Added: 2 months ago
From: TheXFactorUSA
Views: 386,102
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,014)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Essa cara é sensacional. A Rihanna não chega nem perto disso.

  • one word: DAMN !

  • Really like this version

  • Josh Krajcik is one of those people who can sing anything and make me love it. We need more talent like him to become famous and I know its out there. If any talented people are reading this you should take your talent to the MakeAStar website. Post a video of yourself singing! Its easy and if enough people vote for your vid you win money!

  • LA REED IS A DUMBASS!!! he know nothing about a REAL SINGER!!! .........

  • What are they waiting on to get this Man's CD on the Market!!!!!! I would include this Song and Love in a Hopeless Place!! With his Soulful voice , the org artists on both songs do not come close to what he does with them!!!!

  • the ORG does not come close to this Man !!!!!

  • If I'm being honest,I love this more than the original!

  • Le dio un sentido a una cancion que no seria para el

  • He takes this song to a new place!!!!!!!!! Sound is amazeing, it goes around in my head all day after I listen to this 

  • Rihanna was brave singing this tonight after Josh nailed it. His is just so much better! I really like the song now.

  • i have nothing about blacks but L.A. Reid said yes to the black girl and the other black man but when Josh the white man comes and sings his ASS off better than anyone L,A Reid said no

  • @gorillakid3 couldnt have said it any better man. la reid is a racist fvck..and i hope he sees this that d!ck wad...

  • i dont think melanie should have won, there was so many better singers.......i just dont understand.....

  • @antaressuper1966 melanie appeals to all the little girls with cell phones. it's the parents fault for letting these little girls get unlimited texting. fuck em

  • @bdahits unlimited texting has nothing to do with voting i believe voting costs im sure what the price is but it costs every vote..

  • if i would own a recording label i would instantly give him a contract

  • I love Josh's version! What are those judges talking about when they diss this? He was going with the theme! Love that Krajcik Magic!

  • Simon wanted his girl to be the best, that is why the comments. Josh did really well on this song, but I think he did good on all his songs. Simon had to throw him under the bus many times, to help Melanie win. GOD I LOVE HIS PERFORMANCES!

  • i thought his voice strangely worked!!!!! it was really good!

  • THIS IS EXCELLENT! Every time I am reminded of this song, his version is the one that takes me there! It's a beautiful rendition! I wish he makes a version of this with just an acoustic guitar , drums, and vocals. It to me, exceeds Rihanna's version! Although I love Ri RI..THIS IS DOPE! LOL

  • better than original for me

  • How did the judges not like this????

  • I like rihanna´s version better

  • I thought this was his best vocal and I hope this is the kinda music he makes. LA needs to go. He single handedly ruined Marcus's chances. Yes the production was retarded but the vocal was great! I never wanna hear Rihanna's version again!

  • i think his voice is great, just not his song...

  • I can't stop listening to it!! It's just an amazing combination of a great song and a beautiful voice!!

    

  • I think he did amazing with what he had. I would listen to this song sung by him forever. He's not a pop star but he didn't choice the genre. He's just incredible. I cant wait to hear his album.

  • Song sounded sick as fuck with josh.

  • Are you kidding me!!! Thats how a guy can make a decent song sound epic. First time that this song actually sounds good...

  • Comment removed

  • I like this version better.

  • They are crazy, he made it his!!!!!!!!! I did not know who Rihanna was (generation gap) I went on YouTube and found her , this is totaly another song from her's. He did a wonderful job, he made it his!!!!!!!!!! How was it not appropriate, it was a dance song, was that not the theme.

  • This version is awesome go Josh, I believe in music!!!!!

  • Josh Krajicik singing Rihanna is like Michael Bolton singing LMFAO.

  • Comment removed

  • I'm surprised this song does not have more views. The more I listen to it the more I love it. Every song Josh sings becomes the original as far as I'm concerned. When he sings a song it is sung. There can be no cover because no one can match his passion and unique style.

  • @peaceandcharity Thank you for saying that!!! I feel the same as you, same as Pretender, etc. he is truly one of a kind!!!

  • @peaceandcharity PS. I think part of it is there are so many other videos posted of the same songs, not by XFactor, if you add them all together numbers are much larger.

  • @peaceandcharity Such a true comment... 100% agree.

