As many people have quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
As rhov233 quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
As rhov233 quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
If you listened to the song he is saying that if you find the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you are morally misguided.
Unless your one of the possible boys the pope fucked and wanted him to... But you were under age so I'm sorry it's still class as rape maybe when your older and grow some actual balls the pope won't love you anymore
Tim Minchin's "lie filled, hate-mongering" anti-Pope song has more fucking honesty in it than the entire Catholic church. Fuck the Pope. Fuck kiddie fiddling Priests. Fuck the tunnel vision of the gullable idiots who defend the rapists and most importantly FUCK YOU! When you die, you'll just be dead. There will be no judgement. No paradise. No fuck all. Make your peace with it and move on. Fucker.
SIGH. Tim said it himself- "If you find the possibility that some priests had sexual relations with children less offensive than me (Tim) swearing at a man, you have something seriously wrong with you."
Now stop preaching, nobody's listening.
There's nothing I hate more than a religious person who tries to force me to see things their way.
And by the way, before you say it-
Tim Minchin is not forcing us to see things this way with his so called "lies".
Are you really saying I should read like an HOUR WORTH OF ARTICLES just to realize this particular 2 minute comedy song about "the pope" is full of fiction?
REALLY? :D
Ahahha. Sorry, but that's not going to happen.
I'll just take your word on it and consider Tim Minchin as ENTERTAINMENT.
Some people just don't understand comedy. Did Tim ever mention the name "Benedict"? In the song?
The song is about christianity and the weird occurance that alot of priests have had sexual relations with little boys and got in to trouble. The pope may or may not helped these priests. Bottomline; If he would; he'd be as bad as them.
So the song is nothing but a little critisism on the subject in a fictional comedy form.
jerryassholemanda i agree with enraged seph below: this video was a huge fucking waving cock of a waste of time. maybe if you had a bigger cock you would be waving it in some girl's face and stop wasting people's time
Or maybe you should stop being such a brainwashed little baby! If you are offended by this song you should worry more about your delicate sensitivity regarding the lampooning of ridiculous traditions. Grow up you ignorant petty little boy...
I watched that vid you posted, and I find it funny that you would think that standing on a street corner with a sign saying fuck the pope is totally comparable to singing it in a COMEDY SONG.
Maybe you were too busy being outraged but there is actually a little disclaimer on the end of that song. I guess you are doing exactly what he said people like you should do, but incidently do you then find this song more offensive than the thought that the pope was actually covering for child molesters?
I love how YouTube has put Tim Minchin's Pope Song as the number 1 suggestion. Just thought I'd mention it as a respite from the mud-slinging contest between the learned persons who have done research into the facts... and Jerrymanda
It saddens me to know that there are still people in this world who are so blind as to ignore the facts of reality and cry foul at those who point out uncomfortable truths about the world and those people who they believe in. Regardless of your personal beliefs, if you are that incapable of accepting that other people have differing opinions than yours that you need to make 2 different videos about one particular instance that 'offends you', you should seriously seek therapy.
You're a wanker for leaving this video up now that you've been un-banned... which any YouTube account holder is well within their rights to do... *smh*
@jerrymanda101, in regards to your comment reply to amberdextrix, the fact that there are abusive priests in the first place is completely absurd and disgusting. nothing can justify their actions.
Ratings dissabled - not overly shocking. Just another case of a brainwashed shmuck desperately defending the sad and out of date myths .... Dissabling ratings for a video with this particular message is just pathetic. Clearly they were not satisfactory therefore highly negative ...
it's unbelievable the stupidity of some people, you should read more before calling ppl liars, listen to Dan Bull - An Open Letter to Benny (The Pope). to quote Tim "But if you find me more offensive than the F possibility
The pope protected priests when they were getting F fiddly
Then listen to me motherF - this here is a fact,
You are just as morally misguided as that motherF,
Power-hungry, self-aggrandized bigot in the stupid F hat
YOU'RE A COMPLETE DICK! Everyone is open to there opinion so don't go calling his "evil" when they are based on pure fact, you can be a catholic, whatever, I don't care, but the fact that your pope covered up for paedophiles all over the world should not be shoved under the blanket, if you had any belief in this supposed "Omnibenevolent God" you would feel some sort of moral obligation to letting this guy carry on representing your religion, but not you're just an ignorant, self-righteous idiot!
I wonder why? Probably because you're tags say "Tim Minchin Pope Song", where they should be "Winging About Minchin".
Also, while it is unfortunate for you that the critic was banned, it was probably because he was being unnecessarily rude whilst voicing his own opinion, just as many are in the comments on this video. There's no need for either side to be so immature about it.
@b0omp3z I agree, fucktards should get a clue... The reason that religion still exists is because some people are just to dumb to understand basic science :) having blind faith in a bearded man with a serious god-complex, whom's stories are told to the next 10 or so generations, and finally written down by the 11th (or so).. and it's nearly impossible for so much information to land in the lap of one writer at that time. So clearly he made up a lot of it!
Maybe you should give substantiating evidence rather than going "YOU'RE LYING AND THIS IS DECEITFUL." This is not a critique as you claim it is, this is an unbased claim. Your opinion's relevance in your being blocked is improvable and improbable. You could have been banned for simply spamming the above message past Davidson's patience. Lastly, a blog is not evidence/proof. A blog is open to bias, incorrectivity and all-around flashy bollucks.
If you've got any more "points," I'm more than open.
How clever of you to disable ratings on your video. I guess your foresaw that your video ratings would go down faster than a Catholic priest on a 13-year old choir boy.
also, dear Jerry, the song isn't about the pope. if you listen, its actually about how you're a complete fucknut if you defend child rapists by not doing anything. hence the lyrics 'it doesn't matter if your plumber or a prince" you're a fucker too for defending the rapists
I cbf to find the comment on the actual video, so here: there's this thing. It's called a hierarchy. Priests are under the control of the bishop, then the arch bishop, then the cardinal, then the pope. The Cardinal who arranged the distribution of priests under JPII was Ratzinger. JPII put the stamp of approval on them, and the local bishops put that into action. SO Ratzinger is just as guilty as the kiddy fiddling priests. Learn to Catholic.
A lot of people (both Christian and atheist) rely on media soundbites and use them to justify their own entrenched positions.
Would it surprise you to know, for example, that homophobia is explicitly contrary to Catholic teaching and the use of artificial contraception actively promoted in certain circumstances by the Pope himself?!
If there's one thing this thread teaches us, it's not to rely on sound-bites (or songs!) for the facts.
While I distrust priests, I remain a committed Catholic. We shouldn't be surprised when people in the Church let us down - the Bible is full of them committing murder (Paul), adultery (David) and deceit (Peter). As Catholics, we must think for ourselves and challenge those in authority when they're wrong.
