this is so fucking bad lol. i played troy, and although i don't really look the part so much (tall, thin, wear glasses, pale) i acted it very well and sang it well. and my gabriella is a 3 time all-state choir selection as well as winning lot's of competitions and stuff. oh and our ryan was accepted to julliard and is a counter-tenor, no big deal.
I was Troy this year in my high school play. These notes are killer, I'm like a meso-tenor andits rough but come on dude, the verse's should at least be in the right octave. Good job though
do not even think about say bad things about hsm you re like the cerk ones you re the one of who cant understand that hsm has something special that makes you a loser silly
those high notes are so hard. i had to sing this for an hsm audition and i could hardly hit them, and i'm a first tenor. but he still sounds like a cold.
And to those who arn't singers or anything, it's not that easy to find a guy that can hit those high notes. At our callbacks even the guys that are tenor in chior had problems with the high notes. And the way they pick their leads is if they look and act the part. Yes singing is important, but in most cases they don't always pick the best singer. And i'm sure you all that are critisizing them can't even sing. And for those who can sing better, well good for you then.
Though it may be hard to find a guy who can hit the high B-flats this song calls for, it should not be hard to find a guy who knows how to sing harmony down an octave. Instead of singing Troy's line down an octave, this guy is simply singing Gabriella's line. That's pretty bad...
im doing hsm at my school and im gonna be honest. my 8th grade friend sounds better. i mean, your troy is NOT a tenor. (which is what zac efron is). yalls troy needs to get some vocal lessons to work on those high notes and stuff. it was all low and thats not how it is in the movie. im not trying to be mean, just honest!
Sorry guys, but as a recent troy in a totally sold out show for two weeks straight I have to tell you, you need work. You're not terrible by any means, Troy you have a decent tone on your lower register, don't know why exactly you're a Troy, but hey it happens sometimes. As for Gabriella, you have an enjoyable warmness to your voice, but your vibratto kicks in sometimes when it shouldn't be.
hey , Um my school is doing a production of this. I've been cast as troy, dreading it. Anyone give any tips??? oh btw, I'm blonde, and the guy cast as ryan has dark hair, which is rather funny!!
I'm playing troy in our show right now and this is horrible...troy is a tenor, did they just not get the memo? I get that the Bb is really high but seriously...an octave lower? and as for the rest of the "choreography"...yeah no comment
OK... I played Troy in the Stage version and I know how hard it is for a guy to sing such a high part, but common that song is supposed to be the climax of the whole play and it defiantly didn't sound like it! I am sorry :(
Thats just a bit general, and a bit racist, but in fairness when theres a country with so many fricken people theres bound to be a few crows! Haha this is good though. I'd rather them sing it down the octave than screaming it to hit the notes.
Ok I am troy in our show and here is what I have to say. 1. The jocks should not have left early it takes the mood away. 2. The jocks should not huddle in the middle of the song. 3. the words were wrong. and last but not least I was not feeling it AT ALL no emotions Use your hands more gosh!
OK SO give the guy a break...hes a bass yes...and heck...at least he is having fun up there...I was Troy in our show...and I kinda sucked too...the only thing that matters is that you try your hardest...and allow the audience to have fun...
ummm, the 8th grader who's playing troy in my schools production of hsm is waaaaaaaay better than this dude. he needs to learn how to act and sing. he looks like he doesn't know what to do with all 6 feet of him. and for god's sake, learn the words! i don't even sing his part and i know the words better than him. and has anyone ever heard of harmonies?
OK I know they're trying, but come on. Troy could have been way better, our school's troy can't really hit the notes but at least he knows the words and he can sing it a little better.
What the fuck?? the guy's one octave down... no screw that, he's 2 octaves off! its fucking shit! god, why the hell is a baritone singing a tenor song??
This was absolutly god awful, th girl has good pitch but her vowels are like a 3 year old. The guy is a good bass but zach sings tenor in HSM so it sounds terrible
This guy obviously is singing through his nose..he shows no emotion, and doesn't know the harmony.. O_O..haha. "/ I'm not sure what to say if he was the best to audition. lol.
i am in the middle of playin troy in my school the musical director told me that troy and ryans parts are written for boy sopranos some of the lines in this are manageable but sum are way too high
would people ever fuckin stop comparin the people who play these parts to zac and vanessa?!! jesus not all of them are fuckin pros. they gave it their best leave them be......lets see all u jerks get up and do it if ur so good like zac and vanessa
I Have To Admit That The Music For Troy Is Very High... As I Myself Am Struggling, But You Cannot Sing It Low, It Doesn't Work, Can't Sing High Don't Do HSM
That's right motherfucker! Sing it in your octave. More power to the baritones!!!
