Porcupine Tree - Shallow

[00ThePolice00]

That was fucking fantastic, especially the fact that you're a multi-instrumentalist. Your voice really suits the Porcupine Tree sound and the drumming is great considering you are covering Gavin Harrison.

[CoasterBob62]

AWESOME!! This freakin JAMS.

[flakosergio1]

suena la raja compadre...

[DPScott20]

Very cool, buddy. :o)

[mariusel666]

holy fucking shit your voice is awesome i'd play porcupine tree covers with you all day man

[DviniciusribeiroT]

GREAT!

[gazuul]

It's obvious that you have to some more work with the guitars etc, but man - you've got a shitass nice voice!

[NickBolland]

You're very fucking talented, you play all those instruments and got good vocals... nice

[deederzzz]

the timing is perfect if you go back and listen its not 4 4 timing and he is spot on with his timing

[fingerboy18]

The timing on the guitar is a little off, but it sounds really good! Definitely a Tool vibe on this track.

[1337rocklee]

The timing seems to be a bit off, I suppose that's a given though when you play 3 different parts at once. Good work

[capasquarello]

i dont listen to the original anymore..

[DviniciusribeiroT]

@capasquarello Man, me too.

[gogolMax]

Wow! Well done dude, you rock!

[samoaapia1970]

sometimes your voice sound like geddy lee????:D

[202roller]

could you make a tab for the guitar plz :DD

[draperyfallsdrums]

dude do you have 2 much money :O

all those instruments and especially all those sabian aax cymbals :O

i was happy as hell when i got my aax ride this christmas :D

[Snedd99]

@draperyfallsdrums

Hehe it took a lot of years to build up my set of instruments. I kept on adding to my drumkit one piece at a time to transform it into the kit it is today. Good shout on the AAX ride though, it definitely pays to go for decent quality cymbals.

[dkortekaas2]

to f*cking cool!

yea, to good

[rickycuquis]

Excelent cover, really amazed on how you handle all the instruments including voice. Congratulations and greetings from Mexico.

[Shezmen88]

why not putting "cover" in the title...?

[ericmauromusic]

Awesome cover. Steven Wilson should include you in his next album.

[beefjirky]

I'm not a professional or anything, but i would suggest when mixing to try to muffle the high-hat a little bit. It's kind of a piercing sound, otherwise it sounds great :p

[Lohior]

@gecsomane This is... an insult?



[roodiedroogie]

This is just amazing!!

[xWildxChildx92x]

@gecsomane i see nothing homosxual about this vieo. watch your mouth, homophobe

[xWildxChildx92x]

PHENOMENAL

[zzzzz674]

@gecsomane If you are better just prove it , 11 years old dickhead.

[Azz1883]

Brilliant cover guys!

[Azz1883]

@gecsomane we don't want to hear you coming out of the closet on youtube.

[Dennishallback]

Great cover, unbelievable musical talent!

[watercolorkingdom]

I enjoyed all your talents put into this excellent choice of pt

[laripsspiral]

Fantastic.

[tim6687]

You did and AWESOME job covering this song...Well Done!!!!!!!!

[melmec]

@gecsomane

its really nice you finally came out of your shell....my little butterfly

[Keksdiebchen]

got it neraly 3 years on my xbox 360 and never realized that this song was made by porcupine tree haha. love this band

[RBPowerS2]

Yeah loved it mate, u pretty much > the whole band by yourself!

At one poit you cant make out the difference between real and cover imo ;)

[BeyondApathy]

Great vocals!

[xgloid]

Awesome! Good job!

[AliceDamnation]

Awesome!

[FoamingGypsy]

your vocals are epic man

[Xoutravolta]

Your singing is beautiful.

[platinumdynamite]

Excellent vocal work.

[faceofmelinda1]

Well done dude! Really good job! Thumbs up. Cheers

[skateNappreciate]

you guys should start a band, ASAP

[DistractBot]

timing's a bit off but fantastic otherwise! Your voice is great! Maybe the guitars need to be sped up a bit or put ahead of the mix a bit

[dirkjakobmetal1]

i need to learn how to play all those instrument O.o i'm doing bass guitar atm did drums when i was 7-8... xD

[pilarpenaescobar]

download it from Ares, for free

[Jdcie]

Way to step up the normal bland you tube cover! I love full covers of tunes, specially Porcupine Tree. Nicely done!

[xxFallenxxAngelx]

@gecsomane OMG!  just like you :D awesome n_n

[txd]

I actually thought it was the real song until i read "me playing"

really talented :D

[txd]

OMG awesome :D

[PurpleFunion]

great cover

[PATRICKoxoEthafulm]

Awesome job, you don't need any "friends to mention" because you are doing great on your own

[dirlewanger42]

great cover dude

[XjerichoX12]

this is the only song i listen to on xbox.

