wow your choices are pretty amazing. normally im very picky with kartik but yours was really good although i would love to see zayed khan play him and john abraham play amar. but otherwise this is the best ive seen so far nobody could really get felicity right but you chose a very good one !
except tom doyle is blonde and james mcavoy is brunette and far too charming to play tom. although i think james mcavoy would make a good simon middleton
That is a mostly perfect cast except for Gemma and Felicity. I think for Gemma they should cast an undiscovered actress because I can't think of anyone suited to play her.
I love James McAvoy!!!!!!!!! I would die if he was tom!!!!!!! But i pictured Henry Cavill to be tom. Either would be great because i love them both! Plus i agree, kartik is really tough. Because just like with robert pattinson as edward, people are going to be upset if it's not who they saw in their heads.
Kartik's definitely hardest to cast...I think it's mainly because the majority of readers were girls, so lots of them fell in love with him and saw him CRYSTAL-CLEAR in their minds (I sure did!) and aren't entirely open to other choices, or are just super-picky. And tons of devoted book fans will be SO disappointed with the movie if Kartik doesn't seem right to them.
love rachel for gemma, SO MUCH, your felicity is really great too, and i love alexis bledel for pippa because she has the doe-eye thing going for her (lol, i ALWAYS say pippa with that) and i think she looks innocent enough to be truely haunting when she gets corrupted. your ann is PERFECT and i've never seen her before so kudos for originality! tom's PERFECT(can't believe i didn't think of james!), kartik's alright (i just always saw him as steven strait, tho he's not indian, still!) simon's ok
Not too fond of Alexis for Pippa because she's a very bland actress. James McAvoy would be a great choice, though, but he's getting bigger in his career (and hell knows he deserves it) and he's taking a lot of leading roles. Ann's adorable, though!
Ok guys. Get ready for the pickiest person to judge thez vids.
MY GOSH PEOPLE! HAVE YOU SEEN RACHEL ACT?! A little too pretty for felicity. Alexis is too light too. Hey, your ann's allright! Kartik-yuk. james-perfect! *-*
They are really hard to pick. I like Karoline for Gemma too. I still haven't found the perfect Kartik. Even the ones in my video aren't really what I pictured.
Yeh this is deffiently my favourite cast selection so far. The only minor issue would be that Ann is prehaps too pretty, but they will probably do that in the movie anyway. Good work!
who's the actress as felicity? :)
heartofmyocean 1 year ago
@heartofmyocean Jessica Stam. She's a model.
megdondero 1 year ago
Who plays Kartik in your cast?
MidnightThief15 1 year ago
@MidnightThief15 Steven Strait and Eugen Bauder.
megdondero 1 year ago
Gemma-NO- not Gemmas personality in her,too cute
Felicity-YES-great
Pippa-Maybe-pretty
Ann-NO-too pretty,not fat
Kartik-YES-perfect
Tom-YES-great
Simon-YES-good
Great Cast, is it comming a movie? <3 :)
underlinemisstory101 1 year ago
your cast is perfect, but you need someone that is not as hot as james mcavoy to play the jerk that is tom!
alexatetris 1 year ago
@alexatetris Aw, Tom's not that bad. I liked him by the end.
Thanks. :)
megdondero 1 year ago
your cast is perfect and espesially ann! very great
Msvampiresister 1 year ago
@Msvampiresister Thanks!
megdondero 1 year ago
Your choices are excelent!
Thats the best ann ive seen
And Felicity is just 100% perfect, Thats exactly how i imagine her!!!
Katarzyna93cr 2 years ago
Thank you! Felicity and Ann are my favorite choices as well. They're perfect. =)
megdondero 2 years ago
LOVE IT. Who are the actresses you used for Ann and Gemma?
Megerz16 2 years ago
Thanks. :)
Ann- Carey Mulligan
Gemma- Rachel Hurd Wood
megdondero 2 years ago
wow your choices are pretty amazing. normally im very picky with kartik but yours was really good although i would love to see zayed khan play him and john abraham play amar. but otherwise this is the best ive seen so far nobody could really get felicity right but you chose a very good one !
Mrjustmean 2 years ago
Thank you!
megdondero 2 years ago
Finally someone who doesn't pick Keira Knightley or Anne Hathaway for Ann!!! Your Ann was great!!!
DemyxAxel123459 2 years ago
Thanks! Keira and Anne are not how I picture Ann at ALL.
megdondero 2 years ago
i like your cast
and i also like felicity jones as pip, not alexis bledel
evyProductions 2 years ago
Thanks. =)
megdondero 2 years ago
Your casting is divine.
The best Felicity and Kartik by far!
Kairbear19 2 years ago
Thank you! I love Jessica Stam as Fee. =)
megdondero 2 years ago
wow, this is by far the best cast I have seen so far:)
fizzbomblover 2 years ago
Thank you!
megdondero 2 years ago
I totally love your cast!!!! Good choices ;)
lalalindsay0819 2 years ago
Thanks!
megdondero 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ok is it just me or could Corbin Bleu totally play Kartik. He is so hot now! :)
Iyeshia09 2 years ago
wooow,
this is probably my favorite agatb cast! :3
atinr0bot 3 years ago
Thanks!
megdondero 3 years ago
wow great cast
whooohooo1212 3 years ago
Thanks. :)
megdondero 3 years ago
what movie is at :57? i like your kartik!!
swimmingdafree 3 years ago
Tuck Everlasting.