Father Oliver O'Grady, a Catholic priest who was relocated to various parishes around the United States during the 1970s in an attempt by the Catholic Church and the pope to cover up his rape of dozens of children......ENOUGH SAID!
@14Innes If you had bothered to go to the God Botherers website via the link in the Video Description you would have seen the case discussed there. Go to the God Botherers website via the link provided and scroll down to Item 2 - The Case of Fr Stephen Kiesle. The facts of that case continue to point to Tim Minchin being a lying hate-monger.
@14Innes While Tim Minchin's Pope Song collaborator and friend Fraser Davidson did "unblock" me from his comments sections, he then at the same time removed any comments I posted in his comments section. The upshot is, Tim Minchin's Pope Song collaborator continued to censor my comments on the "official" YouTube Pope Song video site even after "unblocking" me. If I have the time I might add that information to the video clip.
Amnesty International's latest annual human rights report, which cited the Holy See for the first time, concluded there was widespread evidence of child sexual abuse by members of the clergy over past decades, and an "enduring failure" of the Catholic church to seek redress.
In the headlines, as of Sept 13: Pope accused of crimes against humanity by victims of sex abuse. Victims' complaint to the international criminal court accuses Pope Benedict and three others of failing to prevent abusers
Amnesty International's latest annual human rights report, which cited the Holy See for the first time, concluded there was widespread evidence of child sexual abuse by members of the clergy over past decades, and an "enduring failure" of the Catholic church to seek redress.
In the headlines, as of Sept 13th: Pope accused of crimes against humanity by victims of sex abuse. Victims' complaint to the international criminal court accuses Pope Benedict and three others of failing to prevent abusers
I see you've disabled ratings, wonder why. I dunno if you thought anyone would take you seriously, but hey, you got the trolling you deserve. I'd like to say, that if you place all your faith in your god, in a man instead, that is a heresy as your giving your worship to an idol. I think that if a god does exist, and this polar universe provides an evil as it's opposite, that opposites office is the Vatican. They took all your love for the meek and turned you on them.
@Jerrymanda101 : You're clearly just jealous of Tim's awesomeness <3! Just 'cause you're puny and pathetic. Tell you what you need? Alcohol. It's good for the soul, so much better than the pope, who btw did cover up sex scandals everyone knows so you die hard loyalists may aswell give up haha. But seriously, a litre of vodka is well needed.
Even if you Pope apologists (or Papologists, how witty) did manage to prove that he had no part in covering up the sex abuse scandals, it wouldn't change my mind that he's a bad person. His homophobia encourages abuse of innocent people by millions of his followers, and his outdated, unscientific, inconsistent and self-contradictory views on contraception contribute to the AIDs epidemic that is ruining Africa. And through all of this he claims to have moral authority. Bastard.
"A child protection official for the Catholic Church has been caught with 4,000 pictures of child porn... Married Jarvis, 49, a former social worker, was employed by the church following sex scandals about pervert priests. His job was to monitor church groups to ensure pedophiles did not gain access to children in the church’s congregations." Oops! Looks like they didn't have enough time to shift Jarvis around in location and/or back to the Vatican to avoid his detainment and prosecution.
@Amberdextrix I’m not sure how you’ve concluded that Pope Benedict is somehow involved or how this case supports Tim Minchin’s theme that Pope Benedict has been covering up sex abuse.
In an article on the Examiner.com it has been revealed that the Pope and two other officials have been served papers in a child abuse case in Wisconsin alleging that the Pope and his co-defendants conspired to protect a child abuser and keep the allegations of child abuse quiet.
It claims Pope Benedict XVI and two other top Vatican officials knew about allegations of sexual abuse at St. John's school for the Deaf outside of Milwaukee and called off internal punishment of the accused Rev. Lawrence Murphy. Murphy died in 1998 but there have been several attempts throughout the years to serve the Vatican to no avail.
@Amberdextrix The case of Fr Murphy is discussed in detail at the God Botherers website given in the video. There's nothing to suggest the Vatican did anything wrong in that case. Breifly, the Vatican was informed of the case some 20 years after the last known abuse by Fr Murphy, who had long before been reported to police. The Vatican approved of a Church trial against Fr Murphy. Murphy appealed against a trial on the grounds of ill health and died 2 days after his trial was halted.
Even though Reverend Lawrence C. Murphy has since died, the case continues because of the allegation that the Vatican attempted to systematically cover-up the case. It could even be said that they have obstructed justice and put other children is harms way. If this case is allowed to proceed, it will open up the door for similar cases throughout the world. Earlier this year, a Philadelphia Grand Jury revealed a similar sexual molestation scandal involving 37 priests of the Catholic Church.
In the past, the Pope and Vatican officials were immune from such lawsuits under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976. However, in June of last year the Supreme Court declined to hear a Vatican appeal to a Ninth Circuit ruling that the Vatican can be held accountable for priest’s actions under the “tort exceptions” clause of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 under certain conditions.
Oh my god, have a whinge! You’re like a sooky 10 year old who didn’t get invited to the cool kid’s birthday party. If you yourself believe this stuff isn’t true, isn’t that enough? Why so much hatred toward those that like or, god forbid, AGREE with this song? I have no problem with people believing what they want. I have a problem with people trying to make ME believe what THEY want. And this is a classic example. Let it go mate
@fruit103 So you're okay with the likes of Tim Minchin and Fraser Davidson promoting lies to advance their hate-mongering? Why do you like Tim Minchin's Pope Song?
@Jerrymanda101 I like this song because he is making a fantastic point. A lot of people will see this song as just a silly, rude song with unnecessary swearing in it but the swearing is important to illustrate his point:
That is it ironic for people (like you) to be offended by such language yet to not be offended by the pope's protection of molesting preists.
You are obsessed with needing everyone to agree with you. Not everyone believes in the same things mate, no one ever will. Let it go.
In that case, Oregon man anonymously named John V. Doe alleged that Catholic Priest, Father Andrew Ronan sexually abused him on multiple occasions when he was a teenager in the 1960s. Like many similar cases, Father Ronan was alleged to have been engaged in sexual abuse with children in Ireland and in Chicago. Both times, the Vatican relocated him until he ended up in Oregon.
@Amberdextrix But once again what does all this have to do with Pope Benedict and Tim Minchin's theme of Benedict covering up sex abuse? At the time of the Fr Ronan's abuse, that happened in the US and Ireland, Benedict was an Archbishop in Germany. Can you see how you're not putting up a coherent argument?
While Father Ronan died in 1992, the plaintiffs in the case alleged that he was an employee of the Vatican and was engaged as an employee when he was sexually molesting children. The Vatican created the conditions in which sexual abuse could occur and as such the Vatican can be held accountable for the priest’s actions under the “tort exceptions” clause of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976.