I'm doing troy for Maloney High, in CT. And goddamn that part is high! But the ending of this song was really lame. I like the way they did it on the tour.
i remembered very well tat "troy" should be wearing white jacket and white long pants... they cant even get the costume right dun even think about the vocals...:(
can't you guys give them a break they are trying the best they can. You can't expect them to be perfect. They are trying their best. Before you even judge can you even sing at all. Have you got the gut's to do that on stage
Judging by how incredibly ignorant your comments/language skills have proved you to be, even if you did have the "guts" to sing on stage, you have no clue what you are doing, have any true talent in the art, or have an appreciation of what it means to be an actor/singer/dancer. NO true performer would be so ignorant in critiquing a video of highschool efforts.
I watched this whole play for some odd reason and this fucker playing troy keep saying kindergader(typo)WTF!! I didn't know troy and gabby knew each other that long
dude inthe movie he says something about kindegarten[typo] so thats why they say it. just like in the movie. and people stop putting them down! their doing their best and thats all that counts, if they had the guts to get up there then thats great. STOP PUTTING THEM DOWN!!!!!! OMG just because they dont sound like zac and vanessa they suck, just stop omg, yall being stupid.
Great job on yall play. I think its very good. Keep up the good work.
1. if you're going to insult the video, at least do it in proper English.
2. The dude is fine, yes it's an octave low and at points slightly offkey but thats fine. Yes it's HSM but high schools dont exactly have the mixers that professional movie producers have. Zac Efron and Drew Seeley's voices aren't nearly as good without all the different mixers applied. (as shown in the movie's start of something new reprise)
3. Choreography is kinda bland in my opinion but its a hard song to work with.
:-o whys everyone being so mean? thats so cruel!! they've obviously rehearsed really hard and put tonnes of effort into this so why be so mean, i dont understand people doing that :( why comment if its just to be nasty? (they've done the same thing on my groups page :()
our class is way way better than this. At least we can sing. Our class has actually rehearsed and it doesnt look a those they have. What is up with the guys voice!!!!!
I was in a program last year and we did this and I was gabriella and now me and the guy who played Troy are dating-3
monicay1001 7 months ago
this is so fucking bad lol. i played troy, and although i don't really look the part so much (tall, thin, wear glasses, pale) i acted it very well and sang it well. and my gabriella is a 3 time all-state choir selection as well as winning lot's of competitions and stuff. oh and our ryan was accepted to julliard and is a counter-tenor, no big deal.
redarmygeneral06 9 months ago
the girl sounds nice but theyre rushing it and the guy sounds soo FLAT
madyandmariah 10 months ago
My middle school did High School Musical last year, You guys are great but it doesnt compare to us. But good job!
logant1123 1 year ago
nice play!!
u all have a great future!!
hahah
it's made my day guys!!
carljeanixzs 1 year ago
I was Troy this year in my high school play. These notes are killer, I'm like a meso-tenor andits rough but come on dude, the verse's should at least be in the right octave. Good job though
prudh0mme 1 year ago
We're 11-13 and ours is about 100 times better.
sergevil 1 year ago
yes they should have.....
MsTwilight411 2 years ago
why is troy singing an octave lower than he's supposed to???? he sucks! gabriella's ok, but i can barely hear him!
Sophieste163 2 years ago
omg they suck! :)
like seriously
im in the play and we are like all 15 and we sound so much better than them.
the girl isnt that bad but 'troy' sounds like he is constipated they are trying way to much.
but its not that bad if they were just doing it cause they were bored. :)
TheBubbly9900 2 years ago
Now where's your videos?
kaileemouse 2 years ago
omg there so good
goonyfish5 2 years ago
stop with all the hate! do you have any idea how hard it is to do a musical?
evilmonkeyactress 2 years ago
awful!!!!!!!1
miransabose 2 years ago
during a few of his lines troy didnt follow the most basic and most important rule: never turn ur bak on the audience
qsrgyj7 2 years ago
High school musical is like the worst movie.
