( 2 )), any artist performing on an electronic medium can make us believe that this "live" apart from the comment thing I hear my thousands of artists, Enya is the only artist I have heard continuously for years ... the best., Oh by the way, sorry this comment is translated from Spanish to English by googletranslator ...
( 1 )for those who critique the presentation of Live Enya understand, if you see this video on YOUTUBE, what does that use playback, you can still all be previously recorded as if live, with slight modifications, to know that something is live must be "no electronic devices in between", that is, while you were with the artist (basically impossible really),), ....
Wow. I remember this when it was on the radio (and not played often enough.) The closest we've gotten in modern times with music as pure art. Beautiful. Thank you for posting!
Only Linda Ronstat can do as well............. Beauty at it's best.... Linda only copied, this talent of a woman did much more. You are so cool Enya!!!!!
All you walking wounded with written negative comments about her live voice, can look in the mirror and get a life.She has more talent in her pinky then most of you knuckleheads.Enya has given her life her fans. She basically has to remain at home for any attempts at having a life.Talent is based on a life time of work, not a "moment in time" or a live performance. Enya, thanks for the memories. Your body of work is everlasting.To making each day count! PS, Enya,Please come to Florida,USA. DS
@xibalbaist She is singing. She just has the background music with her harmonies too loud to hear her. I can hear bits and pieces of her. I wish she'd either turn down the backing vocals or just take it out completely and use actual back up singers to do the harmonies. I know she does that sometimes, but not solely
muy buena musica para soñar- escribir- caminar- recordar -- y solo ser. mirando al cielo sonreir ,, mirando al viento ser... sintiendo el abrazo de la vida y el beos de una suave brisa ,, nusica k inspira saludos a los que lean esto y compartan lo que escribi .....
effects as the multiple voices is easily done with current studio gear. most of it is all done on a PC/MAC platform with specific software. delay, room effect, soft reverb, and other process can be instantly applied with the click of the mouse by the sound engineer. Commercial releases are 'cleaner' as they can split every sound into separate tracks and then mix as they please. Live is more difficult, but planning helps.
Acctually it is live but they take vocals from her albulm for the vibrating vocal part ,because im sure they can't get alot of women that sing like her to sing in the background.
@magicalfushiadoll actually there is a singer that re-create all the background vocals live!!! she is juana molina. check it out! i'm sure you'll like her! specially 'un día' song.
It is rather easy to discover if someone is really singing the song live. If it sounds like the studio version, then it is a playback. The live act is real only if you notice differences between the live and studio performances. You can check this with any artist cause it is a universal truth! :P
I also thought it would be obvious (because it is to me) but when I see people mistakenly assume that there is a live performance when clearly there isn't one it just makes me wonder if they are seeing the same thing as I... :P
Although I myself doubt it, it could be possible that an artist is so talented that they sound exactly the same live/in studio, which is really unheard of, IMO.
But ultimately the decision whether or not it is a live perf/playback lies with the viewer - and since we can never know for sure whether it is live/playback, we should just accept all views and opinions :).
I remeber back in the early 90's I went to a Van Halen Concert. Sammy sounded exactly the same but Eddie, Alex, and Michael sounded like crap. but Sammie was awesome.
yes, it change the world...there was a war and everything afterwards...AND nobody asked HER for permission to use that song! i could have screamed when i heard that, it was such an arrogant thing to do! and it was a great and tactful gesture of her not to do anything about it!
she usually sings over a pre recorded track. some of the vocals were recorded prior to the peerformance but the main vocals is a live one. it is not really difficult to sings so why bother to lypsynch? the violin parts are live because the plucking is sharper than the recordings
u obviously don't know about lipsynching. they usually record different versions specifically for lipsynching so the hardcore fans can't tell the difference.
If by "playback", you mean lip sync, I don't agree. It was on "The View" and their musical guests perform live. Otherwise, why bother to have those violinist plucking at their strings and all the other things like a huge grand piano and backup singers?
I find this song sooooo hauntingly beautiful and I loved seeing performed live with the grand piano, the violins, and the backup singers. It was sheer bliss *s*.