@Amberdextrix That may well be your opinion, but the facts show otherwise. Priests are under the control of their local bishop, not the Vatican. And it was the responsibility of local bishops to deal with abusive priests. In some cases local bishops were suppose to inform the Vatican of abusive priests, but it seems until the last 10 years or so they rarely did.
@Jerrymanda101 Surely, if father Ronan was directly employed by the Vatican & not his local bishop, then he was answerable to the Vatican & not his local bishop. The fact that Amberdextrix is quoting acts of law implies they might have a snifter of an idea what they're talking about. Sorry, but I think you got banned for a reason, which appears to be you lack of. You need to get over the fact that there are people in this world who simply do not agree with you with regrads to this issue.
@Jerrymanda101 Let's talk about facts shall we? Science is fact, Religion is believing.
Science is the understanding of how things work fed by FACTS. Religion includes no -none at all- facts!
Clearly something went wrong, as it seems to be a widely-known issue around the world "priests abusing kids". And yes, 2000 years ago, it was the norm of the master to learn sex to his kid. later it was the norm to have sex with men. now the church doesn't have any clues about anything anymore it seems :P
Calm down children, don't you think that maybe we should be allowed to express opinion? Condemning him for condemning others is hypocrisy ,although I suppose you catholics are already familiar with that one. The other problem is that there HAVE been countless cases of child molestation in the Catholic Chruch, and the Church always denies all allegations. The Pope is at the top of the Church, therefore it is his job to keep an eye on what it is doing. It is his fault that he is not doing his job.
It's not 'hatemongering' when it's true. Way to parrot the Vatican's 'they're just trying to bring the Pope down!' party line though, you tool. I suppose he also lied about his recruitment into the Hitler Youth and service in the Nazi military because he was just trying to test all of your faith too, right?
"Ratings have been disabled for this video." Well, i guess if you're a Catholic you are already so used to hypocrisy that you are unaware that you're doing it.
The case is way broader than just the 3 priests on your God bothering website. The Catholic Church has a long history of committing and covering up paedophilia. The Pope is its final earthly authority, and if he does not condemn outright all criminal acts carried out by any in his church...
@SkyCreeper1 Fraser Davidson, who provided Tim Minchin with the animation for his Pope Song, has reinstated his ban on me. That's okay I can live with that, but it does reflect poorly on Tim Minchin when his main collaborator for "Pope Song" is prepared to censor those who are critical of Tim Minchin's hate-mongering. I've provided much evidence to show that Pope Benedict's critics are either ill-informed or liars.
man I'd sure like to put a thumbs up or a thumbs down on this video.... oh hmm it seems like that ability has been banned for people commenting on this video.
@tglass55 Errr irony, I don't think so. You're free to state your opinion on any of my videos. Tim Minchin's mate of course doesn't won't anyone providing evidence showing up his hate-mongering. In case you missed that evidence here it is again:
I don't believe tim lied. One of the pages on your link was "what the New York Times didn't tell you" or something, so he might have been under the same impression that everyone else was because of what the media told us. Don't hate the player, hate the game
@PickleRadio I'm sorry, I don't follow your reasoning at all. But I do know that Tim Minchin does believe in free speech, so I thought it ironic that Tim Minchin's friend and "partner in crime" Fraser Davidson would ban me from commenting on YouTube's main "Pope Song" video.
ffs, why is it that people in this world cannot understand the most simplest level of humour we know? Tim is putting his thoughts into a song that is supposed to cause a humorous response, not a debate as to why he's wrong. No sane person will listen to that song and think "Yeah he's got a point there." Mr. Minchin is a musically talented man, and he has decided to voice exaggerated versions of his personal beliefs, which is more than you can say for the likes of the mainstream artists nowadays.
@Jerrymanda101 people dont agree with things, but normally they just say "oh... i dont agree with that, so i shall move on with my life and not get involved with this" but you've just gone way to far and now your associated with this song
@SmartAssLIVE I didn't reply to your previous comment made some 11 hours ago on another channel because that particular "YouTuber" has banned me from posting on his channel. Minchin's mate Fraser Davidson has also blocked me from commenting on his channel again. It's not surprising that Minchin or at least his partner in crime and their followers want to censor their critics. I suppose the truth is hard for them to bear.
@Jerrymanda101 meh meh meh meh meh meh meh, i have a religion, but if people insult it, i just say "okay then" and move on with my life... you've taken this to far
Love the update Jerry. In a video demanding your right to post freely on my video, you have subtitles stating I should take the video down. Your ideas of free speech are so deliciously Christian.
@fraserdldavidson Decent people don't tell lies or promote lies about other people. Tim Minchin is telling lies about Pope Benedict and you're promoting them. The evidence presented against Pope Benedict has always ranged from weak down to ridiculous, and has always been easily refuted with factual documentation.
If you and Minchin wish to continue promoting demonstrable lies against Pope Benedict so be it, but in the end truth wins and history will show Minchin to be an anti-Catholic bigot.
@Jerrymanda101 Im sorry, but the 'evidence' exonerating the Pope is very weak. Your links and references were from poor sources and the weight of evidence clearly shows the pope is implicated in the shuffling of pedophiles. Instead of bitching and whining, why not make a video response stating your case and refuting the argument in popesong. At least then we would have a platform on which to discuss your points.
@fraserdldavidson I gave plenty of evidence against the lies of Tim Minchin that you seem so eager to promote. I guess that's why you deleted nearly every comment I made on your "Pope Song" video. Even the New York Times which published a deceitful article against Pope Benedict later admitted they had nothing on the Pope, yet anti-Catholic nutters continue to sight that same deceitful article in their raging against the Pope.
To date you've provided no credible proof to support Minchin's lies.
You've been unblocked. I barred your comments because you were filling up my inbox with spam comments on the Popesong thread. I turned off the email notifications so it shouldn't bother me anymore. Knock yourself out. Stay crazy, your friend Fraser xxx.
Yes Jerrymanda when you read the actual details of the abuse cases the pope supposedly covered up you realise Tim Minchin is just another loud mouthed atheist talking shit.
I also read through the comments section on Fraser Davidson's pope song video. Seriously apart from your own comments and those of a few others they seem to be made by knuckle draggers. I wonder if atheists are devolving back to their think headed primate ancestors?
Keep battling. It's tough against a rock star like TM.
@MrMrsCarpenter Comments such as yours have never seen the light of day without a serious case of misunderstanding or lack of education. You are not to be blamed. I would believe the existence of God if I had never been presented with the option of a rational decision about my beliefs.
Unfortunately, you were not privileged with the opportunity to educate yourself or to experience rationality. You were thought to believe in an almighty God and you were told there was no other option. It's sad.