Thanks. =)
megdondero 3 years ago
i like it. its really good :)
except tom doyle is blonde and james mcavoy is brunette and far too charming to play tom. although i think james mcavoy would make a good simon middleton
SusieA94 3 years ago
Thanks. :)
I thought of James for Simon too, but I like Tom Sturridge better.
megdondero 3 years ago
Do you know the name of the guy for th efirst picture of Kartik?? I think he'd make an outstanding Kartik <3
xXxgryffindorxXx 3 years ago
That's Steven Strait.
:)
megdondero 3 years ago
Cool thanks!
xXxgryffindorxXx 3 years ago
That is a mostly perfect cast except for Gemma and Felicity. I think for Gemma they should cast an undiscovered actress because I can't think of anyone suited to play her.
heyheyitsmj 3 years ago
Thanks. :)
Like I said, this is just based on looks. I don't think they should acually be in the movie. I would prefer unknowns too.
megdondero 3 years ago
I love James McAvoy!!!!!!!!! I would die if he was tom!!!!!!! But i pictured Henry Cavill to be tom. Either would be great because i love them both! Plus i agree, kartik is really tough. Because just like with robert pattinson as edward, people are going to be upset if it's not who they saw in their heads.
italiagrl02 3 years ago
Yeah, no matter who they pick, someone will be unhappy.
I just hope they actually make the movie!
megdondero 3 years ago
alexis bledel is too old and an american. i actually prefer anna popplewell as pippa.
pkatharine 3 years ago
Yeah, I don't like Alexis for Pippa anymore. But Ann's not exactly how I picture her either. Felicity Jones is the best I've found so far.
megdondero 3 years ago
damni t! why does kartik have to DIE?!
tehpowerfullhitler 3 years ago
I don't know!!
I cried so much. D=
megdondero 3 years ago
Kartik's definitely hardest to cast...I think it's mainly because the majority of readers were girls, so lots of them fell in love with him and saw him CRYSTAL-CLEAR in their minds (I sure did!) and aren't entirely open to other choices, or are just super-picky. And tons of devoted book fans will be SO disappointed with the movie if Kartik doesn't seem right to them.
KennaHuliaGulia 3 years ago
love rachel for gemma, SO MUCH, your felicity is really great too, and i love alexis bledel for pippa because she has the doe-eye thing going for her (lol, i ALWAYS say pippa with that) and i think she looks innocent enough to be truely haunting when she gets corrupted. your ann is PERFECT and i've never seen her before so kudos for originality! tom's PERFECT(can't believe i didn't think of james!), kartik's alright (i just always saw him as steven strait, tho he's not indian, still!) simon's ok
KennaHuliaGulia 3 years ago
Thanks! Glad you liked my choices. =)
megdondero 3 years ago
AH! I love Loreena McKennitt!
Not too fond of Alexis for Pippa because she's a very bland actress. James McAvoy would be a great choice, though, but he's getting bigger in his career (and hell knows he deserves it) and he's taking a lot of leading roles. Ann's adorable, though!
FantasmaLuna 3 years ago
Thanks. =)
I like Felicity Jones better than Alexis as Pippa now anyway.
megdondero 3 years ago
Ok guys. Get ready for the pickiest person to judge thez vids.
MY GOSH PEOPLE! HAVE YOU SEEN RACHEL ACT?! A little too pretty for felicity. Alexis is too light too. Hey, your ann's allright! Kartik-yuk. james-perfect! *-*
redlipstickchick 3 years ago
Well...no, I haven't seen her act, but like I said, it's JUST based on appearance. And my new favorite Pippa is Felicity Jones.
But, um, glad you like Ann and Tom.
megdondero 3 years ago
Yea, if it's based on appearence I understand.
redlipstickchick 3 years ago
this was a good cast, it is hard to find someone for Kartik, but you have good ideas. Love Tom as Simon and James as Tom, keep up the good work
Liliah121 3 years ago
Thanks! I just got really confused there, with all the Toms. :P
megdondero 3 years ago
They are really hard to pick. I like Karoline for Gemma too. I still haven't found the perfect Kartik. Even the ones in my video aren't really what I pictured.
Thanks. :)
megdondero 3 years ago
:) Thanks!
Do you have a Simon in mind?
megdondero 3 years ago
Thanks so much. :)
megdondero 3 years ago
This is a great cast Felicity is exactly how I pictured her
The only thing is Pippa should have brown eyes and I'm not really sure Alexis Bledel is pretty enough(I mean she's pretty just not Pippa pretty)
wecfa 3 years ago
Actually, Pippa is supposed to have violet eyes. But I agree that Alexis isn't pretty enough. My new favorite Pippa is Felicity Jones.
Thanks though!
megdondero 3 years ago
oh- I must have just filled in the brown eyes thing- but Felicity Jones does look more like what I pictured
wecfa 3 years ago
Pippa has purple eyes
TheGemmaDoyle4 3 years ago
yes we've established that
wecfa 3 years ago
Yeh this is deffiently my favourite cast selection so far. The only minor issue would be that Ann is prehaps too pretty, but they will probably do that in the movie anyway. Good work!
Saibryel 3 years ago
Thanks. She'd be good for the realms anyway. :)
megdondero 3 years ago
Thanks. :)
megdondero 3 years ago
Tom Sturridge is yummy!
BeautyVintageRoses 3 years ago
Yes. =D
megdondero 3 years ago