None of us will. However, it is important to note that Enya wrote this song two years before 9/11. Enya was at first uncomfortable with the song being shown on television and becoming the backdrop for 9/11, but eventually gave her blessing because the song was helping people cope. Enya is an amazing person.
I just wanted to post this to counteract all the artists that wrote songs because of 9/11. Enya didn't. Her music is just so beautiful it can lift you no matter what.
My heart goes out to all effected on that day, afterwards. However, Enya did not approve of the link between the event and this song. But it is a very appropriate song.
i love this song so badly ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
This can't be live. It is EXACTLY like the real song. Either she pulled a fast one on the view or else someone put music over this. Great song either way, but I was let down. :(
She does use the real music in the background because she feels most comfortable but she isn't lip synching. She is singing for real with the song. If you listen to Book of Days live you can hear her normal singing voice at the beginning because she wasn't in synch.
well,,,, im only 21, and my mother used to play these enya songs, i loved em, truly classic, dont be shy of liking enya peeps , the best going to sleep music EVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR...ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZLOL
really, all those rock bands sound like shit live...only REAL singers who actually are able to sing in tune and well succeed in live performances and actual singing. LIke the people on american idol. please dont say anything mean this is my opinion.
This must be an older piece - Enya looks much more relaxed in the more recent live shows she's done. Look up "Enya Amarantine Live" here on YouTube and pick the CBS version to see what I mean.
you're right, though I truly love this expression of total concentration and stage fright on Enya's face here. She resembles an angel during the last minute of the song, I can't explain it. By the way, do you think the main vocal is live?
Just Beatiful.
Katarsislab 2 days ago
true music and true talent !
freoltic 6 days ago
only time :)
Gruzinu94 3 weeks ago
What movie is this from I can't remember?
MrDreadedbwoy 1 month ago
@MrDreadedbwoy
Sweet november :-)
kevpike1 1 month ago
@MrDreadedbwoy was used in many different things but the first time was for the movie Sweet November in 2000
Lightbane1 4 weeks ago
delo mejor en el mundo
vampiro16161 2 months ago
Id love to see someone post the video of her performing Only Time on the TV program Entertainment Tonight, back on New Years Eve 1998. Cheers,
radiodf 2 months ago
Enya and Suzanne Ciani.............take me back to 1994
catndryer 2 months ago
three people that run the pop industry...
vegetaum 2 months ago
3 PEOPLE dislikes becaue they are DEAF to bad. I LOVE ENYA
fwildflower0426662 3 months ago 4
3 people have no respect for true talent.
EmmyRossumFan94 3 months ago 2
Beautifull song. Absolutely beautifull.
hicknan219 3 months ago 2
I'm sorry to say this. Buy she is the most beautiful woman I have ever seen. Like an angel singing
taggett666 3 months ago 2
( 2 )), any artist performing on an electronic medium can make us believe that this "live" apart from the comment thing I hear my thousands of artists, Enya is the only artist I have heard continuously for years ... the best., Oh by the way, sorry this comment is translated from Spanish to English by googletranslator ...
laloalacran 3 months ago
@laloalacran You did fine!
magpie4321 3 months ago
( 1 )for those who critique the presentation of Live Enya understand, if you see this video on YOUTUBE, what does that use playback, you can still all be previously recorded as if live, with slight modifications, to know that something is live must be "no electronic devices in between", that is, while you were with the artist (basically impossible really),), ....
laloalacran 3 months ago
Wow. I remember this when it was on the radio (and not played often enough.) The closest we've gotten in modern times with music as pure art. Beautiful. Thank you for posting!