@MrMrsCarpenter Thank you for your words. It is amazing to read through the comments of Minchin's Pope Song fans. So many of them do seem very stupid and ignorant. However I don't for put Tim Minchin himself in that category. He does appear to be intelligent and he was educated at a very posh school. It's Minchin's deceitfulness which is a problem. I think "eikons" in his reply to you was trying to bridge that gap between the stupidity & ignorance of a Pope Song fan to Minchin's wit, but failed.
He blocked because he wanted... end.
cesarcaio100 4 days ago
Pathetic. Fuck you motherfucker, you're no fucking better than the mother fucking rapist ^_^
sabotagethefool 1 week ago
Tim Minchin is a comedian/entertainer...
Snollygoster123 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As many people have quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
ilovecomedyhahaha 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As rhov233 quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
ilovecomedyhahaha 2 weeks ago
As rhov233 quoted, Tim is saying that if you find the swearing and the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you need to sort out your priorities.
ilovecomedyhahaha 2 weeks ago
If you listened to the song he is saying that if you find the song more offensive than the pope covering up kiddie fiddlers then you are morally misguided.
ilovecomedyhahaha 2 weeks ago
"FUCK THE POPE" by Tim Minchin is great :) good luck :) or god lack or sth
MrAndkok 1 month ago
"But if you find me more offensive than the fucking possibility
The pope protected priests when they were getting fucking fiddly
Then listen to me motherfucker, this here is a fact
You are just as morally misguided as that motherfucking
Power-hungry, self-aggrandised bigot in the stupid fucking hat"
rhov233 1 month ago
Fuck you motherfucker!
pmuaddib12 1 month ago
I think someone is kidding themselves... :D
golem1180 1 month ago
I love how this guy is whining about being banned from commenting, even while he's disabled ratings on this video.
maikeru48 1 month ago
@maikeru48 I was going to up-thumb your comment, but then I realized...
aliendragon17 1 month ago
The question is how do you know that it is lies?
Unless your one of the possible boys the pope fucked and wanted him to... But you were under age so I'm sorry it's still class as rape maybe when your older and grow some actual balls the pope won't love you anymore
MultiMonkeypoop 2 months ago
Yeah, I discovered when you post pointless self-righteous bullshit on videos people can block you, too. Funny, that.
Equihan 2 months ago
Catholics really don't have a sense of humour...
CadentialSixFour 2 months ago
@CadentialSixFour That's the best comment on here!!!
brainsparkles 1 month ago
DID THE POPE TELL YOU TO SAY THIS LIE!!!
GrumpierCallumM1 2 months ago
sad
GrumpierCallumM1 2 months ago
lol@ catholics
uknowispeaksense 2 months ago
Tim Minchin's "lie filled, hate-mongering" anti-Pope song has more fucking honesty in it than the entire Catholic church. Fuck the Pope. Fuck kiddie fiddling Priests. Fuck the tunnel vision of the gullable idiots who defend the rapists and most importantly FUCK YOU! When you die, you'll just be dead. There will be no judgement. No paradise. No fuck all. Make your peace with it and move on. Fucker.
Sporky86 2 months ago
SIGH. Tim said it himself- "If you find the possibility that some priests had sexual relations with children less offensive than me (Tim) swearing at a man, you have something seriously wrong with you."
Now stop preaching, nobody's listening.
There's nothing I hate more than a religious person who tries to force me to see things their way.
And by the way, before you say it-
Tim Minchin is not forcing us to see things this way with his so called "lies".
IT'S CALLED COMEDY.
Lieetheawsomelion 2 months ago
@Lieetheawsomelion You're cool. Couldn't have said it better myself. I LOVE TIM MINCHIN!!!!!!
brainsparkles 1 month ago
And are you SERIOUS about the blog thing :D
Are you really saying I should read like an HOUR WORTH OF ARTICLES just to realize this particular 2 minute comedy song about "the pope" is full of fiction?
REALLY? :D
Ahahha. Sorry, but that's not going to happen.
I'll just take your word on it and consider Tim Minchin as ENTERTAINMENT.
You should try that too.
sarkasmi83 2 months ago
Oh wow *chuckles*
Some people just don't understand comedy. Did Tim ever mention the name "Benedict"? In the song?
The song is about christianity and the weird occurance that alot of priests have had sexual relations with little boys and got in to trouble. The pope may or may not helped these priests. Bottomline; If he would; he'd be as bad as them.
So the song is nothing but a little critisism on the subject in a fictional comedy form.
sarkasmi83 2 months ago
jerryassholemanda i agree with enraged seph below: this video was a huge fucking waving cock of a waste of time. maybe if you had a bigger cock you would be waving it in some girl's face and stop wasting people's time
s0meb0dyst0pme 2 months ago
if you find him more offensive than the fucking possibility
The pope protected priests when they were getting fucking fiddly
Then listen to me motherfucker, this here is a fact
You are just as morally misguided as that motherfucking
Power-hungry, self-aggrandised bigot in the stupid fucking hat
HarveyPseudonymus 2 months ago
This video was a huge fucking waving penis of a waste of time.
EnragedSephiroth 2 months ago
Or maybe you should stop being such a brainwashed little baby! If you are offended by this song you should worry more about your delicate sensitivity regarding the lampooning of ridiculous traditions. Grow up you ignorant petty little boy...
connorseidel 3 months ago
this seems like almost as much of a waste of time as the catholic church. Oh, I went there!
emerodriscollpaton 3 months ago
I watched that vid you posted, and I find it funny that you would think that standing on a street corner with a sign saying fuck the pope is totally comparable to singing it in a COMEDY SONG.
Maybe you were too busy being outraged but there is actually a little disclaimer on the end of that song. I guess you are doing exactly what he said people like you should do, but incidently do you then find this song more offensive than the thought that the pope was actually covering for child molesters?
MrBanden 3 months ago
I wonder if...If I wrote a comment to him or letter or just a reply...And blocked him...Would he make a video about it...O.o
Narutoisawesum 3 months ago
What lies did he tell?
JustAnotherHumanist 3 months ago
@JustAnotherHumanist None
Narutoisawesum 3 months ago
Why can't I thumbs up any of the comments?
27philby 3 months ago
@27philby 'ecause he's doing the same thing that the guy who put the song up did
Narutoisawesum 3 months ago
So does this mean that this person is as morally misguided as the self-aggrandized bigot in the stupid fucking hat? I think so.
TheCraich 3 months ago
I love how YouTube has put Tim Minchin's Pope Song as the number 1 suggestion. Just thought I'd mention it as a respite from the mud-slinging contest between the learned persons who have done research into the facts... and Jerrymanda
TheBahamunt 3 months ago
so that's your opinion.... Why did you make a video about it? confused.
BeautifulLyrics01 3 months ago
Jerrymanda101... shut up.
