Love Will Tear Us Apart by The Complete Stone Roses

[verstimmung]

Ахуенная песня!!!!!!!! в этом исполнении круче оригенала!!!

[CodaRockFest]

This is kinda funny actually. haha

[joe0910LFC]

terrible just terrible!

[MrKeepCalm]

Paul Young did a better version of that song. 

[RickyGums]

This is pish

[kingtiguer88]

NICE JACKET STONE ISLAND ;)

[bobbj77]

its 3 am, im pissed after another gig and was admiring the club lighting, then i remembered that i did it

[upyourtits]

...WEEKENDER! Pish

[stasonpodolski]

Please die

[TerryNicholson]

Great version,of a great song, great video, endorsed by Mr Hook, my Sister Joanne 39, breast cancer, no musical taste, but

Awesome, just love it for what it is, a top verson of a classic, top vid, top vocals, Mr Hook endorsed, dig the Roses, dig Joy Division, New Order, give these guys a break, top job. El-Tel66

[kwikfit76]

just realized who ya sound like flowerd up weekender

[kwikfit76]

well done lads better than the original much more up beat and funky and excellent guitar riffs. well suprised ;)

[MrSjb1963]

this is total bollox

[mclellanscott100]

if they wrote it ,,it would be a diffrent story & use no it so wake up people,..scott mclellan....& peter & carol take care scott..xx

[FrankChickens]

Great job of raping the corpse of Ian Curtis, Peter. Now why don't you boil his bones to make glue so you can make some more money from that?

[Noodles37UK]

Prospecthill Road at the Cathcart Road ?

[kaney1967]

I know this is for charity but they would have made more money and dented their reputation less if they sat in a bath of beans.

Horrible.

[foreverninio]

esto es una caca...this sucks!

[mikepee123]

WHAT A DISGRACE , produced by peter hook , he mite aswell go spit on ian cutis' grave ffs

[testoffaith1972]

Hmm dunno……fair play to them for giving it a go and trying something different. Not sure if I like it tho and obviously nothing will ever compare to the original……. liked the video tho, Morag Calder's gorgeous!

[sratus]

i feel sick

[9Arctic7Monkeys4]

Poor Ian Curtis!!!!! I hope he doesn't hear that in heaven!!!

[STFCstoneroses]

Shame coz these boys can play and are a sound bunch

[Bravo3zero]

S-H-I-T-E!!!!!

[deandorcy]

drek. absoloute and complete fucking shite. in the name of christs fat cock just step away from the mic and get a job in Currys or something.

[reddyredd]

Oh Yes It Will Now, Oh Yes It Will Now, It'll Tear Us, It'll Tear Us Woop Woop

[weavehole]

Who gave Robert Carlisle a Dirty Beppe?

[harryhunting]

shite shite shite and more shite

[stendeb]

what a pile of wank, from the beginning to the end I have have never heard something so shit

[bankslord]

A karaoke band doing a cover??

Jog on.

[Raighne1894]

It sounds more like a cover of 'Weekender' by Flowered Up.

[khalithistle]

cunts aboot forty year auld and hes goin tae the garage

[epping2ongar]

The worst video and cover of a song I have EVER seen on youtube.

[bittersound]

Holy shit, that was awful.

[interzoneinc84]

Fuck, that's gruesome.

[dharma3333]

couldn't get robert carlyle. cut your hair. uhhhhhhhhhhhhrrrrrreeeehhhh!

[rnrdemon]

Mediocre and kinda annoying. The video with that crappy happy end does the rest. If this would have been a record on my turntable it would have gone straight into the trash can. Using torture to collect money for cancer research: Ouch!

[badmadpilot]

Beyond awful. Not surprised to see Hooky's involved with this.

[DavidFromTrade]

Fuckin' Boo!

[ShabeyBambles]

a fuckin hate the complete stone roses !!!! they must be gutted they cant write new songs

there fuckin terrible

mon the actual stone roses

[b4k3r1]

one word describes this  PISH!

[ilovetheMCDonaldbros]

its her from river city

[1twistedfirestarter]

WELL BAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[splitpane]

FRANK GALLAGHER

[Aurality]

Holy Fuck.. what is this shit... It stinks of a dried up uncreative way of trying to make

money. It reaks of business. I have about as much respect for this as Crazy frogs

version of Axel F.

[georgejd29]

shite shite ahite

[redderstheamazing]

only good thing about this is his stone island jacket.

[youngie123]

@redderstheamazing be even better if it was real

[togetherwearemusic]

this maes me laugh, sounds like shit

[joa07caj]

The Completes are great but they should stick to being an exceptional Roses tribute band. I'm afraid this is awful.