[RumIslandoftheP]

Well Done! Hate to say it, but I like it better than the original. Sharper, cleaner, better singing.

[V1Mag]

great going dude, kudos to you!

[jtaber]

that is impressive. i barely play one instrument right haha

[Snedd99]

@gecsomane

Mate, whatever you are, I'm cool with it.

[PcpTree]

excellent work dude.!

[chinguidinsky]

you know i couldn't find the original anywhere on youtube, it's all covers and shit, but then i said whata hell, let's give a try, clicked on yours and i had no need for the original no more, this is porcupine tree nicely done.

[vaibanez17]

You're really good. Keep it up. PT Rules.

[deathmetalwalrus]

fucking amazing, specially singing! =O .. Just the guitar timing let it down big time aye... Plus I reckon you should have used a better distortion tone. Or maybe it was just the recording quality?

[TroubadorToday]

Very impressive!! Have your own studio and all that equipment? Good job putting that all together!!! Keep on jammin'!

[schirick]

wow, that is extremely well done! hats off to you, talented man!

[aarohv]

perfect sound..amazingly played......you can really sing steven's songs.......unlike everyfuckinOne tryin to cover PT

[aarohv]

nicely done man!!!!..

the first cover of PT on youtube i actually liked..

[origindirewolf]

should have put "cover" in the title

[Fen3rbahce]

good job man sounds perfectly in tune

[killAlot80]

you're fuckin' awesome o.o... so impressive!

[MalinTantoDecesso]

Can someone give me a Link where i can download this song? thx (no cover!)

[Snedd99]

@MalinTantoDecesso

Amazon or iTunes sell it, or I think it comes bundled with an Xbox 360 (although that'd be a really expensive way of getting it).

[N3Ti]

@Snedd99 XD hahahaha

[GamerfreakB7]

@Snedd99 ANOTHER person who has this music on their 360. I've NEVER met anyone else who got this music on their 360. Did yours also have "Band-Girls-Money", "Pressure", "Get Up" or "Happens All The Time"?

[Snedd99]

@GamerfreakB7 I've never owned a 360 myself, but one of my mates who had one commented on the fact that it was bundled with it. It may have only been a certain edition or region that got it.

[evilresidence4]

@GamerfreakB7 i got all those aswell.

[dxAngelxOfxChaosxb]

@GamerfreakB7 on my first xbox i had the songs. but that was a while back when Oblivion was still a huge title. i've gotten a new xbox xince then so i dont have them and more.

[Fatgnomeable]

@MalinTantoDecesso Buy The Album.

[MalinTantoDecesso]

Canj i find this song somewhere not covered??

[baneXVII]

The way you say "Not if you bleed" a bit slower than the rest of the song, is magnificent! These little details make a big difference! Well done!

[mrdigits1]

nice job...it's a lot of work to learn someone else,s entire song...all the parts...pretty f#&king talented

[Nagraath]

Good work with hitting some of those vocals. Need to fix some timings up though. Still, great work.

[SmileysRevenge100]

YEAH! GO TRENT REZNOR GO!

[me141094]

whoever disliked i will personally cry at XD

[GREATGOOGOLYMOOGOLY]

Holy crap! You're awesome! I seriously would never have expected a cover of a song to be this good and close to the original.

[LyraGothe]

I love it. Good voice!

[drummer42065]

Nice job! Make some more PT or Blackfield covers :D

[AlexPastiu]

good stuff man

[death377]

this is the only cover of this song i can listen to. All the others suck

[Desiderata321]

I heard about this band because of this song. It was on my xbox when i got it. Looks like MS knows good music.

[spike12256]

Awesome cover!

[9TayldFox]

Great vocals!

[toedivillarock]

like steven willson... good!

[qwertysow]

That's a cover right there!

[TimandJakeTV]

you're absolutely awesome dude! good job.

[couragios]

The best there ever was, really !!!!

[davidalejandro90]

what a cover, dude!!!!!

5 stars, no doubt about it...

[MrCarmelist]

nice mixxxxxx!!!!!

[Simmoexd97]

You voice is so exaclty same as the singer hope it's you :D Keep it up!

[mismiks]

love it. :)

[TheLore]

Absolutely awesome!

[1HottieChick1]

ohmygod! its fricking awesome!!!!! it sounds so fricking much like the original!!!! freaking awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[OORESTIS]

one of the best PT cover ever heard... keep it going man

[alien8ted]

In-fucking-credible talent! I am gobsmacked by your proficiency on all those instruments! 5 stars!

[barrystock4]

great job dude !

[95TurboSol]

Good job man!

[amaranthAngels]

wow :D

[WoisWalter]

i like this song

[lifesXaXgift]

You are sooo talented :).  Keep going, this is awesome.