  • I think Josh is more a kind of serious, and rock artist so I dont think he was that comfortable singing this dancey song, but he has a terrific voice so WHO CARES?? =)

  • i like it.. nice  nice nice...

  • simon cowell fuck off!

  • I though Josh was really good and he did a beautiful job singing this song that have a strog femmale voice and this one is full of tricks!! He was the best and the only one that sang rock in the rock n roll night, and a little note for L.A. Ried: being on the Rock n Roll hall of fame don't make you a rock singer/band (like ABBA)!!!

  • josh >> you are bigger than X factor !!

  • I'd way rather listen to this version.

  • amazing voice..... good goood goooooood version....even better than the original...

  • This just proves that Josh could sing the phonebook and make me a believer!

  • way better than rihanna

  • Love the way he sings this song!!!! He is trully awesome!!!!!!! Can not waite to buy his CD's!!!!

  • This was a phenomenal peformance!

  • if you can't feel this then you're missing out on life.

  • ilovethisyou...*-* .

  • I like this song, And I like Rihanna singing it and since Josh´s version is so different I love it as much! Well done both artists!!! But I don´t think this will be the music he will make later on... but whatever he will make I will buy his CD!!!

  • I had never heard this song before Josh k sang it. Now I do heard it by some girl singer. But Josh k did the song a million time better.

  • Rocked it, i like this version better!

  • @MrLuzi1987 he did sing it check out Josh Krajcik Top 11.

  • when is he going to sing joe cocker - with little help from my friends ?? suites hes voice perfectly!

  • @MrLuzi1987 he did.

  • I Love him, he can sing the alphabet and making it amazing. Please come out with a CD already :)

  • amazing performance :) best club song :)

  • i had never heard this song before, and i loved how he sounded.

  • Please make a CD fast.

  • josh did the best he could. I will not want to see Josh go pop. I hope he goes bluesy rock or RB.

  • He is so awesome, he can sing anything, not like some others stuck in a rut.

  • This was epic. It did show how versatile he could be. This is the first time I heard this song and I loved it. It sounded like coldplay. After I found it was Rihanna's song. I listened to her version and thought it was just ok. Josh's rendition gave me chills. Wish he could record it professional and release as a single. I bet it would be # 1 in no time.

  • @bettergetdave I agree!! it would be #1 over night!!! even older ppl like myself would buy it in a Heart Beat!!!!!!

  • im going to have to agree with simon and la on this one. josh is amazing, he really is. this was a decent performance, but not his best and in my opinion, not his style

  • love this song but cant listen to the orignal only joshs

  • josh you are amazing you are a man i love u.

  • he snapped on this song. he made me actually like this song with his rendition

  • This version is so awesome! Josh's rendition could be the number 1 hit instead of Rihanna's

  • i love IT!!!!!!!!!

  • Am I the only one who notices Steven Retchless, the pole dancer from America's Got Talent at 1:15?

    

  • L.A. Reid is just jealous because Josh sang this better than Rihanna

  • @geri10messi La reid knows nothing about dance music so its understandable that he was confused i dont blame him...

  • @geri10messi  without a DOUBT !!!!

  • what's the title of the song?

  • @erikoyable Rihanna - We Found Love..

  • I truely hope the music industry was not so stupid as to let this guy go back home with no contract he is awesome and really really hope to see a cd out soon!!!

    I know mel had a great voice but to be honest been there dont that and would not buy her stuff not my thing i would however buy anything josh does hes awesome

  • We love you all the way from Canada Josh!!!!

  • Wow!

  • Comment removed

  • we know now that x factor was fixed. It is Simon's show so only his little no talent @@@@@ could win. They knew that people where only watching to see Josh k. So they kept him to keep the viwers. Then at the end Josh k was the winner but it is Simon's show so they had to give it to Simon's pet. We will never watch x factor again. WHY? because only Simon's pets can win. We love Josh k and we will buy only his CDs.

  • @507dannyfe are u from america or something then cos he took it over there to see if it would work we have had it here in the uk for 8 years and out of those years simons act has won once

  • music sounds like VIVA LA VIDA :)

  • @woolka7 which sounds like joe satriani's if i could fly.