15krystek15 2 years ago
Why bother commenting on the video?
PRICK
FalkirkFCcasual80 2 years ago
Coz I feel like to! and is non of u r business Brick.
15krystek15 2 years ago
Well don't.
Your negativity is not wanted here.
You've made it my business by replying to comment. You easily could have not replied to my comment if its none of my business.
FalkirkFCcasual80 2 years ago
I think that you are crazy for hsm but but you want to act like a loser
kayraes2 2 years ago
HA me crazy for this shit, change u r doctor, one person in here who act like a loser its YOU!!
15krystek15 2 years ago
dont be cerk
kayraes2 2 years ago
do not even think about say bad things about hsm you re like the cerk ones you re the one of who cant understand that hsm has something special that makes you a loser silly
kayraes2 2 years ago
The only thing that ppl watch this shit is because of this gay guy I forgot his name and this lesbian girl but I also forgot her name.
15krystek15 2 years ago
okey maybe you dont like hsm what do you mean with gay and lesbian
kayraes2 2 years ago
think.
15krystek15 2 years ago
you think that they look like thats bad I know
kayraes2 2 years ago
They do look stupid. I don't care who they are I can course and say what I think about them in their face.
15krystek15 2 years ago
Why, Troy's not even #14...
Directorboy91 2 years ago
Well guys.. I'll give you this.. I had a laugh while watching this
steve6684 2 years ago
those high notes are so hard. i had to sing this for an hsm audition and i could hardly hit them, and i'm a first tenor. but he still sounds like a cold.
kevinkda 3 years ago
And to those who arn't singers or anything, it's not that easy to find a guy that can hit those high notes. At our callbacks even the guys that are tenor in chior had problems with the high notes. And the way they pick their leads is if they look and act the part. Yes singing is important, but in most cases they don't always pick the best singer. And i'm sure you all that are critisizing them can't even sing. And for those who can sing better, well good for you then.
xmusicxisxlifex09x 3 years ago
Though it may be hard to find a guy who can hit the high B-flats this song calls for, it should not be hard to find a guy who knows how to sing harmony down an octave. Instead of singing Troy's line down an octave, this guy is simply singing Gabriella's line. That's pretty bad...
operapirate 2 years ago
Yeah... This is pretty bad :O
theatrejunky31965 2 years ago
Good Job! Not in the right range, but that's ok
xmusicxisxlifex09x 3 years ago
a mess.
zashley1430102 3 years ago
it's not good
TheeCookie 3 years ago
You're right. Sounds boring...
Drace90 3 years ago
He put me to sleep.
Was he singing Bass?
Was that the best that Houston could offer?
Besides the fact that HE GOT THE WORDS WRONG AT 2:16.
Really?
JoshRoxxx 3 years ago
haha true
im playing troy in my school production
i can hit those notes RIGHT tho
7xXwhysoseriousXx7 3 years ago
im doing hsm at my school and im gonna be honest. my 8th grade friend sounds better. i mean, your troy is NOT a tenor. (which is what zac efron is). yalls troy needs to get some vocal lessons to work on those high notes and stuff. it was all low and thats not how it is in the movie. im not trying to be mean, just honest!
jobrosloveyou 3 years ago
Sorry guys, but as a recent troy in a totally sold out show for two weeks straight I have to tell you, you need work. You're not terrible by any means, Troy you have a decent tone on your lower register, don't know why exactly you're a Troy, but hey it happens sometimes. As for Gabriella, you have an enjoyable warmness to your voice, but your vibratto kicks in sometimes when it shouldn't be.
Helterskelter212 3 years ago
woooow
that's all i have 2 say!! terrible!!
Anderwaldmanman 3 years ago
yikes=[
italiaababii13 3 years ago
hey , Um my school is doing a production of this. I've been cast as troy, dreading it. Anyone give any tips??? oh btw, I'm blonde, and the guy cast as ryan has dark hair, which is rather funny!!
