[shitfucksuck]

anyone knows the name of the secession guitarist?

[forever2271]

The solo was better than the one in 2003. But nothing can beat 1996 version! 1996 version was the most genuine expression. Could hear they were crying. That is how powerful music is and what music is about!

[forever2271]

This song was written for Beyond 10 yr anniversary. It ended up a signature song for Beyond. Everyone could feel their pain when they sing this song even without knowing the story. For those who know story, can't stop crying!

[larrainewong]

anybody know where i can get their album from online and download it cause every x i try to look for album to download from a music artist i can never find it

[lowping54]

雖然世榮唱歌係差dd,

但係睇得出佢有心唱

[CrazyLimz90]

Really heart touching song....

[CrazyLimz90]

Indeed

[CrazyLimz90]

Indeed

[winforlily]

點解beyond咁中意撒旦手勢？

[chrisku2002]

@winforlily this is symbol of ROCK

[millywml]

@winforlily 係和平手勢

[ifortube]

搖滾不死!

[eason163]

聽到有少少想喊,太感人

[xusiduo2u]

这个版本的尾奏很狂妄

[ParadiseQ]

@xusiduo2u 明显不是。这个尾奏是所有尾奏中最稳定的。结束音很和谐，以往的­包括03和96的结束音都有未完待续的感觉。

[xusiduo2u]

@ParadiseQ 你何以听出稳定？我对你的看法是这么理解的，这个版本是和CD里­最像的。

[ParadiseQ]

@xusiduo2u 如果你说的CD原版是指家驹的版本，那尾奏应该是无限延长然后渐­渐消失的。我说的稳定是指最后结束的时候，96和03的尾奏结束­音应该是F调的G,05版本结束音就是F调的C了，显然C比G稳­定多了。G尾音很容易让人产生没有完成的感觉。你仔细想想这3个­版本最后的结束部分就知道了。

[pall0121]

@xusiduo2u

這個結尾我感覺不是狂妄 應該是他對家駒的一的思念 用更長更激昂的方式來跟家駒"對話"

[Samuel08052]

能聽得出最後一段solo奏出paul對beyond依依不捨之­情,paul是不捨得的

[alex2388hk]

對!

[ParadiseQ]

@Samuel08052 感情很复杂。有恋恋不舍，但是结束音又让人感觉已经很满足了。这­个尾音和以往的尾奏都不一样。感觉是个完整的句号。

[ejsionan]

@Samuel08052 BEYOND迷也不捨啊！不管以後還會不會再重組或在音樂路上有­更多的做為、作品，BEYOND迷永遠支持！永遠的BEYOND­....

[MrDjthew]

4:25 百聽不厭

[MyCreal]

My fav band since im 6 years old, even i am lakia..i really love beyond & their songs.. =)

[jwh8808]

best solo ever....such emotion....

[reviver4dream]

阿paul 真噶sexy

[jason93629]

BAND SOUND NEVER LEFT HK!

[hide98000]

香港樂壇既傳奇!!!!

再唔會有好似佢地咁既樂隊,,

beyond!!!!

[funnyjoke23]

how is beyond like, this they r different from 10-15 years ago. their style is different, and the notes are off. But bryond r the best and 4 of the bandmates r never left behind

[AwesomeElvee]

of course man! 葉世榮is awesome

[changalator]

I think the drummer is the best singer in the group besides Ka Kui.

[austinsavage]

@changalator the drummer is the worst singer in the group, thats why he doesnt sing a lot on the albums. still, each one of them deserves respect and i love them all

[funnyjoke23]

Wong ka kui is so much better

this person is 70% is good, 30% off note!

ka kui is 100 % good,

thanks for sharing

[austinsavage]

@funnyjoke23 of course ka kui is 100%. still, there's no reason to diss his bandmates. they've always insisted they are a 4 person band and they deserve respect coz they still play the old songs even though they can't match ka kui's original vocals.

[funnyjoke23]

thank you, Thatas what I meant

[websaint]

Yes ka kui has a wider dynamic voice so his version is in the key F, whereas post beyond manage the song in E.

[gaojinghong]

a paul 的和声很准呢

[gaojinghong]

听过无数遍之后，还是无畏与无助并存，很奇妙

[badboy250984]

no wonder ka keung's bass sound different on this gig. He uses ampeg 8x10 cab where he use to use 4x10 + 1x15 cabs on his show.

[xxedisonx]

man i cant stop listening to this song. ive been replaying this song since i was 12. theres some curse lolol. my friends got influence by me after singing this song everyday now and then. LOL

[pckp83]

gives me such a complicated feeling everytime when i listen to this wonderful song...a mix feeling of 喜,怒,哀,樂

[helen0music]

很喜欢阿paul这个版本的吉他独奏～很有感觉～

[marilyn735294]

love this song

[cafeteria0060]

事實上，我們的確不可能再像海闊天空中聽到家駒的聲音，但是，我­每次都很期待聽beyond演繹這首歌，因為他們每次都會加上新­的變奏，尤以尾段最為靈活，每每聽到海闊天空的魂，那磅礡的音樂­魂

[SabeRmIKi]

真的很堅強他們  那淒厲的結他聲 淚珠不自覺地流

[batongalmusic]

I would give anything to hear KaKui sing this sing again... T.T

[batongalmusic]

*song

[fourteennd]

Ka Kui --- We will always remember u .....

[stupidbiker]

The guitar solo just gets better and better !

[kokia333]

ka kui：我一世都不會忘記您！

[pckp83]

they sing with different tone in this concert...very nice...beyond forever!!!

[imeight]

百听不厌

[SuHangSit]

顶BEYOND！

[JoeSon]

this is good stuff

[wuttivai]

經典作品，

悅耳好聽，

無懈可擊！

beyond, you are the best.

[lom98c73]

加油!!

[nokia8250]

was this is singapore?

[alex2388hk]

in hk

[acaftermath007]

love it

[hannah516]

I miss ka kui.....................