This scene struck me later, as fridge logic is wont to do, the same way the ninja section did. It seemed over the top to have ninjas be these "evil mean moral-less monster" types, and this part?
I'm not saying this didn't happen, but...Japanese men? In a Japanese city? There wasn't even a caucasion boss to instigate. They just mobbed the Samurai for giggles. And cutting off his top not? Yet LEAVING him with his swords!?
Dramatic and powerful, but...with any luck, unrealistic.
@HotaruZoku Maybe I'm missing something about your comment but the soldiers didn't leave the swords*. Take a look at the left-most soldier starting @1:18. He's holding the young samurai's katana & wakizashi.
Roger Joseph Ebert (pronounced /ˈiːbərt/; born June 18, 1942) is an American film critic and screenwriter. Forbes has described him as "the most powerful pundit in America".[8]
He is known for his film review column (appearing in the Chicago Sun-Times since 1967, and later online)[9] and for the television programs Sneak Previews,
Critique is a method of disciplined, systematic analysis of a written or oral discourse. Critique is an accepted format of written and oral debate. Critique differs from (is not) criticism in that critique is never personalized nor ad hominem, but is instead the analyses of the structure of the thought in the content of the item critiqued. .
AHHH! I saw him at the Cherry Blossum parade!! Had no idea he was there and suddenly he announced his name and he came by in a car! So awesome to see him!! :)
I'm curious...do you think a "real" samurai would've submitted in this manner? These are warriors who will die at there OWN hands to avoid disgrace, much less someone else...
yeah they all had long hair then it was some sort of statuse i think bwing a westerner from Scotland iv no idea about the samurie only that they were really brave warriors
does anyone know where i could find a video tutorial to tie their hair in a top-knot like Nobutada? this scene really inspired me to do my hair that way!!
just look it up on you tube i geuss or why not email Shin on his offishal Myspace site hes on my contacts but the internet is your best bet really and good luck my Samurai
this is my favourite scene out of any movie i've ever seen in my entire life. i cry every time i watch it....i can see this guy becoming the next Bruce Lee - so talented!!!
Shin Koyamada is his real name hes a well known Japanese actor and verywell known for his martial arts hes also a bloodline off the real samuria that was on his fansite he lives in LA now and does a lot of work with Disney hes a huge Disney fan and hes 26 just now
I love these american morons on this forum. This scene is not meant to express happiness or how hot japanese-american actors are. Edward Zwick specifically directed this scene to show that the samurai's top knot was in fact his very soul. It is the highest form of self-preservation or honor a samurai has.
@Romansteel13 - don't get your panties in a wad. As someone who studies cultures and religions, I'm fully aware of what is happening to him and the situation. I just chose to comment on the actor. Asshole.
Wrong euphemism, I think you mean twist. He isn't an actor far from it, the reason why Edward Zwick hired him is because he is an adept martial artist do some research before you run your mouth moron.
@Romansteel13 for heaven's sake shin actually was partly there in the movie so that he could HONE on his acting sills.......get ur facts straight dude.............
Wrong putz, Shin was put there on the request, nay behest of Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise produced the film, and put his money in it. He was the big boss. Shin is a martial artist by trade, acting just pays the bills kiddo. Get your facts straight, moron. SCHMUCK!
@Romansteel13 oh i got em straight allright.......i know what i'm talking about......ur just mixing 2 different thing s2gether :/ sorry can't help ya :(
Wrong putz, Shin was put there on the request, nay behest of Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise produced the film, and put his money in it. He was the big boss. Shin is a martial artist by trade, acting just pays the bills kiddo. Get your facts straight, moron. SCHMUCK!
why the hell do all of you tal like that?! i don'T think ANYONE can really tell what happened to them or how it was. Not you. not me. i truly doubt that most japanese can. none of us lived in that times! you can hardly reproduce the feeling it gave! we all can just GUESS.
damm straight im not japnesse but ive read and study the samurai so im a geek i dont care but the samurai were great and id glady become one if i could
the first time i saw that scene i was a little bit to young to understand the scene but i thought that he was getting his head cut off lol i was so stupid back then lol.
you asshole you wouldnt understand im not japnesse but ive read and researched samurai cultue call me a geek if u want but i respect the samurai if they still existed id gladly become one the way of bushido and honor are truly great
ah son please.what do u know of bushido?just casue i insulted you dont presume i have no knowledge of the samurai.lol i have meiyo tattooed on my chest im a black belt in TKD (although) thats korean but have a vast knowledge of this that you speak of..kids these days.
