Porcupine Tree - Trains

[saurabhbasu86new]

damn good vocals, damn good guitar tone.. only with that one string in your guitar was better tuned..

[Graath666]

well done.

[gipuxx]

Such a nice cover, huge respect to you, guys.... :)

[djfrank203]

i like your voice a lot

[dumbdummy]

great voice, even better than Steven wilson!!! ^^

[SirEnte93]

Great voice dude ;)

[fullmetalcornflake]

not bad, not bad, keep it up!!

[doctorcoxable]

awesome cover dudes!

great voice!

[elruly89]

great cover man !!

=)

[hcassar]

it's just not the same without the acoustic

[ArrueVT]

It's Ok. This song is magic.

[Obskur777]

Superve voix ! Proche de celle de Steven. Très bonne reprise d'ailleurs

[gratteurdebluesteel]

@Obskur777

euh merci beaucoup... peut être un peu too much kan même pour la voix ;p mais c'est très gentil.

[alfalex38]

Un batteru français... et GAUCHER!!! =D

[ajvar4e]

FUCK !!! Your voice is awesome... and everything else... :) YOU ROCK DUDES!!! :) AWESOME COVER!!!

[Incredevil]

really good!

[Deathshuck]

Great cover! :D I'm sure Steven and boys would be proud. Greetings from Finland.

[frozenmouse76]

excelent !

[Loskeviiva]

WOW! Was a pleasure watching this. Keep it up! The singer has a great voice - usually these "would-be-bands" tend to crash to a crappy vocalist, but he is GREAT!

[gratteurdebluesteel]

@Loskeviiva

thx u very much :)

[joelioes]

nice !!! really nice !!!! and great voice too !!!

Thumbs Up From NYC !!

[gratteurdebluesteel]

@joelioes

;) thx you!

[Porter07]

GOOD ONE!!! WATCH OUT THAT VOICE!

[RadioBreizh]

Ca fait plaisir de voir des groupes FR jouer du Porcupine Tree. ;)

Bon cover !

[gratteurdebluesteel]

@RadioBreizh

Merci beaucoup :)

[TheCoder09]

i have to say, the drummer isn't that good... always crash / Ride. As good as no variation.

sry...

[JakeTheFakez]

Very nice!

[carleysmada]

Good cover! Great song, very impressive.

[Chimpanzor]

Good cover :)

[EliasUlrich1984]

cool, good song to cover.....

[murtaznawaz]

Not that Bad..! As a Cover, it's Good...!

[blackfild]

beautiful, good voice

[jenskurtstein]

No solo? ):

[gratteurdebluesteel]

sure..... with my feet? :D

[riolimagic]

good cover, but the drumming was shight.

[stupenka]

wow

[mtabet02]

tune those guitars, practice a bit, could be worse

[Metallophilic]

nice cover! :D

[shadowz2112]

2:14

did samus just drop a bomb in the backround?

[RosSigurs]

This is good band

[BrotherGilburt]

Well done.

[xeeipee]

exelente voz..muy buena..

[polotenchikof]

like your voice =)

[meetmeatthe1]

Great vocal work!

[dionysio90]

very good cover, but it was better with another distorted guitar and a second voice to support....good job ;)

[JupiterIsland91]

why no distortion? :(

[HomoRidiculus]

great job!

[StupidoForte89]

very good execution but you must move a little bit, while you play

[BenniMuzak]

good singer...

[magedtarek]

very good work guys! it is one of the hardest song to play and u played it very good.

[lukeydeey]

I agree it's definately a hard song to play and you played it well, could've done with second guitarist tho!

[GiulioTrust]

?? hardest song? I play in a PT cover band and...I say I desagree...

[Darksquad666]

I agree with you, this isn't hard to play ! but to make it sounds good that's the hardest part with all the PT songs ! Anyway ! nice work guys ;)!

[Scarteh]

@GiulioTrust

me too.

[TheRandomNab]

@GiulioTrust ye agree..I would say one of their easiest songs. one of their best aswell imao

[superstriker00]

@GiulioTrust Out of curiousity sir, I'd like to ask what their hardest one in your opinion is?

[GiulioTrust]

It's not the hardest...i play in a PT tribute band and I disagree...check the mine if you want...look to the right in "correlated videos", it's the first "Trains" - Porcupine Tree by Giulio trust

[EliasUlrich1984]

Maybe you're a super musician.......I can say I'm good one too, but hate when people feels superior, maybe you didn't mean it......PT rules.

[Brageca]

Your version is recorded using Pro Tools. This version is live. You can't compare the difficulty of playing in a studio with playing and singing live

[grf0492]

Well, umm, actually, this is a very easy song to play. I've been playing guitar for 3 weeks and I can play Trains. But regardless, this song is incredible. Porcupine Tree=genius.

[7153eric]

bullshit

[pinescentedwoodsmoke]

try singing and playing, it's a lot harder.

[erikeepper]

@grf0492 Actually this is a very hard song to play on guitar.

[urbokenji]

@erikeepper thats not true!!

[J0000OOOO]

@erikeepper

i agree. much harder than it sounds.

[daryljoseph777]

not true!

[Chavii185]

great job

I´d never thought of a maraca doing the claping part. if you can call it that way On min. 3.35.