TVH11 3 years ago
You could always transpose the part down. Or just breathe a lot. But yeah troy part is not written for a guy. lol
Bmlover5 3 years ago
1ST troy is number 14 not 5
2nd if you cant sing it correctly dont sing it at all
3rd choreography very poor
basically not very good in all honesty ive got a run of this show cuming up and tbh ours is way better.
jaysmith2108 3 years ago
omg :O:O lol yer ur soo right lol :D:D yay wooop we r amazin ours is fab :d
xxx
wickedangel991 3 years ago
god u guys did good for the amount of space u had
vitagerulz16 3 years ago
wooooow to much red guys but some more white in
vitagerulz16 3 years ago
great job guys u two r great
sexyscottishboy 3 years ago
o no
vista8808 3 years ago
I'm playing troy in our show right now and this is horrible...troy is a tenor, did they just not get the memo? I get that the Bb is really high but seriously...an octave lower? and as for the rest of the "choreography"...yeah no comment
matthewjohn350 3 years ago
yeah i agree with everything you said!
jobrosloveyou 3 years ago
OK... I played Troy in the Stage version and I know how hard it is for a guy to sing such a high part, but common that song is supposed to be the climax of the whole play and it defiantly didn't sound like it! I am sorry :(
audiman2009 3 years ago
be happy? dance? smile even?
theres no emotion! i want to be moved!
bleep111 3 years ago
i absolutely agree!
jobrosloveyou 3 years ago
the girl is wailing a tiny bit. if she added some vibrado she would sound much nicer
bleep111 3 years ago
yea go Troy... ever heard of harmony, or an octave higher??? having trouble with that B flat lol
TehAmazingJonathan 3 years ago
Just shows that foreigners can't spell! Dance***
playa25827085 3 years ago
just goes to show americans cant sing, act or danse
mongooseman556 3 years ago
Thats just a bit general, and a bit racist, but in fairness when theres a country with so many fricken people theres bound to be a few crows! Haha this is good though. I'd rather them sing it down the octave than screaming it to hit the notes.
davo664 3 years ago
Ok I am troy in our show and here is what I have to say. 1. The jocks should not have left early it takes the mood away. 2. The jocks should not huddle in the middle of the song. 3. the words were wrong. and last but not least I was not feeling it AT ALL no emotions Use your hands more gosh!
ElderBordum 3 years ago
wonr words wrong words!!
HSMusicalfan4EvEr 3 years ago
what bits are rong jw
mongooseman556 3 years ago
you guys suck ass. for reals.
mrpanget 3 years ago
What the heckkk, they can't sing!
Bellax3Donna 3 years ago
That's not even lines from High School Musical, they're just making it up, and how did that guy even get the role of Troy no offence
taggerRLS 3 years ago
yer this is the stage version
..... a pretty shit take on it but they gotta stick 2 the script i got ryan and we wanted a scene added and it cost like £50,000
mongooseman556 3 years ago
They can't sing and there was no choreography
haawwttaay 4 years ago
It is ok but not the best
lizadog2 4 years ago
OK SO give the guy a break...hes a bass yes...and heck...at least he is having fun up there...I was Troy in our show...and I kinda sucked too...the only thing that matters is that you try your hardest...and allow the audience to have fun...
goldog26 4 years ago
ummm, the 8th grader who's playing troy in my schools production of hsm is waaaaaaaay better than this dude. he needs to learn how to act and sing. he looks like he doesn't know what to do with all 6 feet of him. and for god's sake, learn the words! i don't even sing his part and i know the words better than him. and has anyone ever heard of harmonies?
gilmoregirl0306 4 years ago
lol. yeah the 8th grader at my school is wayy better too. hahah.
jobrosloveyou 3 years ago
omg he sucks...sorry :) i am troy 2 (tomorow!) and i sing it low aswell, but it only sounds gd if u put in effort, and not flat!
invertedcab5 4 years ago
We've just done that production ... That troy has the worst voice on stage every ... and he needs to act alot more!!
5050Media 4 years ago
HE needs to show more energy on stage
singingchristian 4 years ago
OK I know they're trying, but come on. Troy could have been way better, our school's troy can't really hit the notes but at least he knows the words and he can sing it a little better.
madegurl4u 4 years ago
What the fuck?? the guy's one octave down... no screw that, he's 2 octaves off! its fucking shit! god, why the hell is a baritone singing a tenor song??
captainjohnharkness 4 years ago
This was absolutly god awful, th girl has good pitch but her vowels are like a 3 year old. The guy is a good bass but zach sings tenor in HSM so it sounds terrible
aljripc 4 years ago
yeah no emoton woowza
itsemily114 4 years ago
umm....oh my...I'd like to see some emotion...some love ?