Are you fucking kidding dude. If you disrespected me I'd disrespect you all fucking day. You're a fucking faggot meiyo8. You wanna be respected you show it. Thats MY rule.
Wolfwar97 is damn right! The Samurai were great warriors!I'd give up the whole live I have now to become one! What they say in the movie is true: Honor has become a long forgotten word!
Honor!? Respect?? I'm afraid so many have bought into the glorification of these people. They were nothing but thugs, assassins, murders, rapist, and quite often mercenaries. Just because one is looked up upon highly does not mean that when they kill a peasant for their posessions they are any better than the common street filth. Come on morons, learn your facts before you buy into the an image. That being said, they were good at what they did, and later on did became great artisans.
Nobutada did not kill any peasents in the movie and certianly did NOT deserve to have his hair cut off that was an assult on him their was good samurai guys like him
shut up you jackass you know nothing about the samurai if u know what they had to to become samurai it really really fucked up im not japnesse but it just fucked up what happend to them
how the heck do you tie a topknot ?!
i wana now :D
sergio311 2 weeks ago
Do you think the scene meant to show "the price of modernization".
thawhtet8 3 weeks ago
@thawhtet8 so true, nice interpretation
sergio311 2 weeks ago
This scene struck me later, as fridge logic is wont to do, the same way the ninja section did. It seemed over the top to have ninjas be these "evil mean moral-less monster" types, and this part?
I'm not saying this didn't happen, but...Japanese men? In a Japanese city? There wasn't even a caucasion boss to instigate. They just mobbed the Samurai for giggles. And cutting off his top not? Yet LEAVING him with his swords!?
Dramatic and powerful, but...with any luck, unrealistic.
HotaruZoku 6 months ago
@HotaruZoku Maybe I'm missing something about your comment but the soldiers didn't leave the swords*. Take a look at the left-most soldier starting @1:18. He's holding the young samurai's katana & wakizashi.
*I watched this scene 3 times to be sure.
jaykrue 1 month ago
@jaykrue Ah. I see how that wording could be misleading.
I meant "Leaving with swords" as in, "They left WITH those swords" seized and confiscated.
HotaruZoku 1 week ago
He reminds me of Vegeta lool
TBK1979 9 months ago
Legolas?
Mefis55 10 months ago
@Mefis55 japanese legolas
enticingmuffin 6 months ago
JOLLY GOOOOD!!!! oh wait.
championofcathay 11 months ago
It'd be hilarious if he yelled out jolly good instead, just imagine lol.
Ratchet25 11 months ago
question but was this the alternative to that deleted beheading scene?
xXdenee 11 months ago
this part made me cry damn america
BriCareful 1 year ago 2
@freacis ur actually wrong he killed around 15 or 20 people when he was dying
1346798520q 1 year ago
Jolly Good. GOD SHIN IS SEXY!
WeCanCos 1 year ago 2
Anyone that finds this scene interesting should watch the Masaki Kobayashi movie "Hari Kiri"
V70ROB 1 year ago
cutting a samurai's hair is like striping someone naked. you're taking away their dignity
foodbug 1 year ago 12
@foodbug a samurai who got his hair cut would be certainly made to seppuku.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@TrueTriad4Life
Roger Joseph Ebert (pronounced /ˈiːbərt/; born June 18, 1942) is an American film critic and screenwriter. Forbes has described him as "the most powerful pundit in America".[8]
He is known for his film review column (appearing in the Chicago Sun-Times since 1967, and later online)[9] and for the television programs Sneak Previews,
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@TrueTriad4Life
Critique is a method of disciplined, systematic analysis of a written or oral discourse. Critique is an accepted format of written and oral debate. Critique differs from (is not) criticism in that critique is never personalized nor ad hominem, but is instead the analyses of the structure of the thought in the content of the item critiqued. .
