Added: 4 years ago
From: microbot23
Views: 56,117
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (56)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What a nice version!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This is my favorite version of my favorite song by Chan.

  • going through the different versions of metal heart on utb, i feel that none have come near reaching the dislodging of emotions achieved with the drunken, delayed timing of the guitars in the original album recording. later versions seem to mishandle and inarticulate this crucial timing and, in the end, loose the soul of the song as it was forged. nonetheless, all are valuable, despite the fact that newer recordings change the meaning of the song .

  • too good

  • the most beautiful version of the most beautiful song.

  • saw her at this time -1998 - in australia. hadn't heard of her but she was playing with jim white, drummer from the dirty three so went. small bar & small crowd, she stood mostly behind & off to side of jim white, with a long fringe covering her face, so quite distant & reserved. but was compelling, as quite different feel to average rock gig at time, the reserve toward audience made it bit uneasy & out of norm, audience wasn't entirely sure how to respond to absent/present singer. her best song

  • GOOSEBUMPS

  • I like the band and hard core stuff better than her solo emo shit. She is amazing however, especially the voice and attitude.

  • Cat Power is amazing, the metal and background instruments on this number is really cool. I like the more hard core stuff better than the complete solo stuff she does, that sometimes borders on emo.

  • I like to be sad, I love this song. I work better in sadness so I enjoy.

  • I think I read that she got sober... and, I'm glad for that... but her music has suffered, I think.... This is great! Contrast to the later versions...

  • Viva The Cat !!

  • Thank you

  • This song had to be a single... I Still waiting for a video ToT

  • this should be played on radio stations. there is no need for a video... grow up!

  • @microbot23 But that would be amazing *w*

  • I Like This Version The Best..... Incredible .........Sad Sad Zoo.... That Voice.

  • Comment removed

  • Absolutley! Love You Baby.. Dillon

  • Blue Smoke Will Take A Very Violent Flight...

  • Beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful Chan :D :), something for car driving :)

  • Greatest song ever???

  • best version of this one i have heard

  • This version is beyond words.

  • One of my favorite photos of her! Soooo cute!

  • definitely the best version i've heard. better than both recorded versions (both of which are still awesome). wish i could find it somewhere...

  • its here

  • best version yet. thanx for posting it. where can i get the mp3?

  • yeah id like to get the mp3 too (:

  • oh i know where i can find it , read old comments

  • Google "youtube to mp3" and be satisfied.

  • this song kicks Ass!!! Brilliant!!!!!!!

  • this performance is pretty awesome! i thought her new version on Jukebox was the best it could get, but this may top it for me :)

  • this is a very wierd song.

    I love it

  • This is the best version ever! I love it! Thank you so much for putting this on here!

  • The greatest version of such an amazing song and still my favorite song of all time. Thank you so much for posting this microbot23! And did you realize you added this video the same day as Chan Marshall's birthday? Jan. 21st!!

  • pic looks like my girlfriend,shes other side of the world at the moment,fuck me i need a drink ha

  • Thanks a lot for the website! :)

  • Most. Brilliant. Song. Ever.

  • This song is so good.... but it makes me sadder than I've felt in over a year =(

  • Comment removed

  • If I was a song, I would probably be this one...

  • this version of the song is very heartfelt! i really love the texture of her voice! i think i am in love :)

  • how can i have it on my pc? can i?

  • chan . microbot . ch

  • It's so awesome to listen to this and to b eable to listen to the 2008 rendition, and know that when she used to sing it she thought she had life figured out, but when she sings it now she can look back and see how much better life really is. I'm so happy that she's finally free as she always wanted to be (at least from alcohol).

  • this is so good

    and i'm not kidding

  • A beautifully sublime version. That has to be Jim White on drums, yes?

  • Wow. :'(

  • This version is beyond words.

  • Yes I agree this is gorgeous. The sound is almost swollen. I don't like the cover version on jukebox, but this is so moving

  • Mymy, this is beautiful stuff.

    I would never believe I would find a version superior to the studio-take. You've proven me wrong, microbot.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more