Not as bad as the Collins or Gabriel hacks would lead you to believe, and not as good as the Wilson fans think. I like it, but it lacked the warmth of Gabriel or Collins Genesis. I'm one of the rare Genesis fans that really loves the Gabriel and Collins eras. Wilson actually sounds like Gabriel to a point, but lacks the range.
@TheMoodah It was never officially released. It was only available on demos released to radio...thankfully some DJ was nice enough to leak the song to the Internet.
This song and The Dividing Line are my two favorite songs by Ray Era Genesis, only my opinion but there is not another song by Ray that can touch these two.. Congo may be closest though..
I think this is a great song. Genesis should have made another album with Ray and have this song as the single. I think it would have been recieved well. This is a radio friendly song.
this is better than half the tunes on the album, especially better than if that's what you need and small talk.
I listen to this, anything now, sign you life away and run out of time and I think Mike and Tony were stupid not to put them on the album in place of some of the others.
@SPeacock I understand. I think Calling All Stations was a very well created progressive rock album. It's just that it didn't get any chance to breathe. And I think Ray and Steve both played very important roles in Genesis history.
Why do I have a mental image of "Friends" while hearing this song? Never thought I'd put Friends and Genesis in the same sentence.
SPeacock 1 month ago
:-)
chitchitify 3 months ago
what a great song and it should have appeared on CAS along with Sign Your Life Away.
MrBorninthe80s 4 months ago
@MrBorninthe80s sign your life away is really one of the best from those sessions.
kuragari85 1 month ago in playlist GENESIS Extra Tracks
THIS NOT GENESIS SORRY RAY
ILAN2187 4 months ago
Many thanks for posting this.
This is the first time i have had the opportunity to here this outtake.
I wish i could get my hands on a top quality WAV copy of this song.
If anyone cares to help me, please get in touch and i'll provide an email address.
Thank you fellow Genesis fan!
btw, i'll get back with a rating for this song when i've absorbed it...
laughingpines 5 months ago
@laughingpines
jwavada 1 month ago
sounds a bit like beggar on a beach of gold chords in into
skintrade 6 months ago
Not as bad as the Collins or Gabriel hacks would lead you to believe, and not as good as the Wilson fans think. I like it, but it lacked the warmth of Gabriel or Collins Genesis. I'm one of the rare Genesis fans that really loves the Gabriel and Collins eras. Wilson actually sounds like Gabriel to a point, but lacks the range.
vmopsick 6 months ago
just not the same with out phil or peter
sorry Ray,good but no cigar
tiedupsmurf 8 months ago
The intro to me sounds a lot like some of Tony' Banks'' solo stuff. Then it has that gurgling guitar sound that was Rutherford's trademark.
raelraven2 8 months ago
"Calling all stations" is not a masterpiece, but not so bad.
Surely is 10,000 times better than the ugly "Invisible Touch" in its globality.
SprigganLook 8 months ago
buenisimooo!!
Joacoleoni 9 months ago
Nice song from a line-up that should have lasted a lot longer.
analogueaddict 11 months ago
@analogueaddict No way!! Boy did Ray Wilson kill Genesis' groove :( I sold "Calling All Stations" off less than a year after buying it UGH!
stoopidmonkeyful 9 months ago
another unreleased treasure!
Thanks for posting!
reiltations 1 year ago
please someone kill this "band" ahah
miliziametallica 1 year ago
Strange, it sounds like a Mike And The Mechanics song..Not bad...probably a song written by Rutherford..
carl13220 1 year ago
Doesnt it sound a little bit like Ballad of Big or Eleventh Earl of mar? Well the intro?
:D
illegalalien2 1 year ago
Thanks for posting. I didn't even know I was missing it.
I've even got Indians on vinyl. I thought I had it all :)
(Where was it? It wasn't on Not About Us and Congo Singles.)
Wherever it came from, thank you!
TheMoodah 1 year ago
@TheMoodah It was never officially released. It was only available on demos released to radio...thankfully some DJ was nice enough to leak the song to the Internet.
joepod 1 year ago
@joepod Thanks again for posting it.
TheMoodah 1 year ago
If That's What You Need was awful. It sounded like a REALLY bad Phil Collins throwaway.
SilentGunman 1 year ago
@SilentGunman Yes I'd agree with that actually. A very sluggish song that goes nowhere.
XXWXWXW 8 months ago
This song and The Dividing Line are my two favorite songs by Ray Era Genesis, only my opinion but there is not another song by Ray that can touch these two.. Congo may be closest though..
pcgenesispg 1 year ago
I think this is a great song. Genesis should have made another album with Ray and have this song as the single. I think it would have been recieved well. This is a radio friendly song.
thanks for posting it. How did you find it?
8imagemaker 1 year ago
this is better than half the tunes on the album, especially better than if that's what you need and small talk.
I listen to this, anything now, sign you life away and run out of time and I think Mike and Tony were stupid not to put them on the album in place of some of the others.
MRix1985 1 year ago 2
Ohhhh but this is greaaaaat!
Eldanoth 1 year ago
Ouck! What the hell!!! This great!
Eldanoth 1 year ago
God bless you for uploading this!!! :-D It´s hard to understand why this track wasn´t included on the 1983-1998 box set. A real rarity!
kaspervzzzbx 1 year ago
That's greaaaat! How a shame. This song should be heard by everithing with love for real great music!
Eldanoth 1 year ago
@kaspervzzzbx I agree. I think they should have included all the b-sides and this song from the ...Calling All Stations... sessions.
8imagemaker 1 year ago
@8imagemaker Calling All Stations should have been a full double album. :)
SPeacock 1 year ago
@SPeacock I agree, I think they should release all the b-sides on its own CD and see how the fans deal with it.
8imagemaker 1 year ago
@8imagemaker Sometimes, I hate them for treating Ray Wilson like they treated Steve Hackett.
SPeacock 1 year ago
@SPeacock I understand. I think Calling All Stations was a very well created progressive rock album. It's just that it didn't get any chance to breathe. And I think Ray and Steve both played very important roles in Genesis history.
8imagemaker 1 year ago
@kaspervzzzbx Apparently, Ray Wilson (who wrote this song) considers this song to be crap (I've heard).
SPeacock 1 year ago
Thank you. This is great! :)
yamahasynth 1 year ago
Very thanks ....
Mister Best !
Indeed !
SPECTRE1961 2 years ago