[Theblob516]

Wow, best cover of this song on youtube.

I'll subscribe in hopes that you make more videos like this one!

[gODHEAD999]

great

[makokan2000]

led zeppelin crossed with tool.....about timeand later a little pink floyd

[heavyonit]

Did you perchance record the guitars/bass before the drums? The drums sound like they're trying to keep up with the guitars rather than the other way around.

Still, awesome work. You're very multi-talented.

[NOVAVALIANT]

Well done man. Awesome Video work as well.

[chrisDOTnet]

This is great, well done!!

[arquis5274]

My favorite song of Porcupine Tree...you rock pal!

[jamy313]

amasing man not 2 sure bout the singin tho

[Metsuri34]

i think even the singing is perfect. it's almost like orginal... :)

[newknick5]

Pretty damn good, but a tip on the chorus, when you sing shallow, shallow give it to me, you stop short on shallow which makes it not flow as well

[inuyashafan3448]

This song is epic. You made the best cover, easy.

[tomergery22]

you rock!!!

[mattlightbound]

good but a tad slow i think.

[Snedd99]

@mattlightbound

It's to-the-millisecond the same speed as the original.

[Fuel62100]

good job :)

[noteinteresa1717]

You spend a lot of money in instruments, do you wanna make a band or something like that, i play guitar and bass

[alihaus]

niceee , i love it  :)

[oshobaba]

awesommooo.......

[ILpisa9493]

Very good job! *_*

[jayakishore1234]

dude whoaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!­!

genius

[FabulousButLazy]

Hey I liked your voice, it spices your cover very well. Awesome song.

[heinzie5]

damn thats impressive!

[therealmorpheu5]

Damn, this was good :)

[TastySnacks]

really good! wow steve wilson would be impressed! :D

[jcreighton13]

Nice job!

[1Vomit1]

FAIL... dude u FAIL...

[heinzie5]

how the fuck does he fail?!

[burningthecake]

Awesome cover!!

[inhalingsounds]

The tempo mistakes make it "original". Outstanding work dude!

[couragios]

One of the best covers i've ever seen

[clwatts88]

lol, air drums at 4:00, this is very good, a metronome would fix those timing issues but its not a big problem

[Snedd99]

I recorded the track to a metronome that was synced to the original track, the timing issues are from my guitar playing, which at the time of recording this wasn't too great hehe.

[javimati80]

This is awesome. Keep up the good work!!!!!

[Pacifist75]

bravo

[jefferyvonlindt]

Very cool!! Too bad you don't live close....my son could use a real guitarist to jam with, for now, he's stuck with me.

[terrf66]

wow. good job dude

[ashwalk85]

some timing problems, but otherwise great

right amount of feeling

you sound a whole lot like ty tabor!

[toolfan92]

wowowowowowow awesum

[goshops]

I almost thought this was fake because it was too good. But then there are some minor mistakes, which makes it even better!

Fantastic cover!

[PadraigTKav]

This is literally the most amazing cover I have ever heard done by ONE person.

GREAT job man.

[mohamedbeard]

that was pretty sexual

[MYM0NK3YD13D]

NICE!

[Neanderskrikaren]

Awesome :O

[MorandRuler]

reeaally nice! respect

[Molochai01]

great

[cloudsaredreams]

awesome cover man! :)

but may I say, that when you go to the drum clips, your hair grows. :s  xD

[Drumpro712]

sweeeeeeeeet !

[DSkehan2004]

I first heard their music Porcupine Tree in 2005. This was the first song I heard. It was playing in Four Brothers.

[WickedCrawl]

Holy shit, fucking great !!!

I'd love to do something like this, but I don't have the money T_T

[Schirf]

Good job...

[MrMusic25]

you are very talented. all i play is guitar/bass, and only an amatuer drummer, all of which i can only play this song on guitar. Bravo to you!

[TheLittleDB]

I love it man

Your voice is better than in the original.

keep up ;)

[deficx]

Guitars weren't kinda on time sometimes, but other than that: BRILLIANT! :)

[RobTiser]

Love it.

[duffypinecrest]

Epic win, sir.

[BenniMuzak]

good voice! i liked it ;D

[luckyisretarded]

Damn brother, you rip it up! Wish you lived in Vegas so we could jam some PT covers!Ha!

[diffoperator]

Holy crap....

[chuck4545]

Wow that was good. Great!

[WashAwayUsAll]

simply awesome

[WashAwayUsAll]

one of the best covers i have ever hear

keep it up,man

[WashAwayUsAll]

one of the best covers i have heard

gr8 job done and keep it up

[pmschoolsucks]

simply amazing seriously man great job!

[flubass]

very nice!

I have to say... Incredible my friend !!!!