This really is magnifacent. I love how you didn't use a lot of effects, yet it still gave the effect the audience wanted. And incredible choice of music! Matched perfectly. Good luck in the contest! I was going through everyones stuff and I stopped at yours. The best in my oppinion. I think you'll do VERY well:-) I'm not sure how I'll do, but it was worth a try:-) But good luck! I've never seen this movie, but you really captured the beauty of it for me. 5*!
Thank you so much, I'm absolutely overwhelmed by your nice words! I'm actually quite proud of this video because it's a bit different from my other stuff and I'm so happy to receive such wonderful feedback!
I'm sure your video has good chances in the contest, too, I think it's really haunting and the effects are well chosen. Good luck to you as well!
Very cool I could tell you were inspired by Ehryn's These Words BJ video! Your video had a mix of happy and sad moments with such a cool song. I had to love it!!! Especially your editing skills. 5 stars and saved to playlist.
Thank you very much for the lovely comment, Bluann! I especially appreciate your opinion because you're one of THE vidders whose work I totally admire. :D
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW,..how i lovvvve this vid,.it is one of the verrrrry best Atonement vids,.really,.I can't believe how well made it is,.OMG,.the scenes with the beat,.JUST beyond perfect,.GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRREAT :D a milllion star and favvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvs :D
OMG OMG OMG!!! I'd never have expected SUCH a wonderful comment! I can't tell you how very very very happy I am that you liked this video so much! :DDDD
Oh I loved this! And I can see how ehrynL85's video inspired this. (It actually inspired one of my videos.)
I think you did a really nice job.
And since you asked for feedback, the only thing I can say about this is that you should make it a little bit more obvious that you're trying to match the beats. Change the person you're looking at, or find a zoomed in version, then go back to the original one you had. Does that make sense?
Oh, wow! Thank you for the approval! And for the helpful tip about the beat as well - I really have to admit that it doesn't work everywhere. Zoom... I think I'll have to try to work with it in my next video. Anyway - thanks a lot!
Vanessa aka FelicityKing is an awesome vidder herself and she promotes other videos as well, so another "thank you" to her! And to you for the lovely comment, thanks a lot! ;-D
Thank you! The idea came when I listened to the track once more and just thought - Briony is writing, Robbie is writing, it's about love - why not do it? :-)
Amazing! This song is so perfect too for Atonement! I Loved the editing. Particularly the scene where Briony is walking and it switches between when she is older and younger.
Such a lovely comment, thank you, Vanessa! You might have noticed the similarity of this vid with the one that inspired me - "Becoming Jane - These Words" by ehrynL85, a wonderful video. I tried to improve my vidmaker skills, you see. ;-D
Hallo Kathy, den Film muss ich mir unbedingt noch anschauen! Er scheint wunderschön romantisch und dramatisch zu sein. Du hast das wirklich ganz toll gemacht, ich liebe Natascha Bedingfields Lieder,dafür dass du Ihren Song genommen hast kriegst du einen extra Stern von mir, wirklich eine gute Auswahl! Und für die Story 5 Sterne dazu :).
Wünsche dir einen guten Start an der Schule, und hoffe, dass du bald wieder bei Youtube reinschaust :). Liebe Grüsse, Celina
Oh, vielen Dank für den schönen Kommentar, Celina! Ich habe wirklich nicht mehr so viel Freizeit, aber ich werde versuchen, so oft wie ich kann, hier vorbeischauen! :-)
I came back to enjoy this! :D
I still love how everything goes with the beat and flow of the song!
bluesalad 2 years ago
It's cool seeing clips of Atonement, but using "These Words"...seriously??
I mean come on..no way does that song go well with describing the movie
chanandler20 2 years ago 2
This was a great video. I really like it..
beretta1342000 3 years ago
i really like this one too:)
im glad you entered it:D
charmedkitten 3 years ago
Thanks for the nice comment! :D
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
This really is magnifacent. I love how you didn't use a lot of effects, yet it still gave the effect the audience wanted. And incredible choice of music! Matched perfectly. Good luck in the contest! I was going through everyones stuff and I stopped at yours. The best in my oppinion. I think you'll do VERY well:-) I'm not sure how I'll do, but it was worth a try:-) But good luck! I've never seen this movie, but you really captured the beauty of it for me. 5*!