Love it. keep it up

[progkidjoel]

I'd just like to say this is a really fantastic job.

You pulled off the vocals really well, considering your voice is quite different to Steve Wilson's.

Allround 5/5 Job guys. Keep it up :)

[marillionjenn]

great job on this!!!!

the vocal sounds like the dude from Lifehouse.

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx you for your comment but for the voice i don't now if i really worth the comparison ;)

[masterchui]

wow... excellent guys

[koolakalle]

dats c00l

[aut212]

awesome cover

nice place for a gig :)

[carol0v3]

really did this justice in my opinion.

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx a lot for your comment :)

[Lustmord1970]

Pretty good work guys.... :)

[dyingforacup12]

That was actually pretty good. Real version's better though. And what strokesonfilm said, drummer should use more symbals, and more groove.

[strokesonfilm]

To play something with three that's normally played by five people is gutsy. Especially outdoors. Great job. Drummers tip: use more hi hat and use the other crash cymbal(s).

[demolitionhammer23]

man i loved this video. As big as a fan I am. I think it sounded great. Keep it up

[lorentejean]

Excellent mon fils, continue, tu es doué !

bises

[evoeight04]

Excellent!

[AlekzisResdau]

Esta versión jamás sera superada, es hiperbólica, acabarca la totalidad de la trascendencia del tema. Un franco Homenaje a un grupo de chicos (otros no tanto) que se esfuerzan, ensayando día tras día por ser mejores músicos.

Ojo:

con la habilidad del Batero. Glam.

Con la capacidad de improvisación del bajista. Grupo Folklore.

Con la prolijidad de la guitarra y voz, ese muchacho aspira. El grunge del grupo.

[JulE0n]

Nice cover. Acoustic guitar may have worked a bit better for this song, but still not bad at all.

[jmill3223]

take the bass out of the intro

[Legatedamar1]

Everything was good actually. I just wasn't too crazy about the bass player. It sounds like he's out of tune slightly. And one or two times i heard him playing the wrong notes.

[Teletransmutacion]

Great :) this is the best cover of trains that i have seen

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx you very much :)

[ferenc59]

What chords are you playing at the "Hiss of the train at the railway head"?

They should be C - A7 - Am - Em (Positions relative to the 5th fret)

Sounds like you're playing D - A - Am - Em

just a little poke but I am a stickler for playing covers precisely.

I don't see any problems with the drums.

All in all very pleasant. I really loved your vibrato in the vocals and the chorus is just angelic, AAAAAlllways the summers are slipping away!!!

[gratteurdebluesteel]

i do A Am C Em.... i'll try with the chords you've told me. thx a lot for your comment :)

[mislibelulas]

heyyles sale muy bieen :)

felicidades!!

[gratteurdebluesteel]

muchas gracias :)

[Shreshth91]

The vocals are just... amazing! =O

I didn't like the drums though.

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx for my voice :) don't be soo rude with my drummer please ;)

[parrappluie]

belle reprise bravo =)

[gratteurdebluesteel]

merci:)

[YogritMUN]

awesome singing, mediocre drums

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx for my voice. don't be soo rude with the drummer, "mediocre" is quite hard no??? you don't like, give advice, a video from you to improve or something like that should be better don't you think? thx a lot for you comment :)

[YogritMUN]

I've actually been thinking about putting a drum video up for Trains, so I may just take your advice. Sorry if I came off as mean to your drummer. You guys probably work hard, so I apologize. All I've got to say though, is that the drums for that song are more intricate than what your drummer is playing, and really not hard at all if he practices it more.

[kushisaac]

nice cover, where y'all located?

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx a lot, we're from Chabeuil, near Valence in France

[darksomethingg]

Hmm not bad at all.. keep it up

[gratteurdebluesteel]

thx ;)

[mastontq1pijo]

q ascooooooo

joder como se puede destrozar una obra de arte

maxo antes de tocar una guitarra estudia ostia

[gratteurdebluesteel]

before saying something like that, show us what you're able to do... i can't see any video on your profile.... we play music just for fun, we don't think we're professionals or something like that, and our band play only since few month. so if you don't like, and it's your right, there's a lot of great bands (earning money cause it's their job) you can watch here... so stop being so sarcastic... at 25, it's time to grow up and learn to shut up when it's time to...

[andrisvk]

Greeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeat !!! :) I like that.

[gratteurdebluesteel]

Glad you like it ;) woooo, now we're known in slovakia! You have to tell your friends about us Andry ;)

[Sophak]

super les gars! ça assure :)

[gratteurdebluesteel]

Merci à toi c'est vraiment sympa, j'en profite pour remercier tout ceux qui sont passés voir nos vidéos (deja + de 600 a l'heure à laquelle j'ecris ces lignes!), et n'hésitez pas à nous laisser un petit com.

[DoSith]

perhaps you could next time use a akustic guitare sounds better =)

[gratteurdebluesteel]

Yes... that's what i've thought about when i've seen the video for the first time... :/ next time!

[DoSith]

sry but i dont like, what you drummer played. The reason for only 4 Stars :D

But nice cover

[gratteurdebluesteel]

we played this song only 5 or 6 times before... drums are difficult on this song and can't be learned just like that...

Thx for your comment ^^