  • I actually got a little depressed when the show ended, to think that I won't hear Josh Krajcik's music again, I found some of his other non X Factor related performaces on youtube. I'm waiting for your album Josh, I will always support your career

  • the best version ever, greetings from slowakia

  • La Reid, jealous? Dude, I would be.

  • I love love love love love love love how he sang this song. I can't wait to buy his album! I am going to buy tons and give them to all my friends throughout Cleveland! Josh rocks!!!! He is the best of the best!!!

  • he should have won i would buy his abulm not hers

  • now that we know the x factor is just a joke we will never show it again. But when we find a josh k cd we will buy it

  • This is the sellout part of X-Factor... He shouldnt be doing this, a voice is not something that can fit perfectly to every genre, exactly the same thing with an instrument, not every instrument fits every genre... Make the song to the voice, not the voice to the song...

  • @joselimai

    I do agree with you completely, but, in Josh's case, his voice is nothing but perfect in this song. Sincerely, I think L.A. Reid and Simon Cowel were just to afraid for their own pupils to say a good word about Josh"s performance.

  • @joselimai yeah, but its subjective. I think his voice suited this song perfectly, giving it a soulfulness that Rihanna has nowhere near enough ability to give it. So, I have to agree and disagree with you there.

  • @joselimai its not a sell out part dumbass its called they have to do their own version and he is by far the best i love josh he can sing anything

  • @joselimai i think he made it sound good

  • I think she should have slowed it down so he could really show off his voice and make the song deeper.

  • awesome! Simple!

  • God Rihanna sucks so bad.

  • Josh for the $5 MIL!

  • when the heck will he sing use somebody

  • @hotrode96 I agree, I would love to hear Josh singing some Kings Of Leon

  • To night is the show down! Win or not Josh is my top pick, then Melanie, then Chris. Chris may be original , but to me can't sing all that good! guess we will see...

  • It is really difficult to decide which i should vote for Josh has an amazing voice but Chris is soo original and entertaining and he really sings with so much passion ....

  • simon was on a TV show and said that his trasty girl was going to win. X Factor is his show. If the trasty girl wins then we know that X Factor was just a fake show. But Josh K is the only real winner and he will out sell all other singers.

  • 185 Dislikes.. nice try Rihanna.

  • better than Rihanna.... nuff said

    

  • ....he did it WAY better than Rihanna

  • i thought he was gonna sing a coldplay song when i first heard the beginning of the song :P

  • In every Josh's performances he increases quality to the songs and put your face in music!!!! He is amazing and should record every songs of his participation in X factor!!!! I would buy definetly.

  • A billion times better than original!!!! Very good!!!!

  • He kills every song! This is the X Factor, no doubt

  • I honestly think that if Josh sang,recorded and released this song before Rihanna, it would've done just as well as Rihanna's. I defiantly would've bought it.

  • LA and Simon should piss off. This guy simply CAN"T give a bad performance. He is TOO GOOD. All pale in comparison to him. Vote Josh people! If Xfactor is to have any credibility (pretty cheesy show), Josh must win. Any other outcome would be an embarrassment.

    Imagine a CD with most of his Xfactor songs and his brilliant original songs (Suzanne, Shorn, Shut your Mouth, Altavastic, etc, etc,) combined. An American musical legend in the making!

    I am captivated and a fan for life!

  • shaddap L.A!

  • I love his version of this song, I hope they have an mp3 of it.

  • This version is much more soothing to my ears :)

  • This version made me love this song!!

  • Once again...Josh brought this song to another level! WOW WOW WOW!!!!

  • i found love in a hope less place

  • If that no talent big fake boobs Melenie wins X the Factor :YUCK" I do not know one person who would throw their money away on her. The world loves Josh k. He will out sell all other singers. 

  • i think that the light shows are too distracting. amazing yes, but a bit too much

  • This song is incredible! Much better than Rihana's version! I can't stop listening to the song. This song surprisingly well fitted your voice. I was impressed by this song! You will win!

    A fans from Hungary.

  • Swear to god I didn't even notice the dancers while he was singing. I was like "What dancers?" When Simon was talking about it haha.

  • ELE é o MELHOR!!! Tem que ganhar!!! E essa música na voz dele ficou PERFEITA!!! ADOREI!!! MUITO BOM MESMO!!!

