Bach's message is that it is the individual sinner who is responsible for Christ's suffering and death. It was what Christ wanted. It is wrong to act against Jewish people in this context. To do so misses the point of the piece.
Christian anti-Jewish sentiment comes through in this section of the passion. It's disfiguring, though it's not Bach's fault. It's in the New Testament, for a variety of reasons.
Their faces xD F'ing priceless
CaineFulumTryst 1 month ago
05:00 and 06:47 !!!
omarisbck 10 months ago
In my opinion better turba is in JohannesPassion.
stach1991 1 year ago
words are too much poor to comment this MUSIC...
MyZenzero 2 years ago 7
I really like the period instruments (aka flute/oboe)
EmGem1986 2 years ago
wow! 1:40!! 2:30!!
Lesamisdeloeillet 2 years ago
Could we just admire this wonderful masterpiece? and leave the rest apart. this is insanely difficult and beautiful
drtrance 2 years ago 13
@drtrance I doubt it. This is You Tube, where only every third person has grown up.
pianomags 1 year ago
The audacity of "Sehet, Jesus hat die Hand" is incredible, and this is the best performance I've ever heard. Alto, oboists, everyone. I'm in awe.
alarob 4 years ago
the director follows asking little things. It seems he is directing a kid's chor or he is asking a little cup of cofee.
friendlybarman 4 years ago
Bach, oboe/Oboe da Caccia and the human voice......perfection!
Bachsoboe 4 years ago 2
I agree... oboe sounds great...
drtrance 2 years ago 2
you are my hero bachojoli
silla20 4 years ago 3
Bach's message is that it is the individual sinner who is responsible for Christ's suffering and death. It was what Christ wanted. It is wrong to act against Jewish people in this context. To do so misses the point of the piece.
Teigen64 4 years ago 4
Christian anti-Jewish sentiment comes through in this section of the passion. It's disfiguring, though it's not Bach's fault. It's in the New Testament, for a variety of reasons.
solotyro 5 years ago
Its absolutely not disturbing. Perfectly normal.
Any form of Anti-jewish sentiment is wrong. The bible is right however (even though I am not christian)It is not anti-jewish sentiment . it is fact
firebreathone 5 years ago