Doomsdayjeezuz88 3 months ago
I could go down and like just about every comment of this video. Seems Tim has a bigger fan base then the pope mate...
oxminiminchinxo 3 months ago
Hmmmm...I wonder...If he feels that strongly about that...Time to introduce him to some black metal :D
Narutoisawesum 3 months ago
@Narutoisawesum Rape Of The Bastard Nazerene would be my personal choice. Or Raped By The Light Of Christ.
Powell101 3 months ago
It saddens me to know that there are still people in this world who are so blind as to ignore the facts of reality and cry foul at those who point out uncomfortable truths about the world and those people who they believe in. Regardless of your personal beliefs, if you are that incapable of accepting that other people have differing opinions than yours that you need to make 2 different videos about one particular instance that 'offends you', you should seriously seek therapy.
Or maybe a way out.
WarchiefOneTin 3 months ago
@Jerrymanda101
You are sick dude, just fucking sick.
dipstickewew 3 months ago
Tim Minchin fights for the truth. Religion fights against the truth and common sense and logical thinking. That is the point.
pickaflower 3 months ago
You're a wanker for leaving this video up now that you've been un-banned... which any YouTube account holder is well within their rights to do... *smh*
TheresaTV1 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Listen to me motherfucker, this here is a fact:
you are just as morally misguided as that mother fucking power hungry self aggrandized bigot in the stupid fucking hat.
PrincepsNemesis 3 months ago
Listen to me motherfucker, this here is a fact:
you are just as morally misguided as that mother fucking power hungry self aggrandized bigot in the stupid fucking hat.
jacklawlz 3 months ago
@jerrymanda101, in regards to your comment reply to amberdextrix, the fact that there are abusive priests in the first place is completely absurd and disgusting. nothing can justify their actions.
taylahsaysawesome 3 months ago
Ratings dissabled - not overly shocking. Just another case of a brainwashed shmuck desperately defending the sad and out of date myths .... Dissabling ratings for a video with this particular message is just pathetic. Clearly they were not satisfactory therefore highly negative ...
eluvss 3 months ago
"Ratings have been disabled for this video."
That sound you hear Jerrymanda, is the shattering of every pane in your glass house.
Stop throwing stones and instead turn the other cheek like a good christian.
Epicurus341 3 months ago
try the facebook page on OccupyTheVatican
it's unbelievable the stupidity of some people, you should read more before calling ppl liars, listen to Dan Bull - An Open Letter to Benny (The Pope). to quote Tim "But if you find me more offensive than the F possibility
The pope protected priests when they were getting F fiddly
Then listen to me motherF - this here is a fact,
You are just as morally misguided as that motherF,
Power-hungry, self-aggrandized bigot in the stupid F hat
ssuami 3 months ago
Tim Minchins statements are far from lies.
MorvSaysHi 3 months ago
lol. bumface.
DedeInChains 3 months ago
YOU'RE A COMPLETE DICK! Everyone is open to there opinion so don't go calling his "evil" when they are based on pure fact, you can be a catholic, whatever, I don't care, but the fact that your pope covered up for paedophiles all over the world should not be shoved under the blanket, if you had any belief in this supposed "Omnibenevolent God" you would feel some sort of moral obligation to letting this guy carry on representing your religion, but not you're just an ignorant, self-righteous idiot!
mistyrose1995 3 months ago
vatican is a shit hole and the whole religious world is full of hypocrites
stephenrodgers1000 3 months ago
"Ratings have been disabled for this video"
I wonder why? Probably because you're tags say "Tim Minchin Pope Song", where they should be "Winging About Minchin".
Also, while it is unfortunate for you that the critic was banned, it was probably because he was being unnecessarily rude whilst voicing his own opinion, just as many are in the comments on this video. There's no need for either side to be so immature about it.
SamJohn95 3 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 Tim is a comedian. Get over yourself.
ethanL337 3 months ago
Fuck all of you catholic dickheads, get a clue
b0omp3z 3 months ago
@b0omp3z I agree, fucktards should get a clue... The reason that religion still exists is because some people are just to dumb to understand basic science :) having blind faith in a bearded man with a serious god-complex, whom's stories are told to the next 10 or so generations, and finally written down by the 11th (or so).. and it's nearly impossible for so much information to land in the lap of one writer at that time. So clearly he made up a lot of it!
6SIX6Bloodshedded 3 months ago
wow its a little odd that there aint no thumbs up or thumbs downs allowed in this video... maybe a massive RED bar could have caused it
senneuh1 3 months ago
@senneuh1 Yeah, I had noticed that too..it's the same with his other vids..quite convenient you say ?
nonutsnorris 3 months ago
If I was Fraser I wouldn't have lifted it..But then again, he is a nicer person than you..
nonutsnorris 3 months ago
Maybe you should give substantiating evidence rather than going "YOU'RE LYING AND THIS IS DECEITFUL." This is not a critique as you claim it is, this is an unbased claim. Your opinion's relevance in your being blocked is improvable and improbable. You could have been banned for simply spamming the above message past Davidson's patience. Lastly, a blog is not evidence/proof. A blog is open to bias, incorrectivity and all-around flashy bollucks.
If you've got any more "points," I'm more than open.
BECAUSECAPSLOCK 3 months ago
How clever of you to disable ratings on your video. I guess your foresaw that your video ratings would go down faster than a Catholic priest on a 13-year old choir boy.
xaratherus 3 months ago
@xaratherus i fell over laughing when i read this comment! I love you
42Kilgore42 3 months ago
@xaratherus
HAHA <3 Best
b0omp3z 3 months ago
I would block your ass
LtMusicDude 4 months ago
there are no lies, its all ifs... idiot, read the motherfucking text to th motherfucking song :P
WarriorOfTheEmperor 4 months ago
lol Jerry is a pedofile
skogsman7 4 months ago
I like the way you don't allow comments
is that because you don't want to know just how unpopuar you and your pedo enabling pope are?
Atheist88mphPirate 4 months ago
"I only read one book but its a good book don't ya know"
crazyspazzer 4 months ago
also, dear Jerry, the song isn't about the pope. if you listen, its actually about how you're a complete fucknut if you defend child rapists by not doing anything. hence the lyrics 'it doesn't matter if your plumber or a prince" you're a fucker too for defending the rapists
silly jerry. listen to timmy
shadowstone13 4 months ago
Disabled ratings...Hypocrisy 10 - Credibitily 0
ginganz13 4 months ago
I cbf to find the comment on the actual video, so here: there's this thing. It's called a hierarchy. Priests are under the control of the bishop, then the arch bishop, then the cardinal, then the pope. The Cardinal who arranged the distribution of priests under JPII was Ratzinger. JPII put the stamp of approval on them, and the local bishops put that into action. SO Ratzinger is just as guilty as the kiddy fiddling priests. Learn to Catholic.
randomquotage 4 months ago
The funny thing is that Tim clearly says in his song that if it offended you, write him a letter
altoidyboy 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i bet you also believe George W Bush...
iluvyesung 4 months ago
Oh, just shut up.
mgbn 4 months ago
*gasp* Jerrymanda101 _ has banned _ everyone _ from rating _ your idiotic complaint video.