MiniMeJonas 3 years ago
Thank you so much, I'm absolutely overwhelmed by your nice words! I'm actually quite proud of this video because it's a bit different from my other stuff and I'm so happy to receive such wonderful feedback!
I'm sure your video has good chances in the contest, too, I think it's really haunting and the effects are well chosen. Good luck to you as well!
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Very cool I could tell you were inspired by Ehryn's These Words BJ video! Your video had a mix of happy and sad moments with such a cool song. I had to love it!!! Especially your editing skills. 5 stars and saved to playlist.
bluesalad 3 years ago
Thank you very much for the lovely comment, Bluann! I especially appreciate your opinion because you're one of THE vidders whose work I totally admire. :D
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW,..how i lovvvve this vid,.it is one of the verrrrry best Atonement vids,.really,.I can't believe how well made it is,.OMG,.the scenes with the beat,.JUST beyond perfect,.GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRREAT :D a milllion star and favvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvs :D
Hannah ^_^
PeriodDrama 3 years ago
OMG OMG OMG!!! I'd never have expected SUCH a wonderful comment! I can't tell you how very very very happy I am that you liked this video so much! :DDDD
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Oh I loved this! And I can see how ehrynL85's video inspired this. (It actually inspired one of my videos.)
I think you did a really nice job.
And since you asked for feedback, the only thing I can say about this is that you should make it a little bit more obvious that you're trying to match the beats. Change the person you're looking at, or find a zoomed in version, then go back to the original one you had. Does that make sense?
Other than that... FANTASTIC! 5*
meeshell384 3 years ago
Oh, wow! Thank you for the approval! And for the helpful tip about the beat as well - I really have to admit that it doesn't work everywhere. Zoom... I think I'll have to try to work with it in my next video. Anyway - thanks a lot!
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
it´s perfect!!! xD very very good!
lg eyleen hdl
batman22burns 3 years ago 2
wow!!!!! goregous editing and very creative !!!!!! Amazing ! Thanks to felicityking for sharing ! 5 stars and *faved*
veryval 3 years ago 2
Vanessa aka FelicityKing is an awesome vidder herself and she promotes other videos as well, so another "thank you" to her! And to you for the lovely comment, thanks a lot! ;-D
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Really wonderful job. The song is perfect!
theresavs 3 years ago 3
Thank you! The idea came when I listened to the track once more and just thought - Briony is writing, Robbie is writing, it's about love - why not do it? :-)
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Kathy,you always do an AMAZING job!!!!!!!!
Patty
uniapit 3 years ago
Ahh, thank you very much, Patty! I'm very very glad you liked this video! :-)
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Amazing! This song is so perfect too for Atonement! I Loved the editing. Particularly the scene where Briony is walking and it switches between when she is older and younger.
5 stars, faved, and to be shared!
FelicityKing 3 years ago
Such a lovely comment, thank you, Vanessa! You might have noticed the similarity of this vid with the one that inspired me - "Becoming Jane - These Words" by ehrynL85, a wonderful video. I tried to improve my vidmaker skills, you see. ;-D
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
That was completely awesome, its so original and the editing was perfect 5*
MissGreenGables22 3 years ago
I'm so happy that you liked the video so much, thanks a lot! I'm very glad to get any kind of feedback! ;-)
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
Hallo Kathy, den Film muss ich mir unbedingt noch anschauen! Er scheint wunderschön romantisch und dramatisch zu sein. Du hast das wirklich ganz toll gemacht, ich liebe Natascha Bedingfields Lieder,dafür dass du Ihren Song genommen hast kriegst du einen extra Stern von mir, wirklich eine gute Auswahl! Und für die Story 5 Sterne dazu :).
Wünsche dir einen guten Start an der Schule, und hoffe, dass du bald wieder bei Youtube reinschaust :). Liebe Grüsse, Celina
poucelina79 3 years ago
Oh, vielen Dank für den schönen Kommentar, Celina! Ich habe wirklich nicht mehr so viel Freizeit, aber ich werde versuchen, so oft wie ich kann, hier vorbeischauen! :-)
katinkagirlie 3 years ago
great vid, hun 5/5 faves!
sheelz321 3 years ago
thank you! *jumping up and down* first comment! :-D
katinkagirlie 3 years ago