[togetherwearemusic]

THIS IS WANK

[bxtrb86f]

only paul young's version is worse...

[thegrinch1973]

TRASH

[makeloveandomlettes]

this is a disgrace hope all involved with this die

[parapax]

total shit. 

[doubleredsx3]

shit, i can imagine ian curtis literally jumping up from his grave. what in the fuck is this?

[20LiamScholes09]

This is shit.

[M245475SH]

Hooky, why?

[joemunkey30]

i think this one would of sent ian to kill himself if he hadnt again

i feel like doing it now

[sijw1977]

This is true drivel...

[TerryNicholson]

Any one who uses the term 'pish' should just go back to rimming his little Sister or licking his own shite of his Dads cock, I am suprised you manage to type with your webbed fingers. I have life size statue of William Wallace's head on a pikestaff on my patio, we bring him in the house when England are on the telly, or when Murray is getting tubbed by anyone , I swear he looks like he's weeping, I've adapted his left ear so it functions as a bottle opener (I'm right handed) .

[djluckywiz]

this is awful

[SettingSun77]

Absolutely bobbins.

[sunnyb92]

oh dear! i'd rather hear the paul young version.

[15harbourstreet]

You can see by the content of the posts on this, that the combined IQ is probably about 3.

Imagine writing something like Ian Curtis would Turn in his Grave! WHY! do you expect it to sound exactly the same!

They are a Stone Roses Cover Band , Having a go at a Classic Joy Division Song, Good luck to them, sadder still if it was never covered ! Surely a tribute in itself.

Don't try to make yourself sound Clever, by Saying Mr Curtis. Hed be glad somebody covered his stuff, You Stupid Cunt!

[charlie4005]

Seriously? What a bunch of utter dog shit! Hey yeah we are fookin' mad for it an all that! Bad cover! Gives the roses a bad name.....wankers!

[juanaloulehoux]

this sucks

[danathorGR]

NO... You Suck

[scootb73]

Haha I used to be best mates with the actor in that video.

[ayeayebadman]

utter pants.theres some tunes u just dont mess around with.his accents shite in this song.

[dmcmusicalboy]

awsome...I live two streets down....thats Mount Florida Glasgow....cool!

[stecky1]

mr curtis will be turning in his grave , long live joy division.

[sitivvi]

stone island!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! hooligans

[SligStorm65]

1st time i heard this i thought it was rlly rlly bad and now im actually startin to like it O...O

[StyleSessions]

decent tune. Although yer not gonna get many people admitting that on here, too many wannabe new romantic emo cunts on youtube to admit anything but the original is even passable.

[SuperClarker]

awful. sorry, try again

[RoggenWolfe]

WTF....NO .....WTF IS THIS COCKSWEAT ?? For starters people dont sound like that in Glasgow , its much more better soundin really...AND 2nd ! ... A wuz lookin at Stone Roses Vids n this HEAD NIPPIN PISH pops up k GTF !!! YOUTUBE BAN THIS VID PLEASE FOR BEIN ANNOYIN AND NOT TO MENTION TOTALLY PISH . Whos gonny play this on teh auld IPod ?? A couple a fannys thats who . Interuptin ma wee personal session wi Stone Roses . Ma dunt's pure shattered !

[THthefirst]

you sound like the music police..."ban this video...". It's just music, it's for everyone to enjoy in their own way. So this band have interpreted the song in a different way - what's the harm done? It's just creativity, who are you to judge what is good and bad for everyone.

I like it. It's not as good as the original.

[RoggenWolfe]

mate the songs total PISH !

[megamollie9]

@RoggenWolfe is teh scottish for the?

[eastendthug360]

@RoggenWolfe well said sir

[brummiegreen]

there is shite!! i do like complete stones good band but thats naff

[paulwwwynne]

terrible

[joesnow1]

The fact it throws in a keyboard sound straight from the Inspiral Carpets is magic, I see from comments opinion is divided. Each to their own. I loved both the Roses and Joy Division and anyone with any musical sense will see that no matter what their opinion on the song that the fact the complete stone roses have made it sound like a roses song is genius. No one else has produced a better cover of this song. BONO IS A CUNT

[joesnow1]

Perhaps the finest cover of our time, up there with Hendrix's All Along the Watchtower and Guns n Roses Live & Let Die.

To take one of the finest songs of our time and make it sound like the finest band of our time and make it so fucking good is awesome. I can't believe it as any other cover of this song has been mince as the original is perfect.