Jerry, I'm sure you'd agree with me that Tim Minchin's fans need to express our annoyance regarding your video.
... you hypocritical prick
shadowstone13 4 months ago
A lot of people (both Christian and atheist) rely on media soundbites and use them to justify their own entrenched positions.
Would it surprise you to know, for example, that homophobia is explicitly contrary to Catholic teaching and the use of artificial contraception actively promoted in certain circumstances by the Pope himself?!
If there's one thing this thread teaches us, it's not to rely on sound-bites (or songs!) for the facts.
humbug2468 4 months ago
While I distrust priests, I remain a committed Catholic. We shouldn't be surprised when people in the Church let us down - the Bible is full of them committing murder (Paul), adultery (David) and deceit (Peter). As Catholics, we must think for ourselves and challenge those in authority when they're wrong.
(continued...)
humbug2468 4 months ago
ENABLE RATINGS THEN you f*cking hypocrite.
Jaybeat2k6 4 months ago
Father Oliver O'Grady, a Catholic priest who was relocated to various parishes around the United States during the 1970s in an attempt by the Catholic Church and the pope to cover up his rape of dozens of children......ENOUGH SAID!
matyboy58 4 months ago
@14Innes If you had bothered to go to the God Botherers website via the link in the Video Description you would have seen the case discussed there. Go to the God Botherers website via the link provided and scroll down to Item 2 - The Case of Fr Stephen Kiesle. The facts of that case continue to point to Tim Minchin being a lying hate-monger.
Jerrymanda101 4 months ago
@14Innes While Tim Minchin's Pope Song collaborator and friend Fraser Davidson did "unblock" me from his comments sections, he then at the same time removed any comments I posted in his comments section. The upshot is, Tim Minchin's Pope Song collaborator continued to censor my comments on the "official" YouTube Pope Song video site even after "unblocking" me. If I have the time I might add that information to the video clip.
Jerrymanda101 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Just because you liked it when he bummed you
Anevilglare 5 months ago
Amnesty International's latest annual human rights report, which cited the Holy See for the first time, concluded there was widespread evidence of child sexual abuse by members of the clergy over past decades, and an "enduring failure" of the Catholic church to seek redress.
In the headlines, as of Sept 13: Pope accused of crimes against humanity by victims of sex abuse. Victims' complaint to the international criminal court accuses Pope Benedict and three others of failing to prevent abusers
Amberdextrix 5 months ago
Amnesty International's latest annual human rights report, which cited the Holy See for the first time, concluded there was widespread evidence of child sexual abuse by members of the clergy over past decades, and an "enduring failure" of the Catholic church to seek redress.
In the headlines, as of Sept 13th: Pope accused of crimes against humanity by victims of sex abuse. Victims' complaint to the international criminal court accuses Pope Benedict and three others of failing to prevent abusers
Amberdextrix 5 months ago
You are scum. Have a nice day, scum.
brad0544 5 months ago
Comment removed
Shmiddy76 5 months ago
I see you've disabled ratings, wonder why. I dunno if you thought anyone would take you seriously, but hey, you got the trolling you deserve. I'd like to say, that if you place all your faith in your god, in a man instead, that is a heresy as your giving your worship to an idol. I think that if a god does exist, and this polar universe provides an evil as it's opposite, that opposites office is the Vatican. They took all your love for the meek and turned you on them.
Cylixx3 6 months ago
He's as bad as the paedophiles themselves as he has hidden it from the public. Fuck the mother fucker
dyerskyle 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck you mother fucker
zZCrAyoNz 6 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 : You're clearly just jealous of Tim's awesomeness <3! Just 'cause you're puny and pathetic. Tell you what you need? Alcohol. It's good for the soul, so much better than the pope, who btw did cover up sex scandals everyone knows so you die hard loyalists may aswell give up haha. But seriously, a litre of vodka is well needed.
BabyObrienX 6 months ago
Even if you Pope apologists (or Papologists, how witty) did manage to prove that he had no part in covering up the sex abuse scandals, it wouldn't change my mind that he's a bad person. His homophobia encourages abuse of innocent people by millions of his followers, and his outdated, unscientific, inconsistent and self-contradictory views on contraception contribute to the AIDs epidemic that is ruining Africa. And through all of this he claims to have moral authority. Bastard.
andymci2 6 months ago
@andymci2 *thumbs up!*
dubdidub13 5 months ago
"A child protection official for the Catholic Church has been caught with 4,000 pictures of child porn... Married Jarvis, 49, a former social worker, was employed by the church following sex scandals about pervert priests. His job was to monitor church groups to ensure pedophiles did not gain access to children in the church’s congregations." Oops! Looks like they didn't have enough time to shift Jarvis around in location and/or back to the Vatican to avoid his detainment and prosecution.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix I’m not sure how you’ve concluded that Pope Benedict is somehow involved or how this case supports Tim Minchin’s theme that Pope Benedict has been covering up sex abuse.
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In an article on the Examiner.com it has been revealed that the Pope and two other officials have been served papers in a child abuse case in Wisconsin alleging that the Pope and his co-defendants conspired to protect a child abuser and keep the allegations of child abuse quiet.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix Let me guess was it by Jeff Anderson, the serial server of papers on the Vatican?
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
It claims Pope Benedict XVI and two other top Vatican officials knew about allegations of sexual abuse at St. John's school for the Deaf outside of Milwaukee and called off internal punishment of the accused Rev. Lawrence Murphy. Murphy died in 1998 but there have been several attempts throughout the years to serve the Vatican to no avail.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix The case of Fr Murphy is discussed in detail at the God Botherers website given in the video. There's nothing to suggest the Vatican did anything wrong in that case. Breifly, the Vatican was informed of the case some 20 years after the last known abuse by Fr Murphy, who had long before been reported to police. The Vatican approved of a Church trial against Fr Murphy. Murphy appealed against a trial on the grounds of ill health and died 2 days after his trial was halted.
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
Even though Reverend Lawrence C. Murphy has since died, the case continues because of the allegation that the Vatican attempted to systematically cover-up the case. It could even be said that they have obstructed justice and put other children is harms way. If this case is allowed to proceed, it will open up the door for similar cases throughout the world. Earlier this year, a Philadelphia Grand Jury revealed a similar sexual molestation scandal involving 37 priests of the Catholic Church.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix How could the Vatican be obstructing justice or covering up anything in this case when;
1. They only found out about the case 20 years after the last known abuse by Fr Murphy.
2. They started a Church trial against Fr Murphy - something the secular courts couldn't do because the secular statute of limitations had cut in.