Musicloversweetheart 4 years ago
This guy obviously is singing through his nose..he shows no emotion, and doesn't know the harmony.. O_O..haha. "/ I'm not sure what to say if he was the best to audition. lol.
timonlinenow 4 years ago
he doesnt know the words either
ch3ymusic 4 years ago
i am in the middle of playin troy in my school the musical director told me that troy and ryans parts are written for boy sopranos some of the lines in this are manageable but sum are way too high
chriscur08 4 years ago
troy is a baratone but his songs are written for tenors thats why his voice was mixe in HSM 1 and then gotvoice lessons, boy soprano's really,
aljripc 4 years ago
oh ya btw zac didnt even sing in the original....
catcherinred 4 years ago
yes he did not live but thats his voice thats the way you make music videos and do u go around calling them fake NO so shove off
ch3ymusic 4 years ago
No it isn't, he couldn't sing those notes, check the label on the soundtrack.
catcherinred 3 years ago
The video keeps stopping at 12 seconds.
Maserati777 4 years ago
refresh the page
slytheringal1994 4 years ago
they suck. the skool sucks if this is how the leads sound. messy choreagraphing too. my middle scool did like 10xs better
todynody 4 years ago
would people ever fuckin stop comparin the people who play these parts to zac and vanessa?!! jesus not all of them are fuckin pros. they gave it their best leave them be......lets see all u jerks get up and do it if ur so good like zac and vanessa
chriscur08 4 years ago
i will
ch3ymusic 4 years ago
tahts not troys number his number is 14
jadeymadey58 4 years ago
zac and vanessa are way better!!
volleyballrocks101 4 years ago
Playing Keyboard for this show in February- hopefully will sound good!
thepianoman2008 4 years ago
I Have To Admit That The Music For Troy Is Very High... As I Myself Am Struggling, But You Cannot Sing It Low, It Doesn't Work, Can't Sing High Don't Do HSM
Rich66633366325 4 years ago
MY school did this and I played Gabrella
and it was hars to sing her song and now were doing Hsm2 ow and the dances are so hard
Motownfever 4 years ago
Troys voice is way too low. I suggest vocal lessons or a another troy. Nice stage though.
ranrooree 4 years ago
my school is going to do this too.
haawwttaay 4 years ago
That's right motherfucker! Sing it in your octave. More power to the baritones!!!
I'm doing troy for Maloney High, in CT. And goddamn that part is high! But the ending of this song was really lame. I like the way they did it on the tour.
deathjr777 4 years ago
Aw That Troy Isnt Very Good! Lol.
My Skools Doin It Aswell.
My Boyfrend Is Troy. =]
Going To See It Next Week Bt Wat Ive Seen Its Very Good! :D
HannyLou123 4 years ago
i remembered very well tat "troy" should be wearing white jacket and white long pants... they cant even get the costume right dun even think about the vocals...:(
JanetiaDilton05 4 years ago
can't you guys give them a break they are trying the best they can. You can't expect them to be perfect. They are trying their best. Before you even judge can you even sing at all. Have you got the gut's to do that on stage
tracey355 4 years ago
Hey dun think so u daring enough to tat....
Dun think to highly of urself larh..
wat fi i've got the guts to sing on stage??
wat are u gonna do??
they're making a show and wat if something goes wrong?? everything has to be good to gi right??
think again....-.=
JanetiaDilton05 4 years ago
Judging by how incredibly ignorant your comments/language skills have proved you to be, even if you did have the "guts" to sing on stage, you have no clue what you are doing, have any true talent in the art, or have an appreciation of what it means to be an actor/singer/dancer. NO true performer would be so ignorant in critiquing a video of highschool efforts.
jlpmusic100 4 years ago
Oh watever...-.=
JanetiaDilton05 4 years ago
I watched this whole play for some odd reason and this fucker playing troy keep saying kindergader(typo)WTF!! I didn't know troy and gabby knew each other that long
holybid 4 years ago
dude inthe movie he says something about kindegarten[typo] so thats why they say it. just like in the movie. and people stop putting them down! their doing their best and thats all that counts, if they had the guts to get up there then thats great. STOP PUTTING THEM DOWN!!!!!! OMG just because they dont sound like zac and vanessa they suck, just stop omg, yall being stupid.
