Shirley is only my most favorite Hong Kong singer. The sentimental changes based on lyrics, and only Shirley with lots of life experience can handle it. No one can ever imitate Shirley's super special character. Wing yee did not sing bad but she totally ruined the song by no injection of feeling. It is better for her to sing soft tragic songs in her own style.
By the way it is not Wing Yee's fault because TVB had her to sing other people's song in Jade Solid Gold without reasons.
i absolute agree with u...nowadays whoever doesn't sing out of tune becomes 實力派...i'm so glad someone realise that singing in tune is the most fundamental component in vocal...
還是關淑怡唱的驚艷！！！！這位小姐只是做到了音準而已，完全沒有感情。。。
sofialiubcn 4 weeks ago
不錯。。。
fattization 2 months ago
个人感觉遮。无必要人身攻击。我觉泳儿应该算唔错啦
penguintan87 10 months ago
我覺得ok丫
但始終冇關淑怡唱得咁正
hehehahawowawo 1 year ago 4
Shirley is only my most favorite Hong Kong singer. The sentimental changes based on lyrics, and only Shirley with lots of life experience can handle it. No one can ever imitate Shirley's super special character. Wing yee did not sing bad but she totally ruined the song by no injection of feeling. It is better for her to sing soft tragic songs in her own style.
By the way it is not Wing Yee's fault because TVB had her to sing other people's song in Jade Solid Gold without reasons.
cheungwc56 1 year ago
完全欠缺關淑怡既 power. 依家D人好得意,冇走音就叫唱得好.以前冇走音係最基本,好似打籃球帶波唔走步一樣
Jonwucf 1 year ago
@Jonwucf
我好贊成你既說話
佢根本冇唱呢類型既歌既聲底
以為自己唱得好
我真係覺得依家d人好不自量力
明明冇之前d人咁勁
都敢挑戰
我真係覺得依家d樂壇好黑暗
winggisee 1 year ago
@winggisee イ巨幾時話過自己唱得好好?
仲有唱舊歌應該係電視台要求GA WO~
咁事實一定冇關淑怡唱得咁好GA LA~
首歌又吾係イ巨GE~新一代又無原唱者咁多經驗~
唱人地GE 歌目的可以係欣賞/紀念原唱歌手而唱~
吾一定係挑戰@@
ikitkit2008 1 year ago 4
@Jonwucf
i absolute agree with u...nowadays whoever doesn't sing out of tune becomes 實力派...i'm so glad someone realise that singing in tune is the most fundamental component in vocal...
hoiningt 1 year ago
有關小姐既9成 好好聽
mslam71 1 year ago 7
Comment removed
mslam71 1 year ago
excellent!!
ying8013 1 year ago 4