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@Romansteel13 Never gave those two words having distinct meaning any thought....interesting insight.
HotaruZoku 1 week ago
@TrueTriad4Life
Genuine actor, really man? Wow. I did not know this.
Shakespeare must be rolling over his grave.
Where did you find this genuine actor?
As I have said in my previous assertion.
My dog is a power ranger, it means nothing.
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@TrueTriad4Life
My dog is a power ranger.
Romansteel13 1 year ago
dude i saw this guy today at a career panel! i was too nervous to go up to him....i wanted his autograph so badly...but i was too shy...T^T
MewIchigolove 1 year ago
does anyone know what he screams out while there cutting his top knot off?
killuhmike99 1 year ago
@killuhmike99 I think it was "Yamero!!!"
raraireng 1 year ago
I actually cried in the theatre when I first saw this. =(
JuuhachigouSama 1 year ago
@JuuhachigouSama Not alone.
HotaruZoku 1 week ago
@HotaruZoku Good to know I wasn't the only one! My bro and dad looked at me like I was crazy, lol.
JuuhachigouSama 1 week ago
as a sikh, this is a very powerful scene to watch, and hans zimmer is one the best score composers ever.
singhisking01 1 year ago
AHHH! I saw him at the Cherry Blossum parade!! Had no idea he was there and suddenly he announced his name and he came by in a car! So awesome to see him!! :)
B3Ger 1 year ago
I'm curious...do you think a "real" samurai would've submitted in this manner? These are warriors who will die at there OWN hands to avoid disgrace, much less someone else...
skidrum11 1 year ago
There are no words to describe HOW sad this scene is...
USSRangel85 2 years ago
Where THE FUCK CAN I GET THIS MUSIC ?
musherally 2 years ago
@musherally the soundtrack is by Hans Zimmer
singhisking01 1 year ago
i think for a samurai to get he's top - knot cut is more fucked up then getting raped man .....
musherally 2 years ago
that fat piece of shit cutted the top-knot of nobutada What a loser
1vs1 he would get pwned!
musherally 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i woulda cut off their heads
Edd692 2 years ago
This is a powerful scene.
zoltankissjnr 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
zoltankissjnr 2 years ago
that is SADDD!!
futureshocker 2 years ago 4
dam thats fucked up.
jetdatboy 2 years ago 2
still think thise is a sad scean my heart goes out to poor Nobuutada [yet i think his hair is thise leagnth to his shoulders for real
freacls 2 years ago 3
wait is is bad for a samurai to get there hair cut, cuz i have long hair and i would get mad if some dude cut it
ajthemooonster 2 years ago
yeah they all had long hair then it was some sort of statuse i think bwing a westerner from Scotland iv no idea about the samurie only that they were really brave warriors
freacls 2 years ago
does anyone know where i could find a video tutorial to tie their hair in a top-knot like Nobutada? this scene really inspired me to do my hair that way!!
perttybeta 2 years ago
just look it up on you tube i geuss or why not email Shin on his offishal Myspace site hes on my contacts but the internet is your best bet really and good luck my Samurai
freacls 2 years ago
殺してっ!!殺してっ!!(トム)
SAMURAIHEARTX3 2 years ago
oooh. x'(
x♥
Prochazkova94 2 years ago
".... jolly good. " haha i had to laugh. but i love dis movie!
Belaubodyboarder 2 years ago
なんか警察の方えらいチンピラだな~
そこまで怒ならくても・・・・
サムライが警察にリンチされてるのを見ると、欧米人は、サムライこそが正しい日本人で急速に欧米化した日本人が間違っているなんていう風にみえるんだけど。何かやだな~そういうの。監督がそういう風に暗示してるかは知らないけど・・
SAMURAIHEARTX3 2 years ago
so u like how people dis each other ? im no good at this and never will be never do this.