Great job on yall play. I think its very good. Keep up the good work.
gbyall01 4 years ago
my schools doing this too...troys better in our production, he can hit the real notes lol and we have way better choreography
jazzie0707 4 years ago
Not bad.. but.. why don't you guys try to sing with 1st and 2nd vocal like in the movie.. that would sound much better to me ;)
And a male singer with who could reach a high C would be awesome seriously! ;)
JeffreyMiddelveld 4 years ago
not a good song for the boy's voice, too low to sing, but too high to bring it up ann ocvtave! gabriella has a sweet voice
thesbian2007 4 years ago
The guys got the wrong number on his shirt it should be 14 an most of the song he's out of tune
BBeth336 4 years ago
oh my gosh!! that is sooooo sick! i already watch the high school musical 1 and 2... that is soo suck...
fatalclaw06 4 years ago
i did one proucdicton on monday with a diffrent drama group we were much better
XxilovewestlifexX 4 years ago
1. if you're going to insult the video, at least do it in proper English.
2. The dude is fine, yes it's an octave low and at points slightly offkey but thats fine. Yes it's HSM but high schools dont exactly have the mixers that professional movie producers have. Zac Efron and Drew Seeley's voices aren't nearly as good without all the different mixers applied. (as shown in the movie's start of something new reprise)
3. Choreography is kinda bland in my opinion but its a hard song to work with.
legoexpo 4 years ago
not THAT bad..
cutiegal00 4 years ago
:-o whys everyone being so mean? thats so cruel!! they've obviously rehearsed really hard and put tonnes of effort into this so why be so mean, i dont understand people doing that :( why comment if its just to be nasty? (they've done the same thing on my groups page :()
starstrucksteph 4 years ago
our class is way way better than this. At least we can sing. Our class has actually rehearsed and it doesnt look a those they have. What is up with the guys voice!!!!!
Roseyboy101 4 years ago
this was really bad
justjay222 4 years ago
she girl looks big and beefy! AND they both suck..
VintageSunset 4 years ago
lad stuck it down an octave and fair do's
its a nightmare to sing
bit off key as well
rennettio 4 years ago
You guyys suck!
Goddess6760m 4 years ago
not bad
but legit, there's really not a "good" HSM On Stage, on youtube
MaxCMum 4 years ago
hell this is shit
fuprofk 4 years ago
the girl does a good job but the dude just stands there and is a bad actor (dull)
PianoPlayer08 4 years ago
:D good :D
lolka9999 4 years ago
can someone troys pulse?is he still alive? the girls aiiight but a lil pitchy at times but for a school musical its aiight
Keelan1995 4 years ago
too fast and low
irenexpark 4 years ago
haha thats painful.. jesus christ... the guy hu played troy had to take it down the octave near the beginning... how embarrasing
Rainb0wTrout 4 years ago
fuck shit!!>>>>this is a horseshit!<M<<goddamn boy ruins the show
jaff0791pappz 4 years ago 3
OMG its so fucking bad!!! sing up the octave for god's sake!! ruins the song!!!
richteahobnob 4 years ago
troy needs to sing louder.
donpatch27 4 years ago
i actually think it's quite good.
dolphinhelper 4 years ago
You guys need to move a bit more while singing.
Starrlightangel 4 years ago
THIS SUCKS HAHA
chelseapowell570 4 years ago
The guy isn't very enthusiastic... lol!
ChrisBAshton 4 years ago
pretty good
ilovesinging656 4 years ago
they did pretty good
XOitalia123 4 years ago
I THINK THAT U GUYS ROCK, URE THE BEST!!
hannahfan2222 4 years ago
where is this anyway? this IS pretty good. Looks fun!
born2rock7 4 years ago
i think that they did a nice job :)
taraelizabeth09 4 years ago
aw cute. haha
AliCiAClAiRE93 4 years ago
pretty! =)
thefiona007 4 years ago