[mrmjdinosaur]

Just.Stop.Now.Please.

[kaney1967]

fuck me this is horrible,

both the stone roses, and joy division are on different ends of the scale.

im sorry but this is murder!

[mapleavenue77]

The song's growing on me. Love the guitar at 2:50.

[aadoyle7]

so thats what it feels like knowing those 4.32 of my life are over and there never coming back again. the advertising in there on that taxi were quality...utter balls

[TerryNicholson]

Diggin' this!

[mcpvc]

brilliant!

[enochpowell3]

Is this shot on/in GORGIE ROAD??

[tertommy]

That chick ain't half bad

[celticghirlxxx]

god some youtubers are cruel! I think this is a good cover version and it's for a great cause, well done boys. xx

[J700JAM]

Cant believe Robert Carlyle agreed to appear in this video

[stonesourjim]

its not robert carlyle but it looks the spit of him doesnt it

[djharg1]

They are not copying anyone just the song. Fuck me Ian would have said this done that, Maybe he saw it was for a good cause and a bit of fun!!!!!! Give them a break, Well Done lads!!!!!!!

[robertaguidoni]

Wow!!!<3

[blahblahblah1blah]

toss

[robert99brown]

i actually like this cover purely because it accompanies the vid, on its own i don't like it half as much,factory all stars is my favourite cover done live naturally

[shadowkunt]

shit. this cover gave ME cancer!

[pnnorton]

Crap video. Loved the guitar (sounded alot like the stone roses). Singer is too good to be an Ian Brown impersonator. Great song except for the whispering part that was crap. Other than I think it was a great cover!

[WaxdollyPodcasts]

I know some people may not like it, but it was for a good cause - cancer charities.

I Think the band actually did a great job and had the full support of Peter Hook - 1/4 of Joy Division.

It's a different take on a classic track, and beats the s**t out of the awful pish poor parodies by The Cure and U2

[visioncommission]

this is not the stone roses--the singer is not off key but I don't know why the hell it has "the complete stone roses" when it is not--

the band should concentrate on original shit and that is it-

[s0348953]

i think i hear ian turning in his grave

[samnninty]

this is awful

this song is meant to be dark you fucking idiots

[tylerkershaw]

this is really horrible

[1999trinity]

I agree.

[MickSmooth]

I like it better than the original. Thanx 4 posting!

[pierceroe13]

wow i like the stone roses, but this really really sucks

[altondesu]

Sounds more like Love Will Tear Us Apart by The Complete Nickelback

[lilroo2]

@altondesu If that comment is not the funniest thing I have read this year, I don't know what is!! Of course, the "cocksweat" one below is pretty funny...

[02daft]

haha, fucking cheesy

[darkocek]

this is a comedy.. not even close to the original....

[Strangerstheband]

Hooky co-produced this? That's awesome! Great cover too.

[hyperfex]

Well, I like it.

[SeAnMoChAn]

haha MACS barbers a go there ! :)):))

[ChaOsAngEL1973]

quite well done actually, im impressed.

[prebenh]

nothing like the original....but not bad, not bad at all....that pretty much sums it up for me.....Ian curtis forever

[mikethompson1991]

obviously played in the style of the roses you can hear the mani-esque bass and squire-esque guitar... not bad though, alot better than other covers of the same tune.

[longlivetheroses]

way better than j.d

[artificeconstruct]

Wrong.

[longlivetheroses]

no.....no im not

[joostisabelle]

that chick sounds just like Diane from Trainspotting

[clevergirlrocks]

Hmmm this is growing on me.....not bad at all !!

[olhckk]

"the complete stone roses", what a crock of shit band, not fit to bear the great name stone roses in their name..sacrilegious

[LozMac33]

pretty clever

[jojo1791]

I'd dump him. He looks like a right wierdo.

[appraze]

Actually I like the first part of this song - the bass is cool. Funky man!

[appraze]

Not bad - not too great either - but better than nohting.

[stranger1503714]

really cheesy cover..... i hate this band for making an awful cover of such a beautiful song................. RIP Ian Curtis

[thenorthernsoldier]

i disagree i quite like this version nice one lads!

[DavidSim1994WATP]

Agreed, this is the only cover version of any thats quite decent

[DavidSim1994WATP]

Hahahahahaha, that woman who was arguing with the guy at the start is Ruth from River City

[congamario654]

hahaha so it is

[thisrocks88]

I love when people play around with musical arrangements!! This isn't quite to my taste, the music is pretty decent, but the lyrics don't go with the music to be honest, should keep the melody but try better matching lyrics.