SRB427 4 months ago
not playback ,you are playback :D
yildiz487 4 months ago
Only Linda Ronstat can do as well............. Beauty at it's best.... Linda only copied, this talent of a woman did much more. You are so cool Enya!!!!!
lencho234 4 months ago
she is more than any religion to me
jcliveron 4 months ago
thats a woman in balance
love her and her music.
kimkules 5 months ago
This song is indescribably. Only wonderful and the emotionallyst song I've ever heard. <3 <3 Very profound... *.*
oONinjaTigerOo 5 months ago in playlist Weitere Videos von marianotkd
PLAYBACK!!!! :(
Anttonooii 5 months ago
This world needs more singers like her ♥
Heyitsmeaw 5 months ago 15
This world needs more singers like her ♥
Heyitsmeaw 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
All you walking wounded with written negative comments about her live voice, can look in the mirror and get a life.She has more talent in her pinky then most of you knuckleheads.Enya has given her life her fans. She basically has to remain at home for any attempts at having a life.Talent is based on a life time of work, not a "moment in time" or a live performance. Enya, thanks for the memories. Your body of work is everlasting.To making each day count! PS, Enya,Please come to Florida,USA. DS
dbird1956Thunderbird 6 months ago
I love Enya.. LOVE MY LIFE que la musica divina de tus sueños te llenen en el sueño!
jplabourd 6 months ago
I don't really like songs of this genre, but fuck... Her voice is amazing.
UnknownGenius01 6 months ago
hermoso video eres una angel ENYA una voz alentatadora llena de magia de admirar de sentir de reflexionar, de sentir abiertamente con el corazon
pedrito52074 7 months ago
actually i cant believe you people how can you believe her live performances she is not even singing just lipsinging
biggest dissapointing in my life i love her music but i ve seach many many times but each video the same she is not singing live
xibalbaist 9 months ago
@xibalbaist maybe she's singing, just the mic is off :P
anyway, I believe she's actually singing... and if not I don't care, at least it's great music... and not some JB o BKB stupid backtrack...
with all due respect of course...
Gonenashvili 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@xibalbaist h t t p : / / w w w . youtube.com/watch?v=m5JvQp75TrA
Except this one! ;)
100% Live
LenarLontoc328 8 months ago
@xibalbaist She is singing. She just has the background music with her harmonies too loud to hear her. I can hear bits and pieces of her. I wish she'd either turn down the backing vocals or just take it out completely and use actual back up singers to do the harmonies. I know she does that sometimes, but not solely
emotiwreck 6 months ago
" 9/ 11!" she did her part ! ♥I Love her so fer that
shieldwolf49 1 year ago
muy buena musica para soñar- escribir- caminar- recordar -- y solo ser. mirando al cielo sonreir ,, mirando al viento ser... sintiendo el abrazo de la vida y el beos de una suave brisa ,, nusica k inspira saludos a los que lean esto y compartan lo que escribi .....
luis8az 1 year ago 4
her voice is so weak, actually. That's why she has to sing with pre-recorded voices singing along with her. Still it sounds boring here, live
FC3692230 3 years ago
effects as the multiple voices is easily done with current studio gear. most of it is all done on a PC/MAC platform with specific software. delay, room effect, soft reverb, and other process can be instantly applied with the click of the mouse by the sound engineer. Commercial releases are 'cleaner' as they can split every sound into separate tracks and then mix as they please. Live is more difficult, but planning helps.
hapticz 3 years ago
Acctually it is live but they take vocals from her albulm for the vibrating vocal part ,because im sure they can't get alot of women that sing like her to sing in the background.
magicalfushiadoll 3 years ago 16
@magicalfushiadoll Yepp. I thought either that or some sort of effect through the mic.
Electra72 8 months ago
@magicalfushiadoll actually there is a singer that re-create all the background vocals live!!! she is juana molina. check it out! i'm sure you'll like her! specially 'un día' song.
xoxox
versionsofbliss 4 months ago
Thourgh the laws of attraction it vibrates with my spirit.
OCHAMBERLA 3 years ago
What? Are you serious? YOu believe in the law of attraction bullshit. Come on, anybody is a little bit smarter than that. I hope you're just kidding.
lebannen21 3 years ago
thats just beutifull full stop
byrnemonty 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
I spam you.