  • Amazing i wish CANADAINS could vote cause im sure you would win

  • @riyamalik94 Some have posted you could with Twitter, follow xfactor USA, I'll try it myself

  • ugh Simon gets on my nerves

  • he is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Pls vote for josh he is the one wif originality, talent and soul

  • i cry. beautiful people. :)

  • Im sorry, but that was awesome!!! Josh's voice is great!!! I agreed with Paula!!!!

  • JOSH FOR THE WIN>>>>>AMAZING VOICE...

  • famous voice Josh, wish you good luck from poprad, slovakia

  • his voice is great - strong but he just sing the wrong song and the dancerz ooooooh man .....

    Nicole Nicole Nicole i love her style and some parts of her songs BUT SHEZ GONNA GET IT HIM DOWN.

    i really agree with LA and Simon "Lovely - sexy Simon" <3

    he's sooooo good at country - rock songs ... KEEP IT UP JOSH AND PLEASE CHOOSE THE SONGES BY YOUR SELF.

    LOVE FROM K.S.A

  • La Reid has got stupid written all over his bald head. Simon, fear this.

  • Anyone else noticed he forgot the lyrics in the end of the second verse? I mean, not that it changes the fact he was spectacular.

  • @RoCkStaRkRok Didn't notice. Never stayed with this song long enough to hear the second verse, until Josh sang it.

  • I think I'm in love with this man.

  • I heard Rihanna made a cover of this song

  • @eastonman123 and @maggiethefamous Don't disrespect Rihanna like that. Rihanna sings this song perfectly, and it is very fitting for her to sing. Josh sounds good as always, but he did NOT make the song better. Club songs are not Josh' area, though he might be able to sing them nicely.

  • @Nexuzdk Never gave the song a second listen until Josh sang it. He made it better. Love this version. LaLa Reid, I would buy this version.

  • so stupid this is not rihannas song

  • I think it's was good trance music.

  • This song was very appropriate! Simon I love you, but you were wrong on this one. I love the Viva La Vida Coldplay/Rihanna mashup. And Josh, you look like little brother to Javier Bardem/Jeffrey Morgan...and you can sing. Best of luck to you.

  • He picked a really bad song

  • me encanta josh krajick :D

  • verryyy gooooddd a lott its a smatch music with the josh

  • I prefer his version to Rihanna's, his voice is SO DAMN UNIQUE. JOSH TO WIN!

  • LA, being green with envy is not really attractive. Unlike your remaining act, Josh can sing! Simon, your remaining act shouldn't even be there. You sent her home, remember? VOTE JOSH!

  • Why couldn't LA be a bigger man, just becoz other contestants sing better than the artists u signed doesn't mean u need to be mean!! Be a bigger man, be more subjective

  • Gosh, L.A., you always just HAVE to kill it -.-

  • love Riri but this is way better than her version!! its awesome!! can't stop singing his version!! his voice on this track reminds me of someone elses track!! help me!! who is it!! im still trying to put my finger on it!! grrrr its going to bug me!!

  • This guy can sing anything and is so musically talented!!! He is the whole package, Reminds me of a cross between Michael Bolton and Joe Cocker only better and I just can't get enough!!! He's great to listen to but I prefer watching him sing so...when his first CD comes out I hope it's a CD/DVD combo! He doesn't need all those back-up singers and dancers either; just give us JOSH!!!

  • Josh for 5 Million!!!

  • I don't care what anyone says he did great

  • Amazing! I love it that Josh can take any song, and make it his own! And loved how he comes out and bam! he grabbed that song by the tail and went with it. Matters not about the dancers, I didn't pay any attention to them because Josh has a way of demanding attention, regardless, when singing. Super job! Loved it!

  • I think he is better than the original.

  • @maggiethefamous ditto

  • Josh all day!

  • What a really nice version of this song : This guy deserve to win !!! ( It's me or the melody is kinda like "Viva la vida " by coldplay ?)

  • Proof he can make anything sound good.

  • i love Josh singing this song..he is a bit michael bolton, michael mcdonald and joe cocker. I think L.A has a hearing problem.. The show isnt about the judges bickering like 10 year olds, it's about the singers...geesh, you all go to your room and kneel in the corner.

  • love it..

  • wow!

    

  • For a "dance week" i could dance all night long!

  • hey HEY.. rihanna!!!!

    um..yeah..sorry..