[blumphy]

Bad this, this is a bad cover, as bad covers go this has to be up there with ANYTHING Jive Bunny have ruined. Sorry lad's that's just how I feel.

[xLittleRoomx]

Stick to the covers, lads.

[TinSoldierMan]

TERRIBLE!

[tonyouth]

BAD BAD BAD

[Josephkirkham]

altogether now....Giggs Giggs will tear you apart again.

[TerryNicholson]

Dig this, 2 times...

[loushky619]

woh my dads called terry nicholson lol.

[antlockyer]

hahaha what the cock is this???

[Gsixtyboy]

Fucking scouse sounding shite!

[mattproctor333]

THIS IS A DISCRACE TO JOY DIVISON

[joydivisionrule]

this cover is fucking awesome great upload

[powe0001]

think this is the best cover - far better then U2, NIN, Cure, Paul Young! Just because they'rea tribute band doesn't mean they can't play, and doesn't mean they can't be respected for their music. OK they didn't write it but the arrangement is definitely new and theirs alone.

[trimmytrab]

Brave attempt but ultimately a bloke imitating another bloke doing yet another blokes cover. Where is it going to end? A fat fuckin Shaun Ryder impersonator singing Girls Aloud?

Wke up, smell the Roses

[mcginlay7]

why are the people commenting on this if you think its crap?

nothing better to do?

its the best joy division cover ive heard for this song its what u call skill cause the song sounds completely different to the original

i think its good personally

[chrisboydelluk]

It's not actually that bad. Lighten up. BUt seriously..You can't re-Manc anything!! It's so engrained in peoples skulls that you don't tamper with that stuff.. So much emotion and realism in the originals etc.. It's like trying to re-do stuff like remake Citizen Kane or City of God.. There's simply no point.. Everything else is just gonna inevitably and simply end up inferior..

?

[ThatSchmuck]

sounds like some a random emo-pop cover , this is so awful

[NNNNNNNNNN1515]

This is awful.

The video is so corny, it's embarrassing.

And while I love covers that take risks and depart from the original song, the way you arranged and sang Love Will Tear us Apart Again only shows you have no idea of what the song means.

[bigdecobruva]

love this song by the complete stone roses, should change there name agreed ! and release this :D

[mhenry781]

this is pish

[makeloveandomlettes]

this is horrible, ian curtis will be turning in his grave

[khalithistle]

aside from the horrible music, i really hope they didnt actually PAY someone to direct this video, because it's seriously awful. there's a completely unnecessary, awkward shot or cut literally about every five seconds. like we dont need to see him giving money to the taxi driver, for fucks sake

[shaunyMP72]

less of the slagging.I don't know this band but the other 2. J.D & Ian B.that's another story and these guys are not to bad in my eye but as for changing the name i agree on that 1.

[bigdecobruva]

going to see them tonight at the garage really im going to see THE HAZE,..... much better

mon the HAZE ure local boys!!

[revcoco]

wtf they obviously couldn't get robert carlyle to do the vid so they got the worst begbie lookalike ever haha

[neebzio]

iv seen them live they are sooo good, they dont sound the same in this vid, but really they sound soo much better live, They RULE :D Ian Brown i LOVE YOU!!!

[Hatter1990]

I have that jacket hes wearing!

Other than that its rather shit.

[brincat93]

this is shit

[NothingSacred27]

Wow, awful. It didn't start THAT bad but the vocals sure killed it.

[littlejonnyfrost]

Well I'm lost! What the fuck are doing? This sounds nothing like the Roses, but it does make my skin crawl. If you're going to start doing songs by other artists (and recording them!!!), why don't you start a proper band lads? call yourselves something else... what would mister brown say???

[CaptainRockNRoll]

right. well said. since they're not a stone roses cover band anymore, obviously, they really should change their name, and stop trying to be the roses. which they really shouldn't try to begin with. be yerself.

[CaptinCrawky]

For fucks sake! this is shit, what the fuck are they thinkin? Ive seen this band in Leeds, they wernt that bad but this is fuckin bollocks, wankers!

[ST0MP0]

What the fuck is this shit? how dare they fuck around with a Joy Division song, absolute fuckin shite, WANKERS!

[kingsman565]

3:50 It's the Garage aka the worst club in Glasgow :D

[paisley12345]

fucking love it

[Bexorcist]

WTF! Love stone roses but this is complete rubbish! Dumb clip as well. Ian would be ashamed!

[bromide01]

Wait a second. There's a cover band called "The Complete Stone Roses"? That doesn't make any sense. Isn't that the name of a "best of" album? Don't cover bands usually name themselves something move clever?