RogerFedererTennis08 3 years ago
It is rather easy to discover if someone is really singing the song live. If it sounds like the studio version, then it is a playback. The live act is real only if you notice differences between the live and studio performances. You can check this with any artist cause it is a universal truth! :P
jmldspt 3 years ago
Er yeah, that's pretty obvious XD.
navinkc5 3 years ago
I also thought it would be obvious (because it is to me) but when I see people mistakenly assume that there is a live performance when clearly there isn't one it just makes me wonder if they are seeing the same thing as I... :P
jmldspt 3 years ago
Although I myself doubt it, it could be possible that an artist is so talented that they sound exactly the same live/in studio, which is really unheard of, IMO.
But ultimately the decision whether or not it is a live perf/playback lies with the viewer - and since we can never know for sure whether it is live/playback, we should just accept all views and opinions :).
navinkc5 3 years ago
ok, here is an example where the live performance even is BETTER imo... :)
But mostly that what u said is the truth
Here the example:
Gary Moore, Parisienne walkways. It's the one that has around 160 000 views atm
lnsaneMoose 3 years ago
Ooo, nice!
:)
navinkc5 3 years ago
I remeber back in the early 90's I went to a Van Halen Concert. Sammy sounded exactly the same but Eddie, Alex, and Michael sounded like crap. but Sammie was awesome.
fromundaphil 3 years ago
nobody can sing like that. this is lipsynched.
d3fyinggr4vity 3 years ago 4
she is so pretty
liwen4 3 years ago 4
11 september the day whose chance the world......:cry:
jessidiecoole 3 years ago
yes, it change the world...there was a war and everything afterwards...AND nobody asked HER for permission to use that song! i could have screamed when i heard that, it was such an arrogant thing to do! and it was a great and tactful gesture of her not to do anything about it!
Silmaril11 3 years ago
this is indeed live because one of the back up singers went out of tune in the middle of the songs.
mrbaxteria 3 years ago
Yes they are singing 'live' and she is singing along live but 90% of her 'voice sound' is actually 80-500 pre recordings of her own voice.
She is singing along with a pre recorded voice orchestra of herself backing her up.
And she admits this on her own fansite.
vuxfeon 3 years ago 2
she usually sings over a pre recorded track. some of the vocals were recorded prior to the peerformance but the main vocals is a live one. it is not really difficult to sings so why bother to lypsynch? the violin parts are live because the plucking is sharper than the recordings
mrbaxteria 3 years ago
contrary to the mis informed fellow who made a comment that this is lypsync it is not. if you have a copy of the album you can tell the difference.
mrbaxteria 3 years ago
u obviously don't know about lipsynching. they usually record different versions specifically for lipsynching so the hardcore fans can't tell the difference.
d3fyinggr4vity 3 years ago
The difference is she cuts from 500 pre-recorded layers of her own voice down to 80 or so for 'live' performances.
So she is singing there on stage sure,along with another 79 electronic versions of her own voice layered in.
vuxfeon 3 years ago
your wrong there. she layers or rather Nicky ryan layers her voice 100 not 500 she even said it herself.
quinn244 3 years ago
Enya es magnifica la amo....es hermosa.
YasetCrash 3 years ago
This is my all time favorite from Enya.
bourne9999 3 years ago
I love Enya! I love her songs, i love her voice. Enya is an amazing person... =)
Afterlif 3 years ago 3
i know enya, i'm her big fan...
and i think...its a lip sync..i'm disapointed :(
ALLAH5army 3 years ago
If by "playback", you mean lip sync, I don't agree. It was on "The View" and their musical guests perform live. Otherwise, why bother to have those violinist plucking at their strings and all the other things like a huge grand piano and backup singers?
jbrut 3 years ago
they have violinist and sh1t for cover the lyp syn, definetly lyp sync
tehagoelamor 3 years ago
si. muy tranquilizante la cancion
meowmix 3 years ago
playback...
but i dont care. very good song.
poplolcool 3 years ago
I find this song sooooo hauntingly beautiful and I loved seeing performed live with the grand piano, the violins, and the backup singers. It was sheer bliss *s*.
jbrut 3 years ago
is this live or mime?
jordimla 3 years ago
again she is ahead of our time
tantradrewien 3 years ago
enya`s got the gods voice...in this world so violent and sad she takes me to heaven and i even can feel God.
elvislandia74 3 years ago
this song was in a video we watched in my History class on 9/11. the video was so sad, i almost cried. this song is SOOO beautiful.