3iHard 2 years ago
this is my favourite scene out of any movie i've ever seen in my entire life. i cry every time i watch it....i can see this guy becoming the next Bruce Lee - so talented!!!
meletui 2 years ago 3
yeah hes awsome and hes so hot too[even pretteir than Gackt] i wish him all the best in his career and with his good looks hell get fangirls too
freacls 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LOL, this is funny, hes acting like his dick got cut off..
weedymcweed1 2 years ago
i went to Supercuts today, and now I understand how Nobutada felt there...
:(
secretsoftheninjas 2 years ago
so sad.... but I love this scene. . . and shin ;D
OmajaO 2 years ago 4
Is Shin Koyamada the actors name, or do you think thats his name in the movie? His name was Nobutada in the movie.
GuamKomudo 3 years ago
Shin Koyamada is his real name hes a well known Japanese actor and verywell known for his martial arts hes also a bloodline off the real samuria that was on his fansite he lives in LA now and does a lot of work with Disney hes a huge Disney fan and hes 26 just now
freacls 2 years ago
This is my favorite scene in the film. Had me tearing up.
AmanoHybrid 3 years ago
Anyone who cuts my long hair will die a violent death
CosmicDestroyer99 3 years ago 13
thats easy to do...Nobutada showed restraint...thats a real warrior.
jetdatboy 2 years ago 3
@jetdatboy I agree with you, Nobutada's actions in the scene is him showing restraint; even in the face of humiliation or possibly death.
One of the many reasons why I love the Samurai so much
sadlobster1 2 weeks ago
lol wendy wu
SweetLittleElise 3 years ago
ou man, i love this scene
inetkiddy 3 years ago
Nobutada is hot. I love that dude.
DiamondHobbit 3 years ago 24
It's not him, he's dead.
PegasoltaEclair 3 years ago
I dont think he was dead here, yet.
darkarson999 3 years ago
Oh, sorry...chronological problems.
PegasoltaEclair 3 years ago
Peace. XD
darkarson999 3 years ago
no he gets beaten up a bit but he dies later saving his friends he was fine after thise just a bit sore and shorter hair thats all
freacls 2 years ago
@DiamondHobbit
I love these american morons on this forum. This scene is not meant to express happiness or how hot japanese-american actors are. Edward Zwick specifically directed this scene to show that the samurai's top knot was in fact his very soul. It is the highest form of self-preservation or honor a samurai has.
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@Romansteel13 - don't get your panties in a wad. As someone who studies cultures and religions, I'm fully aware of what is happening to him and the situation. I just chose to comment on the actor. Asshole.
DiamondHobbit 1 year ago
@DiamondHobbit
Wrong euphemism, I think you mean twist. He isn't an actor far from it, the reason why Edward Zwick hired him is because he is an adept martial artist do some research before you run your mouth moron.
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@Romansteel13 Actually, someone else on this forum said he was a Japanese actor as well. Get a life and get off my ass.
DiamondHobbit 1 year ago
@Romansteel13 for heaven's sake shin actually was partly there in the movie so that he could HONE on his acting sills.......get ur facts straight dude.............
ADMJCXNK97fan 1 year ago
@ADMJCXNK97fan
Wrong putz, Shin was put there on the request, nay behest of Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise produced the film, and put his money in it. He was the big boss. Shin is a martial artist by trade, acting just pays the bills kiddo. Get your facts straight, moron. SCHMUCK!
Romansteel13 1 year ago
@Romansteel13 oh i got em straight allright.......i know what i'm talking about......ur just mixing 2 different thing s2gether :/ sorry can't help ya :(
ADMJCXNK97fan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ADMJCXNK97fan
Wrong putz, Shin was put there on the request, nay behest of Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise produced the film, and put his money in it. He was the big boss. Shin is a martial artist by trade, acting just pays the bills kiddo. Get your facts straight, moron. SCHMUCK!