But hey, lawyer come media tart, Jeff Anderson got some more free publicity, which is no doubt what he wanted.
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
In the past, the Pope and Vatican officials were immune from such lawsuits under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976. However, in June of last year the Supreme Court declined to hear a Vatican appeal to a Ninth Circuit ruling that the Vatican can be held accountable for priest’s actions under the “tort exceptions” clause of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 under certain conditions.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix However, as the judges repeatedly said, granting a hearing doesn't mean the case has any merit.
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
@Jerrymanda101
Oh my god, have a whinge! You’re like a sooky 10 year old who didn’t get invited to the cool kid’s birthday party. If you yourself believe this stuff isn’t true, isn’t that enough? Why so much hatred toward those that like or, god forbid, AGREE with this song? I have no problem with people believing what they want. I have a problem with people trying to make ME believe what THEY want. And this is a classic example. Let it go mate
fruit103 6 months ago
@fruit103 So you're okay with the likes of Tim Minchin and Fraser Davidson promoting lies to advance their hate-mongering? Why do you like Tim Minchin's Pope Song?
Jerrymanda101 5 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 I like this song because he is making a fantastic point. A lot of people will see this song as just a silly, rude song with unnecessary swearing in it but the swearing is important to illustrate his point:
That is it ironic for people (like you) to be offended by such language yet to not be offended by the pope's protection of molesting preists.
You are obsessed with needing everyone to agree with you. Not everyone believes in the same things mate, no one ever will. Let it go.
fruit103 5 months ago
In that case, Oregon man anonymously named John V. Doe alleged that Catholic Priest, Father Andrew Ronan sexually abused him on multiple occasions when he was a teenager in the 1960s. Like many similar cases, Father Ronan was alleged to have been engaged in sexual abuse with children in Ireland and in Chicago. Both times, the Vatican relocated him until he ended up in Oregon.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix But once again what does all this have to do with Pope Benedict and Tim Minchin's theme of Benedict covering up sex abuse? At the time of the Fr Ronan's abuse, that happened in the US and Ireland, Benedict was an Archbishop in Germany. Can you see how you're not putting up a coherent argument?
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 your just a fatass you 31 year old retard dummy head.
fuckinemos1 5 months ago
While Father Ronan died in 1992, the plaintiffs in the case alleged that he was an employee of the Vatican and was engaged as an employee when he was sexually molesting children. The Vatican created the conditions in which sexual abuse could occur and as such the Vatican can be held accountable for the priest’s actions under the “tort exceptions” clause of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976.
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
@Amberdextrix That may well be your opinion, but the facts show otherwise. Priests are under the control of their local bishop, not the Vatican. And it was the responsibility of local bishops to deal with abusive priests. In some cases local bishops were suppose to inform the Vatican of abusive priests, but it seems until the last 10 years or so they rarely did.
Jerrymanda101 6 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 Surely, if father Ronan was directly employed by the Vatican & not his local bishop, then he was answerable to the Vatican & not his local bishop. The fact that Amberdextrix is quoting acts of law implies they might have a snifter of an idea what they're talking about. Sorry, but I think you got banned for a reason, which appears to be you lack of. You need to get over the fact that there are people in this world who simply do not agree with you with regrads to this issue.
lexyellis 4 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 - Like Tim says - if you think its OK to hide behind hierarchy you're as bad as the rapist.
ginganz13 4 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 Let's talk about facts shall we? Science is fact, Religion is believing.
Science is the understanding of how things work fed by FACTS. Religion includes no -none at all- facts!
Clearly something went wrong, as it seems to be a widely-known issue around the world "priests abusing kids". And yes, 2000 years ago, it was the norm of the master to learn sex to his kid. later it was the norm to have sex with men. now the church doesn't have any clues about anything anymore it seems :P
6SIX6Bloodshedded 3 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 dailymotion.c om/video/xbvr0m_the-intelligence-debate-stephen-fr_shortfilms?ralg=behavior-meta2
I think you would benefit from listening to this man speak.
hwtpants 3 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 they're supposed to inform the police not the vatican
ukcroupier 3 months ago
Calm down children, don't you think that maybe we should be allowed to express opinion? Condemning him for condemning others is hypocrisy ,although I suppose you catholics are already familiar with that one. The other problem is that there HAVE been countless cases of child molestation in the Catholic Chruch, and the Church always denies all allegations. The Pope is at the top of the Church, therefore it is his job to keep an eye on what it is doing. It is his fault that he is not doing his job.
SuperSmashyfication 6 months ago
It's not 'hatemongering' when it's true. Way to parrot the Vatican's 'they're just trying to bring the Pope down!' party line though, you tool. I suppose he also lied about his recruitment into the Hitler Youth and service in the Nazi military because he was just trying to test all of your faith too, right?
Amberdextrix 6 months ago
all of this hate over some ones imaginary friend hay jerrymanda fuck you mother fucker
LOLWARZ 6 months ago
Oh how I love religious nut jobs. =D
Amazed you haven't joined the Westboro Baptist Church by now. They're full of opinions...
But hey... That's just my opinion... =)
QuirkyGirl12345 6 months ago
tim minchin is a fucking hero... and the catholic church should be disbanded for spreading hate and lies and hording money for themselves!!
darthesgoobis123 6 months ago
The pope is a nazi scumbag and you're a fucked up clown. Trololoolol
Whatthefudgeablu 6 months ago
"Ratings have been disabled for this video." Well, i guess if you're a Catholic you are already so used to hypocrisy that you are unaware that you're doing it.
The case is way broader than just the 3 priests on your God bothering website. The Catholic Church has a long history of committing and covering up paedophilia. The Pope is its final earthly authority, and if he does not condemn outright all criminal acts carried out by any in his church...
Then fuck you, motherfucker...
ZarquonFillibuster 6 months ago
Isn't it sad when you aren't allowed to express your opinion... even though it doesn't involve swearing, just lies??
SkyCreeper1 7 months ago
@SkyCreeper1 Fraser Davidson, who provided Tim Minchin with the animation for his Pope Song, has reinstated his ban on me. That's okay I can live with that, but it does reflect poorly on Tim Minchin when his main collaborator for "Pope Song" is prepared to censor those who are critical of Tim Minchin's hate-mongering. I've provided much evidence to show that Pope Benedict's critics are either ill-informed or liars.
thegodbotherers.blogspot.com/p/defending-pope-benedict_04.html
Jerrymanda101 7 months ago
mimimmimimmmimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiiiiiii
DerVagabundli 7 months ago
man I'd sure like to put a thumbs up or a thumbs down on this video.... oh hmm it seems like that ability has been banned for people commenting on this video.
oh irony
tglass55 7 months ago
@tglass55 Errr irony, I don't think so. You're free to state your opinion on any of my videos. Tim Minchin's mate of course doesn't won't anyone providing evidence showing up his hate-mongering. In case you missed that evidence here it is again:
thegodbotherers.blogspot.com/p/defending-pope-benedict_04.html
Jerrymanda101 7 months ago
your a total mother fucker
Jjsuperstar54321 7 months ago
Lies, ey? Kind of like in the bible...