<3
i will never forget 9/11
bandlover524 3 years ago
None of us will. However, it is important to note that Enya wrote this song two years before 9/11. Enya was at first uncomfortable with the song being shown on television and becoming the backdrop for 9/11, but eventually gave her blessing because the song was helping people cope. Enya is an amazing person.
I just wanted to post this to counteract all the artists that wrote songs because of 9/11. Enya didn't. Her music is just so beautiful it can lift you no matter what.
dahmk 3 years ago 3
she has a beautiful voice
Pain08MX 3 years ago 2
q idiota soy pense que enya es el grupo pero ahora veo que es solista
capitancronos 3 years ago
this song bring bac what happen during 911
ratedrkumar2008 3 years ago 4
My heart goes out to all effected on that day, afterwards. However, Enya did not approve of the link between the event and this song. But it is a very appropriate song.
Great song, Enya.
CHFCooper 3 years ago 3
I love her and her music!
nickysims 3 years ago 2
~BEAUTIFUL SONG...LIVE ON ABC~
witchweb20 3 years ago
this is the only time i have ever cried to a wonder song. GOD BLESS YOU ALL and the angels
janakillerro 3 years ago
i love this song so badly ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
animeforlife2 3 years ago 2
Soo Beatifull This Is the Song Of Angels
LouiisVuitton 3 years ago
This can't be live. It is EXACTLY like the real song. Either she pulled a fast one on the view or else someone put music over this. Great song either way, but I was let down. :(
Thetolan87 3 years ago
She does use the real music in the background because she feels most comfortable but she isn't lip synching. She is singing for real with the song. If you listen to Book of Days live you can hear her normal singing voice at the beginning because she wasn't in synch.
CocoaMug 3 years ago
i jus noticed her mic is atleast a bac tune dropped down a bit to echoe jus perfect tho this song is CUTEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
SpeakFanatic 3 years ago
well,,,, im only 21, and my mother used to play these enya songs, i loved em, truly classic, dont be shy of liking enya peeps , the best going to sleep music EVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR...ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZLOL
addwada 3 years ago 3
really, all those rock bands sound like shit live...only REAL singers who actually are able to sing in tune and well succeed in live performances and actual singing. LIke the people on american idol. please dont say anything mean this is my opinion.
CherrieShine 3 years ago 2
is this really live?? it sounds so perfect
nevermind2527 3 years ago
Linda essa musica, ainda mais ao vivo!!!!
ludiascastro 3 years ago 3
the song of angels.
Beautiful.
Samjapa 4 years ago 5
this song is a true inspiring sprit that makes you remember of the past throu such chimestry!!
jimmyc2009 4 years ago 5
I cry when I hear this. my "uncle" left me in 2000. He introduced me to Enya and said this was his favourite song.
SHAYmovies 4 years ago 19
she is unique~
she is a legend.
shaynazhang 4 years ago 5
she is unique. It's impossible to find another singer like her within 1oo hundred years~
shaynazhang 4 years ago 25
@shaynazhang Agree
KattMercy 6 months ago
u know how many times this song had made me cry
guthan12 4 years ago 2
This must be an older piece - Enya looks much more relaxed in the more recent live shows she's done. Look up "Enya Amarantine Live" here on YouTube and pick the CBS version to see what I mean.
Progressive75 4 years ago 2
you're right, though I truly love this expression of total concentration and stage fright on Enya's face here. She resembles an angel during the last minute of the song, I can't explain it. By the way, do you think the main vocal is live?
dragoness17 4 years ago 2
awesome!
ChrisDaniels80 4 years ago 2
It was nice to catch Eithne's voice over the track...so beautiful
OregonWineBaby 4 years ago
The must beatuful and soulful song I've ever heard
rthomasmcpherson 4 years ago