NONE OF my friends is a murderer!!!!!!!!!!!!
Romansteel13 1 year ago
He was screaming "Stop"
catkilling 3 years ago 4
anyone know what he was yelling out when he was getting his topknot cut off?
yawteg 3 years ago
why the hell do all of you tal like that?! i don'T think ANYONE can really tell what happened to them or how it was. Not you. not me. i truly doubt that most japanese can. none of us lived in that times! you can hardly reproduce the feeling it gave! we all can just GUESS.
VisualCode 4 years ago
damm straight im not japnesse but ive read and study the samurai so im a geek i dont care but the samurai were great and id glady become one if i could
wolfwar97 4 years ago 7
yea but u cant cause ur a panzy
meiyo8 4 years ago
nice dick keep talking
wolfwar97 4 years ago 2
meiyo fuck you man wolf is thrice the man you will ever be you ignorant piece of shit.
xxhermitxx 3 years ago
very sad momentin the movie... it was sad when he died as well.
findingfishy 4 years ago 2
to the japanese to die without honor is a worthless death and it meant nothing. Cutting of his hair was dishonoring him.
devilsimp 4 years ago
I still can't believe that Tom Cruise is the last samurai... lol
whyiscrowdpurpl 4 years ago 2
Lol, yeah.
FoxtrotNinja 4 years ago
Jolly Good...
findingfishy 4 years ago
the first time i saw that scene i was a little bit to young to understand the scene but i thought that he was getting his head cut off lol i was so stupid back then lol.
darksphere1 4 years ago
just tie a new one, lmao
Nilz2k 5 years ago
lol
japoi00 5 years ago
you asshole you wouldnt understand im not japnesse but ive read and researched samurai cultue call me a geek if u want but i respect the samurai if they still existed id gladly become one the way of bushido and honor are truly great
wolfwar97 4 years ago 6
ah son please.what do u know of bushido?just casue i insulted you dont presume i have no knowledge of the samurai.lol i have meiyo tattooed on my chest im a black belt in TKD (although) thats korean but have a vast knowledge of this that you speak of..kids these days.
meiyo8 4 years ago
in that case im sorry for disrespecting you and youre awesome
wolfwar97 4 years ago
fukin right.if u were a samurai youd have killed urself for this disrespect.
meiyo8 4 years ago
yeah pretty much i fucked up badly right now sorry man
wolfwar97 4 years ago
Are you fucking kidding dude. If you disrespected me I'd disrespect you all fucking day. You're a fucking faggot meiyo8. You wanna be respected you show it. Thats MY rule.
recniabsal 2 years ago
Samurai culture was based around respect, you insulted him, and his honour, you should be apologising, not him.
kingsharksam 3 years ago
Wolfwar97 is damn right! The Samurai were great warriors!I'd give up the whole live I have now to become one! What they say in the movie is true: Honor has become a long forgotten word!
maffiosie25 4 years ago 15
Honor!? Respect?? I'm afraid so many have bought into the glorification of these people. They were nothing but thugs, assassins, murders, rapist, and quite often mercenaries. Just because one is looked up upon highly does not mean that when they kill a peasant for their posessions they are any better than the common street filth. Come on morons, learn your facts before you buy into the an image. That being said, they were good at what they did, and later on did became great artisans.
youwillhatemesoon 3 years ago 5
Nobutada did not kill any peasents in the movie and certianly did NOT deserve to have his hair cut off that was an assult on him their was good samurai guys like him
freacls 2 years ago
Be better to die than to endure that bullshit!!!
Joninsho 5 years ago
no wat bullshit he difide japanese law so he is to pay for his crimes dee dee dee it's stupid to die like that aka kamikaze pilots
alisouvannakhily 5 years ago
shut up you jackass you know nothing about the samurai if u know what they had to to become samurai it really really fucked up im not japnesse but it just fucked up what happend to them
wolfwar97 4 years ago