I don't believe tim lied. One of the pages on your link was "what the New York Times didn't tell you" or something, so he might have been under the same impression that everyone else was because of what the media told us. Don't hate the player, hate the game
bojemann94 7 months ago
Oh get over it, it's just a song! and lots of people like it - if you dont then just dont watch it! simple
mariejs123 7 months ago
@mariejs123 No Marie it's not just a song - it's lie filled hate-mongering, and hate-mongering should not be tolerated or left unanswered.
Jerrymanda101 7 months ago
the fact you actually made a video to say that you got banned makes you seem like an angry child whose points shouldn't be considered at all
PickleRadio 8 months ago
@PickleRadio I'm sorry, I don't follow your reasoning at all. But I do know that Tim Minchin does believe in free speech, so I thought it ironic that Tim Minchin's friend and "partner in crime" Fraser Davidson would ban me from commenting on YouTube's main "Pope Song" video.
Jerrymanda101 7 months ago
Glad you explained how Tim lied
MeFoRResToW 8 months ago
Glad you explained how Tim was lying
MeFoRResToW 8 months ago
Comment removed
elikay65 8 months ago
@elikay65 Only if he stopped me from using facts to counter his lies!
Jerrymanda101 8 months ago
ffs, why is it that people in this world cannot understand the most simplest level of humour we know? Tim is putting his thoughts into a song that is supposed to cause a humorous response, not a debate as to why he's wrong. No sane person will listen to that song and think "Yeah he's got a point there." Mr. Minchin is a musically talented man, and he has decided to voice exaggerated versions of his personal beliefs, which is more than you can say for the likes of the mainstream artists nowadays.
animatedjim 9 months ago
@animatedjim I can at least agree on one point you make:
"No sane person will listen to that song and think 'Yeah he's got a point there.' "
But there's plenty of crazies out there who will use Tim Minchin's hate-mongering to comfirm themselves in their anti-Pope bigotry.
Jerrymanda101 9 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 people dont agree with things, but normally they just say "oh... i dont agree with that, so i shall move on with my life and not get involved with this" but you've just gone way to far and now your associated with this song
SmartAssLIVE 7 months ago
@SmartAssLIVE I didn't reply to your previous comment made some 11 hours ago on another channel because that particular "YouTuber" has banned me from posting on his channel. Minchin's mate Fraser Davidson has also blocked me from commenting on his channel again. It's not surprising that Minchin or at least his partner in crime and their followers want to censor their critics. I suppose the truth is hard for them to bear.
thegodbotherers.blogspot.com/p/defending-pope-benedict_04.html
Jerrymanda101 7 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 meh meh meh meh meh meh meh, i have a religion, but if people insult it, i just say "okay then" and move on with my life... you've taken this to far
SmartAssLIVE 7 months ago
Love the update Jerry. In a video demanding your right to post freely on my video, you have subtitles stating I should take the video down. Your ideas of free speech are so deliciously Christian.
fraserdldavidson 10 months ago
@fraserdldavidson Decent people don't tell lies or promote lies about other people. Tim Minchin is telling lies about Pope Benedict and you're promoting them. The evidence presented against Pope Benedict has always ranged from weak down to ridiculous, and has always been easily refuted with factual documentation.
If you and Minchin wish to continue promoting demonstrable lies against Pope Benedict so be it, but in the end truth wins and history will show Minchin to be an anti-Catholic bigot.
Jerrymanda101 10 months ago
@Jerrymanda101 Im sorry, but the 'evidence' exonerating the Pope is very weak. Your links and references were from poor sources and the weight of evidence clearly shows the pope is implicated in the shuffling of pedophiles. Instead of bitching and whining, why not make a video response stating your case and refuting the argument in popesong. At least then we would have a platform on which to discuss your points.
fraserdldavidson 10 months ago
@fraserdldavidson I gave plenty of evidence against the lies of Tim Minchin that you seem so eager to promote. I guess that's why you deleted nearly every comment I made on your "Pope Song" video. Even the New York Times which published a deceitful article against Pope Benedict later admitted they had nothing on the Pope, yet anti-Catholic nutters continue to sight that same deceitful article in their raging against the Pope.
To date you've provided no credible proof to support Minchin's lies.
Jerrymanda101 10 months ago
@fraserdldavidson i like you for promoting THE TRUTH
SmartAssLIVE 7 months ago
@fraserdldavidson You are correct, delciously Catholic=ridiculously hypocritical!
hollyandfreddie 9 months ago
You've been unblocked. I barred your comments because you were filling up my inbox with spam comments on the Popesong thread. I turned off the email notifications so it shouldn't bother me anymore. Knock yourself out. Stay crazy, your friend Fraser xxx.
fraserdldavidson 10 months ago
lol owned.
TehKidCharisma 10 months ago
@TehKidCharisma Okay I'm not as "street" as you. I understand "lol", but what does the "owned" mean? I'm guessing it's not a complement.
Jerrymanda101 10 months ago
Yes Jerrymanda when you read the actual details of the abuse cases the pope supposedly covered up you realise Tim Minchin is just another loud mouthed atheist talking shit.
I also read through the comments section on Fraser Davidson's pope song video. Seriously apart from your own comments and those of a few others they seem to be made by knuckle draggers. I wonder if atheists are devolving back to their think headed primate ancestors?
Keep battling. It's tough against a rock star like TM.
MrMrsCarpenter 10 months ago
@MrMrsCarpenter Comments such as yours have never seen the light of day without a serious case of misunderstanding or lack of education. You are not to be blamed. I would believe the existence of God if I had never been presented with the option of a rational decision about my beliefs.
Unfortunately, you were not privileged with the opportunity to educate yourself or to experience rationality. You were thought to believe in an almighty God and you were told there was no other option. It's sad.
eikons 10 months ago
@MrMrsCarpenter Thank you for your words. It is amazing to read through the comments of Minchin's Pope Song fans. So many of them do seem very stupid and ignorant. However I don't for put Tim Minchin himself in that category. He does appear to be intelligent and he was educated at a very posh school. It's Minchin's deceitfulness which is a problem. I think "eikons" in his reply to you was trying to bridge that gap between the stupidity & ignorance of a Pope Song fan to Minchin's wit, but failed.
Jerrymanda101 10 months ago